3D QSAR and molecular docking studies of benzimidazole derivatives as hepatitis C virus NS5B polymerase inhibitors

The urgent need for novel HCV antiviral agents has provided an impetus for understanding the structural requisites of NS5B polymerase inhibitors at the molecular level. Toward this objective, comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) of 67 HCV NS5B polymerase inhibitors were performed using two methods. First, ligand-based 3D QSAR studies were performed based on the lowest energy conformations employing the atom fit alignment method. Second, receptor-based 3D QSAR models were derived from the predicted binding conformations obtained by docking all NS5B inhibitors at the allosteric binding site of NS5B (PDB ID: 2dxs). Results generated from the ligand-based model were found superior (r2cv values of 0.630 for CoMFA and 0.668 for CoMSIA) to those obtained by the receptor-based model (r2cv values of 0.536 and 0.561 for CoMFA and CoMSIA, respectively). The predictive ability of the models was validated using a structurally diversified test set of 22 compounds that had not been included in a preliminary training set of 45 compounds. The predictive r2 values for the ligand-based CoMFA and CoMSIA models were 0.734 and 0.800, respectively, while the corresponding predictive r2 values for the receptor-based CoMFA and CoMSIA models were 0.538 and 0.639, respectively. The greater potency of the tryptophan derivatives over that of the tyrosine derivatives was interpreted based on CoMFA steric and electrostatic contour maps. The CoMSIA results revealed that for a NS5B inhibitor to have appreciable inhibitory activity it requires hydrogen bond donor and acceptor groups at the 5-position of the indole ring and an R substituent at the chiral carbon, respectively. Interpretation of the CoMFA and CoMSIA contour maps in context of the topology of the allosteric binding site of NS5B provided insight into NS5B-inhibitor interactions. Taken together, the present 3D QSAR models were found to accurately predict the HCV NS5B polymerase inhibitory activity of structurally diverse test set compounds and to yield reliable clues for further optimization of the benzimidazole derivatives in the data set.     

CBP/P300溴结构域联芳基类抑制剂三维定量构效关系研究

CREB结合蛋白(CBP)和与其高度同源的P300蛋白是组蛋白乙酰化酶的两个亚型,两者通过它们的溴结构域(bromodomain,BRD)与染色质结合,目前,CBP/P300已经成为人类在肿瘤靶点领域中的研究热点。本研究基于CBP/P300溴结构域联芳基类抑制剂建立三维定量构效关系,采用比较分子力场分析法(Co MFA)和比较分子相似性指数分析法(Co MSIA)分别建立35个已知活性抑制剂的3D-QSAR模型,以确定CBP/P300溴结构域联芳基类抑制剂分子结构与生物活性之间的定量关系。Co MFA和Co MSIA模型活性数据p IC50的预测值与实验值基本一致,说明这两个模型具有较高的预测能力和统计学意义。根据Co MFA和Co MSIA模型所提供的立体场、静电场、疏水场、氢键给体场、氢键供体场等信息提出了改善此类抑制剂活性的药物设计思路,为指导设计具有更高活性的新分子和预测更加有效的CBP/P300溴结构域抑制剂提供理论依据。     

Molecular modeling studies on 11H-dibenz[b,e]azepine and dibenz[b,f][1,4]oxazepine derivatives as potent agonists of the human TRPA1 receptor

A computational strategy based on comparative molecular fields analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) was performed on a series of the 11H-dibenz[b,e]azepine and dibenz[b,f][1,4]oxazepine derivatives as potent agonists of the human TRPA1 receptor. The CoMFA and CoMSIA models resulting from a 21 molecule training set gave r2(cv) values of 0.631 and 0.542 and r2 values of 0.986 and 0.981, respectively. The statistically significant models were validated by a test set of five compounds with predictive r2(pred). values of 0.967 and 0.981 for CoMFA and CoMSIA, respectively. A systemic external validation was also performed on the established models. The information obtained from 3D counter maps could facilitate the design of more potent human TRPA1 receptor agonists.     

