The structure of decomposing [C7H7O]+ ions: Benzyl versus tropylium ion structures

The unimolecular dissociation reactions for [C₇H₇O]⁺ ions generated by fragmentation of a series of precursor molecules have been investigated. The metastable kinetic energy values and branching ratios associated with decarbonylation and expulsion of a molecule of formaldehyde (CH₂O) from the [C₇H₇O]⁺ ions are interpreted as the hydroxybenzyl and hydroxytropylium [C₇H₇O]⁺ not interconverting to a common structure on the microsecond time-scale. In addition, similar measurements on protonated benzaldehyde, methylaryloxy and phenyl methylene ether [C₇H₇O]⁺ ions are interpreted as the dominant fraction of these decomposing ions having unique structures on the microsecond time-scale. These results are supported by experimental heats of formation calculated from ionization/appearance energy measurements. The experimental heats of formation are determined as: hydroxybenzyl ions, 735 kJ mol^?1; hydroxytropylium ions, 656 kJ mol^?1; phenyl methylene ether ions, 640 kJ mol^?1; methylaryloxy ions 803 kJ mol^?1. The combination of the results reported in this paper with previously reported experimental data for stable [C₇H₇O]⁺ ions (see Ref. 1, C. J. Cassady, B. S. Freiser and D. H. Russell, Org. Mass Spectrom.) is interpreted as evidence that the relative population of benzyl versus tropylium [C₇H₇O]⁺ ion structures from a given precursor molecule is determined by isomerization of the parent ion and not by structural equilibration of the [C₇H₇O]⁺ ion.     

Ion structural studies by ion kinetic energy spectrometry: [C7H7]+, [C7H8]+˙, [C7H7OCH3]+˙

The use of kinetic energy release measurements in the structural characterization of ions formed in the mass spectrometer and in the determination of fragmentation mechanisms is demonstrated. In combination with information on the mode of energy partitioning in some of these reactions this allows the following conclusions: (i) The metastable [C₇H₈]⁸˙ ions formed from toluene, cyclohepatatriene, n-butylbenzene, the three methyl anisoles, methyl tropyl ether and benzyl methyl ether all undergo loss of H˙ from a common structure. (ii) The metastable [C₇H₇]⁺ ions generated from the same sources and from benzyl bromide, benzyl alcohol, p-xylene and ethylbenzene appear to undergo loss of acetylene from both the benzylic and the tropylium structures. (iii) The metastable [C₇H₇OCH₃]⁺˙ ether molecular ions undergo loss of CH₃˙ by two types of mechanism, simple cleavage to give the aryloxy cation (not observed for benzyl methyl ether) and a rearrangement process which appears to lead to protonated tropone as the product. (iv) Loss of formaldehyde from the metastable [C₇H₇OCH₃]⁺˙ molecular ions involves hydrogen transfer via competitive 4- and 5-membered cyclic transition states in the case of the anisoles and in the case of methyl tropyl ether, while for benzyl methyl ether, hydrogen transfer in the nonisomerized molecular ion occurs via a 4-membered cyclic transition state to yield the cycloheptatriene molecular ion.     

Assigning structures to [C2H3O]+ ions

The problem of assigning structures to [C₂H₃O]⁺ ions produced from a wide variety of precursor molecules has been readdressed. The identification of the acetyl cation, \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ {\rm{CH}}_{\rm{3}} \mathop {\rm{C}}\limits^{\rm{ + }} = {\rm{O}} $\end{document}, from metastable peak characteristics and collisional activation mass spectra appears to be straightforward. The structure \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ {\rm{CH}}_{\rm{2}} = \mathop {\rm{C}}\limits^{\rm{ + }} - {\rm{OH}} $\end{document} is also known to exist as a stable ion. A third ion, whose structure may be represented as \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ \mathop {\rm{C}}\limits^{\rm{ + }} {\rm{H}}_{\rm{2}} {\rm{CHO}} $\end{document} or has also been characterized.     

Structures of decomposing and non-decomposing gas-phase [C4H6O]+· radical cations,and their [C2H2O]+· and [C3H6]+· product ions

The structures of gas-phase [C₄H₆O]^+· radical cations and their daughter ions of composition [C₂H₂O]^+· and [C₃H₆]^+· were investigated by using collisionally activated dissociation, metastable ion measurement, kinetic energy release and collisional ionization tandem mass spectrometric techniques. Electron ionization (70 eV) of ethoxyacetylene, methyl vinyl ketone, crotonaldehyde and 1-methoxyallene yields stable [C₄H₆O]^+· ions, whereas the cyclic C₄H₆O compounds undergo ring opening to stable distonic ions. The structures of [C₂H₃O]^+· ions produced by 70-eV ionization of several C₄H₆O compounds are identical with that of the ketene radical cation. The [C₃H₆]^+· ions generated from crotonaldehyde, methacrylaldehyde, and cyclopropanecarboxaldehyde have structures similar to that of the propene radical cations, whereas those ions generated from the remainder of the [C₄H₆O]^+· ions studied here produced a mixed population of cyclopropane and propene radical cations.     

