Role of adsorption in liquid chromatography of macromolecules and potential of liquid chromatography in assessing adsorption of macromolecules onto solid surfaces

Many liquid chromatographic (LC) separations of macromolecules are influenced or directly based on adsorption of solutes on column packing. In the case of well known size exclusion chromatography (SEC), adsorption effects are usually unwanted and therefore suppressed. Still they appear in many SEC systems and may badly affect precision of results obtained. In other LC methods applicable to high polymers, adsorption is deliberately combined with exclusion. The aim is to discriminate complex polymer systems which exhibit more than one single distribution of their molecular characteristics. The main goals of such combinations include either a controlled increase or a full suppression of separation selectivity according to one molecular characteristics. Most important so far known exclusion-adsorption compensation methods allowing to suppress dependence of LC retention volumes on polymer molar mass are reviewed. The discussion is accomplished with a presentation of newly developed full adsorption - desorption (FAD) method which can be combined with various LC procedures. A very useful combination represents the on-line FAD/SEC procedure which enables also to study adsorption and desorption phenomena in the systems solid surface - solvent - macromolecules.     

Liquid chromatography of polymers under limiting conditions of desorption II. Tandem injection and quantitative molar mass determination

Liquid chromatography under limiting conditions of desorption (LC LCD) is a method which allows molar mass independent elution of various synthetic polymers. A narrow, slowly moving zone of small molecules, which promotes full adsorption of one kind of polymer species within column (an adsorli) acts as an impermeable barrier for the fast moving macromolecules. The latter accumulate on the barrier edge and elute nearly in total volume of liquid within column. At the same time, transport of less adsorptive macromolecules is not hampered so that these are eluted in the size exclusion (SEC) mode. As result, polymers differing in their polarity and adsorptivity can be easily separated without molar mass interference. Three methods of barrier creation are discussed and compared. It is shown that a fraction of sample may elute unretained if the adsorli sample solvent is used as a barrier in connection with a narrow-pore column packing. One part of excluded macromolecules likely breaks-out from the adsorli zone and this results in partial loss of sample and distortion of the LC LCD peaks. This problem can be avoided if the adsorli zone is injected immediately before sample solution. Applicability of the LC LCD method for polymer separation has been demonstrated with a model mixture of poly(methyl methacrylate) (adsorbing polymer) and polystyrene (non adsorbing polymer) using bare silica gel as a column packing with a combination of tetrahydrofuran (a desorption promoting liquid -a desorli) and toluene (adsorli). It has been shown that the LC LCD procedure with tandem injection allows simple and fast discrimination of polymer blend components with good repeatability and high sample recovery. For quantitative determination of molar masses of both LC LCD and SEC eluted polymers, an additional size exclusion chromatographic column can be applied either in a conventional way or in combination with a multi-angle light scattering detector. A single eluent is used in the latter column, which separates the mixed mobile phase, system peaks and the desorli zone from the polymer peaks so that measurements are free from disturbances caused by the changing eluent composition. The resulting LC LCD x SEC procedure has been successfully applied to poly(methyl methacrylate) samples.     

New Developments in Multidimensional Chromatography of Complex Polymers

Summary: Complex polymers are distributed in more than one direction of molecular heterogeneity. In addition to the molar mass distribution, they are frequently distributed with respect to chemical composition, functionality, and molecular heterogeneity. One approach for the analysis of the heterogeneity of complex polymers is their chromatographic separation by combining different separation mechanisms. A typical experimental protocol includes the separation of the sample according to composition to yield fractions that are chemically homogeneous. These fractions are transferred to a size‐selective separation method and analyzed with respect to molar mass. As a result of this two‐dimensional (2D) separation, information on both types of molecular heterogeneity is obtained. So far, 2D chromatography has been applied mostly to polymers that are soluble in organic solvents. There are several problems related to the use of aqueous mobile phases in polymer chromatography. These problems relate to the very polar or ionic character of the polymers and the experimental conditions, including the use of salt‐containing eluents. The present paper addresses the different parameters that influence the chromatographic experiments. For a model polymer system resulting from the grafting of methacrylic acid (MAA) onto poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG), i.e., PEG‐g‐PMAA, it will be shown that different chromatographic techniques including SEC, LC‐CC, and 2D chromatography, as well as coupled LC‐CC/FT‐IR can be used to analyze the molecular complexity of the copolymers.

