Development of a proficiency testing scheme for a limited number of participants in the field of natural water analysis

A proficiency testing (PT) scheme was developed for a limited number of analytical laboratories participating in the analysis of natural water in Israel. Three fit-for-intended-use reference materials (RMs) were prepared for a pilot PT from natural water: RM-blank and two in-house reference materials (IHRMs) with seven analytes fortified to achieve different levels of analyte concentrations. The measurands for the PT participants were the traceable spike values certified in the IHRMs, i.e., added mass concentrations of the analytes. The RM-blank and IHRMs were found to be homogeneous and stable over 11 days, the time necessary for the experimental part of the PT. The RMs were distributed to the PT participants as unknown test items similar to routine samples. The test results were evaluated using their deviations from the IHRM-certified values. Eight Israeli laboratories took part in the interlaboratory comparison. Individual laboratory performance and metrological compatibility of the PT results of the participants, as a local group of laboratories, were evaluated for every analyte.     

Preparation and characterization for mineral elements and total dietary fiber and testing for stability of β-carotene of an ARC/CL carrot powder multipurpose candidate reference material

As part of the analytical assurance system of the FAO European Cooperative Research Network on Trace Elements programme an ARC/CL-coded carrot flakes powder (CFP) candidate reference material (RM) has been prepared from a lot of commercial carrot flakes. The candidate RM has been homogenized using a Robot Coupe blender fitted with titanium blades, carefully homogenized in large teflon/polypropylene containers, bottled in 1000 numbered polyethylene containers (20 g samples) and tested for homogeneity. Interlaboratory comparison studies for 9 essential elements, cadmium and total dietary fiber (TDF) based on the AOAC-method resulted in the characterization of the contents of those compounds in the above material. After exclusion of outliers, mean values from at least nine different laboratories based altogether on three independent analytical principles have been used to calculate the recommended concentration ranges for mineral elements. Testing of homogeneity and stability for β-carotene over a period of one year has been additionally carried out. The mean water content in the material amounted to 4.97% and remained stable over a one-year period. Homogeneity of the RM was within 3.0% for almost all included mineral elements as tested for a sample size of 0.5 g. The 95% confidence limits for the mean values of the established recommended concentrations of mineral elements in the present ARC/CL Carrot Powder candidate RM fell within 5% for all the other elements and TDF except for Fe (6.3%) and B (5.7%). The stability of β-carotene in the present candidate RM stored in darkness over a one-year period at room temperature was within 6.3%.     

Characterization of a wheat flour reference material (ARC/CL) for twelve elements

Summary An ARC/CL coded wheat flour reference material (ARC/CL RM) with established recommended concentration values for 12 elements [1,2] was further characterized for P, K and Cr contents by means of an intercomparison study. Minor corrections were made to earlier recommended values in accordance with new results obtained. Fifteen laboratories using a total of 11 methods based on six entirely different analytical principles participated in the intercomparison study. The medians and standard deviations were calculated for the results of the intercomparison study. After rejecting as outliers values falling outside the median ± sd, the present recommended values were obtained by recalculating the median and 95% confidence limits. Recommended values were established for the major elements Ca, K, Mg, P, the minor elements Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, and the trace elements Mo, Cr, Ni and Se. The relative standard deviations for the 95% confidence limits of the medians were lower than 10% for major and minor elements, 11% for Mo and 18% for Cr. All of the recommended concentration values fell into category A, having a high degree of confidence. The present RM, with its 16 recommended concentrations, is of value for use in nutritional, food composition and contaminant monitoring studies.     

A review of proficiency testing scheme in Republic of Korea: in the field of water analysis

For regulatory purposes, it is often required to check the quality of environmental chemical analyses by routine proficiency testing (PT). In this study, the PT scheme of environmental laboratories in Republic of Korea has been reviewed. Especially, real water-based reference materials (RMs) were prepared and distributed for PT schemes. The consensus values from the PT were calculated by robust statistics with its standard uncertainties. The relative bias between the reference values and the consensus values was used as one of the indicators for the determination of the assigned values. The relationship between the performances of the laboratories, expressed by Z scores, and the concentration levels of the RMs were also revealed.     

