Propensity rules for inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy of single-molecule transport junctions

Using a perturbative approach to simple model systems, we derive useful propensity rules for inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) of molecular wire junctions. We examine the circumstances under which this spectroscopy (that has no rigorous selection rules) obeys well defined propensity rules based on the molecular symmetry and on the topology of the molecule in the junction. Focusing on conjugated molecules of C(2h) symmetry, semiquantitative arguments suggest that the IETS is dominated by a(g) vibrations in the high energy region and by out of plane modes (a(u) and b(g)) in the low energy region. Realistic computations verify that the proposed propensity rules are strictly obeyed by medium to large-sized conjugated molecules but are subject to some exceptions when small molecules are considered. The propensity rules facilitate the use of IETS to help characterize the molecular geometry within the junction.     

Chemical imaging of single 4,7,12,15-tetrakis[2.2]paracyclophane by spatially resolved vibrational spectroscopy

Single 4,7,12,15-tetrakis[2.2]paracyclophane were deposited on NiAl(110) surface at 11 K. Two adsorbed species with large and small conductivities were detected by the scanning tunneling microscope (STM). Their vibrational properties were investigated by inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) with the STM. Five vibrational modes were observed for the species with the larger conductivity. The spatially resolved vibrational images for the modes show striking differences, depending on the coupling of the vibrations localized on different functional groups within the molecule to the electronic states of the molecule. The vibrational modes are assigned on the basis of ab initio calculations. No IETS signal is resolved from the species with the small conductivity.     

Phenyl species formation and preferential hydrogen abstraction in the decomposition of chemisorbed benzoate on Cu(110)

The adsorption and decomposition of benzoic acid on the Cu(110) surface has been investigated using temperature-programmed reaction (TPR) spectroscopy and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). The benzoate species is found to exist in two conformations--a phase containing upright species at monolayer saturation and a phase containing many lying-down species at lower coverages. Thermal decomposition begins to occur near 500 K, yielding benzene and CO(2). It is found that phenyl species, generated preferentially from the lying-down benzoate species, efficiently abstract H atoms from undecomposed benzoate species to produce benzene in a rate-controlling process with an activation energy of about 29 kcal/mol. Using deuterium-atom substitution at the 4-C position on the benzoate ring it is found that the hydrogen-abstraction reaction is selective for 2,3 and 5,6 C-H bonds. This observation indicates that the mobile phenyl species is surface bound and preferentially attacks C-H bonds which are nearest the Cu surface and bind the benzoate species as either an upright species or a tilted species.     

Chemisorbed benzoate-to-benzene conversion via phenyl radicals on Cu(110): kinetic observation of conformational effects

The adsorption and decomposition of benzoic acid on the Cu(110) surface has been investigated using temperature-programmed reaction (TPR) spectroscopy and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). The benzoate species is found to exist in two conformations: a phase containing upright species at monolayer saturation and a phase containing many tilted species at lower coverages. Thermal decomposition begins to occur near 500 K, yielding benzene and CO2. It is found that phenyl radicals, generated preferentially from the tilted benzoate species, efficiently abstract H atoms from undecomposed benzoate species to produce benzene in a rate-controlling process with an activation energy of about 29 kcal/mol. Using deuterium atom substitution at the 4-C position on the benzoate ring, it is found that the hydrogen abstraction reaction is selective for 2-,3- and 5-,6-C-H bonds. This observation indicates that the mobile phenyl radical is surface bound and preferentially attacks C-H bonds which are nearest the Cu surface binding the benzoate species, either as an upright species or as a tilted species.     

Inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy by STM of phonons at solid surfaces and interfaces

Inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) combined with scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) allows the acquisition of vibrational signals at surfaces. In STM-IETS, a tunneling electron may excite a vibration, and opens an inelastic channel in parallel with the elastic one, giving rise to a change in conductivity of the STM junction. Until recently, the application of STM-IETS was limited to the localized vibrations of single atoms and molecules adsorbed on surfaces. The theory of the STM-IETS spectrum in such cases has been established. For the collective lattice dynamics, i.e., phonons, however, features of STM-IETS spectrum have not been understood well, though in principle STM-IETS should also be capable of detecting phonons. In this review, we present STM-IETS investigations for surface and interface phonons and provide a theoretical analysis. We take surface phonons on Cu(1?1?0) and interfacial phonons relevant to graphene on SiC substrate as illustrative examples. In the former, we provide a theoretical formalism about the inelastic phonon excitations by tunneling electrons based on the nonequilibrium Green’s function (NEGF) technique applied to a model Hamiltonian constructed in momentum space for both electrons and phonons. In the latter case, we discuss the experimentally observed spatial dependence of the STM-IETS spectrum and link it to local excitations of interfacial phonons based on ab-initio STM-IETS simulation.     

Direct STM investigation of cinchona alkaloid adsorption on Cu(III)

Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) combined with cyclic voltammetry has been employed to investigate the adsorption of cinchonine on Cu(111). Similar to cinchonidine, cinchonine forms a long-range ordered adlayer with (4 x 4) symmetry on the substrate. The structural details on molecular adsorption were obtained by high-resolution STM images. On the basis of the previous results and obtained STM images, the quinoline ring is proposed to lie parallel to Cu(111) and serve as an anchoring group. The chiral quinuclidine moiety extends out of the surface to facilitate the interaction with the prochiral reactants.     

Inelastic tunneling spectroscopy using scanning tunneling microscopy on trans-2-butene molecule: spectroscopy and mapping of vibrational feature

Inelastic tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) measurement using scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) with a commercially available STM set up is presented. The STM-IETS spectrum measured on an isolated trans-2-butene molecule on the Pd(110) shows a clear vibrational feature in d2I/dV2 at the bias voltage of 360 mV and -363 mV, which corresponds to the nu(C-H) mode (d2I/dV2 approximately 10 nA/V2). In addition, we have obtained an image by mapping the vibrational feature of nu(C-H) in d2I/dV2. The image is obtained by scanning the tip on the surface with the feedback loop activated while the modulation voltage is superimposed on the sample voltage. With the method that is readily performable with conventional software, we have clearly differentiated the molecules of trans-2-butene and butadiene through the mapping of the vibrational feature, demonstrating its capability of chemical identification in atomic scale.     

Vibrations of a single adsorbed organic molecule: anharmonicity matters!

Vibrational spectroscopy is a powerful tool to identify molecules and to characterise their chemical state. Inelastic electron tunnelling spectroscopy (IETS) combined with scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) allows the application of vibrational analysis to a single molecule. Up to now, IETS was restricted to small species due to the complexity of vibration spectra for larger molecules. We extend the horizon of IETS for both experiment and theory by measuring the STM-IETS spectra of mercaptopyridine adsorbed on the (111) surface of gold and comparing it to theoretical spectra. Such complex spectra with more than 20 lines can be reliably determined and computed leading to completely new insights. Experimentally, the vibrational spectra exhibit a dependence on the specific adsorption site of the molecules. Theoretically, this dependence is only accessible if anharmonic contributions to the interaction potentials are included. These joint experimental and theoretical advances open new perspectives for structure determination of organic adlayers.     

Scanning tunneling microscopy, orbital-mediated tunneling spectroscopy, and ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy of metal(II) tetraphenylporphyrins deposited from vapor.

