Omega-iodoalkylammonium salts as permanent capillary silica wall modifiers. Comparative analysis of their structural parameters and substituent effects

Following previous work on the modification and inversion of electroendoosmotic flow (EOF) of naked silica by a cyclic diamine [1-(4-iodobutyl)-1,4-dimethylpiperazin-1-ium iodide] [J. Chromatogr. A 894 (2000) 53], the present report considerably expands previous data by describing additional compounds of the same series of omega-iodoalkylammonium salts. Four of them are able to instantaneously reverse the EOF, thus producing a cationic surface with a highly stable reverse EOF. All these compounds are believed to become covalently attached to the silica surface via alkylation occurring by nucleophilic substitution of ionized silanols on the silica wall by the omega-iodo functionality in the modifier. The unique advantage of such compounds, as compared to adsorbed polymers or oligoamine EOF quenchers, is that they are not needed any longer in the background electrolyte, after the initial conditioning step inducing the covalent bond. It is additionally demonstrated, by running a mixture of cinnamic acid compounds, that some of the omega-iodoalkylammonium salts can act as modulators of analyte migration, thus inducing separations of otherwise identical compounds, such as isomeric species. Such interactions can only occur when the analytes drift close to the silica wall, and must be rapidly reversible, since no peak tailing or broadening is experienced.     

Novel, trifunctional diamine for silica coating in capillary zone electrophoresis

A novel compound ?quaternarized piperazine [(N-methyl,N-4-iodobutyl)-N'-methylpiperazine] (QPzI)? for the coating of a silica capillary able to reduce or invert the electroosmotic flow (EOF) in capillary zone electrophoresis is reported. Unlike standard oligoamines (like spermine and tetraethylene pentamine) which are very efficient in quenching macromolecule interaction with the silica wall, but only in acidic pH ranges, QPzI acts all along the pH scale, including alkaline pH ranges. It is believed that QPzI behaves like a trifunctional derivative: it forms ionic bonds with dissociated silanols via its quaternary nitrogen, hydrogen bonds via its tertiary nitrogen and, most importantly, a covalent bond via alkylation of ionized silanols through the terminal iodine atom in the butyl chain. Excellent separations are obtained with a variety of organic compounds, such as aromatic carboxylic acids, tryptophan metabolites and arylalkanoic acids. Such separations could not be obtained in naked capillaries in the presence of oligoamines and on some occasions not even with capillaries coated with a covalent layer of neutral polymers. In separations taking place in alkaline media, QPzI is not added to the background electrolyte, but is used simply in the capillary pre-conditioning step, a unique feature strongly supporting the hypothesis of its covalent binding to the silica surface. In difficult separations, such as in the case of o-/p-OMe-phenylacetic acids or nicotinic/picolinic acid, which would not normally occur under standard conditions, it is believed that QPzI acts as a discriminator, thus playing an active role in the separation process, rather than simply modulating the EOF.     

Surfing silica surfaces superciliously

The present mini-review summarizes the experience gathered by our group in developing different classes of novel quaternarized heterocyclic compounds able to modulate and reverse the electroendoosmotic flow (EOF) in a most peculiar manner. The first class comprises mono-salt compounds, with the determinant omega-iodoalkyl chains of different lengths (typically C4-C8), able to be adsorbed by silicas, at alkaline pH, and spontaneously alkylate ionised silanols, thus becoming covalently affixed to it. The second class is constituted by di-salt compounds, attached at the termini of an alkyl chain of variable lengths (here too, typically, C4-C8). This second class is unable to bind covalently silica surfaces, although, in thin-layer chromatography, it exhibits an extraordinary affinity for silica beads, contrary to the first one. On the basis of the strikingly different behaviour, structural rules are derived for the minimum requirements for general classes of amines to bind to silica walls and modify EOF. For compounds unable to bind covalently to the wall, the most important structural motif is two quaternary nitrogens spaced apart by a C4 chain: this seems to be the average distance (i.e., 0.8 nm) between two adjacent, ionized silanols for a snug fit. The other structural binding motif is the "hydrophobic decoration", i.e., the ratio of charged groups to alkyl residue in the various amines; amines with high levels of such alkane groups (i.e., with higher hydrophobicity), seem to bind more tenaciously to the wall, probably due to hydrophobic interaction not to the wall but among the amine derivatives themselves, when carpeting the silica.     