Characterization of ARC/CL wheat flour, pork meat and skim milk powder reference materials for contents of toxic elements

Summary Wheat flour, pork meat and skim milk powder reference materials (RM) prepared and employed for the activities of the Sub-network on Trace Element Status in Food of the FAO European Cooperative Research Network on Trace Elements were subjected to an interlaboratory comparison study on the contents of Pb, Cd and Hg. The homogeneity of the above materials had earlier been shown to be within 2% for several essential elements and within 5 to 10% for Pb and Cd. An interlaboratory comparison study was conducted involving 17 reference laboratories recognized for their reliability and specialized in heavy metal determinations in biological materials. A total of seven methods based on four different analytical principles were employed to determine the contents of the above heavy metals. After the exclusion of outliers, the recommended concentration values expressed as the medians ±95% confidence limits were established. All of the recommended values reported here fell into category A, i.e. values recommended with a high degree of confidence according to the certification criteria established by Pszonicki. The present materials contain very low naturally occurring levels of all the heavy metals studied and have been successfully employed in the analytical quality control program of the above FAO study during the past five years.     

Comparability of reference values

Summary Harmonization of certified values in Reference Materials (RMs) can be carried out by applying nuclear analytical techniques to RMs of various matrix types and concentration levels. Although RMs generally should not be used as primary standards the cross evaluation of concentrations in RMs leads to better compatibility of reference values and thus to a greater agreement between analytical results from different laboratories using these RMs for instrument calibration and quality assurance.     

Performance evaluation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons analysis in sediment from proficiency testing with metrological reference values

This paper describes a metrological approach to evaluate the measurement capability of laboratories participating in two proficiency testing (PT) programmes involving the analysis of five polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in sediment samples. Reference values of PAHs in the programmes for performance assessment were obtained from an accurate isotope dilution gas chromatography mass spectrometry (ID-GCMS) method which was thoroughly validated and verified. Isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IDMS) technique usually has a well-defined measurement uncertainty budget and a traceability link to an International System of Units. Provision of the metrological reference values in PT enables the establishment of a technical platform to assess the actual competence of the participating laboratories in sediment PAHs analysis. Results of the PT programmes showed that about 80 % of the laboratories employed gas chromatography in their analyses and the remaining used liquid chromatography. Irrespective of the techniques being used, however, the majority of the participating laboratories were observed to underestimate values in which the mean values of the five reported PAHs were less than those of the ID-GCMS-derived reference values by 13–20 %. Only 41–44 % of the participating laboratories were able to achieve satisfactory z-scores. The present study revealed that the reinforcement of the capability for accurate measurement of PAHs in sediment samples in laboratories worldwide should be addressed.     

Measurements for certification of chlortetracycline reference materials within the European Union Standards, Measurements and Testing programme

The experimental design of a material certification programme is described. The matrix reference materials (RMs) comprised chlortetracycline (CTC)-containing and CTC-free lyophilised porcine liver, kidney and muscle produced under the European Commission's Standards Measurements and Testing (SMT) programme. The aim of the certification programme was to determine accurately and precisely the concentration of CTC and 4-epi-chlortetracycline (epi-CTC) contained in the RMs. A multi-laboratory approach was used to certify analyte concentrations. Participants (n = 19) were instructed to strictly adhere to previously established guidelines. Following the examination of analytical performance criteria, statistical manipulation of results submitted by 13 laboratories, (6 withdrew) allowed an estimate to be made of the true value of the analyte content. The Nalimov test was used for detection of outlying results. The Cochran and Bartlett tests were employed for testing the homogeneity of variances. The normality of results distribution was tested according to the Kolmogorov-Smirnov-Lilliefors test. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was employed to calculate the within and between-laboratory standard deviations, the overall mean and confidence interval for the CTC and epi-CTC content of each of the RMs. Certified values were within or very close to the target concentration ranges specified in the SMT contract. These studies have demonstrated the successful production and certification of CTC-containing and CTC-free porcine RMs.     