The heats of formation of some protonated olefinic carbonyl compounds: [C5H9O]+ and [C4H7O2]+ ions

The proton transfer equilibrium reactions involving 3-penten-2-one, 3-methyl-3-buten-2-one, crotonic acid and methacrylic acid were carried out in an ion cyclotron resonance (ICR) spectrometer. The semiempirical method MNDO, used to estimate the heats of formation for 14 protonated [C₅H₉O]⁺ and [C₄H₇O₂]⁺ ions and the energetic aspect of the fragmentations of metastable [C₆H₁₂O]^+. and [C₆H₁₂O₂]^+. ions, leads to the conclusion that the ions corresponding to protonation at the carbonyl oxygen are the most stable. Thus the experimentally determined heats of formation of protonated olefinic carbonyl compounds can be attributed to the following structures: [CH₃COHCHCHCH₃]⁺ (δH_f = 490 KJ mol^?1), [CH₃COHC(CH₃)CH₂]⁺ (δH_f = 502 KJ mol^?1), [HOCOHCHCHCH₃]⁺ (δH_f = 330 KJ mol^?1) and [HOCOHC(CH₃)CH₂]⁺ (δH_f = 336 KJ mol^?1).     

Formation of [C18H36]+ ˙ and [C7H7O2]+ in the mass spectrum of n-octadecyl benzoate

A series of deuterium-labeled n-octadecyl benzoates serves to extend the literature using lower homologues for study of the mass-spectral reactions characteristic of alkyl esters. The benzoic acid radical cation (a) arises largely via hydrogen migration from C(2), as expected for the conventional mechanism passing through a six-membered quasicyclic intermediate; the presence of contributions from other processes is simply noted in passing. The octadecene radical cation (b) and protonated benzoic acid (c) arise by paths seemingly closely related to each other but differing from the path dominant for a. The data are rationalized in terms of a reaction sequence passing through two ion-neutral complex intermediates. The first, (d), consists of octadecyl carbenium ion and benzoyloxy radical; the second, (e), consists of octadecene radical cation and benzoic acid. The ionized partner in d appears to undergo none to several hydride migrations, but most prominently one; that in e may dissociate promptly to yield b or may persist, undergoing multiple hydride migrations to effect essentially complete scrambling of hydrogens, before dissociating to yield c. The argument for this mechanistic sequence to form b and c rests basically on its ability to account plausibly for the experimental data, and literature precedents cited for specific aspects of it furnish additional support. The low critical energies and small kinetic energy releases observed in this work are in accord with the characteristics listed by McAdoo for decompositions mediated by ion-neutral complexes, and the selection of an octadecyl, as opposed to a smaller alkyl, ester predisposes the molecule to favor such low-energy processes.     

Structure and formation of gaseous [C4H5O]+ ions. IV—Ions derived from the cyclopropenium ion [C3H3]+

Characterization of [C₄H₅O]⁺ ions in the gas phase using their metastable ion and collisional activation spectra shows that the three isomeric ions HC?C? \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ \mathop {\rm C}\limits^{\rm + } $\end{document}H? OCH₃, CH₃O? \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ \mathop {\rm C}\limits^{\rm + } $\end{document}?C?CH₂ and ? OCH₃ related to the two stable [C₃H₃]⁺ cations [HC?C? CH₂]⁺ and are stable for ≥ 10^?5s. In contrast to the formation of cyclopropenium ions, it is found that the methoxy cyclopropenium ion is not generated from acyclic precursor molecules. The small but significant intensity differences found in the collisional activation spectra of [C₃H₃]⁺ ions generated from HC?C? CH₂I and HC?C? CH₂Cl possibly indicate the presence of [C₃H₃]⁺ ions of different structures.     

Fragmentation of selected C6H10O isomers: Evidence for a common [C5H7O]+ ion generated by methyl loss from cyclohexene oxide and 5,6-dihydro-4-methyl-2H-pyran

The loss of CH₃˙ from the molecular ions of cyclohexene oxide and 5,6-dihydro-4-methyl-2H-pyran has been investigated. On the basis of metastable peak shape analysis, collision-induced dissociation/mass-analysed ion kinetic energy spectra and thermochemical data it is concluded that the same [C₅H₇O]⁺ ion is formed in both cases.     

Gaseous [C2H3O]+ ions

[C₂H₃O]⁺ ions with the initial structures [CH₃CO]⁺, and [CH₂CHO]⁺ cannot be distinguished on the basis of their collisional activation spectra, demonstrating that these isomers interconvert at energies below their threshold for decomposition. Self-protonation of ketene leads to the [CH₃CO]⁺ ion, while the [C₂H₃O]⁺ ion generated from glycerol most probably has the structure of an oxygen protonated ketene [CH₂?C?OH]⁺.     

