Calculation of singlet oxygen dose from photosensitizer fluorescence and photobleaching during mTHPC photodynamic therapy of MLL cells

Predicting the therapeutic outcome of photodynamic therapy (PDT) requires knowledge of the amount of cytoxic species generated. An implicit approach to assessing PDT efficacy has been proposed where changes in photosensitizer (PS) fluorescence during treatment are used to predict treatment outcome. To investigate this, in vitro experiments were performed in which Mat-LyLu cells were incubated in meta-tetra(hydroxyphenyl)chlorin (mTHPC) and then irradiated with 652 nm light. PS concentration, fluence rate and oxygenation were independently controlled and monitored during the treatment. Fluorescence of mTHPC was monitored during treatment and, at selected fluence levels, cell viability was determined using a colony-formation assay. Singlet oxygen dose was calculated using four different models and was compared with cell survival. For the dose metric based on singlet oxygen-mediated PS photobleaching, a universal relationship between cell survival and singlet oxygen dose was found for all treatment parameters. Analysis of the concentration dependence of bleaching suggests that the lifetime of singlet oxygen within the cell is 0.05-0.25 micros. Generation of about 9 x 10(8) molecules of singlet oxygen per cell reduces the surviving fraction by 1/e.     

In vivo mTHPC photobleaching in normal rat skin exhibits unique irradiance-dependent features

We report measurements performed on the normal skin of rats in vivo, which provide information on the photobleaching kinetics and mechanisms of the photosensitizer meso-tetrahydroxyphenyl chlorin (mTHPC). Loss of mTHPC fluorescence was monitored using in vivo fluorescence spectroscopy during photodynamic therapy (PDT) performed using 650 nm laser irradiation. The bleaching was evaluated for irradiances of 5, 20 and 50 mW cm(-2). Two distinct phases of mTHPC photobleaching were observed. In the first phase there was no obvious irradiance dependence in the loss of fluorescence vs fluence. The second phase was initiated by an irradiance-dependent discontinuity in the slope of the bleaching curve, after which the photobleaching rates showed an irradiance dependence consistent with an oxygen-dependent reaction process. To investigate the unusual shape of the in vivo bleaching curves, we measured the PDT-induced changes in O2 concentrations in mTHPC-sensitized spheroids irradiated with 2, 5 and 20 mW cm(-2) of 650 nm light. The oxygen concentration data indicated no unusual features within the range of fluences where the discontinuities in fluorescence were observed during in vivo spectroscopy. The fluorescence from the in vivo bleaching experiments thus reports a phenomenon that is not reported by measurements of the photochemical oxygen consumption in the spheroids.     

Intracellular photobleaching of 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(m-hydroxyphenyl) chlorin (Foscan) exhibits a complex dependence on oxygen level and fluence rate

The understanding of photosensitizer photobleaching is important not only for mechanistic studies, but also for the development of monitoring techniques for clinical dosimetry in photodynamic therapy. In this study, we investigated the intracellular photobleaching of 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(m-hydroxyphenyl)chlorin (mTHPC, Foscan) in the murine macrophage cell line J774A.1, using quantitative fluorescence imaging microscopy, microspectrofluorometry and microspectrophotometry. Using 652 nm laser irradiation, it was found that mTHPC exhibits oxygen- and fluence rate-dependent intracellular photobleaching. The kinetics showed an inverse dose-rate behavior, i.e. a reduction of fluence rate resulted in more photobleaching at comparable fluences. The effect of deoxygenation was found to be more complex, with decreased bleaching at low fluence rates and increased bleaching at higher fluence rates. The intracellular formation of reactive oxygen species was measured using 2',7'-dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate. The results are analyzed in terms of competitive Type-I and Type-II mechanisms.     

Photophysical parameters, photosensitizer retention and tissue optical properties completely account for the higher photodynamic efficacy of meso-tetra-hydroxyphenyl-chlorin vs Photofrin

Meso-tetra-hydroxyphenyl-chlorin (mTHPC) is one of the most potent photosensitizers currently available for clinical photodynamic therapy (PDT). However the reason or reasons for its high photodynamic efficacy remain(s) unresolved. To investigate the PDT efficacy of mTHPC vs Photofrin we use the knowledge of photophysical parameters extracted from the analysis of oxygen electrode measurements in spheroids to compute and compare their respective singlet oxygen (1O2) dose depositions. The electrode measurements indirectly report the bleaching kinetics of mTHPC and indicate that its photobleaching mechanism is consistent with 1O2-mediated reactions. mTHPC's photodegradation via 1O2 reactions is confirmed by a more direct evaluation of the spatially resolved fluorescence in confocal sections of intact spheroids during irradiation. The PDT efficacy comparisons establish that mTHPC's enhanced potency may be accounted for completely on the basis of its ability to sequester tightly in cells and its photophysical properties, in particular its higher extinction coefficient at a redshifted wavelength. We extend the efficacy comparison to include the influence of hemoglobin absorption of PDT treatment light and show that incorporating the influence of wavelength-dependent light attenuation in tissue further contributes to significantly higher efficacy for mTHPC- vs Photofrin-PDT.     