Prediction of Migration Times of Organic Ions in Capillary Zone Electrophoresis

The electrophoretic mobility ratio (R value) of any two ions is constant and independent of the capillary type and electrophoretic conditions if their electrical charges and hydration radii are constant. The use of strong acid salts and quaternary ammonium salts is therefore proposed for the determination of R values. Such analytes are called markers. The following determinations can be carried out: (i) the determination of the migration time corresponding to the electroosmotic flow (EOF) in any capillary under any electrophoretic condition by measuring the migration times of two markers in the condition studied (useful when the EOF is weak); (ii) the determination of the migration time of an analyte in any capillary by knowing the migration time of the markers in the capillary studied. If the pH is changed and the ionization of the analyte is pH dependent, the resulting migration time for the analyte can be calculated. The constancy of the mobility ratios of seven markers was checked experimentally at eight different pH values (between pH 3 and 10), at three temperatures, and for two buffer concentrations. The predicted and experimental migration times were also compared in two different types of capillaries.     

Applications of a sulfonated-polymer wall-modified open-tubular fused-silica capillary in capillary zone electrophoretic separations

A fused-silica capillary that is wall-modified via chemically bonding a sulfonated polymer to the capillary wall has a uniform negative charge density on its surface and produces an electroosmotic flow (EOF) greater than 4 x 10(-4) cm2 V(-1) s(-1) The EOF is nearly independent of buffer pH over the pH range of 2 to 10 and is lower than the EOF obtained for the bare fused-silica capillary at the more basic pH but is higher at the more acidic buffer pH. Optimization of buffer pH can be based on analyte pKa values to improve the overall quality of the capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) separation of complex mixtures of weak acid and base analytes. Because of the high EOF in an acidic buffer, the capillary is useful for the separation of weak organic bases which are in their cation forms in the acidic buffer. EOF for the sulfonic acid bonded phase capillary can be adjusted via buffer additives such as organic solvent, tetraalkylammonium salts, multivalent cations and alkylsulfonic acids. The advantages of utilizing buffer pH and the EOF buffer modifiers to enhance migration time, selectivity, and resolution in CZE separations with this capillary are illustrated using a series of test analyte mixtures of inorganic anions, carboxylic acids, alkylsulfonic acids, benzenesulfonic acids, sulfas, pyridines, anilines or small-chain peptides.     

New isoelectric buffers for capillary electrophoresis: N-carboxymethylated polyethyleneimine as a macromolecular isoelectric buffer

Isoelectric buffers are attractive for electrophoresis because of their low conductivity, and their compatibility with indirect photometric detection in capillary electrophoresis (CE) where they do not interfere with the detection by exhibiting competitive displacement of the UV-absorbing probe ion. N-carboxymethylated polyethyleneimine (CMPEI) was prepared by introducing a half molar equivalent of carboxylate groups onto a polyethyleneimine backbone. Its isoelectric point determined by conductometric titration and from the pH of its dilute aqueous solution is approx. 6.8, which allows isoelectric buffering at a lower pH compared to histidine (pI7.7). Although the isoelectric point is somewhat diffuse, as expected for a polymeric compound, it exhibits a buffering capacity at a pI point of about twice that of histidine. Studies of electroosmotic flow (EOF) profile at various pH values in fused silica capillaries showed that CMPEI adsorbs onto the fused silica wall and reverses the EOF at pH < 6.5. CMPEI was applied as a buffer in an electrolyte containing 0.5 mM of the anionic dye tartrazine used as the probe for indirect detection of anions. The separation system exhibited a stable baseline, no system peaks, separation efficiencies of up to 195,000 theoretical plates, and detection limits down to 0.2 microM or 2 amol of injected analyte.     

