Highly accurate gas chromatographic analysis of reference gases for use in vehicle emission measurements

A highly accurate gas chromatographic analytical method has been developed for the determination of the composition of gas mixtures. It was tested using a reference gas as an example consisting of 3.5% of CO, 14% of CO₂, 0.2% of propane and residual N₂ intended for the use in vehicle emission measurements. The method is based on comparison measurements with samples of a calibration gas, whose composition is iteratively adapted to that of the sample investigated using a gravimetric gas mixing method. For the gas chromatographic measurement, a molecular sieve column and a polymer column are used in parallel and in isothermal operation. All gas components can be determined by a single gas chromatographic measurement, and the relative uncertainty of measurement achievable is ?0.4%.     

Highly accurate gas chromatographic analysis of reference gases for use in vehicle emission measurements

 A highly accurate gas chromatographic analytical method has been developed for the determination of the composition of gas mixtures. It was tested using a reference gas as an example consisting of 3.5% of CO, 14% of CO₂, 0.2% of propane and residual N₂ intended for the use in vehicle emission measurements. The method is based on comparison measurements with samples of a calibration gas, whose composition is iteratively adapted to that of the sample investigated using a gravimetric gas mixing method. For the gas chromatographic measurement, a molecular sieve column and a polymer column are used in parallel and in isothermal operation. All gas components can be determined by a single gas chromatographic measurement, and the relative uncertainty of measurement achievable is ?0.4%. Received: 6 March 1996/Revised: 30 May 1996/Accepted: 6 June 1996     

Development of a certified reference material of nitrous oxide in nitrogen for emission gas measurement

A reference gas mixture of nitrous oxide (N₂O) in nitrogen, filled in a 10-L high-pressure aluminum alloy gas cylinder, has been developed as a certified reference material for emission measurement of exhaust gases from automobiles. As an example of certified values, mole fraction of N₂O is 302.36 μmol/mol. An electronic mass comparator with a home-made automatic cylinder exchanger, gas-filling equipment, and a gas chromatograph with a thermal conductivity detector have been used for the production of this CRM. The gas chromatographic analysis has of sufficient precision. The mole fraction of N₂O has good long-term stability for 10 years and is independent of inner pressure in the gas cylinder. As these results, a relative expanded uncertainty (coverage factor is 2) of the certified value has become 0.28 %. This sufficiently small uncertainty of the N₂O mole fraction will be advantageous in the calibration of analytical instruments for emission gas analysis.     

Uncertainty profiles for the validation of analytical methods

This article aims to expose a new global strategy for the validation of analytical methods and the estimation of measurement uncertainty. Our purpose is to allow to researchers in the field of analytical chemistry get access to a powerful tool for the evaluation of quantitative analytical procedures. Indeed, the proposed strategy facilitates analytical validation by providing a decision tool based on the uncertainty profile and the β-content tolerance interval. Equally important, this approach allows a good estimate of measurement uncertainty by using data validation and without recourse to other additional experiments.In the example below, we confirmed the applicability of this new strategy for the validation of a chromatographic bioanalytical method and the good estimate of the measurement uncertainty without referring to any extra effort and additional experiments. A comparative study with the SFSTP approach [1] showed that both strategies have selected the same calibration functions.The holistic character of the measurement uncertainty compared to the total error was influenced by our choice of profile uncertainty. Nevertheless, we think that the adoption of the uncertainty in the validation stage controls the risk of using the analytical method in routine phase.     

