Static TOF‐SIMS. A VAMAS interlaboratory study. Part II — accuracy of the mass scale and G‐SIMS compatibility

An interlaboratory study involving 32 time‐of‐flight static SIMS instruments from 13 countries has been conducted. In Part I of the analysis of data, we showed that 84% of instruments have excellent repeatabilities of better than 1.9% and that a relative instrument spectral response (RISR) can be used to evaluate variations between different generic types of instrument. Use of the RISR improves comparability between instruments by a factor of 33. Here, in Part II, we study the accuracy of the mass scale calibration in TOF‐SIMS and evaluate instrument compatibility with G‐SIMS. We show that the accuracy of calibration of the mass scale is much poorer than generally expected (?60 ppm for peaks <200 u and ?150 ppm for a large molecular peak at 647 u). This is a major issue for analysts. Elsewhere, we have developed a detailed study of the factors affecting the mass calibration and have developed a generic protocol that improves accuracy by a factor of 5. Here, this framework of understanding is used to interpret the results presented. Furthermore, we show that eight out of the ten participants submitting data for G‐SIMS could use operating conditions that generated G‐SIMS spectra of the PC reference material. This demonstrates that G‐SIMS may be conducted with a wide variety of instrument designs. © Crown Copyright 2007. Reproduced by permission of the Controller of HMSO. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Advanced Mass Calibration and Visualization for FT-ICR Mass Spectrometry Imaging

Mass spectrometry imaging by Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) yields hundreds of unique peaks, many of which cannot be resolved by lower performance mass spectrometers. The high mass accuracy and high mass resolving power allow confident identification of small molecules and lipids directly from biological tissue sections. Here, calibration strategies for FT-ICR MS imaging were investigated. Sub-parts-per-million mass accuracy is demonstrated over an entire tissue section. Ion abundance fluctuations are corrected by addition of total and relative ion abundances for a root-mean-square error of 0.158?ppm on 16,764 peaks. A new approach for visualization of FT-ICR MS imaging data at high resolution is presented. The ??Mosaic Datacube?? provides a flexible means to visualize the entire mass range at a mass spectral bin width of 0.001?Da. The high resolution Mosaic Datacube resolves spectral features not visible at lower bin widths, while retaining the high mass accuracy from the calibration methods discussed.     

MALDI produced ions inspected with a linear ion trap-orbitrap hybrid mass analyzer

A MALDI source is interfaced to a modified LTQ Orbitrap XL instrument. This work gives insight into the MALDI source design and shows results obtained with the MALDI source coupled to an accurate mass, high-resolution hybrid mass spectrometer. MALDI-produced ions and fragment ions thereof produced in the mass spectrometer may be analyzed and detected by the Orbitrap analyzer at a maximum mass resolution of 100,000 (FWHM) at m/z 400 with high mass accuracy. An accuracy of ≤2 ppm is achieved by internal mass calibration using lock mass functionality; using external mass calibration, an accuracy of ≤3 ppm is routinely obtained. External mass calibration of the hybrid mass spectrometer is performed using a standard calibration mixture of different peptides and matrix components. The instrumental capabilities are demonstrated for analytical methodologies such as Protein ID using Peptide Mass Fingerprint (PMF) and MS/MS analyses of small molecule samples. Stability of mass accuracy and signal-to-noise ratio for low samples loads (on plates) are demonstrated as well as the experimental dynamic range using α-cyano-4-hydroxy cinnamic acid (CHCA) matrix.     

Surface analysis of polymer materials by secondary ion mass spectrometry

Atomic as well as molecular secondary ions are emitted from the uppermost monolayer of a solid during ion bombardment. Mass analysis of these positive and negative secondary ions supplies detailed information on the chemical composition of the bombarded surface. High mass range (> 10,000 u), high mass resolution (m/Δm > 10,000), accurate mass determination (ppm range) and high sensitivity (ppm of a monolayer) are achieved by applying time-of-flight (TOF) mass analyzers. TOF-SIMS has been successfully applied to a wide variety of polymer materials, including polymer blends, chemically or plasma modified surfaces, and plasma polymerization layers. Detailed information on the composition of repeat units, endgroups, oligomer distributions, additives, as well as surface contaminants can be obtained. Basic concepts of TOF-SIMS will be described and typical analytical examples for the characterization of polymer materials will be presented.     