Collisional activation spectra. Behavior of [C3H7O]+ and other [CnH2n+1O]+ ions

Collisional activation spectra have identified (i) as Stable ion structures. Evidence is presented for a variety of pathway for their formation, including anchimeric assistance and hydrogen migration in less stable isomers. The fragmentation behavior of a number of [C_nH_2n+1O]⁺ isomers of n = 2 to 5 shows that extensive rearrangements are common, but that some reactions appear to be useful for ion structure elucidation. One reaction identified is unusual in that it represents the decomposition of an even-electron ion to yied an odd-electron ion product in significant abundance.     

Competing metastable transitions of the [C7H6F]+ ion

Metastable transitions arising from the loss of C₂H₂ and HF from the [C₇H₆F]⁺ ion have been investigated. Under standard operating conditions, the intensity ratio of the metastable peaks was approximately independent of the precursor of the [C₇H₆F]⁺ ion, indicating fragmentation from a common structure such as the symmetrical fluorotropylium ion. The variation of the intensity ratio with several instrumental parameters suggests that I(C₂H₂ loss)/I(HF loss) rises as the internal energy of the [C₇H₆F]⁺ ion falls. Possible interference from discrimination effects at the β-slit when comparing intensity ratios for first and second field free region are discussed.     

Structural determination of [C7H7O]+ ions in the gas phase by ion cyclotron resonance spectrometry

The [C₇H₇O]⁺ ions from a series of compounds have been studied using ion cyclotron resonance spectrometry. The techniques employed in this gas phase ion structure determination of [C₇H₇O]⁺ were photodissociation, ion-molecule reactions, and collisionally activated dissociation using a Fourier transform mass spectrometer (FTMS-CAD). In addition to the low energy FTMS-CAD results, high energy CAD data obtained with a sector mass spectrometer is also provided. Evidence was found for five unique [C₇H₇O]⁺ structures, including the hydroxybenzyl ion, the hydroxytropylium ion, the protonated benzaldehyde ion, the methylaryloxy ion and the phenyl methylene ether ion. Ion-molecule reactions, invovling both proton transfer and methylene transfer, provided the most unambiguous results and yielded qualitative and quantitative evidence for the five structures. However, a combined approach using the three techniques was necessary to identify all of the structures. The tropylium form of [C₇H₇O]⁺ was found to absorb strongly at 305 nm, while the protonated benzaldehyde ion was found to have a strong absorption band at 305 nm and a weak band at 370 nm. The proton affinity of 2,4,6-cycloheptatrienone was determined to be 918±8 kJ mol^?1, which is considerably lower than a previously reported value. In addition, deprotonation reactions of the methylaryloxy ion yielded a proton affinity of 871±14 kJ mol^?1 for 4-methylenecyclohexa-2,6-diene-1-one.     

The structures and formation of [C4H6N]+ ions 2—ion structures derived from 2-methylpropanenitrile

The loss of a hydrogen atom from ionized 2-methylpropanenitrile is preceded by a drastic rearrangement of the molecular ion. The result of this fragmentation is the generation of two stable structurally different [C₄H₆N]⁺ ions, formed via different pathways. Their structures can be established by a careful comparison of the metastable ion spectra, collision activation spectra, and charge stripping spectra from the compound and its three deuterium labeled analogues and from [C₄H₆N]⁺ ions generated from reference compounds via electron impact ionization or in selected ion/molecule reactions.     

The decompositions of metastable [C4H8O]+˙ ions and the [C4H8O]+˙ potential surface

Collisionally activated decomposition (CA) spectra of [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions and the products of their metastable decompositions are used to refine a previously presented picture of the reactions of [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions. Metastable [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ isomers predominantly rearrange to the 2-butanone ion and decompose by loss of methyl and ethyl, although up to 38% of the methyl losses take place by other pathways to form \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ {\rm{CH}}_{\rm{2}} = {\rm{CHCH = }}\mathop {\rm{O}}\limits^{\rm{ + }} {\rm{H}}{\rm{.}} $\end{document} . The CA spectra of many of the [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions with the oxygen on the first carbon are very similar, consistent with those ions isomerizing largely to common structures before or after collision. However, several of these ions have unique CA spectra, so they must remain structurally distinct from the majority of the [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions below energies required for decomposition. The CA spectra of ions with the oxygen on the second carbon are distinct from those of ions with the oxygen on the first carbon, so there is limited interconversion of the non-decomposing forms of the two types of ions. A potential energy diagram for the reactions of metastable [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions is constructed from appearance energy measurements. As would be expected, the relative importances of most of the [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ isomerizations seem to be inversely related to the activation energies for those processes. Some parallels between the isomerizations of [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions and those of related ions are pointed out.     

