Comparison of reversed-phase liquid chromatography and hydrophilic interaction/cation-exchange chromatography for the separation of amphipathic alpha-helical peptides with L- and D-amino acid substitutions in the hydrophilic face

Mixed-mode hydrophilic interaction/cation-exchange chromatography (HILIC/CEX) is a novel high-performance technique which has excellent potential for peptide separations. Separations by HILIX/CEX are carried out by subjecting peptides to linear increasing salt gradients in the presence of high levels of acetonitrile, which promotes hydrophilic interactions overlaid on ionic interactions with the cation-exchange matrix. In the present study, HILIC/CEX has been compared to reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) for separation of mixtures of diastereomeric amphipathic alpha-helical peptide analogues, where L- and D-amino acid substitutions were made in the centre of the hydrophilic face of the amphipathic alpha-helix. Unlike RP-HPLC, temperature had a substantial effect on HILIC/CEX of the peptides, with a rise in temperature from 25 to 65 degrees C increasing the retention times of the peptides as well as improving resolution. Our results again highlight the potential of HILIC/CEX as a peptide separation mode in its own right as well as an excellent complement to RP-HPLC.     

Stationary and mobile phases in hydrophilic interaction chromatography: a review

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) is valuable alternative to reversed-phase liquid chromatography separations of polar, weakly acidic or basic samples. In principle, this separation mode can be characterized as normal-phase chromatography on polar columns in aqueous-organic mobile phases rich in organic solvents (usually acetonitrile). Highly organic HILIC mobile phases usually enhance ionization in the electrospray ion source of a mass spectrometer, in comparison to mobile phases with higher concentrations of water generally used in reversed-phase (RP) LC separations of polar or ionic compounds, which is another reason for increasing popularity of this technique. Various columns can be used in the HILIC mode for separations of peptides, proteins, oligosaccharides, drugs, metabolites and various natural compounds: bare silica gel, silica-based amino-, amido-, cyano-, carbamate-, diol-, polyol-, zwitterionic sulfobetaine, or poly(2-sulphoethyl aspartamide) and other polar stationary phases chemically bonded on silica gel support, but also ion exchangers or zwitterionic materials showing combined HILIC-ion interaction retention mechanism. Some stationary phases are designed to enhance the mixed-mode retention character. Many polar columns show some contributions of reversed phase (hydrophobic) separation mechanism, depending on the composition of the mobile phase, which can be tuned to suit specific separation problems. Because the separation selectivity in the HILIC mode is complementary to that in reversed-phase and other modes, combinations of the HILIC, RP and other systems are attractive for two-dimensional applications. This review deals with recent advances in the development of HILIC phase separation systems with special attention to the properties of stationary phases. The effects of the mobile phase, of sample structure and of temperature on separation are addressed, too.     

基于巯基-烯点击化学法的β-环糊精固定相多模式色谱保留行为研究

基于巯基硅胶与单取代-6A-烯丙氨基-β-环糊精的巯基-烯点击化学反应,制备了β-环糊精(Click TE-CD)共价键合固定相。元素分析结果表明β-环糊精被成功键合到硅胶表面。以黄酮苷类化合物为模型,考察了Click TE-CD固定相在亲水、反相和超临界流体色谱等分离模式下的色谱保留行为。黄酮苷类化合物保留时间随流动相中乙腈含量的变化呈现典型的U型曲线,表明Click TE-CD固定相具有亲水/反相的双重保留特性。应用几何学方法测得Click TE-CD固定相在反相/亲水、亲水/超临界、反相/超临界混合模式下的正交性分别为69.8%、50.8%、50.8%。对比复杂中药样品降香提取物在反相、亲水、超临界等模式下的分离情况,结果表明Click TE-CD固定相在分离中药复杂样品方面具有极大潜力,可以在一根色谱柱上通过分离模式的改变,实现二维液相色谱的分离。Click TE-CD固定相不同分离模式的分离性能和较好的正交性表明该固定相具有在液相色谱方法发展和二维液相色谱分离方面应用的潜力。     