Variable alignment of high resolution data by cluster analysis

High resolution time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (HR TOF-SIMS) is a powerful surface analytical method. For complex samples, this technique may yield intricate spectra that are difficult to interpret visually. Chemometric methods are useful for data analysis. However, these methods require that spectra are represented in a matrix format. Variances in mass measurements caused by calibration or instrumental effects may present difficulties in properly aligning mass spectral peaks into the correct columns of the data matrix. Cluster analysis of resolution elements is proposed as an alternative approach to construct the data matrix. An automated method for optimizing the data alignment is presented and evaluated for standard steel samples.     

A modified internal lock-mass method for calibration of the product ions derived from sustained off-resonance irradiation collision-induced dissociation using a Fourier transform mass spectrometer

A modified internal lock-mass calibration method is introduced for improving the mass measurement accuracy of the product ion spectra derived from sustained off-resonance irradiation collision-induced dissociation (SORI-CID) Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometry. This method involves an initial external calibration of the Fourier transform mass spectrometer to obtain the initial A- and B-terms for the equation (f(i) = A/(m/z)(i) + B). The A-term is adjusted by using an empirical relationship between the up-shift of the A-term and the pulse-gas duration, whereas the B-term is adjusted by using the mass of the unfragmented precursor ion from the SORI-CID mass spectrum of the unknown sample as internal lock-mass. These adjusted A- and B-terms are then used to provide exact mass SORI-CID calibration for the unknown sample. The modified internal lock-mass method achieved average mass measurement accuracy of approximately 3 ppm which is significantly better than that of the conventional internal lock-mass calibration ( approximately 9 ppm) and is approaching that of the internal calibration ( approximately 2 ppm) and requires no addition of internal calibrant or instrumental modifications.     

Mass calibration of a matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometer including the rise time of the delayed extraction pulse

To utilize fully modern MALDI-TOF and TOF/TOF mass spectrometers with mass resolution exceeding 10,000 and 2 ppm precision of flight time measurements for high mass accuracy, the model of ion motion used in the mass calibration equation must be expanded. The standard three-term equation providing up to 5-10 ppm (rms) mass accuracy with internal standards was modified with an additional term accounting for the finite rise time of the high-voltage extraction pulse. This new four-term calibration equation minimizes the effect of systematic error resulting from the fact that ion velocities are mass dependent due to the rise time of the extraction pulse. Applying this new calibration equation to a mass spectrum obtained in an axial MALDI-TOF MS containing 70 peaks (sodiated PEG), each with a signal-to-noise ratio greater than 100, a mass accuracy of 1.6 ppm (rms) was obtained over the mass range 1.0-4.0 kDa compared with 3.6 ppm (rms) with the standard three-term equation. The physical basis of the effects of the finite extraction pulse rise time on mass calibration is examined for axial MALDI-TOF mass spectrometers, as well as for orthogonal acceleration TOF mass spectrometers.     

Characterization of Ni(II) complexes of Schiff bases of amino acids and (S)-N-(2-benzoylphenyl)-1-benzylpyrrolidine-2-carboxamide using ion trap and QqTOF electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry

This work demonstrates the application of electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) using two different mass analyzers, ion trap and hybrid quadrupole time-of-flight (QqTOF) mass analyzer, for the structural characterization of Ni(II) complexes of Schiff bases of (S)-N-(2-benzoylphenyl)-1-benzylpyrrolidine-2-carboxamide with different amino acids. ESI enables the determination of molecular weight on the basis of rather simple positive-ion ESI mass spectra containing only protonated molecules and adducts with sodium or potassium ions. Fragmentation patterns are characterized by tandem mass spectrometric experiments, where both tandem mass analyzers provide complementary information. QqTOF data are used for the determination of elemental composition of individual ions due to mass accuracies always better than 3 ppm with the external calibration, while multistage tandem mass spectra obtained by the ion trap are suitable for studying the fragmentation paths. The novel aspect of our approach is the combination of mass accuracies and relative abundances of all isotopic peaks in isotopic clusters providing more powerful data for the structural characterization of organometallic compounds containing polyisotopic elements. The benefit of relative and absolute mean mass accuracies is demonstrated on the example of studied Ni(II) complexes. Copyright (c) 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Sub parts-per-million mass measurement accuracy of intact proteins and product ions achieved using a dual electrospray ionization quadrupole fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer

High mass measurement accuracy (MMA) is demonstrated for intact proteins and subsequent collision-induced dissociation product ions using internal calibration. Internal calibration was accomplished using a dual electrospray ionization source coupled with a hybrid quadrupole Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (Q-FT-ICR) mass spectrometer. Initially, analyte ions generated via the first electrospray (ESI) emitter are isolated and dissociated in the external quadrupole. This event is followed by a simultaneous switch to the calibrant ion ESI emitter and a disablement of the isolation and activation of the external quadrupole such that a broad m/z range of calibrant ions are accumulated before injecting the analyte/calibrant ion mixture into the ICR cell. Two different internal calibrant solutions were utilized in these studies to evaluate this approach for the top-down characterization of melittin and ubiquitin. While external calibration of protein fragments resulted in absolute MMA greater than 16 ppm, internal standardization significantly improved upon the MMA of both the intact proteins and their products ions which ranged from -2.0 ppm to 1.1 ppm, with an average of -0.9 ppm. This method requires limited modification to ESI-FT-ICR mass spectrometers and is applicable for both positive and negative ionization modes.     