LC‐CC/FT‐IR spectra of a PEG‐g‐PMAA sample as function of the elution volume.     

Enthalpy assisted size exclusion chromatography. Part 2. Adsorption retention mechanism

A novel high performance liquid chromatographic method for separation of synthetic polymers has been tested. It involves combination of the enthalpic and entropic retention mechanisms, resulting in increased selectivity of separation within a specific molar mass range. In this present case, the enthalpic retention mechanism is adsorption of macromolecules on a bare silica gel column packing. Under critical conditions of enthalpic interactions, homopolymers are known to elute irrespective of their molar mass. However, in the vicinity of critical conditions, a situation can be identified when retention volumes (V(R)) rapidly decrease with increasing molar mass. Typically, this happens for polymer species close to or above their exclusion limit observed with the same column in the absence of enthalpic interactions between macromolecules and packing, that is near "ideal SEC" conditions. The dependence of polymer retention volume on molar mass closely resembles size exclusion conditions. However, the witnessed rate of change in V(R )with polymer molar mass is more pronounced, thus indicating increased selectivity of separation. This situation not only offers the benefit of more selective separation according to molar mass but efficient discrimination of macromolecules possessing different nature and interactivity with the column packing can be accomplished as well.     

Separation of minor macromolecular constituents from multicomponent polymer systems by means of liquid chromatography under limiting conditions of enthalpic interactions

Minor (<1%) macromolecular constituents may significantly affect physical/utility properties of the multicomponent polymer systems. Separation and molecular characterization of the small amounts of macromolecular additives from the dominant polymer matrices represents an exacting analytical problem. Recently a series of unconventional liquid chromatographic methods was developed for separation of the constituents of polymer blends; their generic name is Liquid chromatography under limiting conditions of enthalpic interactions, LC LC. The LC LC procedures employ the difference in elution rate of the low molecular substances and the macromolecules within the column packed with porous particles. Small molecules permeate practically all pores of the packing and therefore they elute slowly. Polymer species are partially of fully pore excluded and in absence of enthalpic interactions they are rapidly transported along the column. The appropriately chosen low molecular substances promote interactions of macromolecules within the column. If eluted in front of sample, the interaction promoting low molecular substance may create a sort of slowly eluting barrier that is “impermeable” for the interacting macromolecules and efficiently decelerates their fast transport. The blocking action of a barrier differs for macromolecules of distinct nature, which elute from the column with a different rate to be mutually separated irrespectively of their molar mass. In present work, different approaches to the LC LC separations are compared from the point of view of their applicability to complex polymer systems, in which one constituent is present at very low concentration, and also in light of sample recovery. The practical examples are the two- and three-component polymer blends of polystyrenes, poly(methyl methacrylate)s and poly(vinyl acetate)s of different molar mass averages and distributions, as well as the diblock copolymers polystyrene-block-poly(methyl methacrylate) that contain their parent homopolymers.     

Two‐dimensional chromatography as a tool for studying band broadening in size‐exclusion chromatography

Comprehensive 2‐D size‐exclusion chromatography (SEC×SEC) has been realized. SEC×SEC is not a useful technique for characterizing complex polymers. However, it is potentially an elegant tool to study band‐broadening phenomena. If narrow fractions can be collected from the first dimension, the band broadening in the second dimension is only due to chromatographic dispersion. This would allow a clear distinction to be made between chromatographic band broadening (column and extra‐column) and SEC selectivity (band broadening due to sample polydispersity). In comparison with MALDI‐MS, SEC×SEC allows the study of polymers across a much broader molar‐mass range.     

Liquid chromatography of synthetic polymers under critical conditions of enthalpic interactions 4: Sample recovery

Reduced sample recovery is a frequent feature of LC of macromolecules under critical conditions of enthalpic interactions (LC CC). Several methods of assessment of LC CC sample recovery are compared. A novel approach is based on an online combination of the. The LC CC column with a noninteractive SEC column. It provides not only the amount but also the molar mass of the eluted/withheld polymer. The procedure was tested with poly(methyl methacrylate), bare silica gel column packings, and “critical eluent” tetrahydrofuran/toluene. It was shown that macromolecules with higher molar masses were preferentially trapped within the LC CC column packing so that the eluted part of the sample was no longer representative. The incomplete polymer elution can make the LC CC polymer analyses susceptible to significant experimental errors.     