Thin films of vapor-deposited Ni(II) and Co(II) complexes of tetraphenylporphyrin (NiTPP and CoTPP) were studied supported on gold and embedded in Al-Al(2)O(3)-MTPP-Pb tunnel diodes, where M = Ni or Co. Thin films deposited onto polycrystalline gold were analyzed by ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS) using He I radiation. Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and orbital-mediated tunneling spectroscopy (STM-OMTS) were performed on submonolayer films of CoTPP and NiTPP supported on Au(111). Inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) and OMTS were measured in conventional tunnel diode structures. The highest occupied pi molecular orbital of the porphyrin ring was seen in both STM-OMTS and UPS at about 6.4 eV below the vacuum level. The lowest unoccupied pi molecular orbital of the porphyrin ring was observed by STM-OMTS and by IETS-OMTS to be located near 3.4 eV below the vacuum level. The OMTS spectra of CoTPP had a band near 5.2 eV (below the vacuum level) that was attributed to transient oxidation of the central Co(II) ion. That is, it is due to electron OMT via the half-filled d(z)(2) orbital present in Co(II) of CoTPP. The NiTPP OMTS spectra show no such band, consistent with the known difficulty of oxidation of the Ni(II) ion. The STM-based OMTS allowed these two porphyrin complexes to be easily distinguished. The present work is the first report of the observation of STM-OMTS, tunnel junction OMTS, and UPS of the same compounds. Scanning tunneling microscope-based orbital-mediated tunneling provides more information than UPS or tunnel junction-based OMTS and does so with molecular-scale resolution.     

An in situ STM and DTS study of the extremely pure [EMIM]FAP/Au(111) interface

Herein the structure of the interfacial layer between the air- and water-stable ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tris(pentafluoroethyl)trifluorophosphate ([EMIM]FAP) and Au(111) is investigated using in situ scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), distance tunneling spectroscopy (DTS) and cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurements. The in situ STM measurements reveal that structured interfacial layers can be probed in both cathodic and anodic regimes at the IL/Au(111) interface. The structure of these layers is dependent on the applied electrode potential, the number of subsequent STM scans and the scan rate. Furthermore, first DTS results show that the tunneling barrier during the 1st STM scan does not seem to change significantly in the cathodic potential regime between the ocp (-0.2 V) and -2.0 V.     

Adsorption and coordination of tartaric acid enantiomers on Cu(111) in aqueous solution

Chiral modifiers have gained much attention because they can induce high enantioselectivity on reactive metal surface in heterogeneous enantioselective catalysis. The high enantioselectivity is attributed to that the chirality of modifiers is bestowed onto the metal surface upon adsorption. Much study on the adsorption of modifiers on metal surface has been performed in an ultrahigh vacuum. In this paper, the adsorption of tartaric acid on Cu(111) has been studied by electrochemical scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) in aqueous solution. It is found that (R,R)-tartaric acid and (S,S)-tartaric acid can form a well-ordered adlayer on the Cu(111) surface with a (4 x 4) symmetry. A dimeric structure is proposed in the temporary model from STM observation.     

Two-dimensional polymer formation on surfaces: insight into the roles of precursor mobility and reactivity

We report on a combined scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and density functional theory (DFT) study on the surface-assisted assembly of the hexaiodo-substituted macrocycle cyclohexa-m-phenylene (CHP) toward covalently bonded polyphenylene networks on Cu(111), Au(111), and Ag(111) surfaces. STM and XPS indicate room temperature dehalogenation of CHP on either surface, leading to surface-stabilized CHP radicals (CHPRs) and coadsorbed iodine. Subsequent covalent intermolecular bond formation between CHPRs is thermally activated and is found to proceed at different temperatures on the three coinage metals. The resulting polyphenylene networks differ significantly in morphology on the three substrates: On Cu, the networks are dominated by "open" branched structures, on the Au surface a mixture of branched and small domains of compact network clusters are observed, and highly ordered and dense polyphenylene networks form on the Ag surface. Ab initio DFT calculations allow one to elucidate the diffusion and coupling mechanisms of CHPRs on the Cu(111) and Ag(111) surfaces. On Cu, the energy barrier for diffusion is significantly higher than the one for covalent intermolecular bond formation, whereas on Ag the reverse relation holds. By using a Monte Carlo simulation, we show that different balances between diffusion and intermolecular coupling determine the observed branched and compact polyphenylene networks on the Cu and Ag surface, respectively, demonstrating that the choice of the substrate plays a crucial role in the formation of two-dimensional polymers.     