苯并呋喃类N-肉豆蔻酰基转移酶抑制剂的三维定量构效关系研究

摘要采用比较分子力场分析法(CoMFA)和比较分子相似性指数分析法(CoMSIA), 系统地研究了40个苯并呋喃类N-肉豆蔻酰基转移酶(NMT)抑制剂的三维定量构效关系. 在CoMFA研究中, 考察了网格点步长对模型统计结果的影响. 在CoMSIA研究中, 研究了各种分子场组合、 网格点步长和衰减因子对模型统计结果的影响, 发现立体场、 静电场、 疏水场和氢键受体场的组合可得到最佳模型. 所建立的CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的交叉相关系数q2值分别为0.759和0.730, 均具有较强的预测能力. 利用CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的三维等值线图直观地解释了化合物的构效关系, 阐明了化合物结构中苯并呋喃环上各位置取代基对抑酶活性的影响, 为进一步结构优化提供了重要依据.     

3D QSAR studies on protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B inhibitors: comparison of the quality and predictivity among 3D QSAR models obtained from different conformer-based alignments

A set of 65 flexible peptidomimetic competitive inhibitors (52 in the training set and 13 in the test set) of protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B (PTP1B) has been used to compare the quality and predictive power of 3D quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) models for the three most commonly used conformer-based alignments, namely, cocrystallized conformer-based alignment (CCBA), docked conformer-based alignment (DCBA), and global minima energy conformer-based alignment (GMCBA). These three conformers of 5-[(2S)-2-({(2S)-2-[(tert-butoxycarbonyl)amino]-3-phenylpropanoyl}amino)3-oxo-3-pentylamino)propyl]-2-(carboxymethoxy)benzoic acid (compound number 66) were obtained from the X-ray structure of its cocrystallized complex with PTP1B (PDB ID: 1JF7), its docking studies, and its global minima by simulated annealing. Among the 3D QSAR models developed using the above three alignments, the CCBA provided the optimal predictive CoMFA model for the training set with cross-validated r2 (q2)=0.708, non-cross-validated r2=0.902, standard error of estimate (s)=0.165, and F=202.553 and the optimal CoMSIA model with q2=0.440, r2=0.799, s=0.192, and F=117.782. These models also showed the best test set prediction for the 13 compounds with predictive r2 values of 0.706 and 0.683, respectively. Though the QSAR models derived using the other two alignments also produced statistically acceptable models in the order DCBA>GMCBA in terms of the values of q2, r2, and predictive r2, they were inferior to the corresponding models derived using CCBA. Thus, the order of preference for the alignment selection for 3D QSAR model development may be CCBA>DCBA>GMCBA, and the information obtained from the CoMFA and CoMSIA contour maps may be useful in designing specific PTP1B inhibitors.     

含呋喃环双酰脲类衍生物的三维定量构效关系研究

采用比较分子力场分析法(CoMFA)和比较分子相似性指数分析法(CoMSIA), 对27个新型双酰基脲类化合物的杀蚊幼虫(Aedes aegypti L.)活性进行三维定量构效关系(3D-QSAR)研究. 在CoMFA研究中, 考察了网格点步长对统计结果的影响. 在CoMSIA研究中, 系统考察了各种分子场组合、网格点步长和衰减因子对模型统计结果的影响, 发现立体场和氢键供体场的组合得到最佳模型. 所建立的CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的非交叉验证相关系数r2值分别为0.828和0.841, 并都具有较强的预测能力. CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的三维等值图不仅直观地解释了结构与活性的关系, 而且为后续优化该系列化合物提供了理论依据.     

