A pseudo-ligand approach to virtual screening

A virtual screening method is presented that is grounded on a receptor-derived pharmacophore model termed "virtual ligand" or "pseudo-ligand". The model represents an idealized constellation of potential ligand sites that interact with residues of the binding pocket. For rapid virtual screening of compound libraries the potential pharmacophore points of the virtual ligand are encoded as an alignment-free correlation vector, avoiding spatial alignment of pharmacophore features between the pharmacophore query (i.e., the virtual ligand) and the candidate molecule. The method was successfully applied to retrieving factor Xa inhibitors from a Ugi three-component combinatorial library, and yielded high enrichment of actives in a retrospective search for cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) inhibitors. The approach provides a concept for "de-orphanizing" potential drug targets and identifying ligands for hitherto unexplored or allosteric binding pockets.     

Three-dimensional pharmacophore modeling of liver-X receptor agonists

High cholesterol levels contribute to hyperlipidemia. Liver X receptors (LXRs) are the drug targets. LXRs regulate the cholesterol absorption, biosynthesis, transportation, and metabolism. Novel agonists of LXR, especially LXRβ, are attractive solutions for treating hyperlipidemia. In order to discover novel LXRβ agonists, a three-dimensional pharmacophore model was built based upon known LXRβ agonists. The model was validated with a test set, a virtual screening experiment, and the FlexX docking approach. Results show that the model is capable of predicting a LXRβ agonist activity. Ligand-based virtual screening results can be refined by cross-linking by structure-based approaches. This is because two ligands that are mapped in the same way to the same pharmacophore model may have significantly different binding behaviors in the receptor's binding pocket. This paper reports our approach to identify reliable pharmacophore models through combining both ligand- and structure-based approaches.     

Site-Identification by Ligand Competitive Saturation (SILCS) assisted pharmacophore modeling

Database screening using receptor-based pharmacophores is a computer-aided drug design technique that uses the structure of the target molecule (i.e. protein) to identify novel ligands that may bind to the target. Typically receptor-based pharmacophore modeling methods only consider a single or limited number of receptor conformations and map out the favorable binding patterns in vacuum or with a limited representation of the aqueous solvent environment, such that they may suffer from neglect of protein flexibility and desolvation effects. Site-Identification by Ligand Competitive Saturation (SILCS) is an approach that takes into account these, as well as other, properties to determine 3-dimensional maps of the functional group-binding patterns on a target receptor (i.e. FragMaps). In this study, a method to use the FragMaps to automatically generate receptor-based pharmacophore models is presented. It converts the FragMaps into SILCS pharmacophore features including aromatic, aliphatic, hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor chemical functionalities. The method generates multiple pharmacophore hypotheses that are then quantitatively ranked using SILCS grid free energies. The pharmacophore model generation protocol is validated using three different protein targets, including using the resulting models in virtual screening. Improved performance and efficiency of the SILCS derived pharmacophore models as compared to published docking studies, as well as a recently developed receptor-based pharmacophore modeling method is shown, indicating the potential utility of the approach in rational drug design.     

Hot-spots-guided receptor-based pharmacophores (HS-Pharm): a knowledge-based approach to identify ligand-anchoring atoms in protein cavities and prioritize structure-based pharmacophores

The design of biologically active compounds from ligand-free protein structures using a structure-based approach is still a major challenge. In this paper, we present a fast knowledge-based approach (HS-Pharm) that allows the prioritization of cavity atoms that should be targeted for ligand binding, by training machine learning algorithms with atom-based fingerprints of known ligand-binding pockets. The knowledge of hot spots for ligand binding is here used for focusing structure-based pharmacophore models. Three targets of pharmacological interest (neuraminidase, beta2 adrenergic receptor, and cyclooxygenase-2) were used to test the evaluated methodology, and the derived structure-based pharmacophores were used in retrospective virtual screening studies. The current study shows that structure-based pharmacophore screening is a powerful technique for the fast identification of potential hits in a chemical library, and that it is a valid alternative to virtual screening by molecular docking.     