Photodynamic Mechanisms induced by a Combination of Hypericin and a Chlorin Based‐Photosensitizer in Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma Cells

The aim of this study was to elucidate photodynamic therapy (PDT) effects mediated by hypericin and a liposomal meso‐tetrahydroxyphenyl chlorin (mTHPC) derivative, with focus on their 1:1 mixture, on head and neck squamous cell carcinoma cell lines. Absorption, excitation and photobleaching were monitored using fluorescence spectrometry, showing the same spectral patterns for the mixture as measured for single photosensitizers. In the mixture mTHPC showed a prolonged photo‐stability. Singlet oxygen yield for light‐activated mTHPC was Φ_Δ = 0.66, for hypericin Φ_Δ = 0.25 and for the mixture Φ_Δ = ~0.4. A linear increase of singlet oxygen yield for mTHPC and the mixture was found, whereas hypericin achieved saturation after 35 min. Reactive oxygen species fluorescence was only visible after hypericin and mixture‐induced PDT. Cell viability was also more affected with these two treatment options under the selected conditions. Examination of death pathways showed that hypericin‐mediated cell death was apoptotic, with mTHPC necrotic and the 1:1 mixture showed features of both. Changes in gene expression after PDT indicated strong up‐regulation of selected heat‐shock proteins. The application of photosensitizer mixtures with the features of reduced dark toxicity and combined apoptotic and necrotic cell death may be beneficial in clinical PDT. This will be the focus of our future investigations.     

Relationship between mTHPC fluorescence photobleaching and cell viability during in vitro photodynamic treatment of DP16 cells

An implicit dosimetric model has been proposed in which biological damage caused by photodynamic therapy (PDT) is monitored through the decrease in sensitizer fluorescence during treatment. To investigate this, in vitro experiments were performed in which DP16 cells were incubated in meta-tetra(hydroxyphenyl)chlorin (mTHPC) and then irradiated with 514 nm light. Photosensitizer concentration, fluence rate and oxygenation were independently controlled and monitored during the treatment. Fluorescence of mTHPC was continuously monitored via a charge-coupled device-coupled spectrometer during treatment and, at selected fluence levels, cell viability was determined using a trypan blue exclusion assay. The relationship of cell viability to normalized fluorescence was obtained for the different treatment conditions. The relationship was independent of cell medium oxygenation, treatment fluence rate and sensitizer incubation concentration except at a high mTHPC concentration (4 microg/mL). This relationship suggests that fluorescence bleaching may be used to predict mTHPC PDT damage in vitro.     

Photobleaching of hypericin bound to human serum albumin,cultured adenocarcinoma cells and nude mice skin

Hypericin is a promising photosensitizer for photodynamic therapy (PDT) characterized by a high yield of singlet oxygen. Photobleaching of hypericin has been studied by means of absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy in different biological systems: in human serum albumin solution, in cultured human adenocarcinoma WiDr cells and in the skin of nude mice. Prolonged exposure to light (up to 95 min, 100 mW/cm2) of wavelength around 596 nm induced fluence-dependent photobleaching of hypericin in all studied systems. The photobleaching was not oxygen dependent, and singlet oxygen probably played no significant role. Emission bands in the spectral regions 420-560 nm and above 600 nm characterize the photoproducts formed. An emission band at 615-635 nm was observed after irradiation of cells incubated with hypericin or of mouse skin in vivo but not in albumin solution. The excitation spectrum of these products resembled that of hypericin. Hypericin appears to be more photostable than most sensitizers used in PDT, including mTHPC and Photofrin.     