Separation of organic cations using novel background electrolytes by capillary electrophoresis

A background electrolyte for capillary electrophoresis containing tris(-hydroxymethyl) aminomethane (THAM) and ethanesulfonic acid (ESA) gives excellent efficiency for separation of drug cations with actual theoretical plate numbers as high as 300,000. However, the analyte cations often elute too quickly and consequently offer only a narrow window for separation. The best way to correct this is to induce a reverse electroosmotic flow (EOF) that will spread out the peaks by slowing their migration rates, but this has always been difficult to accomplish in a controlled manner. A new method for producing a variable EOF is described in which a low variable concentration of tributylammonium- or triethylammonium ESA is added to the BGE. The additive equilibrates with the capillary wall to give it a positive charge and thereby produce a controlled opposing EOF. Excellent separations of complex drug mixtures were obtained by this method.     

A cationic β‐cyclodextrin as a dynamic coating for the separation of proteins in capillary electrophoresis

A cationic cyclodextrin was used as dynamic coating for the capillary electrophoresis of a model mixture of proteins (i.e., ubiquitin, α‐lactoglobulin, cytochrome‐c, and myoglobin) as positively charged species in a fused silica capillary. An interesting feature of the coating is that by simple adjustment of the concentration of cyclodextrin added into the background electrolyte, a neutral or positively charged surface, which was beneficial in preventing protein adsorption at the inner capillary wall surface, was obtained. This is the first demonstration of a dynamic coating that yielded a neutral surface for protein separations in capillary electrophoresis. Based on electro‐osmotic flow measurements, addition of 0.05 to 0.10 mg/mL quaternary β‐cyclodextrin in a low pH electrolyte resulted in a neutral or positive surface (undetectable to very slow anodic electro‐osmotic flow). The coating approach afforded the electrophoretic separation of the mixture of proteins at positive polarity with good repeatability and separation performance.     

Nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis with alcoholic background electrolytes: separation efficiency under high electrical field strengths

The effect of high voltage on capillary electrophoresis (CE) separations of anionic analytes in nonaqueous separation media was investigated. Methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, and 1-butanol were tested as background electrolyte (BGE) solvents. Experiments were carried out with a laboratory-built CE instrument suitable for high-voltage separations. Potentials up to 60 kV were applied with reversed polarity to generate unusually high field strengths (e.g. 2000 Vcm-1) and so achieve fast and efficient separations. Highest separation efficiencies were obtained with propanol as BGE solvent, and the dependency of the efficiency on the separation voltage was more or less linear. With the other alcohols, separation efficiency decreased or remained roughly constant with increasing absolute voltage. The separation efficiencies are discussed in terms of longitudinal diffusion, Joule heating, and analyte interaction with the capillary wall. Capillary preconditioning had a varied effect on the separations in the different BGEs as the BGE and the conditioning process affected the electroosmotic flow (EOF) velocity and direction.     

Poly(tetrafluoroethylene) separation capillaries for capillary electrophoresis. Properties and applications

Poly(tetrafluoroethylene) (PTFE) is a material widely known for its inertness and excellent electrical properties. It is also transparent in the UV region and has a reasonable thermal conductivity. These properties make PTFE a suitable material for the separation capillary in capillary electrophoresis. Differences in the chemistry of the capillary wall compared to fused silica (FS) can make PTFE an interesting alternative to FS for some special applications. In this work, properties of a commercial PTFE capillary of approx. 100 microm i.d. were investigated, including the dependence of electroosmotic flow (EOF) on pH for unmodified and dynamically modified PTFE, optical properties, and practical aspects of use. The main problems encountered for the particular PTFE capillary used in this study were that it was mechanically too soft for routine usage and the crystallinity of the PTFE caused light scattering, leading to high background absorbance values in the low UV region. The profile of the EOF versus pH for bare PTFE surprisingly showed significantly negative EOF values at pH < 4.2, with an EOF of -30 x 10(-9) m2 V(-1) s(-1) being observed at pH 2.5. This is likely to be caused by either impurities or additives of basic character in the PTFE, so that after their protonation at acidic pH they establish a positive charge on the capillary wall and create a negative EOF. A stable cationic semi-permanent coating of poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) (PDDAC) could be established on the PTFE capillary and led to very similar magnitudes of EOF to those observed with FS. A hexadecanesulfonate coating produced a cathodic EOF of extremely high magnitude ranging between +90 and +110 x 10(-9) m2 s(-1) V(-1), which are values high enough to allow counter-EOF separation of high mobility inorganic anions. In addition, pH-independent micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography (MEKC) separations could be easily realised due to hydrophobic adsorption of sodium dodecylsulfate (used to form the micelles) on the wall of the PTFE capillary. The use of polymers that would be mechanically more robust and optically transparent in the low-UV region should make such CE capillaries an interesting alternative to fused silica.     