On the value of homology models for virtual screening: discovering hCXCR3 antagonists by pharmacophore-based and structure-based approaches

Human chemokine receptor CXCR3 (hCXCR3) antagonists have potential therapeutic applications as antivirus, antitumor, and anti-inflammatory agents. A novel virtual screening protocol, which combines pharmacophore-based and structure-based approaches, was proposed. A three-dimensional QSAR pharmacophore model and a structure-based docking model were built to virtually screen for hCXCR3 antagonists. The hCXCR3 antagonist binding site was constructed by homology modeling and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. By combining the structure-based and ligand-based screenings results, 95% of the compounds satisfied either pharmacophore or docking score criteria and would be chosen as hits if the union of the two searches was taken. The false negative rates were 15% for the pharmacophore model, 14% for the homology model, and 5% for the combined model. Therefore, the consistency of the pharmacophore model and the structural binding model is 219/273 = 80%. The hit rate for the virtual screening protocol is 273/286 = 95%. This work demonstrated that the quality of both the pharmacophore model and homology model can be measured by the consistency of the two models, and the false negatives in virtual screening can be reduced by combining two virtual screening approaches.     

Greedy 3-Point Search (G3PS)—A Novel Algorithm for Pharmacophore Alignment

Chemical features of small molecules can be abstracted to 3D pharmacophore models, which are easy to generate, interpret, and adapt by medicinal chemists. Three-dimensional pharmacophores can be used to efficiently match and align molecules according to their chemical feature pattern, which facilitates the virtual screening of even large compound databases. Existing alignment methods, used in computational drug discovery and bio-activity prediction, are often not suitable for finding matches between pharmacophores accurately as they purely aim to minimize RMSD or maximize volume overlap, when the actual goal is to match as many features as possible within the positional tolerances of the pharmacophore features. As a consequence, the obtained alignment results are often suboptimal in terms of the number of geometrically matched feature pairs, which increases the false-negative rate, thus negatively affecting the outcome of virtual screening experiments. We addressed this issue by introducing a new alignment algorithm, Greedy 3-Point Search (G3PS), which aims at finding optimal alignments by using a matching-feature-pair maximizing search strategy while at the same time being faster than competing methods.     

Identification of Mtb GlmU Uridyltransferase Domain Inhibitors by Ligand-Based and Structure-Based Drug Design Approaches

Targeting enzymes that play a role in the biosynthesis of the bacterial cell wall has long been a strategy for antibacterial discovery. In particular, the cell wall of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) is a complex of three layers, one of which is Peptidoglycan, an essential component providing rigidity and strength. UDP-GlcNAc, a precursor for the synthesis of peptidoglycan, is formed by GlmU, a bi-functional enzyme. Inhibiting GlmU Uridyltransferase activity has been proven to be an effective anti-bacterial, but its similarity with human enzymes has been a deterrent to drug development. To develop Mtb selective hits, the Mtb GlmU substrate binding pocket was compared with structurally similar human enzymes to identify selectivity determining factors. Substrate binding pockets and conformational changes upon substrate binding were analyzed and MD simulations with substrates were performed to quantify crucial interactions to develop critical pharmacophore features. Thereafter, two strategies were applied to propose potent and selective bacterial GlmU Uridyltransferase domain inhibitors: (i) optimization of existing inhibitors, and (ii) identification by virtual screening. The binding modes of hits identified from virtual screening and ligand growing approaches were evaluated further for their ability to retain stable contacts within the pocket during 20 ns MD simulations. Hits that are predicted to be more potent than existing inhibitors and selective against human homologues could be of great interest for rejuvenating drug discovery efforts towards targeting the Mtb cell wall for antibacterial discovery.     

Combining in silico and in cerebro approaches for virtual screening and pose prediction in SAMPL4

The SAMPL challenges provide an ideal opportunity for unbiased evaluation and comparison of different approaches used in computational drug design. During the fourth round of this SAMPL challenge, we participated in the virtual screening and binding pose prediction on inhibitors targeting the HIV-1 integrase enzyme. For virtual screening, we used well known and widely used in silico methods combined with personal in cerebro insights and experience. Regular docking only performed slightly better than random selection, but the performance was significantly improved upon incorporation of additional filters based on pharmacophore queries and electrostatic similarities. The best performance was achieved when logical selection was added. For the pose prediction, we utilized a similar consensus approach that amalgamated the results of the Glide-XP docking with structural knowledge and rescoring. The pose prediction results revealed that docking displayed reasonable performance in predicting the binding poses. However, prediction performance can be improved utilizing scientific experience and rescoring approaches. In both the virtual screening and pose prediction challenges, the top performance was achieved by our approaches. Here we describe the methods and strategies used in our approaches and discuss the rationale of their performances.     