Calculation of singlet oxygen dose using explicit and implicit dose metrics during benzoporphyrin derivative monoacid ring A (BPD-MA)-PDT in vitro and correlation with MLL cell survival

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) oxygen consumption, clonogenic cell survival, fluorescence photobleaching and photoproduct formation were investigated during benzoporphyrin derivative monoacid (BPD-MA)-PDT of MAT-LyLu cells in vitro. Cells were incubated with BPD-MA concentrations of 0.1, 0.5 or 2.5 μg mL(-1) for 2 h and then treated with 405 nm light under oxygenated and hypoxic conditions. Fluorescence spectra were acquired during treatment, and photobleaching and photoproduct generation were quantified using singular value decomposition of the spectra. Cell survival was measured at set times during the treatment using a colony-forming assay. The amount of oxygen consumed by PDT per photon absorbed decreased with BPD-MA intracellular concentration. Survival was correlated with the total amount of oxygen consumed by PDT per unit volume, which is assumed to be equivalent to the amount of singlet oxygen that reacted. A photobleaching-based singlet oxygen dose metric was also found to predict survival independent of intracellular BPD-MA concentration. The BPD-MA photoproduct was bleached during the treatment. Two singlet oxygen dose metrics based on photoproduct kinetics could not be correlated with cell survival over the full range of intracellular BPD-MA concentrations used.     

Fluorescence Photobleaching of ALA-induced Protoporphyrin IX during Photodynamic Therapy of Normal Hairless Mouse Skin: The Effect of Light Dose and Irradiance and the Resulting Biological Effect

The photobleaching of 5-aminolaevulinic acid (ALA)-induced protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) was investigated during superficial photodynamic therapy (PDT) in normal skin of the SKH HRt hairless mouse. The effects of light dose and fluence rate on the dynamics and magnitude of photobleaching and on the corresponding PDT-induced dam-age were examined. The results show that the PDT damage cannot be predicted by the total light dose. Photo-bleaching was monitored over a wide range of initial PpIX fluorescence intensities. The rate of PpIX photo-bleaching is not a simple function of fluence rate but is dependent on the initial concentration of sensitizer. Also, at high fluence rates (50–150 mW/cm², 514 nm) oxygen depletion is shown to have a significant effect. The rate of photobleaching with respect to light dose and the corresponding PDT damage both increase with decreasing fluence rate. We therefore suggest that the definition of a bleaching dose as the light dose that causes a 1/e reduction in fluorescence signal is insufficient to describe the dynamics of photobleaching and PDT-induced dam-age. We have detected the formation of PpIX photoproducts during the initial period of irradiation that were themselves subsequently photobleached. In the absence of oxygen, PpIX and its photoproducts are not photo-bleached. We present a method of calculating a therapeutic dose delivered during superficial PDT that demonstrates a strong correlation with PDT damage.     

Simple Photodynamic Therapy Dose Models Fail to Predict the Survival of MLL Cells After HPPH–PDT In Vitro

Fluorescence photobleaching, photodynamic therapy (PDT) oxygen consumption and clonogenic cell survival were investigated during 2-(1-hexyloxethyl)-2-devinyl pyropheophoribde-a (HPPH) PDT of MAT-LyLu cells in vitro . Cells were incubated with HPPH concentrations of 0.24, 1.2, 3.6 or 12 μ m for 4 h and then treated with 650 nm light under oxygenated and hypoxic conditions. Fluorescence spectra were acquired during treatment and photobleaching was quantified using singular value decomposition of the spectra. Cell survival was measured at set times during the treatment using a colony forming assay. Intracellular fluorescence lifetime measurements were also performed at each incubation concentration. The photobleaching kinetics did not follow first- or second-order kinetics and the fluorescence lifetime was similar for all intracellular concentrations. As the intracellular concentration of drug was increased, the amount of singlet oxygen and the absorbed quanta per cell required to achieve the same cell kill increased. Singlet oxygen dose was calculated using one- and two-compartment models of HPPH intracellular distribution. It was found that a two-compartment model, in which a PDT-sensitive binding site saturates at low concentrations, accounts for the observed photobleaching, oxygen consumption and cell survival.     

Effects of the Oxygenation Level on Formation of Different Reactive Oxygen Species During Photodynamic Therapy

We examined the effect of the oxygenation level on efficacy of two photosensitizing agents, both of which target lysosomes for photodamage, but via different photochemical pathways. Upon irradiation, the chlorin termed NPe6 forms singlet oxygen in high yield while the bacteriopheophorbide WST11 forms only oxygen radicals (in an aqueous environment). Photokilling efficacy by WST11 in cell culture was impaired when the atmospheric oxygen concentration was reduced from 20% to 1%, while photokilling by NPe6 was unaffected. Studies in a cell‐free system revealed that the rates of photobleaching of these agents, as a function of the oxygenation level, were correlated with results described above. Moreover, the rate of formation of oxygen radicals by either agent was more sensitive to the level of oxygenation than was singlet oxygen formation by NPe6. These data indicate that the photochemical process that leads to oxygen radical formation is more dependent on the oxygenation level than is the pathway leading to formation of singlet oxygen.     