Modeling the zeta potential of silica capillaries in relation to the background electrolyte composition

A theoretical relation between the zeta potential of silica capillaries and the composition of the background electrolyte (BGE) is presented in order to be used in capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE). This relation is derived on the basis of the Poisson-Boltzmann equation and considering the equilibrium dissociation of silanol groups at the capillary wall as the mechanism of charge generation. The resulting model involves the relevant physicochemical parameters of the BGE-capillary interface. Special attention is paid to the characterization of the BGE, which can be either salt or/and buffer solutions. The model is successfully applied to electroosmotic flow (EOF) experimental data of different aqueous solutions, covering a wide range of pH and ionic strength. Numerical predictions are also presented showing the capability of the model to quantify the EOF, the control of which is relevant to improve analyte separation performance in CZE.     

电解质溶液组成对低分子量阴离子毛细管电泳分离的影响

研究了毛细管电泳间接紫外检测法测定低分子量阴离子时电解质溶液中背景电解质、电渗流改性剂、ｐＨ值、有机溶剂等对分离的影响；比较了铬酸根、邻苯二甲酸根、苯甲酸根３种背景离子对不同迁移率阴离子分离的影响，并对间接紫外检测的定量基础及灵敏度进行了讨论；考察了３种不同长链烷基三甲基季铵盐电渗流改性剂浓度对阴离子迁移时间和电渗迁移率的影响，结果表明电渗流的改性效果与烷基链的长度有关；ｐＨ影响阴离子的有效迁移率     

Microchannel wall coatings for protein separations by capillary and chip electrophoresis

The necessity for microchannel wall coatings in capillary and chip-based electrophoretic analysis of biomolecules is well understood. The regulation or elimination of EOF and the prevention of analyte adsorption is essential for the rapid, efficient separation of proteins and DNA within microchannels. Microchannel wall coatings and other wall modifications are especially critical for protein separations, both in fused-silica capillaries, and in glass or polymeric microfluidic devices. In this review, we present a discussion of recent advances in microchannel wall coatings of three major classes--covalently linked polymeric coatings, physically adsorbed polymeric coatings, and small molecule additives. We also briefly review modifications useful for polymeric microfluidic devices. Within each category of wall coatings, we discuss those used to eliminate EOF, to tune EOF, to prevent analyte adsorption, or to perform multiple functions. The knowledgeable application of the most promising recent developments in this area will allow for the separation of complex protein mixtures and for the development of novel microchannel wall modifications.     

Peptide and protein separations by capillary electrophoresis in the presence of mono- and diquaternarized diamines

Two compounds, derivatives of 1,4-diazobicyclo[2,2,2]octane (DABCO), have been evaluated as potential quenchers of silanol interactions with peptides and proteins during their capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) separations. They are: 1-(4-iodobutyl)4-aza-1-azoniabicyclo[2,2,2]octane iodide (M7C4I) and 1,4-didecyl-1,4-diazoniabicyclo [2,2,2]octane dibromide (C10M7C10). The first compound is known to react with the wall, by forming a covalent bond via alkylation of silanols. On the contrary, the second one (C10M7C10) can only loosely interact with silica due to lack of reactive iodine and to a much too short distance (a C(2)) between the two quaternary nitrogens. Very good peptide maps of protein digests can be obtained in isoelectric glutamic acid (Glu) buffer, at pH 3.52 by utilizing the M7C4I. However, in the case of total tissue extracts, excellent resolution is obtained only with the first eluting part of the analyte spectrum (i.e., peptides and smaller proteins). With larger proteins, interaction with the wall and loss of resolution is experienced. When using the C10M7C10, good resolution of di- and tripeptides is obtained, while a loss of resolution is observed with entire protein digest. M7C4I does not seem to interact with the peptide/protein analytes, and simply repels them from the wall via its positive charges; it is believed that disalt (C10M7C10) acts by interacting with the same compounds, possibly by forming micelles in solution.     