Using pharmacophore models to gain insight into structural binding and virtual screening: an application study with CDK2 and human DHFR

This study provides results from two case studies involving the application of the HypoGenRefine algorithm within Catalyst for the automated generation of excluded volume from ligand information alone. A limitation of pharmacophore feature hypothesis alone is that activity prediction is based purely on the presence and arrangement of pharmacophoric features; steric effects remained unaccounted. Recently reported studies have illustrated the usefulness of combining excluded volumes to the pharmacophore models. In general, these excluded volumes attempt to penalize molecules occupying steric regions that are not occupied by active molecules. The HypoGenRefine algorithm in Catalyst accounts for steric effects on activity, based on the targeted addition of excluded volume features to the pharmacophores. The automated inclusion of excluded volumes to pharmacophore models has been applied to two systems: CDK2 and human DHFR. These studies are used as examples to illustrate how ligands could bind in the protein active site with respect to allowed and disallowed binding regions. Additionally, automated refinement of the pharmacophore with these excluded volume features provides a more selective model to reduce false positives and a better enrichment rate in virtual screening.     

Comparative analysis of pharmacophore screening tools

The pharmacophore concept is of central importance in computer-aided drug design (CADD) mainly because of its successful application in medicinal chemistry and, in particular, high-throughput virtual screening (HTVS). The simplicity of the pharmacophore definition enables the complexity of molecular interactions between ligand and receptor to be reduced to a handful set of features. With many pharmacophore screening softwares available, it is of the utmost interest to explore the behavior of these tools when applied to different biological systems. In this work, we present a comparative analysis of eight pharmacophore screening algorithms (Catalyst, Unity, LigandScout, Phase, Pharao, MOE, Pharmer, and POT) for their use in typical HTVS campaigns against four different biological targets by using default settings. The results herein presented show how the performance of each pharmacophore screening tool might be specifically related to factors such as the characteristics of the binding pocket, the use of specific pharmacophore features, and the use of these techniques in specific steps/contexts of the drug discovery pipeline. Algorithms with rmsd-based scoring functions are able to predict more compound poses correctly as overlay-based scoring functions. However, the ratio of correctly predicted compound poses versus incorrectly predicted poses is better for overlay-based scoring functions that also ensure better performances in compound library enrichments. While the ensemble of these observations can be used to choose the most appropriate class of algorithm for specific virtual screening projects, we remarked that pharmacophore algorithms are often equally good, and in this respect, we also analyzed how pharmacophore algorithms can be combined together in order to increase the success of hit compound identification. This study provides a valuable benchmark set for further developments in the field of pharmacophore search algorithms, e.g., by using pose predictions and compound library enrichment criteria.     

SHAFTS: a hybrid approach for 3D molecular similarity calculation. 1. Method and assessment of virtual screening

We developed a novel approach called SHAFTS (SHApe-FeaTure Similarity) for 3D molecular similarity calculation and ligand-based virtual screening. SHAFTS adopts a hybrid similarity metric combined with molecular shape and colored (labeled) chemistry groups annotated by pharmacophore features for 3D similarity calculation and ranking, which is designed to integrate the strength of pharmacophore matching and volumetric overlay approaches. A feature triplet hashing method is used for fast molecular alignment poses enumeration, and the optimal superposition between the target and the query molecules can be prioritized by calculating corresponding "hybrid similarities". SHAFTS is suitable for large-scale virtual screening with single or multiple bioactive compounds as the query "templates" regardless of whether corresponding experimentally determined conformations are available. Two public test sets (DUD and Jain's sets) including active and decoy molecules from a panel of useful drug targets were adopted to evaluate the virtual screening performance. SHAFTS outperformed several other widely used virtual screening methods in terms of enrichment of known active compounds as well as novel chemotypes, thereby indicating its robustness in hit compounds identification and potential of scaffold hopping in virtual screening.     

Improving VEGFR-2 docking-based screening by pharmacophore postfiltering and similarity search postprocessing

Conventional docking-based virtual screening (VS) of chemical databases is based on the ranking of compounds according to the values retrieved by a scoring function (typically, the binding affinity estimation). However, using the most suitable scoring function for each kind of receptor pocket is not always an effective process to rank compounds, and sometimes neither to distinguish between correct binding modes from incorrect ones. To improve actives from decoys selection, here we propose a three-step VS protocol, which includes the conventional docking step, a pharmacophore postfilter step, and a similarity search postprocess. This VS protocol is retrospectively applied to VEGFR-2 (Kdr-kinase) inhibitors. The resulting docking poses calculated using the Alpha HB scoring function implemented in MOE are postfiltered according to defined pharmacophore interactions (structure based). The selected poses are again ranked according to their molecular similarity (MACCS fingerprint) to the cognate ligand. Results show that both the overall and early VS performance improve the application of this protocol.     