The influence of oxygen depletion and photosensitizer triplet-state dynamics during photodynamic therapy on accurate singlet oxygen luminescence monitoring and analysis of treatment dose response

To date, singlet oxygen ((1)O(2)) luminescence (SOL) detection was predictive of photodynamic therapy (PDT) treatment responses both in vitro and in vivo, but accurate quantification is challenging. In particular, the early and strongest part of the time-resolved signal (500-2000ns) is difficult to separate from confounding sources of luminescence and system noise, and so is normally gated out. However, the signal dynamics change with oxygen depletion during PDT, so that this time gating biases the (1)O(2) measurements. Here, the impact of gating was investigated in detail, determining the rate constants from SOL and direct pO(2) measurements during meso-tetra(hydroxyphenyl)chlorin (mTHPC)-mediated PDT of cells in vitro under well-controlled conditions. With these data as input, numerical simulations were used to examine PDT and SOL dynamics, and the influence of various time gates on cumulative SOL signals. It is shown that gating can underestimate the SOL at early treatment time points by ～40% and underestimate the cumulative SOL signal by 20-25%, representing significant errors. In vitro studies with both mTHPC and aminolevulinic acid-photosensitizer protoporphyrin IX demonstrate that rigorous analysis of SOL signal kinetics is then crucial in order to use SOL as an accurate and quantitative PDT dose metric.     

Rational design of boron dipyrromethene (BODIPY)-based photobleaching-resistant fluorophores applicable to a protein dynamics study

We studied the photobleaching of a library of boron dipyrromethene (BODIPY) derivatives with a range of electron densities, and found that the photobleaching rate is influenced by the electron-withdrawing capacity of the substituents. Electron-deficient BODIPYs generated less singlet oxygen, were less reactive to singlet oxygen, and were highly resistant to photobleaching. We confirmed the utility of one of these fluorophores, 2,6-diCO(2)R-BDP, for visualizing EGF receptor dynamics in cells expressing an SNAP-tagged EGF receptor.     

Fractionated Illumination at Low Fluence Rate Photodynamic Therapy in Mice

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) for actinic field cancerization is effective but painful. Pain mechanisms remain unclear but fluence rate has been shown to be a critical factor. Lower fluence rates also utilize available oxygen more efficiently. We investigated PDT effect in normal SKH1-HR mice using low and high fluence rate aminolevulinic acid (ALA) PDT and a fractionated illumination scheme. Six groups of six mice with different light treatment parameters were studied. Visual skin damage was assessed up to 7 days post-PDT. Fluorescence and reflectance spectroscopy during illuminations provided us with real-time information about protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) photobleaching. A novel dosing approach was introduced in that we used a photobleaching percentage instead of a preset fluence. Data show similar total and maximum damage scores in high and low fluence rate groups. Photobleaching of PpIX in the low fluence rate groups shows a trend toward more efficient photobleaching. Results indicate that low fluence rate PDT is as effective as and more efficient than high fluence rate PDT in normal mouse skin. Low fluence rate PDT light protocols need to be explored in human studies in search for an effective and well-tolerated treatment for actinic field cancerization.     

Investigation of photobleaching of hypocrellin B in non-polar organic solvent and in liposome suspension

Hypocrellin B (HB) is a natural pigment with a promising application in the photodynamic therapy (PDT) for anticancer treatment. The photobleaching of HB in non-polar organic solvents and in liposomes in aqueous solution were investigated by the measurements of absorption spectra, quenching experiments and determination of photoproducts. Control experiments indicated that the sensitizer, oxygen and light were all essential for the photobleaching of HB, which suggested that it was mainly self-sensitized photooxidation. The illumination of HB with visible light in aerobic non-polar solvent generated singlet oxygen efficiently [Phi(1O(2))=0.76] which then attacked the sensitizer HB with formation of an endoperoxide product. The endoperoxide of HB was unstable at room temperature and underwent predominantly loss of singlet oxygen with regeneration of parent HB. The singlet oxygen released from the endoperoxide of HB was detected with chemical trapping experiments. When HB was embedded in EPC liposomes, no endoperoxide product and no singlet oxygen release from the photobleaching process of HB were detected. The quenching experiments indicated that the singlet oxygen mechanism (type II) played an important role in the non-polar solvent and the free radical mechanism (type I) was predominant in liposomal aqueous solution for the photobleaching of HB.     