A fully automatic system for underway N2O measurements based on cavity ring-down spectroscopy

N₂O is one of the most important greenhouse and ozone-depleting gases and has been the source of considerable concern in recent years. The oceans account for ~ 1/4 of the global N₂O emission budget; however, the oceanic N₂O source/sink characteristics are not well understood. To enhance the study of oceanic N₂O source/sink characteristics, our laboratory developed a fully automatic underway system for surface water N₂O concentration and atmospheric N₂O mole fraction measurements consisting of a cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS) instrument and an upstream device. The developed device can be programmed to switch the CRDS measurements from the equilibrator headspace to the atmospheric sample and the reference gas sample. The surface water N₂O concentration is calculated from the equilibrium headspace N₂O mole fraction in the equilibrator. The response time of this equilibrator is ~ 3.4 min, and the estimated precision of this method for surface water N₂O measurements is better than 0.5% (relative standard deviation, RSD), which is one order of magnitude better than that of traditional gas chromatographic methods and can be further optimised. Data are acquired every 20 s, and the calibration frequency requirement of this system is approximately 7–10 days. This labor-saving underway system is a powerful tool for high-precision and high-resolution measurements of atmospheric and oceanic N₂O and can significantly improve the study of the characteristics of oceanic N₂O sources/sinks and their response to climate change.     

Comparison of different methods to estimate the uncertainty in composition measurement by chromatography

Natural gas is a mixture that contains hydrocarbons and other compounds, such as CO₂ and N₂. Natural gas composition is commonly measured by gas chromatography, and this measurement is important for the calculation of some thermodynamic properties that determine its commercial value. The estimation of uncertainty in chromatographic measurement is essential for an adequate presentation of the results and a necessary tool for supporting decision making. Various approaches have been proposed for the uncertainty estimation in chromatographic measurement. The present work is an evaluation of three approaches of uncertainty estimation, where two of them (guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement method and prediction method) were compared with the Monte Carlo method, which has a wider scope of application. The aforementioned methods for uncertainty estimation were applied to gas chromatography assays of three different samples of natural gas. The results indicated that the prediction method and the guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement method (in the simple version used) are not adequate to calculate the uncertainty in chromatography measurement, because uncertainty estimations obtained by those approaches are in general lower than those given by the Monte Carlo method.     

Uncertainty in quantitative thin-layer chromatography

Globalization forces analysts to demand extended control of variability in analytical measurements. A calculation procedure named the "error budget model" following recommendations proposed more than 20 years ago by the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures is established as a rule for evaluating and expressing the measurement uncertainty across a broad spectrum of measurements. This metrological approach common in physical measurement is not applicable in separation techniques and cannot quantitate measurement uncertainty. Our experiments show that it can be used as a planning tool in the validation of thin-layer chromatographic (TLC) methods. A computer program that quantitates uncertainty components associated with potential sources of uncertainty in quantitative TLC is prepared and tested with experimental data. TLC plates with different qualities of stationary phases (TLC and high-performance TLC) spotted with different types of samples are measured. Application is performed manually and automatically. Plates are scanned with UV-vis scanners and a video documentation system in remission and transmission mode and fluorescence. Although the calculated values are close to the values obtained with validation procedures, the error budget approach cannot substitute validation. Calculated results can predict critical points in real quantitative TLC, but they cannot confirm the validity of a selected chromatographic procedure.     

Speciation analysis of chromium in drinking water samples by ion-pair reversed-phase HPLC–ICP-MS: validation of the analytical method and evaluation of the uncertainty budget

The approach presented in this article refers to the modification of a method for the detection and quantitative determination of chromium species in water by high-performance liquid chromatography inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. The main aim of this work was to establish a detailed validation of the analytical procedure and an estimation of the budget of measurement uncertainty which was helpful in recognizing the critical points of the presented method. As a result of the method validation experiment, the obtained limit of quantification, repeatability and intermediate precision were satisfied for the quantification Cr(III) and Cr(VI) in water matrices. The trueness of the method was verified via an estimation of the recovery of the spiked real samples. The recovery rate of both determined analytes was found to be between 93 and 115 %. Considering that the validation of the method and the evaluation of measurement uncertainty are crucial for quantitative analysis, the above-mentioned assessment of the uncertainty budget was performed in two different ways: a modelling approach and a single-laboratory validation approach. The measurement uncertainties of the results were found to be 4.4 and 7.8 % for Cr(III), 4.2 and 7.9 % for Cr(VI) using the classical concept and method validation data, respectively. This paper is the first publication to presenting all the steps needed to evaluate the measurement uncertainty for the speciation analysis of chromium species. In summary, the obtained results demonstrate that the method can be applied effectively for its intended use.     