Retention behavior of peptides in hydrophilic-interaction chromatography

Selected hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) columns packed with bare silica, bridge-ethyl hybrid silica, or an amide sorbent chemistry were utilized for an investigation of chromatographic behavior and separation selectivity of tryptic peptides. Retention model was proposed allowing for retention prediction of peptides with correlation coefficient R(2)~0.92-0.97 for various columns. The values of optimized amino acid retention coefficients were compared to those obtained for reversed-phase liquid chromatography (Gilar et al., Anal. Chem. 2010, 82, 265-275) and used to elucidate the impact of different amino acid on peptide HILIC retention. In contrast to reversed-phase chromatography, where presence of Phe, Trp, Ile, and Leu amino acid residues in sequence strongly promoted, and presence of hydrophilic His, Lys and Arg residues strongly reduced peptide retention, the effects of these amino acid residues in HILIC were opposite (His, Lys and Arg promote, Phe, Trp, Ile and Leu demote peptide retention in HILIC). Retention coefficient optimized for pH experiments illustrated the impact of silanols on HILIC retention.     

Highly efficient monolithic silica capillary columns modified with poly(acrylic acid) for hydrophilic interaction chromatography

Monolithic silica capillary columns for hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) were prepared by on-column polymerization of acrylic acid on monolithic silica in a fused silica capillary modified with anchor groups. The products maintained the high permeability (K=5 x 10(-14)m(2)) and provided a plate height (H) of less than 10 microm at optimum linear velocity (u) and H below 20 microm at u=6mm/s for polar solutes including nucleosides and carbohydrates. The HILIC mode monolithic silica capillary column was able to produce 10000 theoretical plates (N) with column dead time (t(0)) of 20s at a pressure drop of 20 MPa or lower. The total performance was much higher than conventional particle-packed HILIC columns currently available. The gradient separations of peptides by a capillary LC-electrospray mass spectrometry system resulted in very different retention selectivity between reversed-phase mode separations and the HILIC mode separations with a peak capacity of ca. 100 in a 10 min gradient time in either mode. The high performance observed with the monolithic silica capillary column modified with poly(acrylic acid) suggests that the HILIC mode can be an alternative to the reversed-phase mode for a wide range of compounds, especially for those of high polarity in isocratic as well as gradient elution.     

Mixed-mode hydrophilic interaction/cation-exchange chromatography: separation of complex mixtures of peptides of varying charge and hydrophobicity

Mixed-mode hydrophilic interaction/cation-exchange chromatography (HILIC/CEX) was applied to the separation of two mixtures of synthetic peptide standards: (i) a 27-peptide mixture containing three groups of peptides (each group containing nine peptides of the same net charge of +1, +2 or +3), where the hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity of adjacent peptides within the groups varied only subtly (generally by only a single carbon atom); and (ii) peptide pairs with the same composition but different sequences, where the sole difference between the peptides was the position of a single amino acid substitution. HILIC/CEX is essentially CEX chromatography in the presence of high levels of organic modifier (generally ACN). The present study demonstrated the dramatic effect of increasing ACN concentration (optimum levels of 60-80%, depending on the application) on the separation of both mixtures of peptides. The greater the charge on the peptides, the better the separation achievable by HILIC/CEX. In addition, HILIC/CEX separation of both the peptide mixtures used in the present study was shown to be superior to that of the more commonly applied RP-HPLC mode. Our results highlight again the efficacy of HILIC/CEX as a peptide separation mode in its own right as well as an excellent complement to RP-HPLC.     