Local chemical reaction of benzene on Cu110 via STM-induced excitation

We have investigated the mechanism of the chemical reaction of the benzene molecule adsorbed on Cu(110) surface induced by the injection of tunneling electrons using scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). With the dosing of tunneling electrons of the energy 2-5 eV from the STM tip to the molecule, we have detected the increase of the height of the benzene molecule by 40% in the STM image and the appearance of the vibration feature of the nu(C-H) mode in the inelastic tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) spectrum. It can be understood with a model in which the dissociation of C-H bonds occurs in a benzene molecule that induces a bonding geometry change from flat-lying to up-right configuration, which follows the story of the report of Lauhon and Ho on the STM-induced change of benzene on the Cu(100) surface. [L. J. Lauhon and W. Ho, J. Phys. Chem. A 104, 2463 (2000)]. The reaction probability shows a sharp rise at the sample bias voltage at 2.4 V, which saturates at 3.0 V, which is followed by another sharp rise at the voltage of 4.3 V. No increase of the reaction yield is observed for the negative sample voltage up to 5 eV. In the case of a fully deuterated benzene molecule, it shows the onset at the same energy of 2.4 eV, but the reaction probability is 10(3) smaller than the case of the normal benzene molecule. We propose a model in which the dehydrogenation of the benzene molecule is induced by the formation of the temporal negative ion due to the trapping of the electrons at the unoccupied resonant states formed by the pi orbitals. The existence of the resonant level close to the Fermi level ( approximately 2.4 eV) and multiple levels in less than approximately 5 eV from the Fermi level, indicates a fairly strong interaction of the Cu-pi(*) state of the benzene molecule. We estimated that the large isotope effect of approximately 10(3) can be accounted for with the Menzel-Gomer-Redhead (MGR) model with an assumption of a shallow potential curve for the excited state.     

CoPc adsorption on Cu(111): Origin of the C4 to C2 symmetry reduction

The adsorption of phthalocyanines (Pc) to various surfaces has recently been reported to lead to a lowering of symmetry from C4 to C2 in scanning tunneling microscope (STM) images. Possible origins of the reduced symmetry involve the electronic structure or geometric deformation of the molecules. Here, the origin of the reduction is clarified from a comprehensive theoretical study of CoPc adsorbed on the Cu(111) surface along with the experimental STM data. Total energy calculations using different schemes for the exchange-correlation energy and STM simulations are compared against experimental data. We find that the symmetry reduction is only reproduced when van der Waals corrections are included into the formalism. It is caused by a deformation along the two perpendicular molecular axes, one of them coming closer to the surface by around 0.2 A?. An electronic structure analysis reveals (i) the relevance of the CoPc interaction with the Cu(111) surface state and (ii) that intramolecular features in dI/dV maps clearly discriminate a Co-derived state from the rest of the Pc states.     

Adsorbed structures of 4,4'-bipyridine on Cu(111) in acid studied by STM and IR

The adsorption of 4,4'-bipyridine (BiPy) on Cu(111) has been investigated in 0.1 M HClO4 by cyclic voltammetry, electrochemical scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), and surface-enhanced infrared adsorption spectroscopy (SEIRAS). Cyclic voltammetry showed the double layer region extending from -0.2 to 0.26 V and a pair of redox waves superposing on hydrogen evolution wave at more negative potentials. Diprotonated BiPy, BiPyH2(2+), is adsorbed flat on the Cu(111) (1 x 1) surface and forms a well-ordered monolayer with a (3 x 4) symmetry in the double-layer potential region. At more negative potential, BiPyH2(2+) is reduced to its monocation radical, BiPyH2(*+), and forms another well-ordered structure in which the radicals are stacked in molecular rows with a face-to-face self-dimer as the building unit. The SEIRA spectra of both BiPyH2(2+) and BiPyH2(*+) are dominated by gerade modes which should be IR-inactive for the centrosymmetric species. The breakdown of the selection rule of IR absorption is ascribed to the vibronic coupling associated with charge transfer between BiPyH2(2+) and the surface and between the radicals.     