In Vivo Fluence Rate Effect in Photodynamic Therapy of Early Cancers with Tetra(m-hydroxyphenyl)chlorin

Abstract— Several parameters affect clinical trials in photodynamic therapy and influence the therapeutic outcome. Beside drug dose, light dose, drug-light interval and other variables, the fluence rate is a parameter that can influence the therapeutic results. In this study we have evaluated the fluence rate effect with a second-generation photosensitizer, tetra( m -hydroxyphenyl)chlorin (mTHPC) using a 7,12-dimethylbenz(a)anthracene induced early squamous cell carcinoma of the Syrian hamster cheek pouch as a tumor model. Following injection of 0.5 mg/kg of mTHPC, irradiation tests were performed at two drug-light intervals, 4 and 8 days. Wavelength and light dose were adapted from those applied routinely in clinical trials. Irradiations at 652 nm were carried out with fluences ranging from 8 to 20 J/cm² delivered at fluence rates of 15 and 150 mW/cm². Similar tests were also performed at 514 nm with a fluence of 80 J/cm² delivered at fluence rates ranging from 25 to 125 mW/cm². At both wavelengths and drug-light intervals for a given fluence, the higher fluence rates resulted in less tissue damage in tumor and healthy mucosae. However, the lower fluence rates yielded slightly less therapeutic selectivity. This study confirms that the fluence rate is of major importance in clinical PDT.     

Topical photodynamic therapy at low fluence rates--theory and practice

Photodynamic Therapy (PDT), with topically applied 5-aminolaevulinic acid as the photosensitiser, is an effective treatment for various malignant and pre-malignant skin conditions. Several studies have shown the importance of fluence rate as well as fluence in the efficacy of PDT. We propose a measure of PDT efficacy, Photodynamic Damage Dose (PDD), which uses the product of instantaneous fluence rates, photosensitiser concentrations and oxygen concentrations in its calculation. We derive a qualitative numerical model of PDT and verify it by demonstrating an inverse fluence rate effect, increased efficacy of fractionated PDT, PDT induced hypoxia, and the dependence of photobleaching on fluence rate under certain circumstances. We recommend that fluence, fluence rate and any fractionation regime used should be detailed when reporting a trial as altering any of these has significant effects on PDT efficacy. The model predicts that low fluence rate irradiations should be as effective as high fluence rate irradiations if carried out over the same length of time. To test this we build a light emitting diode-based lamp (fluence rate of 7 mW cm(-2) at 635 nm) and used it to treat 32 superficial basal cell carcinomas on 22 patients (30 min treatment time, fluence 12.6 J cm(-2)). The complete response rate at one year was 84%, which is comparable to that achieved using higher fluence rate sources for similar treatment times. We conclude that this robust, inexpensive light source is effective for topical PDT.     

Photosensitization of red blood cell hemolysis by lutetium texaphyrin

Lutetium (III) texaphyrin photosensitizes postirradiation or "delayed" photohemolysis (DPH) of human and bovine red blood cells at 730 nm by a Type-2 pathway mediated by singlet molecular oxygen. The DPH rate increases with increasing incubation temperature and with the second power of the incident fluence. The experimental DPH curves are in good agreement with a multi-hit kinetics model based on target theory.     

Photodynamic therapy for malignant mesothelioma: preclinical studies for optimization of treatment protocols

Effective photodynamic therapy (PDT) depends on the optimization of factors such as drug dose, drug-light interval, fluence rate and total light dose (or fluence). In addition sufficient oxygen has to be present for the photochemical reaction to occur. Oxygen deficits may arise during PDT if the photochemical reaction consumes oxygen more rapidly than it can be replenished, and this could limit the efficacy of PDT. In this study we investigated the influence of the drug-light interval, illumination-fluence rate and total fluence on PDT efficacy for the photosensitizer meta-tetrahydroxyphenylchlorin (mTHPC). The effect of increasing the oxygenation status of tumors during PDT was also investigated. PDT response was assessed from tumor-growth delay and from cures for human malignant mesothelioma xenografts grown in nude mice. Tumor-bearing mice were injected intravenously with 0.15 or 0.3 mg.kg-1 mTHPC, and after intervals of 24-120 h, the subcutaneous tumors were illuminated with laser light (652 nm) at fluence rates of 20, 100 or 200 mW.cm-2. Tumor response was strongly dependent on the drug-light interval. Illumination at 24 h after photosensitization was always significantly more effective than illumination at 72 or 120 h. For a drug-light interval of 24 h the tumor response increased with total fluence, but for longer drug-light intervals even high total fluences failed to produce a significant delay in tumor regrowth. No fluence-rate dependence of PDT response was demonstrated in these studies. Nicotinamide injection and carbogen breathing significantly increased tumor oxygenation and increased the tumor response for PDT schedules with illumination at 24 h after photosensitizer injection.