Measurements for certification of chlortetracycline reference materials within the European Union Standards, Measurements and Testing programme

The experimental design of a material certification programme is described. The matrix reference materials (RMs) comprised chlortetracycline (CTC)-containing and CTC-free lyophilised porcine liver, kidney and muscle produced under the European Commission’s Standards Measurements and Testing (SMT) programme. The aim of the certification programme was to determine accurately and precisely the concentration of CTC and 4-epi-chlortetracycline (epi-CTC) contained in the RMs. A multi-laboratory approach was used to certify analyte concentrations. Participants (n = 19) were instructed to strictly adhere to previously established guidelines. Following the examination of analytical performance criteria, statistical manipulation of results submitted by 13 laboratories, (6 withdrew) allowed an estimate to be made of the true value of the analyte content. The Nalimov test was used for detection of outlying results. The Cochran and Bartlett tests were employed for testing the homogeneity of variances. The normality of results distribution was tested according to the Kolmogorov-Smirnov-Lilliefors test. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was employed to calculate the within and between-laboratory standard deviations, the overall mean and confidence interval for the CTC and epi-CTC content of each of the RMs. Certified values were within or very close to the target concentration ranges specified in the SMT contract. These studies have demonstrated the successful production and certification of CTC-containing and CTC-free porcine RMs.     

New insights on the photophysical behavior of PRODAN in anionic and cationic reverse micelles: from which state or states does it emit?

6-propionyl-2-(N,N-dimethyl)aminonaphtahalene, PRODAN, is widely used as a fluorescent molecular probe because of its significant Stokes shift in polar solvents. It is an aromatic compound with intramolecular charge-transfer states (ICT) that can be particularly useful as a sensor. The nature of the emissive states has not yet been established despite the detailed experimental and theoretical investigations done on this fluorophore. In this work, we performed absorption, steady-state, time-resolved fluorescence (TRES) and time-resolved area normalized emission (TRANES) spectroscopies on the molecular probe PRODAN in the anionic water/sodium 1,4-bis-2-ethylhexylsulfosuccinate (AOT)/n-heptane and the cationic water/benzyl-n-hexadecyl dimethylammonium chloride (BHDC)/benzene reverse micelles (RMs). The experiments were done by varying the surfactant concentrations at a fixed molar ratio (W = [H2O]/[Surfactant]) and changing the water content at a constant surfactant concentration. The results obtained varying the surfactant concentration at W = 0 show a bathochromic shift and an increase in the intensity of the PRODAN emission band due to the PRODAN partition process between the external solvent and the RMs interface. The partition constants, Kp, are quantified from the changes in the PRODAN emission spectra and the steady-state anisotropy () with the surfactant concentration in both RMs. The Kp value is larger in the BHDC than the AOT RMs, probably due to the interaction between the cationic polar head of the surfactant and the aromatic ring of PRODAN. The partition process is confirmed with the TRES experiments, where the data fit to a continuous model, and with the time-resolved area normalized emission spectroscopy (TRANES) spectra, where only one isoemissive point is detected. On the other hand, the emission spectra at W = 10 and 20 show a dual fluorescence with a new band that emerges in the low-energy region of the spectra, a band that was previously assigned to the PRODAN emission from the water pool of RMs. Our studies demonstrate that this band is due to the emission from an ICT state of the molecular probe PRODAN located at the interface of the RMs. These results are also confirmed by the lifetime measurements, the TRES experiments where the results fit to a two-state model, and the time-resolved area normalized emission spectroscopy (TRANES) spectra where three or two isoemissive points are detected in the AOT and BHDC RMs, respectively. In the AOT RMs, Kp values obtained at W = 10 and 20 are almost independent of the water content; the values are higher for the BHDC RMs due to the higher micropolarity of this interface.     

Laboratory effects models for interlaboratory comparisons

The statistical analysis of results from inter-laboratory comparisons (for example Key Comparisons, or Supplemental Comparisons) produces an estimate of the measurand (reference value) and statements of equivalence of the results from the participating laboratories. Methods to estimate the reference value have been proposed that rest on the idea of finding a so-called consistent subset of laboratories, that is, eliminating allegedly outlying participants. We propose an alternative statistical model that accommodates all participant data and incorporates the dispersion of the measurement values obtained by different laboratories into the total uncertainty of the various estimates. This model recognizes the fact that the dispersion of values between laboratories often is substantially larger than the measurement uncertainties provided by the participating laboratories. We illustrate the methods on data from key comparison CCQM–K25.     