LC method for the determination of R-timolol in S-timolol maleate: Validation of its ability to quantify and uncertainty assessment

This article presents the validation results of a chiral liquid chromatographic (LC) method previously developed for the quantitative determination of R-timolol in S-timolol maleate samples. A novel validation strategy based on the accuracy profiles was used to select the most appropriate regression model, to assess the method accuracy within well defined acceptance limits and to determine the limits of quantitation as well as the concentration range.The validation phase was completed by the investigation of the risk profiles of various acceptable regression models in order to ensure the risk of obtaining the future measurements outside the acceptance limits fixed a priori.On the other hand, the present paper also shows how data used in this validation approach can be used to estimate the measurement uncertainty. The uncertainty derived from β-expectation tolerance interval (), which is equal to the uncertainty of measurements as well as the expanded uncertainty (U_x) using a coverage factor k = 2 was estimated. The uncertainty estimates obtained from validation data were finally compared with those obtained from interlaboratory and robustness studies.     

GC–MS Measurement of 13C-Enrichment of Lactic Acid in Sepsis Plasma

Sepsis is a systemic inflammatory response syndrome arising from infection. The plasma lactic acid level is a reliable marker of sepsis. A novel procedure based on microwave-assisted derivatization followed by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) has been developed for the rapid measurement of ¹³C-isotope enrichment of lactic acid in plasma. The derivatization conditions and method validation were studied. The method was applied to the measurements of isotopic enrichment of lactic acid in the plasma of a rabbits which had received the tracer ([1,2,3-¹³C₃] lactic acid) by carotid infusion 2.5 h before blood sampling from the portal vein. These results show that the proposed method has excellent precision (RSD less than 4.57%), linearity (slope = 0.9936; r ² = 0.9998), accuracy and selectivity. The analytical results show that microwave-assisted derivatization coupled to GC–MS is a rapid method for the direct isotopic measurement of deproteinised plasma. The method could be of great interest for metabolic studies in animal models and human patients.     

Determination of total gas content and its composition in Indian PFBR blanket pellets

Total gas content and its composition are important specifications for sintered nuclear fuel pellets particularly in the case of fast breeder reactor fuels. Most commonly, total gas content and its composition is determined by hot vacuum extraction-quadrupole mass spectrometry (HVE-QMS). A number of parameters in this methodology such as temperature, duration of heating for quantitative extraction of evolved gases, total volume of the system, gas analysis conditions etc. need to be optimized for reliable measurements. In addition, sensitivity factors for various gases like H₂, CH₄, N₂, CO, O₂ and CO₂ in quadrupole mass spectrometry required for quantification of results have been determined and validated employing reference gas mixtures of known composition. Employing these optimized conditions total gas content and its composition in blanket pellets (uranium oxide pellets) of Indian prototype fast breeder reactor was determined employing HVE-QMS. The relative expanded uncertainty (at a coverage factor k = 2) in the measurement of total gas content excluding hydrogen was estimated as per ISO guidelines and it was found to be 9.2 %.     

A Scientific, General Approach to Robustness Validation for an Ion-Pair LC Assay Method Through a Case Study

This paper describes a scientifically sound, systematic approach to the robustness validation of an ion-pair LC assay method. Robustness validation was carried out on all chromatographic parameters, such as ion-pair reagent concentration, buffer concentration and pH, organic to buffer ratio, column oven temperature, and column age. Small, deliberate variations to each parameter were implemented according to reasonably expected laboratory variabilities. For instance, a typical measuring variability with a 2,000-mL graduated cylinder is 20 mL, and this translates into variations of ±1.3% for a volume of 1,560 mL of an aqueous phase. Details on the experimental design of robustness validation are described, such as the parameters considered, the variations chosen for each parameter along with rationales, the probes that were used to assess robustness, and corroboration of method robustness with intermediate precision validation. This robustness validation approach eliminates guess work, ensures scientifically appropriate and customized variations for each method parameter, and has won regulatory acceptance.     