Synthesis,chromatographic evaluation and hydrophilic interaction/reversed-phase mixed-mode behavior of a “Click β-cyclodextrin” stationary phase

A native β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) stationary phase was prepared by covalently bonding β-CD on silica particles via Huisgen [3 + 2] dipolar cycloaddition between the organic azide and terminal alkyne, the so-called Click chemistry. The resulting β-CD bonded silica (Click β-CD) was characterized by FT-IR, solid state ¹³C cross polarization/magic-angle spinning (CP/MAS) NMR and elemental analyses, which proved the successful immobilization of β-CD on the silica support with Click chemistry. The retentive properties of Click β-CD were investigated under hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) mode in different mobile phase conditions with a set of polar compounds including nucleosides, organic acids and alkaloids. The effects of water content, concentration of the salt and pH of the buffer solution on the retention time were studied and the results demonstrated the typical retention behavior of HILIC on Click β-CD. Separation of very polar components, such as nucleosides and oligosaccharides, and chiral separation under HILIC mode were successfully achieved. In addition, Click β-CD was chromatographically evaluated with a set of flavone glycosides. The retention curves depending on the mobile phase of acetonitrile content were “U” curves, which is an indication of HILIC/RPLC mixed-mode retention behavior. The difference of the separation selectivity between HILIC and RPLC was described as orthogonality by using geometric approach and the orthogonality reached 69.4%. The mixed-mode HPLC properties and excellent orthogonality demonstrated the flexibility in HPLC methods development and great potential in two-dimensional liquid chromatography separation.     

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography/electrospray mass spectrometry determination of acyclovir in pregnant rat plasma and tissues

Reversed-phase chromatography is the most common means of separation for small drug molecules. However, polar drugs may suffer from poor retention and peak shape in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) provides a viable alternative to RP-HPLC and is an excellent way to separate polar compounds. This paper describes a HILIC/ESI-MS/MS assay for the determination of acyclovir from rat plasma, amniotic fluid, placental tissue, and fetal tissue. The isocratic separation utilizes an underivatized silica column with an acetonitrile/formate buffer mobile phase (80:20). The method is validated over a range of 50 ng/mL to 50 micro g/mL with % error and % relative standard deviation of <15% over 3 days. All samples are prepared by acetonitrile protein precipitation, which yields high recovery (>84% for acyclovir). This assay can be applied to the pharmacokinetic study of the placental transfer of acyclovir.     

Separation with zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography improves protein identification by matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization‐based proteomic analysis

Comprehensive proteomic analyses necessitate efficient separation of peptide mixtures for the subsequent identification of proteins by mass spectrometry (MS). However, digestion of proteins extracted from cells and tissues often yields complex peptide mixtures that confound direct comprehensive MS analysis. This study investigated a zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (ZIC‐HILIC) technique for the peptide separation step, which was verified by subsequent MS analysis. Human serum albumin (HSA) was the model protein used for this analysis. HSA was digested with trypsin and resolved by ZIC‐HILIC or conventional strong cation exchange (SCX) prior to MS analysis for peptide identification. Separation with ZIC‐HILIC significantly improved the identification of HSA peptides over SCX chromatography. Detailed analyses of the identified peptides revealed that the ZIC‐HILIC has better peptide fractionation ability. We further demonstrated that ZIC‐HILIC is useful for quantitatively surveying cell surface markers specifically expressed in undifferentiated embryonic stem cells. These results suggested the value of ZIC‐HILIC as a novel and efficient separation method for comprehensive and quantitative proteomic analyses. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Prediction of Intact N-Glycopeptide Retention Time Windows in Hydrophilic Interaction Liquid Chromatography

Analysis of protein glycosylation is challenging due to micro- and macro-heterogeneity of the attached glycans. Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) is a mode of choice for separation of intact glycopeptides, which are inadequately resolved by reversed phase chromatography. In this work, we propose an easy-to-use model to predict retention time windows of glycopeptides in HILIC. We constructed this model based on the parameters derived from chromatographic separation of six differently glycosylated peptides obtained from tryptic digests of three plasma proteins: haptoglobin, hemopexin, and sex hormone-binding globulin. We calculated relative retention times of different glycoforms attached to the same peptide to the bi-antennary form and showed that the character of the peptide moiety did not significantly change the relative retention time differences between the glycoforms. To challenge the model, we assessed chromatographic behavior of fetuin glycopeptides experimentally, and their retention times all fell within the calculated retention time windows, which suggests that the retention time window prediction model in HILIC is sufficiently accurate. Relative retention time windows provide complementary information to mass spectrometric data, and we consider them useful for reliable determination of protein glycosylation in a site-specific manner.     