Evaluation of high-performance liquid chromatography column retentivity using macromolecular probes. II. Silanophilic interactivity traced by highly polar polymers

A new method of HPLC column retentivity testing utilizes polymeric probes instead of conventional sets of low molar mass substances. The procedure allows at least semiquantitative, separate and independent evaluation of adsorption and partition properties of column packings. In this present work, the method is applied for comparison of the polar interactivities of selected silica gel C18 HPLC columns. It is shown that free silanols which remained on the surface of the end-capped silica C18 column packings are accessible for interaction with highly polar macromolecules. High molar mass polymeric test probes are adsorbed on the surface silanols and their retention volumes increase. As result, deviations from regular size-exclusion chromatographic (SEC) behavior are observed. The extent of retention volume changes depends on both the nature of polymer probes and on column packing type. Adsorption of macromolecules can be suppressed by addition of a highly polar substance to the mobile phase. The amount of polar additive which is needed to attain regular SEC elution of the polymer probe depends on the column packing type and can be used as a characteristic of silanophilic column interactivity. Courses of dependences of retention volumes on sizes of macromolecules indicate the presence of "U-turn" adsorption which allows two and more silanols situated among C18 groups to be occupied simultaneously with the same macromolecule.     

Liquid chromatography of polymer mixtures applying a combination of exclusion and full adsorption mechanisms. 5. Six-component blends of chemically similar polymers

The separation of six-component blends of chemically similar homopolymers utilising the full adsorption-desorption (FAD) process is presented. The main advantage of the FAD approach over other methods represents the successive and independent size- exclusion chromatography (SEC) characterisation of all blend components. The method is based on the full adsorption and retention of all n or n−1 components of the polymer blend from an adsorption promoting liquid (ADSORLI) in a small FAD column. Nonadsorbed macromolecules are forwarded directly into SEC for molecular characterisation. Next, appropriate displacers are successively applied to the FAD column to selectively release preadsorbed blend constituents into the on-line SEC column. Dynamic integral desorption isotherms for single constituents, as well as for polymer blends to be analysed, allow identification of optimal displacer compositions to release just one kind of macromolecule. Model polymer blends containing polystyrene (PS), poly(lauryl methacrylate), poly(butyl methacrylate), poly(ethyl methacrylate), poly(methyl methacrylate) and poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) or, alternatively, PS, poly(2-ethylhexyl acrylate), poly(butyl acrylate), poly(ethyl acrylate), poly(methyl acrylate) and PEO of similar molar masses can be separated and characterised in one multistep run using nonporous silica FAD packing, toluene as an ADSORLI and its mixtures with a desorption promoting liquid such as ethyl acetate, tetrahydrofuran or dimetylformamide to form displacers with appropriate desorption strength. Received: 9 September 1998 Accepted in revised form: 16 November 1998     

Adsorption and desorption of macromolecules on solid surfaces studied by on-line size exclusion chromatography 2. Preferential adsorption and exchange processes

Preferential and exchange adsorption of polymers differing in molar mass and/or chemical nature under dynamic conditions were investigated using on-line size-exclusion chromatography (SEC). The sample investigated dissolved in an appropriate solvent was injected into a small adsorption–desorption column packed with nonporous silica. A nonadsorbed or desorbed fraction of the polymer was directed into an SEC column for determination of both the amount and the molecular characteristics. This approach is in many aspects superior to other techniques for studies of polymer adsorption onto solid surfaces due to its low sample and time consumption. At a low degree of surface coverage, adsorption and desorption of macromolecules were rapid and were affected by the rate of supply of macromolecules to the adsorbent surface. The exchange between macromolecules at the stage of surface saturation was found to depend on the mean molar masses of preadsorbed and displacing polymer species and possibly also on the chain flexibility of the macromolecules. It was shown that the preferential adsorption driven by the chain-length difference upon saturation of the adsorbent surface was more noticeable if the preadsorbed macromolecules were smaller. Received: 7 April 1999 Accepted in revised form: 21 July 1999     