A global approach to method validation and measurement uncertainty

The enforcement of legal limits for food safety raises the question of decision-making in the context of uncertain measurements. It also puts the question of demonstrating that measurement technique that is used is fit for the purpose of controlling legal limits. A recent European Commision (EC) decision gives some indications how to deal with this question. In the meantime, the implementation of quality systems in analytical laboratories is now a reality. While these requirements deeply modified the organization of the laboratories, it has also improved the quality of the results. The goal of this communication is to describe how two fundamental requirements of ISO 17025 standard, i.e. validation of the methods and estimation of the uncertainty of measurements, can give a way to check whether an analytical method is correctly fit for the purpose of controlling legal limits. Both these requirements are not independent and it will be shown how they can be combined. A recent approach based on the “accuracy profile” of a method was applied to the determination of acrylamide and illustrates how uncertainty can be simply derived from the data collected for validating the method. Moreover, by basing on the β-expectation tolerance interval introduced by Mee [Technometrics (1984) 26(3): 251–253], it is possible to unambiguously demonstrate the fitness for purpose of a method. Remembering that the expression of uncertainty of the measurement is also a requirement for accredited laboratories, it is shown that the uncertainty can be easily related to the trueness and precision issuing from the data collected to build the method accuracy profile. The example presented here consists in validating a method for the determination of acrylamide in pig plasma by liquid chromatography–mass spectromery (LC–MS). Concentrations are expressed as mg/l and instrumental response is peak surface. The calibration experimental design included 5×5×2 measurements and namely consisted in preparing duplicate standard solutions at five concentration levels ranging from 10 to about 5000 mg/l. This was repeated for 5 days. The validation experimental design was similar.     

Uncertainty in chemical analysis and validation of the analytical method: acid value determination in oils

Quantifying uncertainty in chemical analysis, according to EURACHEM document (1995), is based on known relationships between parameters of the analytical procedure and corresponding results of the analysis. This deterministic concept is different from the cybernetic approach to analytical method validation, where the whole analytical procedure is a "black box". In the latter case, analytical results only are the basis for statistical characterization of the method without any direct relationship with intermediate measurement results like weighings, volumes, instrument readings, or other parameters like molecular masses. This difference requires the harmonization of parameters to be validated and to be included in the uncertainty calculation. As an example, results of the uncertainty calculation and validation are discussed for a new method of acid value determination in oils by pH measurement without titration.     

The uncertainty in the calculation of the amount of blocked and reactive lysine in milk products,as determined by the furosine method

The measurement uncertainty in the calculation of the amount of blocked and reactive lysine (as determined by the furosine method) was evaluated according to the procedure described in the Eurachem/CITAC guide. The analytical method involves the chromatographic determination of lysine and furosine after acid hydrolysis. The calculation of blocked and reactive lysine in the initial protein is based on known conversion factors. The estimation of the uncertainty was performed in two steps: (1) determination of the uncertainty in the chromatographic determination of lysine and furosine, and (2) determination of the uncertainty in the calculation of blocked and reactive lysine. The individual contributions to the final uncertainty were identified, quantified, and combined in uncertainty budgets. The largest contribution to the calculation of blocked lysine came from estimating the conversion factor of blocked lysine into furosine during acid hydrolysis. For the calculation of reactive lysine, the main contribution came from the chromatographic determination of lysine. The uncertainty estimates were compared to available validation data (in-house and collaborative standard deviations of reproducibility).     