Fast hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatographic separations on bonded zwitterionic stationary phase

Separation science is an art of obtaining adequate resolution of the desired compounds in minimum time, and with minimum effort in terms of sample preparation and data evaluation. In LC, where selectivity is a main driving force for separation, the availability of different separation modes capable of operating at high flow rates is a way to make combined optimal use of selectivity, efficiency, and speed. The separation of polar and hydrophilic compounds is problematic in RP LC due to the poor retention. Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) is a more straightforward separation mode to address this problem. Herein, it is shown that separations in HILIC mode are equally efficient as for RP, providing a potential for very fast separations on short columns. This is not only facilitated by the low viscosity of the mobile phase compositions used, compared to typical RP eluents, but also due to higher column permeability. To exemplify this, baseline separations of uracil and cytosine are shown in less than 4 s and of Tamiflu and its main metabolite in less than 40 s, both under isocratic conditions. HILIC must therefore be considered having potential for high throughput purposes, and being an attractive candidate as the second separation dimension in 2-D HPLC.     

Preparation of pH-responsive stationary phase for reversed-phase liquid chromatography and hydrophilic interaction chromatography

Novel pH-responsive polymer-grafted silica was successfully synthesized through the radical "grafting from" polymerization on azo initiator-immobilized silica. The immobilization of azo initiator onto the silica surface was achieved by the reaction of surface amino groups with 4,4'-azobis(4-cyanovaleric acid chloride). The polymer-grafted silica was prepared by stirring suspension of the azo initiator-immobilized silica in anhydrous dioxane containing acrylic acid (AAc) and butyl acrylate (BA). The resulting polymer-grafted silica was demonstrated to be pH responsive to hydrophobic/hydrophilic property by reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) and hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC). In RPLC mode, the retention of aromatic compounds decreased with the increase in the pH of mobile phase. However, the opposite result was obtained in HILIC mode; the retention of soybean isoflavones was stronger with the mobile phase at higher pH. Finally, the separations of sulfonamides and soybean isoflavones were carried out in RPLC mode and the separation of some nucleotides was achieved in HILIC mode.     

Temperature selectivity effects in reversed-phase liquid chromatography due to conformation differences between helical and non-helical peptides

In order to characterize the effect of temperature on the retention behaviour and selectivity of separation of polypeptides and proteins in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC), the chromatographic properties of four series of peptides, with different peptide conformations, have been studied as a function of temperature (5-80 degrees C). The secondary structure of model peptides was based on either the amphipathic alpha-helical peptide sequence Ac-EAEKAAKEX(D/L)EKAAKEAEK-amide, (position X being in the centre of the hydrophobic face of the alpha-helix), or the random coil peptide sequence Ac-X(D/L)LGAKGAGVG-amide, where position X is substituted by the 19 L- or D-amino acids and glycine. We have shown that the helical peptide analogues exhibited a greater effect of varying temperature on elution behaviour compared to the random coil peptide analogues, due to the unfolding of alpha-helical structure with the increase of temperature during RP-HPLC. In addition, temperature generally produced different effects on the separations of peptides with different L- or D-amino acid substitutions within the groups of helical or non-helical peptides. The results demonstrate that variations in temperature can be used to effect significant changes in selectivity among the peptide analogues despite their very high degree of sequence homology. Our results also suggest that a temperature-based approach to RP-HPLC can be used to distinguish varying amino acid substitutions at the same site of the peptide sequence. We believe that the peptide mixtures presented here provide a good model for studying temperature effects on selectivity due to conformational differences of peptides, both for the rational development of peptide separation optimization protocols and a probe to distinguish between peptide conformations.     