Energetic analysis of fragment docking and application to structure-based pharmacophore hypothesis generation

We have developed a method that uses energetic analysis of structure-based fragment docking to elucidate key features for molecular recognition. This hybrid ligand- and structure-based methodology uses an atomic breakdown of the energy terms from the Glide XP scoring function to locate key pharmacophoric features from the docked fragments. First, we show that Glide accurately docks fragments, producing a root mean squared deviation (RMSD) of <1.0 Å for the top scoring pose to the native crystal structure. We then describe fragment-specific docking settings developed to generate poses that explore every pocket of a binding site while maintaining the docking accuracy of the top scoring pose. Next, we describe how the energy terms from the Glide XP scoring function are mapped onto pharmacophore sites from the docked fragments in order to rank their importance for binding. Using this energetic analysis we show that the most energetically favorable pharmacophore sites are consistent with features from known tight binding compounds. Finally, we describe a method to use the energetically selected sites from fragment docking to develop a pharmacophore hypothesis that can be used in virtual database screening to retrieve diverse compounds. We find that this method produces viable hypotheses that are consistent with known active compounds. In addition to retrieving diverse compounds that are not biased by the co-crystallized ligand, the method is able to recover known active compounds from a database screen, with an average enrichment of 8.1 in the top 1% of the database.     

Snooker: a structure-based pharmacophore generation tool applied to class A GPCRs

G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) are important drug targets for various diseases and of major interest to pharmaceutical companies. The function of individual members of this protein family can be modulated by the binding of small molecules at the extracellular side of the structurally conserved transmembrane (TM) domain. Here, we present Snooker, a structure-based approach to generate pharmacophore hypotheses for compounds binding to this extracellular side of the TM domain. Snooker does not require knowledge of ligands, is therefore suitable for apo-proteins, and can be applied to all receptors of the GPCR protein family. The method comprises the construction of a homology model of the TM domains and prioritization of residues on the probability of being ligand binding. Subsequently, protein properties are converted to ligand space, and pharmacophore features are generated at positions where protein ligand interactions are likely. Using this semiautomated knowledge-driven bioinformatics approach we have created pharmacophore hypotheses for 15 different GPCRs from several different subfamilies. For the beta-2-adrenergic receptor we show that ligand poses predicted by Snooker pharmacophore hypotheses reproduce literature supported binding modes for ～75% of compounds fulfilling pharmacophore constraints. All 15 pharmacophore hypotheses represent interactions with essential residues for ligand binding as observed in mutagenesis experiments and compound selections based on these hypotheses are shown to be target specific. For 8 out of 15 targets enrichment factors above 10-fold are observed in the top 0.5% ranked compounds in a virtual screen. Additionally, prospectively predicted ligand binding poses in the human dopamine D3 receptor based on Snooker pharmacophores were ranked among the best models in the community wide GPCR dock 2010.     

Modeling flexible pharmacophores with distance geometry, scoring, and bound stretching

The study of pharmacophores, i.e., of common features between different ligands, is important for the quantitative identification of "compatible" enzymes and binding species. A pharmacophore-based technique is developed that combines multiple conformations with a distance geometry method to create flexible pharmacophore representations. It uses a set of low-energy conformations combined with a new process we call bound stretching to create sets of distance bounds, which contain all or most of the low-energy conformations. The bounds can be obtained using the exact distances between pairs of atoms from the different low-energy conformations. To avoid missing conformations, we can take advantage of the triangle distance inequality between sets of three points to logically expand a set of upper and lower distance bounds (bound stretching). The flexible pharmacophore can be found using a 3-D maximal common subgraph method, which uses the overlap of distance bounds to determine the overlapping structure. A scoring routine is implemented to select the substructures with the largest overlap because there will typically be many overlaps with the maximum number of overlapping bounds. A case study is presented in which 3-D flexible pharmacophores are generated and used to eliminate potential binding species identified by a 2-D pharmacophore method. A second case study creates flexible pharmacophores from a set of thrombin ligands. These are used to compare the new method with existing pharmacophore identification software.