Capillary zone electrophoresis with electroosmotic flow controlled by external radial electric field.

A new way of regulation of electroosmotic flow (EOF) in capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) by external electric field has been developed. A set of three high-voltage power supplies is used to form a radial electric field across the capillary wall. One power supply is applied in the usual way as a driving force of CZE and EOF to the ends of the inner capillary compartment dipped into the electrode vessels and filled with background electrolyte. Two power supplies are connected to the ends of the outer low-conductivity coating of the capillary which is formed by the dispersion of copolymer of aniline and p-phenylenediamine in polystyrene matrix. The difference between electric potentials on the outer capillary surface and inside the capillary determines the voltage of radial electric field across the capillary wall and affects the electrokinetic potential at the solid-liquid interface inside the capillary. The effect of magnitude and polarity of external radial electric field on the flow rate of EOF, on the migration times of charged analytes and on the separation efficiency and resolution of CZE separations of synthetic oligopeptides, diglycine, triglycine and octapeptide fragments of human insulin was evaluated. Through the EOF control by external electric field the dynamic effective length of the capillary was obtained and the speed of analysis and resolution of CZE separations of peptide analytes could be optimized.     

Mechanism of action of quaternary diamino quenchers in capillary zone electrophoresis

The synthesis of two novel amino compounds, able to quench and reverse the electroosmotic low (EOF) in capillary electrophoresis is here reported. These chemicals are derivatives of two previously described quaternarized piperazines, 1-(4-iodobutyl)-1,4-dimethylpiperazin-1-ium iodide (M1C4I) and 1-(4-iodobutyl)4-aza-1-azoniabicyclo[2.2.2] octane iodide (M7C4I), believed to bind covalently to the silica surface via alkylation of ionized silanols through their terminal, reactive iodine. The novel compounds, although unable to form a covalent bond, due to lack of the o-butyl iodine, are found to be very efficient in suppressing protein interaction with the wall and reversing the EOF. On the basis of their behavior in solution, the minimal structural motifs for strong binding of amino compounds to the silica wall have been derived and are thought to be: (i) the presence of two quaternary nitrogens in the molecule; (ii) a correct distance between said charged nitrogens, represented by a butyl chain (C(4)); (iii) an hydrophobic "decoration" of the molecules, consisting on a high CH(2)/N ratio (in the present case 8:1).     

Capillary electrochromatography with monolithic stationary phases. II. Preparation of cationic stearyl-acrylate monoliths and their electrochromatographic characterization

A novel cationic monolithic stationary phase based on the co-polymerization of pentaerythritol diacrylate monostearate (PEDAS) with a selected quaternary amine acrylic monomer was designed for performing capillary electrochromatography at high flow velocity. While PEDAS functioned as both the ligand provider and the cross-linker, the quaternary amine acrylic monomer was introduced to control the magnitude of the electroosmotic flow (EOF). The fabrication of the cationic stearyl-acrylate monolith (designated as cationic C17 monolith) with controlled porosity was achieved by free radical polymerization using the initiator 2,2'-azobisisobutyronitrile in the presence of a ternary porogenic solvent composed of cyclohexanol, ethylene glycol and water. Four different quaternary amine acrylic monomers were investigated in order to find the optimum monomer for achieving maximum electroosmotic flow (EOF) velocity. Both photo- and thermally-initiated polymerization proved effective in producing the cationic C17 monolith, and the best monolith was achieved when [2-(acryloyloxy)ethyl]trimethyl ammonium methyl sulfate (AETA) was used as the quaternary amine acrylic monomer. Although the zeta potential of the resulting cationic C17 monolith is positive with respect to water, the magnitude and direction of the EOF was markedly affected by the nature of the electrolyte in the mobile phase. Consequently, anodal, zero or cathodal EOF was observed depending on the nature of the electrolyte, and this was attributed to the adsorption of the ionic components of the electrolyte on to the solid stationary phase, which is characterized by its amphiphilic nature consisting of C17 chains, ester functions, hydroxyl groups and quaternary amine moieties. Optimized PEDAS-AETA monoliths yielded columns with high separation efficiency and allowed rapid separations on the time scale of seconds to be achieved with short capillaries.     