Mixed-mode hydrophilic interaction/cation-exchange chromatography (HILIC/CEX) of peptides and proteins

This review represents a summary of the development and application of a novel mixed-mode HPLC approach to the separation and analysis of peptides and proteins termed hydrophilic interaction/cation-exchange chromatography (HILIC/CEX). This approach combines the most advantageous aspects of two widely different separation mechanisms, i.e. a separation based on hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity differences between polypeptides overlaid on a separation based on net charge. Applications described include HILIC/CEX separations of cyclic peptides, alpha-helical peptides, random coil peptides and modified or deletion products of synthetic peptides. In addition, the excellent resolving ability of HILIC/CEX for modified histone proteins is described. This approach is shown to represent an excellent complement to RP chromatography (RPC), as well as being a potent analytical tool in its own right.     

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC)—a powerful separation technique

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) provides an alternative approach to effectively separate small polar compounds on polar stationary phases. The purpose of this work was to review the options for the characterization of HILIC stationary phases and their applications for separations of polar compounds in complex matrices. The characteristics of the hydrophilic stationary phase may affect and in some cases limit the choices of mobile phase composition, ion strength or buffer pH value available, since mechanisms other than hydrophilic partitioning could potentially occur. Enhancing our understanding of retention behavior in HILIC increases the scope of possible applications of liquid chromatography. One interesting option may also be to use HILIC in orthogonal and/or two-dimensional separations. Bioapplications of HILIC systems are also presented.     

硅胶色谱柱的亲水作用保留机理及其影响因素

亲水作用色谱（HILIC）是替代反相色谱（RPLC）分离强极性及亲水性化合物的另一色谱模式,其分离机理与RPLC有很大不同,具有和RPLC互补的选择性。在HILIC模式中,采用正相色谱（NPLC）中的极性固定相及含高浓度有机溶剂（通常为乙腈）的水溶液为流动相。硅胶是开发最早、研究最为深入及应用最为广泛的HILIC固定相,本文介绍了硅胶色谱柱的HILIC保留机理,详细概述了操作条件如硅胶柱类型、流动相组成及柱温对HILIC分离的影响,并对硅胶填料色谱柱的HILIC模式的发展方向与应用前景进行了展望。     

Determination of catecholamines in urine using hydrophilic interaction chromatography with electrochemical detection

The determination of catecholamines in urine was investigated using hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) as an alternative to the commonly used reversed-phase (RP) method. A number of different approaches were explored, including per-aqueous liquid chromatography (PALC), and HILIC using bare silica, bonded amide and zwitterionic phases. The bonded phases gave superior results in terms of both peak shape and selectivity. The mechanism of the HILIC separation was investigated particularly with respect to the contribution of ion exchange to retention. The electrochemical detection of catecholamines was studied and optimised in typical HILIC mobile phases that contain high concentrations of acetonitrile. HILIC offered a number of advantages over the conventional RP approach, giving good retention of the solutes without use of ion pair reagents, the absence of which also would facilitate detection by mass spectrometry. HILIC used in conjunction with solid phase extraction based on RP also gives orthogonal separation mechanisms in the cleanup and analysis steps. Furthermore, good recoveries from the cleanup stage were obtained, as high concentrations of acetonitrile can be used as eluting solvent that are fully compatible with HILIC, and lipophilic impurities are eluted close to the void volume of the HILIC column.     