Studies on high-performance size-exclusion chromatography of synthetic polymers. I. Volume of silica gel column packing pores reduced by retained macromolecules

Macromolecules, which stay adsorbed within the active size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) column packings may strongly reduce effective volume of the separation pores. This brings about a decrease of retention volumes of the non-retained polymer samples and results in the increased apparent molar mass values. The phenomenon has been demonstrated with a series of poly(methyl methacrylate)s (PMMA) and a polyethylenoxide (PEO) fully retained by adsorption within macroporous silica gel SEC column from toluene or tetrahydrofuran, respectively. The non-retained probes were polystyrenes (PS) in toluene and both PS and PMMA in THF eluents. The errors in the peak molar mass values determined for the non-retained polymer species using a column saturated with adsorbed macromolecules and considering calibration curves monitored for the original "bare" column packing assumed up to several hundreds of percent. Errors may appear also in the weight and number averages of molar masses calculated from calibration dependences obtained with columns saturated with adsorbed macromolecules. Moreover, the SEC peaks of species eluted from the polymer saturated columns were broadened and in some cases even split. These results demonstrate a necessity not only to periodically re-calibrate the SEC columns but also to remove macromolecules adsorbed within packing in the course of analyses.     

Enthalpic Partition-Assisted Size Exclusion Chromatography: 1. Principle of Method

A novel high performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) method viz. “enthalpic partition assisted size exclusion chromatography” deliberately combines entropic and enthalpic partition mechanisms. It enables separation of homopolymers according to their molar mass with increased selectivity, as well as discrimination of polymer species differing in their nature/composition. Enthalpic partition of macromolecules takes place between the mobile phase and the stationary “liquid” of a different chemical nature, which is immobilized within pores of an appropriate carrier (a bonded phase). The extent of enthalpic partition depends on the accessibility of bonded phase for macromolecules and on the difference of polymer solubility in the mobile phase and in the solvated bonded phase. The enthalpic partition in favor of column packing arises from better solubility of polymer solutes in the solvated stationary phase compared to the mobile phase. Macromolecules are “pushed” into the solvated stationary phase and their retention volumes (V_R) increase. In the area of high molar masses, the extent of enthalpic partition as rule raises with the increasing size of macromolecules. However, under properly chosen experimental conditions the enthalpic partition may rapidly diminish with the sample molar mass (M), likely due to the solubility changes and/or due to partial exclusion of macromolecules from the pores. As result, the corresponding retention volumes sharply drop within a narrow range of M with the increasing size of macromolecules. This results in the log M vs. V_R dependences, which resemble in their form that for size exclusion chromatography but are much more flat indicating highly selective separations of homopolymers according to their molar masses. In this way, enthalpic partition “assists” entropic partition (size exclusion). Polymer species, which do not undergo enthalpic partition, elute from the HPLC column in the conventional size exclusion mode and can be discriminated from the partitioning species. Enthalpic partition assisted size exclusion chromatography can be utilized in separation and characterization of various homopolymers, and polymer blends.     

Short metal capillary columns packed with polymer-coated fibrous materials in high-temperature gas chromatography

The high-temperature gas chromatographic (GC) separation of several semivolatile compounds is studied with a short metal capillary column packed with fibrous material, having a polydimethylsiloxane coating thereon. Taking advantage of the excellent heat-resistance of the fiber and also the combination of the surface-deactivated metal capillary, a temperature-programmed separation up to 450 degrees C is successfully demonstrated for the separation of polymer standard samples. The average molecular weight of the commercially-available polymer standard samples for size exclusion chromatography (SEC) is estimated by high-temperature GC analysis and compared with the nominal value determined by a conventional SEC method. Although a slight deviation for the number-average molecular weight is observed between the GC and SEC analysis, the data for the weight-average molecular weight shows a good agreement in these methods. The results also suggest the future possibility of the fiber-packed metal capillary as a miniaturized GC column with an increased sample loading capacity.     