The high-mass component (>m/z 10 000) of coal tar pitch by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation mass spectrometry and size-exclusion chromatography

The size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) of acetone-soluble, pyridine-soluble and pyridine-insoluble fractions of a coal tar pitch indicates a bimodal distribution in each fraction. The proportion of high-mass material excluded from the SEC column porosity increases with solvent polarity. The polymer calibration of SEC shows the mass range of the small molecules to be from approximately 100 u to approximately 6000 u, with the mass range of the large excluded molecules above 200 000 u and up to several million u. In contrast, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) shows a similar low-mass range of ion abundances (< m/z 6000), but with a smaller range of high-mass ion abundances, from approximately m/z 10 000 to 100 000. The large molecules may have three-dimensional structures to allow molecules of relatively low mass to behave as if they are of large size in SEC. Laser desorption mass spectrometry of the acetone- and pyridine-soluble fractions produced molecular ions of polycyclic aromatics that can be related to the known compositions from gas chromatography (GC) mass spectrometry. The experimental conditions used to generate the bimodal distribution by MALDI-MS involve reducing the ion signal intensities to avoid overload of the detector and enable detection of the high-mass ions, by reducing the high-mass detector voltage (i.e. sensitivity) and increasing the laser power.     

Chemometric evaluation of time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry data of minerals in the frame of future in situ analyses of cometary material by COSIMA onboard ROSETTA

Chemometric data evaluation methods for time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) have been tested for the characterization and classification of minerals. Potential applications of these methods include the expected data from cometary material to be measured by the COSIMA instrument onboard the ESA mission ROSETTA in the year 2014. Samples of the minerals serpentine, enstatite, olivine, and talc have been used as proxies for minerals existing in extraterrestrial matter. High mass resolution TOF-SIMS data allow the selection of peaks from inorganic ions relevant for minerals. Multivariate cluster analysis of peak intensity data by principal components analysis and the new method CORICO showed a good separation of the mineral classes. Classification by k nearest-neighbor classification (KNN) or binary decision trees (CART method) results in more than 90% correct class assignments in a leave-one-out cross validation.     

Influence of internal standard charge state on the accuracy of mass measurements in orthogonal acceleration time-of-flight mass spectrometers

Accuracy of mass measurements performed in orthogonal acceleration time-of-flight (oa-TOF) mass spectrometers highly depends on the quality of the signal and the internal calibration. The use of two reference compounds which bracket the targeted unknown, give rise to ions with sufficient signal-to-noise ratio while avoiding detector saturation and produce signals of similar intensity as compared to the target is a common requirement which allow a 5 ppm accuracy on a routine basis. Ion charge state is demonstrated here to be an additional and particularly critical parameter. Using internal references of lower charge state than the target ion systematically yielded overestimated data. Errors measured for quadruply charged molecules were in the range 16-18 ppm when mass calibrants were singly charged ions while accuracy was below 5 ppm when references and target ions were in the same charge state. Magnitude of errors was found to increase with the difference in charge state. This phenomenon arises from the orthogonal acceleration of ions in the TOF analyzer, an interface implemented in all TOF mass spectrometers to accommodate continuous beam ionization sources. Copyright (c) 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Rapid identification of trimethyl and triethyl amines using sulphonic acidic ionic liquids: A time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry study of fragmentation reactions

The time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) has emerged as a powerful tool for the unswerving detection of biomolecules, in particular, proteins and peptides. To date, there is very little information available on the direct determination of trimethyl/triethyl amines using TOF-SIMS. One major hurdle in this regard is an ultrahigh vacuum system, usually needed in TOF-SIMS, which hampers its usability to trimethyl/triethyl amines owing to their high evaporation rate. We designed an efficient and sensitive protocol for rapid identification and sensitive determination of tertiaryalkyl amines using TOF-SIMS. The amines were derivatized by reaction with 1,4-butane sultone and sulphuric acid sequentially to afford the corresponding sulphonic acidic ionic liquids (ILs). The TOF-SIMS analysis of these task-specific ILs (TSILs) was carried out in both positive and negative polarity. The positive ion mass spectra of TSILs showed sharp fragmented peaks for tertiaryalkyl amines at typical level and up to 10 ppm. The possible mechanism for different fragmentation pathways in positive polarity was discussed.     