Grafting of silica with a hydrophilic triol acrylamide polymer via surface-initiated "grafting from" method for hydrophilic-interaction chromatography

A novel hydrophilic polymer-coated silica sorbent has been prepared using the radical "grafting from" polymerization method through surface-bound azo initiators for hydrophilic-interaction chromatography (HILIC). The azo groups were introduced to the surface of silica gel through the reaction with amino groups on the surface of silica gel with 4,4'-azobis(4-cyanopentanoic acid chloride) (ACVC). The resultant azo-immobilized silica gel served as surface initiator to polymerize hydrophilic triol acrylamide monomer N-acryloyltris(hydroxymethyl) aminomethane (NA) in methanol to get hydrophilic polymer-coated silica sorbent. The obtained poly(NA)-coated silica (pNA-sil) was characterized by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), elemental analysis (EA), and nitrogen sorption porosimetry (NSP). Then the pNA-sil was packed into the stainless-steel column and evaluated in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Good chromatographic performance for the separation of peptides and nucleosides was obtained under HILIC mode. The results indicated that the pNA-sil stationary phase behaved as mixed-mode retention mechanisms of hydrophilic and ionic interactions. Furthermore, the pNA-sil phase was used to separate tryptic digest of β-casein and our results showed that more than 12 peptides peaks were resolved and well distributed within the elution window. Finally, the pNA-sil stationary phase was demonstrated to possess remarkable reproducibility and stability. Taken together, the pNA-sil stationary phase prepared in the current study offers a potential application in proteomics study.     

Comparison of hydrophilic-interaction, reversed-phase and porous graphitic carbon chromatography for glycan analysis

Hydrophilic-interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC), reversed-phase chromatography (RPC) and porous graphitic carbon (PGC) chromatography are typically applied for liquid chromatographic separations of protein N-glycans. Hence the performances of these chromatography modes for the separation of fluorescently labeled standard glycan samples (monoclonal antibody, fetuin, ribonuclease-B) covering high-mannose and a broad range of complex type glycans were investigated. In RPC the retention of sialylated glycans was enhanced by adding an ion-pairing agent to the mobile phase, resulting in improved peak shapes for sialylated glycans compared to methods recently reported in literature. For ion pairing RPC (IP-RPC) and HILIC ultra-high performance stationary phases were utilized to maximize the peak capacity and thus the resolution. But due to the shallow gradient in RPC the peak capacity was lower than on PGC. Retention times in HILIC and IP-RPC could be correlated to the monosaccharide compositions of the glycans by multiple linear regression, whereas no adequate model was obtained for PGC chromatography, indicating the significance of the three-dimensional structure of the analytes for retention in this method. Generally low correlations were observed between the chromatography methods, indicating their orthogonality. The high selectivities, as well as the commercial availability of ultra-high performance stationary phases render HILIC the chromatography method of choice for the analysis of glycans. Even though for complete characterization of complex glycan samples a combination of chromatography methods may be necessary.     

Stationary phases for hydrophilic interaction chromatography, their characterization and implementation into multidimensional chromatography concepts

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) is becoming increasingly popular for separation of polar samples on polar columns in aqueous-organic mobile phases rich in organic solvents (usually ACN). Silica gel with decreased surface concentration of silanol groups, or with chemically bonded amino-, amido-, cyano-, carbamate-, diol-, polyol-, or zwitterionic sulfobetaine ligands are used as the stationary phases for HILIC separations, in addition to the original poly(2-sulphoethyl aspartamide) strong cation-exchange HILIC material. The type of the stationary and the composition of the mobile phase play important roles in the mixed-mode HILIC retention mechanism and can be flexibly tuned to suit specific separation problems. Because of excellent mobile phase compatibility and complementary selectivity to RP chromatography, HILIC is ideally suited for highly orthogonal 2-D LC-LC separations of complex samples containing polar compounds, such as peptides, proteins, oligosaccharides, drugs, metabolites and natural compounds. This review attempts to present an overview of the HILIC separation systems, possibilities for their characterization and emerging HILIC applications in 2-D off-line and on-line LC-LC separations of various samples, in combination with RP and other separation modes.