The Chromatographic Analysis of Reduced Sulfur Gases in Antarctic Waters Following Pre-Concentration onto Tenax

Abstract

A technique was developed using sparging and pre-concentration onto a Tenax trap at ambient temperature allowing field measurements to be made of reduced sulfur gases in Antarctic marine and glacial melt waters. Following thermal desorption, gases were determined by gas chromatography using a flame photometric detector. Detection limits in ng 1^?1 were: H₂S 50, OCS 8, SO₂ 160, CH₃SH 6, CH₃SCH₃ 20 and CS₂ 2. Storage of melt water samples for more than 24 hours resulted in concentration changes of the reduced sulfur gases present. While the Antarctic environment imposed limitations on the analytical method, an investigation of various pond and marine waters was undertaken.     

Special Chapter Dedicated to the Memory of Prof. St. Bretsznajder

This study investigates the most appropriate conditions to perform the proximate analysis (moisture, volatile matter, fixed carbon, and ash) of biomasses by thermogravimetry, focusing on providing better distinction for quantification of volatile and fixed carbon components. It was found, using a series of thermogravimetric methodologies, that heating rate and particle size are important factors to be taken into account, whereas temperature and carrier gas (type and flow rate) are critical to enable the proper quantification of volatiles and fixed carbon. In this case, the best condition was achieved by applying 600 °C and CO₂ as carrier gas (instead of N₂). It is the highlight of the proposal method regarding the conditions often applied for this purpose. Furthermore, this method has proved to be advantageous in three important aspects: A single measurement is enough for quantification of all properties, it can be performed in a short time (1 h 27 min) in comparison with methods performed in a muffle furnace, and it can be applied for different kinds of biomasses, from lignocellulosic to residues. The procedure of validation demonstrated the low uncertainty of the data obtained by this method and the low propagation of uncertainty when they were applied for the prediction of the high heating value of the related biomasses, which supports its applicability as an alternative to biomass characterization.     

Production of Reactive Oxygen Species and Application for NOx Control

Current gas ionization discharge techniques used in the removal of NOx from waste gases require large plasma sources, have high energy consumption, and may feature low NOx removal rates. We develop a system to generate reactive oxygen species through a strong ionization discharge, which is injected into a flow of simulated waste gas. The relative proportions and temperatures of input gases were controlled and the rate of consumption by reactive species was monitored. HNO₃ oxidization products of NOx were also collected and measured. The molar ratio of reactive oxygen species to NO was optimized to improve the rate of NOx removal. A input gas temperature of 58–60 °C was also found to be optimal. The O₂ volume fraction has almost no influence on NOx removal, while H₂O volume fractions above 6 %, gave rise to NOx removal rates of 97.2 %. The present study addresses disadvantages of current gas ionization discharge and requires no catalyst, reducing agent or oxidant.     

Toxicological study of pesticides in air and precipitations of Paris by means of a bioluminescence method

A detailed toxicological study on several pesticides, including chlorothalonil, cyprodynil, dichlobénil, pendimethaline, trifluraline, and α-endosulfan, present at trace levels in air and total atmospheric precipitations of Paris is presented. The pesticides contained in the atmospheric samples, collected during sampling campaigns in February–March 2007, are identified and quantified by a high-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC)-UV detection method. The toxicity measurements are performed by means of the Microtox® bioluminescence method, based on the evaluation of the bioluminescence inhibition of the Vibrio fischeri marine bacteria at two exposure times to the pesticide solutions. The specific toxicity, corresponding to the particular toxicity of the compound under study and represented by the EC₅₀ parameter, is determined for these pesticides. Also, the global toxicity, which is the toxicity of all micro-pollutants present in the sample under study, is estimated for the extracts of air and atmospheric precipitation (rainwater) samples. The specific toxicities strongly vary with the nature of the pesticide, the EC₅₀ parameter values being comprised between 0.17 and 0.83 mg/mL and 0.15 and 0.66 mg/mL, respectively, for exposure times of 5 and 15 min. The importance of the atmospheric samples’ global toxicity and the respective contribution of the toxic potency of the various pesticides contained in these samples are discussed.