Capillary-electrochromatographic separations with copolymeric reversed-stationary phase and ion-exchanger-packed columns

A macroporous, spherical, 7 μm, polystyrene–divinylbenzene (PS–DVB), reversed-phase adsorbent (PRP-1) was evaluated as a stationary phase for the capillary electrochromatographic (CEC) separation of neutral, acidic, and basic analytes of pharmaceutical interest. Electroosmotic flow (EOF) for a PRP-1 packed capillary is nearly constant over the pH 2 to 10 range and is higher than for a silica-based C₁₈ packed capillary on the acidic side. EOF increases with an increase in buffer acetonitrile concentration or as applied potential increases. As analyte hydrophobicity increases, analyte retention and migration time increases. Increasing buffer acetonitrile concentration reduces analyte partitioning with the PS–DVB stationary phase and analyte retention and migration time decreases. When exchange sites are present on the PS–DVB copolymer, EOF (EOF is reversed for the anion-exchanger) increases as the exchange capacity increases. An increased exchange capacity also reduces partitioning of the analyte with the PS–DVB matrix and analyte retention and migration time decrease. Because of excellent stability in an acid environment, the PRP-1 packed capillary can be used in strong acid buffer solution and weak acid and base analytes depending on pK_a values can be separated as neutral species and cations, respectively. CEC separations on a PRP-1 capillary of neutral steroids, weak base pharmaceuticals (separation as cations), purines and pyrimidines (as cations), fatty acids (as undissociated species), and sulfa derivatives (as cations) are described. Efficiency for the PRP-1 packed capillary for acetone or thiourea as the analyte is about 6·10⁴ plates m⁻¹.     

Semi-permanent surfactant coatings for inorganic anion analysis in capillary electrophoresis

Capillary electrophoretic separations of inorganic anions are performed using a capillary coated with a mixture of the cationic surfactant didodecyldimethylammonium bromide (DDAB) and the zwitterionic surfactant 1,2-dilauroyl-sn-phosphatidylcholine (DLPC). These double-chained surfactants form semi-permanent coatings on the capillary wall, which allows the excess surfactant to be removed from the buffer prior to separation. Interactions between surfactant aggregates in the buffer and analyte anions are thus eliminated. The electroosmotic flow (EOF) can be altered from fully reversed (100% DDAB) to near zero (100% DLPC) using different ratios of DDAB and DLPC. Controlling the EOF allows for improved resolution of the anions while maintaining a rapid, co-EOF separation, free from analyte-surfactant additive interactions.     

Estimation of the dissociation constants for functional groups on modified and unmodified silica gel supports from the relationship between electroosmotic flow velocity and pH

Electroosmotic volume flow was directly observed in a simple instrument consisting of 1 cm long a home-made support, packed between two polyethylene frits in the polypropylene tube. Equations relating electroosmotic flow (EOF) velocity and pH for two functional groups on the surface of the solid materials were developed. With these equations, we can estimate the dissociation constants of two different kinds of functional groups on modified silica gel materials simultaneously. The dissociation constants of silanol groups, benzene sulfonic acid groups, and alkyl quaternary ammonium groups on the modified and unmodified silica gel supports were estimated. The estimated pK values of the silanol groups on the silica gel and modified silica gel surfaces are between 4.0 and 4.3. The estimated pK values of the benzene sulfonic acid groups and alkyl quaternary ammonium groups on the surface of the modified silica gel are 2.6 and 8.6, respectively.