Structural Characterization of Actinomycin D Using Multiple Ion Isolation and Electron Induced Dissociation

Non-ribosomal peptides are bio synthesized using a range of enzymes that allow much more structural variability compared with “normal” peptides. Deviations from the standard amino acid structures are common features of this diverse class of natural products, making sequencing a challenging process. FTICR mass spectrometry, specifically the complementary tandem mass spectrometry techniques collision activated dissociation (CAD) and electron induced dissociation (EID), have been used to reveal structural information on the non-ribosomal peptide actinomycin D. EID was also combined with a multiple ion isolation method in order to provide an accurate (sub-ppm) internal calibration for the product ions. EID has been found to produce more detailed, complementary data than CAD for actinomycin D, with additional information being provided through fragmentation of the sodium and lithium adducts. Furthermore, the use of isolation in the FTICR cell was found to increase product ion intensities relative to the precursor ion, enabling significantly more peaks to be detected than when using EID alone. The combination of multiple ion isolation with EID, therefore, enables an accurate internal calibration of the fragment ions to be made (average mass uncertainty of <0.3 ppm), as well as increasing the degree of fragmentation of the compound, resulting in detailed structural information.      

Improved mass accuracy for higher mass peptides by using SWIFT excitation for MALDI-FTICR mass spectrometry

Stepwise-external calibration has previously been shown to produce sub part-per-million (ppm) mass accuracy for the MALDI-FTICR/MS analyses of peptides up to m/z 2500. The present work extends these results to ions up to m/z 4000. Mass measurement errors for ions of higher mass-to-charge are larger than for ions below m/z 2500 when using conventional chirp excitation to detect ions. Mass accuracy obtained by using stored waveform inverse Fourier transform (SWIFT) excitation was evaluated and compared with chirp excitation. Analysis of measurement errors reveals that SWIFT excitation provides smaller deviations from the calibration equation and better mass accuracy than chirp excitation for a wide mass range and for widely varying ion populations.     

Structural effects in the analysis of supported lipid bilayers by time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry

We contribute to the rapidly emerging interest in the application of time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) for chemical analysis of biological materials by presenting a careful TOF-SIMS investigation of structurally different SiO2-supported phospholipid assemblies. Freeze-dried supported 1-oleoyl-2-palmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) bilayers, Langmuir-Blodgett POPC monolayers, and disordered thick POPC films were investigated. Compared with the two latter structures, the supported bilayer showed a strong (5-10 times) enhancement in the yield of both the molecular and the dimer ion peaks of POPC, suggesting that the molecular peak may be used as a sensitive indicator for changes in the membrane structure and, in particular, an indicator for the presence of bilayer structures in, e.g., cell and tissue samples. The detection efficiency and the useful lateral resolution indicate that a lateral resolution of around 100 nm can be obtained on all structures by imaging the phosphocholine ion at 184 u using Bi3+ primary ions. For the chemically specific molecular peak at 760 u, the measured detection efficiencies correspond to a useful lateral resolution of around 2 microm for the bilayer structure. The results are discussed in relation to recent dynamic SIMS (nano-SIMS) analysis of freeze-dried supported lipid bilayers, displaying similar or higher lateral resolution, but which in contrast to TOF-SIMS requires isotopic labeling of the analyzed lipids.     

Sub part-per-million mass accuracy by using stepwise-external calibration in fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry

A new external calibration procedure for FT-ICR mass spectrometry is presented, stepwise-external calibration. This method is demonstrated for MALDI analysis of peptide mixtures, but is applicable to any ionization method. For this procedure, the masses of analyte peaks are first accurately measured at a low trapping potential (0.63 V) using external calibration. These accurately determined (< 1 ppm accuracy) analyte peaks are used as internal calibrant points for a second mass spectrum that is acquired for the same sample at a higher trapping potential (1.0 V). The second mass spectrum has a approximately 10-fold improvement in detection dynamic range compared with the first spectrum acquired at a low trapping potential. A calibration equation that accounts for local and global space charge is shown to provide mass accuracy with external calibration that is nearly identical to that of internal calibration, without the drawbacks of experimental complexity or reduction of abundance dynamic range. For the 609 mass peaks measured using stepwise-external calibration method, the root-mean-square error is 0.9 ppm. The errors appear to have a Gaussian distribution; 99.3% of the mass errors are shown to lie within three times the sample standard deviation (2.6 ppm) of their true value.     