Metastable [C4H8O]+˙ ions: Additional decompositions via the [2-butanone]+˙ ion

The losses of methyl and ethyl through the intermediacy of the [2-butanone]⁺˙ ion are shown to be the dominant metastable decomposition of 14 of 19 [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions examined. The ions that decompose via the [2-butanone]⁺˙ structure include ionized aldehydes, unsaturated and cyclic alcohols and enolic ions. [Cyclic ether]⁺˙ [cyclopropylmethanol]⁺˙ and [2-methyl-1-propen-1-ol]⁺˙ ions do not decompose through ionized 2-butanone. The rearrangements of various [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions the the 2-butanone ion were investigated by means of deuterium labeling. Those pathways involve up to eight steps. Ions with the oxygen on the end carbon rearrange to a common structure or mixture of structures. Those ions which ultimately rearrange to the [2-butanone]⁺˙ ion then undergo oxygen shifts from the terminal to the second and third carbons at about equal rates. However, this oxygen shift does not precede the losses of water and ethylene. Losses of water and ethylene were unimportant for ions with the oxygen initially on the second carbon. Ionized n-butanal and cyclobutanol, but not other [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ ions, undergo reversible hydrogen exchange between the oxygen and the terminal carbon. Rearrangement of ionized n-butanal to the [cyclobutanol]⁺˙ ion is postulated.     

Molecular states formed by ion beam neutralization of [C2H2]+ and [C2H3]+ on metal targets

A combination of charge-stripping and beam-scattering techniques has been used to study the molecular states formed when a fast beam of [C₂H₂]⁺ and [C₂H₃]⁺ in several isotopic forms are neutralized by electron transfer from metal target atoms (K, Na, Mg and Zn). For [C₂H₃]⁺ the isotopic compositions and relative abundances of product states were found to be insensitive to the method of ion preparation (electron impact and chemical ionization). Ground state neutrals are formed in partial abundance when Mg or Zn is used as a target atom. With low ionization potential targets (K and Na) excitel dissociative states of C₂H₂ and C₂H₃ are formed as major beam constituents. For these states decomposition products have been identified and fragmentation energies measured. The excited states of C₂H₂ and C₂H₃ lie alout 6.8 eV and 2.9 eV, respectively, above their stable ground states. The discussion focuses on the possible identity of the excited states and their structural relations to the precursor ions.     

1,2-Carbon shifts in [C4H8O]+˙ and [C5H10O]+˙ ions

Present results demonstrate that α,β-shifts of the functional group carbon strongly dominate β,α-methyl shifts in [C₄H₈O]⁺˙ and [C₅H₁₀O]⁺˙ ions, paralleling observations of others on methyl isobutyrate ions.     

Metastable ion studies. IV—thermochemistry and ion structures among fragmenting [C3H6]+· ions

Metastable ion peak shapes, dimensions and relative abundances have been measured for the three fragmentations [C₃H₆]⁺· → [C₃H₄]⁺· + H₂, [C₃H₆]⁺· → [C₃H₅]⁺ + H· and [C₃H₆]⁺· → [C₃H₃]⁺ + H₂ + H·. [C₃H₆]⁺· ions were derived from propene, cyclopropane, tetrahydrofuran, cyclohexanone, 2-methyl but-1-ene and cis-pent-2-ene. Activation energies for these fragmentations have been evaluated. Three daughter ion dissociations ([C₃H₅]⁺ → [C₃H₃]⁺ + H₂, [C₃H₅]⁺ → [C₃H₄]⁺· + H· and [C₃H₄]⁺· → [C₃H₃]⁺ + H·) have been similarly examined. Ion structures have been determined and the metastable energy releases have been correlated with the thermochemical data. It is concluded that the molecular ions of propene and cyclopropane become structurally indistinguishable prior to fragmentation and that differences in their metastable ion characteristics can be ascribed wholly to internal energy differences; the latter can be correlated with the photoelectron spectra of the isomers. The pathway for the consecutive fragmentation which generates the metastable ion peak (m/e 42 → m/e.39) has been shown to be It is likewise concluded that fragmentating [C₃H₆]⁺· ions generated from the various precursor molecules are also structurally indistinguishable and cannot be classified with either molecular ion of the isomeric C₃H₆ hydrocarbons.     

Energy partitioning in the metastable fragmentation [C3H7]+ → [C3H5]+ + H2

The dish-topped metastable peak for the fragmentation [C₃H₇]⁺ → [allyl]⁺ + H₂ is generated by the threshold fragmentation. The fraction of the reverse activation energy which is partitioned as translational energy of the products is 0.9 ± 0.1. It is proposed that a similar partitioning coefficient applies to the excess internal energy above threshold.