Oxygen-promoted synthesis of armchair graphene nanoribbons on Cu(111)

We report the systematic investigation of the effects of oxygen on the synthesis of 3 p sub-family armchair graphene nanoribbons(3 p-AGNRs),which revealed a strong catalytic effect with a reduction in the reaction temperature by approximately 180 K without degradation of the AGNRs.Poly(para-phenylene)(3-AGNR)was generated through Ullmann-type coupling of4,4’’-dibromo-p-terphenyl on Cu(111),which was then converted into wider 3 p-AGNRs via lateral fusion.Scanning tunneling microscopy(STM)and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy demonstrated the formation of different ribbons up to 12-AGNR,which contained regions exhibiting increased STM contrast that we attribute to the intercalation of Br atoms during lateral fusion.     

Molecular aggregation within self-ordered monolayers.

The monolayer growth of pyrimido-pentaphenylbenzene (NPB) on Cu(111) is investigated by means of low-temperature scanning tunneling microscopy (LT-STM). The pyrimidine side group gives rise to a pronounced resonant tunneling state and, furthermore, affects molecular self-ordering. Different molecular aggregates are formed inside the hexagonal closed packed monolayer. A structure model for the monolayer is proposed and the temperature dependence of this self-ordering process is investigated by varying the preparation temperature between 270 and 370 K. The intermolecular bonding of the aggregates is demonstrated by STM manipulation experiments. Moreover, different aggregations of the molecules induce characteristic energy shifts in the resonant tunneling state, as revealed by means of scanning tunneling spectroscopy.     

Self-assembled monolayers on Pt(111): molecular packing structure and strain effects observed by scanning tunneling microscopy

Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of octanethiol and benzeneethanethiol were deposited on clean Pt(111) surfaces in ultrahigh vacuum (UHV). Highly resolved images of these SAMs produced by an in situ scanning tunneling microscope (STM) showed that both systems organize into a super-structure mosaic of domains of locally ordered, closely packed molecules. Analysis of the STM images indicated a (square root 3 x square root 3)R30 degrees unit cell for the octanethiol SAMs and a 4(square root 3 x square root 3)R30 degrees periodicity based on 2 x 2 basic molecular packing for the benzeneethanethiol SAMs under the coverage conditions investigated. SAMs on Pt(111) exhibited differences in molecular packing and a lower density of disordered regions than SAMs on Au(111). Electron transport measurements were performed using scanning tunneling spectroscopy. Benzeneethanethiol/Pt(111) junctions exhibited a higher conductance than octanethiol/Pt(111) junctions.     

Chiral structures of 6,12-dibromochrysene on Au(111) and Cu(111) surfaces

Nanoscale low-dimensional chiral architectures are increasingly receiving scientific interest, because of their potential applications in many fields such as chiral recognition, separation and transformation. Using 6,12-dibromochrysene (DBCh), we successfully constructed and characterized the large-area two-dimensional chiral networks on Au(111) and one-dimensional metal-liganded chiral chains on Cu(111) respectively. The reasons and processes of chiral transformation of chiral networks on Au(111) were analyzed. We used scanning tunneling spectroscopy (STS) to analyze the electronic state information of this chiral structure. This work combines scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) with non-contact atomic force microscopy (nc-AFM) techniques to achieve ultra-high-resolution characterization of chiral structures on low-dimensional surfaces, which may be applied to the bond analysis of functional nanofilms. Density functional theory (DFT) was used to simulate the adsorption behavior of the molecular and energy analysis in order to verify the experimental results.     

Conformation Controls Mobility: 2H-Tetranaphthylporphyrins on Cu(111)

The adsorption behavior and the mobility of 2H-Tetranaphthylporphyrin (2HTNP) on Cu(111) was investigated by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) at room temperature (RT). The molecules adsorb, like the structurally related 2HTPP, in the “inverted” structure with the naphthyl plane restricted to an orientation parallel to the Cu surface. The orientation of the four naphthyl groups yields altogether 16 possible conformations. Due to the existence of rotamer pairs, 10 different appearances are expected on the surface, and all of them are identified by STM at RT. Most interestingly, the orientation of the naphthyl groups significantly influences the diffusion behavior of the molecules on Cu(111). We identify three different groups of conformers, which are either immobile, medium or fast diffusing at RT. The mobility seems to decrease with increasing size of the footprint of the conformers on the surface.