Interpretation of TOF-SIMS data based on information entropy of spectra

Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS), when used for the analysis of complex material samples, typically provides data that are complicated and challenging to understand. Therefore, additional data analysis techniques, such as multivariate analysis, are often required to facilitate the interpretation of TOF-SIMS data. In this study, a new method based on the information entropy (Shannon entropy) is proposed as an indicator of the outline characteristics of an unknown sample, such as changes in the material within the sample and mixing conditions. The Shannon entropy values are calculated using the relative intensity of every secondary ion normalized to the total ion count and reflect the diversity of secondary ions in the spectrum. Mixed samples containing two organic electroluminescence materials of different ratios, multilayers of Irganox 1010, and other organic materials were employed to evaluate the utility of Shannon entropy in the analysis of TOF-SIMS data. The findings demonstrate that the Shannon entropy of a spectrum indicates differences in materials and changes in the conditions of a material in a sample without the need for peak identification or the knowledge of specific peaks corresponding to the materials in the sample.     

Using a triple-quadrupole mass spectrometer in accurate mass mode and an ion correlation program to identify compounds

Atomic masses and isotopic abundances are independent and complementary properties for discriminating among ion compositions. The number of possible ion compositions is greatly reduced by accurately measuring exact masses of monoisotopic ions and the relative isotopic abundances (RIAs) of the ions greater in mass by +1 Da and +2 Da. When both properties are measured, a mass error limit of 6-10 mDa (< 31 ppm at 320 Da) and an RIA error limit of 10% are generally adequate for determining unique ion compositions for precursor and fragment ions produced from small molecules (less than 320 Da in this study). 'Inherent interferences', i.e., mass peaks seen in the product ion mass spectrum of the monoisotopic [M+H]+ ion of an analyte that are -2, -1, +1, or +2 Da different in mass from monoisotopic fragment ion masses, distort measured RIAs. This problem is overcome using an ion correlation program to compare the numbers of atoms of each element in a precursor ion to the sum of those in each fragment ion and its corresponding neutral loss. Synergy occurs when accurate measurement of only one pair of +1 Da and +2 Da RIAs for the precursor ion or a fragment ion rejects all but one possible ion composition for that ion, thereby indirectly rejecting all but one fragment ion-neutral loss combination for other exact masses. A triple-quadrupole mass spectrometer with accurate mass capability, using atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI), was used to measure masses and RIAs of precursor and fragment ions. Nine chemicals were investigated as simulated unknowns. Mass accuracy and RIA accuracy were sufficient to determine unique compositions for all precursor ions and all but two of 40 fragment ions, and the two corresponding neutral losses. Interrogation of the chemical literature provided between one and three possible compounds for each of the nine analytes. This approach for identifying compounds compensates for the lack of commercial ESI and APCI mass spectral libraries, which precludes making tentative identifications based on spectral matches.     

Determination of elemental composition of volatile organic compounds from Chinese rose oil by spectral accuracy and mass accuracy

Elemental composition determination of volatile organic compounds through high mass accuracy and isotope pattern matching could not be routinely achieved with a unit-mass resolution mass spectrometer until the recent development of the comprehensive instrument line-shape calibration technology. Through this unique technology, both m/z values and mass spectral peak shapes are calibrated simultaneously. Of fundamental importance is that calibrated mass spectra have symmetric and mathematically known peak shapes, which makes it possible to deconvolute overlapped monoisotopes and their (13)C-isotope peaks and achieve accurate mass measurements. The key experimental requirements for the measurements are to acquire true raw data in a profile or continuum mode with the acquisition threshold set to zero. A total of 13 ions from Chinese rose oil were analyzed with internal calibration. Most of the ions produced high mass accuracy of better than 5 mDa and high spectral accuracy of better than 99%. These results allow five tested ions to be identified with unique elemental compositions and the other eight ions to be determined as a top match from multiple candidates based on spectral accuracy. One of them, a coeluted component (Nerol) with m/z 154, could not be identified by conventional GC/MS (gas chromatography/mass spectrometry) and library search. Such effective determination for elemental compositions of the volatile organic compounds with a unit-mass resolution quadrupole system is obviously attributed to the significant improvement of mass accuracy. More importantly, high spectral accuracy available through the instrument line-shape calibration enables highly accurate isotope pattern recognition for unknown identification.