Rapid determination of molecular parameters of synthetic polymers by precipitation/redissolution high‐performance liquid chromatography using “molded” monolithic column

Rapid high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) of polystyrenes, poly(methyl methacrylates), poly(vinyl acetates), and polybutadienes using a monolithic 50 × 4.6 mm i.d. poly(styrene‐co‐divinylbenzene) column have been carried out. The separation process involves precipitation of the macromolecules on the macroporous monolithic column followed by progressive elution utilizing a gradient of the mobile phase. Depending on the character of the separated polymer, solvent gradients were composed of a poor solvent such as water, methanol, or hexane and increasing amounts of a good solvent such as THF or dichloromethane. Monolithic columns are ideally suited for this technique because convection through the large pores of the monolith enhances the mass transport of large polymer molecules and accelerates the separation process. Separation conditions including the selection of a specific pair of solvent and precipitant, flow rate, and gradient steepness were optimized for the rapid HPLC separations of various polymers that differed broadly in their molecular weights. Excellent separations were obtained demonstrating that the precipitation‐redissolution technique is a suitable alternative to size‐exclusion chromatography (SEC). The molecular weight parameters calculated from the HPLC data match well those obtained by SEC. However, compared to SEC, the determination of molecular parameters using gradient elution could be achieved at comparable flow rates in a much shorter period of time, typically in about 1 min. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Polym Sci A: Polym Chem 38: 2767–2778, 2000     

Liquid Chromatographic Separation of Olefin Oligomers and its Relation to Separation of Polyolefins – an Overview

Summary: Linear and branched alkanes are oligomers of polyethylene. Alkanes with higher molar masses are called waxes. These substances are widely used as fuels, oils, lubricants, etc. and for these reasons many groups have tried to analyse, separate and characterise alkanes by various methods, including liquid chromatography. Alkanes may be separated according to their size in solution by SEC. In addition to chromatographic systems separating in the SEC mode, various sorbent-solvent systems have been published, where alkanes have been separated one from another by adsorption and/or precipitation mechanism. The mobile phase is either a non-polar solvent or a polar solvent or a mixture of a solvent and a non-solvent for alkanes. Even near critical conditions, which have several advantages for applications of HPLC in polymer analysis, have been identified for alkanes. Moreover, selective separations of branched alkanes according to their structure have been published. In the majority of these published studies, solvents with low boiling points have been used as the mobile phases, which do not allow dissolution of crystalline polyolefins at atmospheric pressure. However, taking into account experiences with the separation of alkanes, new HPLC systems for the separation of polyolefins may be developed. This is a major challenge and first results are presented in this contribution.     

Size-exclusion chromatography—from high-performance to ultra-performance

Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) enables measurement of the average molecular weights and molecular-weight distributions of polymers. Because these characteristics may, in turn, be correlated with important performance characteristics of plastics, SEC is an essential analytical technique for characterization of macromolecules. Although SEC is one of the oldest instrumental chromatographic techniques, it is still under continuous development, as a result of the great demand for increased resolution and faster analysis in SEC. Ultra-high-pressure size-exclusion chromatography (UHPSEC) was recently introduced to satisfy the growing demands of analytical chemists. Using instrumentation capable of generating very high pressures and columns packed with small particles, this technique enables greater separation efficiency and faster analysis than are achieved with conventional SEC. UHPSEC is especially advantageous for high-resolution analysis of oligomers, for very rapid polymer separations, and as a second dimension in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography of polymers. In this paper we discuss the benefits of UHPSEC for separation of macromolecules, with examples from the literature.     

Improved performance of protein separation by continuous annular chromatography in the size-exclusion mode.

In size-exclusion chromatography (SEC), proteins and peptides are separated according to their molecular size in solution. SEC is especially useful as an effective fractionation step to separate a vast amount of impurities from the components of interest and/or as final step for the separation of purified proteins from their aggregates, in a so-called polishing step. However, the throughput in SEC is low compared to other chromatographic processes as good resolution can be achieved only with a limited feed volume (i.e., maximal approximately 5% of the column volume can be loaded). This limitation opposed widespread application of conventional SEC in industry despite its excellent separation potential. Therefore a continuous separation process (namely preparative continuous annular chromatography) was developed and compared to a conventional SEC system both using Superdex 200 prep grade as sorbent. An immunoglobulin G sample with a high content of aggregates was chosen as a model protein solution. The influence of the feed flow-rate, eluent flow-rate and rotation rate on the separation efficiency was investigated. The height equivalent to a theoretical plate was lower for preparative continuous annular chromatography which could be explained by reduced extra column band broadening. The packing quality was proved to be identical for both systems. The productivity of conventional batch SEC was lower compared to continuous SEC, consequently buffer consumption was higher in batch mode.     