Capability of laboratories to determine core nutrients in foods: results of an international proficiency test

A proficiency test (PT) to assess the capabilities of laboratories to determine nutrients in a biscuit sample was carried out in September 2009. The need for such interlaboratory comparison arose from an increasing nutrition labeling requirements of different countries around the world. Forty-eight laboratories worldwide participated in this PT program for the determination of total lipids, saturated fat, trans-fat, protein, sugars, total dietary fiber (TDF), ash and sodium in food. This program was organized under the auspices of the Asia-Pacific Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation (APLAC). APLAC considers PT programs as one of the objective means of assessing the performance of the accredited laboratories. The program is one of the APLAC PT series whose primary purposes are to establish mutual agreement on the equivalence of the operation of APLAC member laboratories and to provide an opportunity to identify testing deficiency so that corrective actions can be taken, if necessary. The results of this program indicated that the consensus mean values estimated by robust statistics were in good agreement with the corresponding values obtained in the homogeneity tests except for trans-fat and TDF. The relative standard deviations of participant results for trans-fat and TDF were also found to be higher (19 and 24%, respectively) than the other test parameters. The relative standard deviations for other test parameters were less than 10%. One-half of the laboratories obtained satisfactory z-scores (| z | < 3) (\left| z \right| < 3) for all their reported results. Although participants were instructed to provide the measurement uncertainties of their reported results, only 27.5% of them had done so. Albeit many of the measurement uncertainties appear to be reasonable, some of them were found to vary widely, indicating that some laboratories still have difficulties in estimating measurement uncertainties. Although the overall measurement capability can be considered to be satisfactory, there is still room for improvement of analytical procedures.     

web-based interactive data processing: application to stable isotope metrology

To address a fundamental need in stable isotope metrology, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has established a web-based interactive data-processing system accessible through a common gateway interface (CGI) program on the internet site http://www. nist.gov/widps-co2. This is the first application of a web-based tool that improves the measurement traceability afforded by a series of NIST standard materials. Specifically, this tool promotes the proper usage of isotope reference materials (RMs) and improves the quality of reported data from extensive measurement networks. Through the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), we have defined standard procedures for stable isotope measurement and data-processing, and have determined and applied consistent reference values for selected NIST and IAEA isotope RMs. Measurement data of samples and RMs are entered into specified fields on the web-based form. These data are submitted through the CGI program on a NIST Web server, where appropriate calculations are performed and results returned to the client. Several international laboratories have independently verified the accuracy of the procedures and algorithm for measurements of naturally occurring carbon-13 and oxygen-18 abundances and slightly enriched compositions up to approximately 150% relative to natural abundances. To conserve the use of the NIST RMs, users may determine value assignments for a secondary standard to be used in routine analysis. Users may also wish to validate proprietary algorithms embedded in their laboratory instrumentation, or specify the values of fundamental variables that are usually fixed in reduction algorithms to see the effect on the calculations. The results returned from the web-based tool are limited in quality only by the measurements themselves, and further value may be realized through the normalization function. When combined with stringent measurement protocols, two- to threefold improvements have been realized in the reproducibility of carbon-13 and oxygen-18 determinations across laboratories.     