Size-Exclusion Chromatography: A Twenty-First Century Perspective

Now in its sixth decade, size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) remains the premier method by which to determine the molar mass averages and distributions of natural and synthetic macromolecules. Aided by its coupling to a variety and multiplicity of detectors, it has also shown its ability to characterize a host of other physicochemical properties, such as branching, chemical, and sequence length heterogeneity size distribution; chain rigidity; fractal dimension and its change as a function of molar mass; etc. SEC is also an integral part of most macromolecular two-dimensional separations, providing a second-dimension size-based technique for determining the molar mass of the components separated in the first dimension according to chemical composition, thus yielding the combined chemical composition and molar mass distributions of a sample. While the potential of SEC remains strong, our awareness of the pitfalls and challenges inherent to it and to its practice must also be ever-present. This Perspective aims to highlight some of the advantages and applications of SEC, to bring to the fore these caveats with regard to its practice, and to provide an outlook as to potential areas for expansion and growth.

     

Liquid chromatography of polymers under limiting conditions of adsorption. IV. Sample recovery

The high performance liquid chromatography of polymers under limiting conditions of adsorption (LC LCA) separates macromolecules, either according to their chemical structure or physical architecture, while molar mass effect is suppressed. A polymer sample is injected into an adsorption-active column flushed with an adsorption promoting eluent. The sample solvent is a strong solvent which prevents sample adsorption. As a result, macromolecules of sample elute within the zone of their original solvent to be discriminated from other, non-adsorbing polymer species, which elute in the exclusion mode. LC LCA sample recovery has been studied in detail for poly (methyl methacrylate)s using a bare silica gel column and an eluent comprised toluene (adsorli) and tetrahydrofuran (desorli). Sample solvent was tetrahydrofuran. It was found that a large part of injected sample may be fully retained within the LC LCA columns. The amount of retained polymer increases with decreasing packing pore size and with higher sample molar masses and, likely, also with the column diameter. The extent of full retention of sample does not depend of sample volume. An additional portion of the injected desorli sample solvent (a tandem injection) does not fully eliminate full retention of the sample fraction and the reduced recovery associated with it. The injected sample is retained along the entire LC LCA column. The reduced sample recovery restricts applicability of many LC LCA systems to oligomers and to discrimination of the non-adsorbing minor macromolecular components of complex polymer mixtures from the adsorbing major component(s). The full retention of sample molecules within columns may also complicate the application of other liquid chromatographic methods, which combine entropic and enthalpic retention mechanisms for separation of macromolecules.     

Comprehensive two‐dimensional monolithic liquid chromatography of polar compounds

Two‐dimensional liquid chromatography largely increases the number of separated compounds in a single run, theoretically up to the product of the peaks separated in each dimension on the columns with different selectivities. On‐line coupling of a reversed‐phase column with an aqueous normal‐phase (hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography) column yields orthogonal systems with high peak capacities. Fast on‐line two‐dimensional liquid chromatography needs a capillary or micro‐bore column providing low‐volume effluent fractions transferred to a short efficient second‐dimension column for separation at a high mobile phase flow rate. We prepared polymethacrylate zwitterionic monolithic micro‐columns in fused silica capillaries with structurally different dimethacrylate cross‐linkers. The columns provide dual retention mechanism (hydrophilic interaction and reversed‐phase). Setting the mobile phase composition allows adjusting the separation selectivity for various polar substance classes. Coupling on‐line an organic polymer monolithic capillary column in the first dimension with a short silica‐based monolithic column in the second dimension provides two‐dimensional liquid chromatography systems with high peak capacities. The silica monolithic C₁₈ columns provide higher separation efficiency than the particle‐packed columns at the flow rates as high as 5 mL/min used in the second dimension. Decreasing the diameter of the silica monolithic columns allows using a higher flow rate at the maximum operation pressure and lower fraction volumes transferred from the first, hydrophilic interaction dimension, into the second, reversed‐phase mode, avoiding the mobile phase compatibility issues, improving the resolution, increasing the peak capacity, and the peak production rate.