web-based interactive data processing: application to stable isotope metrology

To address a fundamental need in stable isotope metrology, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has established a web-based interactive data-processing system accessible through a common gateway interface (CGI) program on the internet site http://www. nist.gov/widps-co2. This is the first application of a web-based tool that improves the measurement traceability afforded by a series of NIST standard materials. Specifically, this tool promotes the proper usage of isotope reference materials (RMs) and improves the quality of reported data from extensive measurement networks. Through the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), we have defined standard procedures for stable isotope measurement and data-processing, and have determined and applied consistent reference values for selected NIST and IAEA isotope RMs. Measurement data of samples and RMs are entered into specified fields on the web-based form. These data are submitted through the CGI program on a NIST Web server, where appropriate calculations are performed and results returned to the client. Several international laboratories have independently verified the accuracy of the procedures and algorithm for measurements of naturally occurring carbon-13 and oxygen-18 abundances and slightly enriched compositions up to approximately 150% relative to natural abundances. To conserve the use of the NIST RMs, users may determine value assignments for a secondary standard to be used in routine analysis. Users may also wish to validate proprietary algorithms embedded in their laboratory instrumentation, or specify the values of fundamental variables that are usually fixed in reduction algorithms to see the effect on the calculations. The results returned from the web-based tool are limited in quality only by the measurements themselves, and further value may be realized through the normalization function. When combined with stringent measurement protocols, two- to threefold improvements have been realized in the reproducibility of carbon-13 and oxygen-18 determinations across laboratories.     

Development of clenbuterol reference materials: lyophilized bovine eye samples free of clenbuterol (CRM 673) and containing clenbuterol (CRM 674)

The certification by inter-laboratory testing of two candidate reference materials (RMs) for the mass concentration of the anabolic agent clenbuterol in bovine eye material is described: RM 674 with ca 10 microg clenbuterol per kg of eye matrix and RM 673 clenbuterol-free eye matrix as the negative control (<0.50 microg kg(-1)). Both candidate RMs were certified by eleven EU laboratories, and sixty-six accepted replicate measurements were included in the "Certification Study". The precision of the measurement process was assessed by calculation of the standard variation determined within each laboratory during the certification step. The study was performed according to the "Guidelines for the production and certification of BCR reference materials" and to "ISO guide 31, 33, and 35". The certified clenbuterol mass concentration for clenbuterol-free eye material CRM 673 (calculated on the basis of clenbuterol as the free base) was <0.50 microg kg(-1). The corresponding concentration for clenbuterol-containing eye material CRM 674 was 9.42 +/- 0.88 microg kg(-1). These certified values are very close to the desired target concentration of <0.5 microg kg(-1) and ca 10 microg kg(-1). This study has demonstrated that successful certification of clenbuterol-containing and clenbuterol-free bovine eye materials is possible.     

Analytical quality control program used by the trace elements in foods and diets sub-network of the FAO European cooperative network on trace elements

Summary The analytical quality control program employed by the ongoing FAO study on 14 trace elements in nationally representative staple foods of European countries is presented. The analytical quality control used is based on: 1) precautions taken to avoid trace element contaminations or losses during sampling and sample handling; and, 2) on methods used to guarantee that the actual determinations yield correct results. The precautions are presented. A number of certified biological reference materials (RMs) were used to validate the analytical methods employed. The following staple food RMs were also prepared: wheat flour, potato powder, animal muscle (pork) and milk powder. They were tested for homogeneity and subjected to an interlaboratory comparison study on the basis of which recommended values for trace element concentrations were defined. Further, the mean relative standard deviation for the 95% confidence limits of the medians in all RMs was below 5% for Ca, Mg and Zn; below 10% for Mn; below 15% for Fe, Cu and Se; and below 25% for Mo and Ni. These RMs were used to control the analytical quality of the trace element determinations in the actual samples. It is concluded that important contaminations were avoided in sampling and sample handling and that use of the RMs described was necessary to guarantee the analytical quality of the results.     

An inter-laboratory comparison study for the determination of copper and lead from the wastewater of printed circuit board manufacturing industry in Pakistan

This inter-laboratory comparison study was arranged for 28 laboratories from different public and private sector organizations in Pakistan having wastewater testing capabilities aimed at improving the quality and comparability of test results. This national inter-laboratory study was started in December 2003 and completed in July 2004. Laboratories were invited to analyze the wastewater collected from printed circuit board (PCB) industry for lead and copper contamination. The samples fulfill the criteria for homogeneity and stability as done by the reference laboratory. The results obtained from participating laboratories were analyzed in terms of Hampel Test for outliers, while the performance evaluation of the participating laboratories was done on the basis of Z-score. An assigned value derived from the participant's results was compared with a reference value provided by a reference laboratory. Overall >50% of the participating laboratories have shown good performance in this PT-program