Three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship analysis of the new potent sulfonylureas using comparative molecular similarity indices analysis

The present study describes the implementation of a new three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (3D-QSAR) technique: comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) to a set of novel herbicidal sulfonylureas targeted acetolactate synthase. Field expressions in terms of similarity indices in CoMSIA were applied instead of the usually used Lennard-Jones and Coulomb-type potentials in CoMFA. Two different kinds of alignment techniques including field-fit alignment and atom-by-atom fits were used to produce the molecular aggregate. The results indicated that those two alignment rules generated comparative 3D-QSAR models with similar statistical significance. However, from the predictive ability of the test set, the models from the alignment after maximal steric and electrostatic optimization were slightly better than those from the simple atom-by-atom fits. Moreover, systematic variations of some parameters in CoMSIA were performed to search the best 3D-QSAR model. A significant cross-validated q2 was obtained, indicating the predictive potential of the model for the untested compounds; meanwhile the predicted biological activities of the five compounds in the test set were in good agreement with the experimental values. The CoMSIA coefficient contour plots identified several key features explaining the wide range of activities, which were very valuable for us in tracing the properties that really matter and getting insight into the potential mechanisms of the intermolecular interactions between inhibitor and receptor, especially with respect to the design of new compounds.     

新型三唑类抗真菌化合物的三维定量构效关系研究

采用比较分子力场分析法(CoMFA)和比较分子相似性指数分析法(CoMSIA), 系统研究了40个新型三唑类化合物抗真菌活性的三维定量构效关系. 在CoMFA研究中, 研究了两种药效构象对模型的影响, 并考察了网格点步长对统计结果的影响. 在CoMSIA研究中, 系统考察了各种分子场组合、网格点步长和衰减因子对模型统计结果的影响, 发现立体场、静电场、疏水场和氢键受体场的组合得到最佳模型. 所建立CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的交叉相关系数q²值分别为0.718和0.655, 并都具有较强的预测能力. CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的三维等值线图直观地解释了化合物的构效关系, 阐明了化合物结构中苯环上各位置取代基对抗真菌活性的影响, 为进一步结构优化提供了重要依据.     

3D-QSAR and molecular docking study of LRRK2 kinase inhibitors by CoMFA and CoMSIA methods

Three-dimensional quantitative structure–activity relationship (3D-QSAR) modelling was conducted on a series of leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 (LRRK2) antagonists using CoMFA and CoMSIA methods. The data set, which consisted of 37 molecules, was divided into training and test subsets by using a hierarchical clustering method. Both CoMFA and CoMSIA models were derived using a training set on the basis of the common substructure-based alignment. The optimum PLS model built by CoMFA and CoMSIA provided satisfactory statistical results (q² = 0.589 and r² = 0.927 and q² = 0.473 and r² = 0.802, respectively). The external predictive ability of the models was evaluated by using seven compounds. Moreover, an external evaluation set with known experimental data was used to evaluate the external predictive ability of the porposed models. The statistical parameters indicated that CoMFA (after region focusing) has high predictive ability in comparison with standard CoMFA and CoMSIA models. Molecular docking was also performed on the most active compound to investigate the existence of interactions between the most active inhibitor and the LRRK2 receptor. Based on the obtained results and CoMFA contour maps, some features were introduced to provide useful insights for designing novel and potent LRRK2 inhibitors.     

Combretastatins类微管蛋白抑制剂的定量构效关系与结合模式

以Combretastatins的B环改造化合物为研究对象, 采用遗传函数分析方法进行了二维定量构效关系研究. 研究结果表明, Apol, PMI-mag, Dipole-mag, Hbond donor和RadOfGyration等描述符对该系列抑制剂活性的贡献最大. 采用比较分子场分析方法(CoMFA)和比较分子相似因子分析方法(CoMSIA)进行了三维定量构效关系研究, 建立的CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的交叉验证相关系数q2分别为0.630和0.634, 具有较强的预测能力. 利用CoMFA和CoMSIA模型的三维等势图解析了Combretastatins类化合物的构效关系, 阐明了B环上各取代基对抑制微管蛋白聚合活性的影响, 同时应用分子对接方法分析并验证了定量构效关系模型.     

Structure-based CoMFA and CoMSIA study of indolinone inhibitors of PDK1

Phosphoinositide-dependent protein kinase-1 (PDK1) is a Ser/Thr kinase which phosphorylates and activates members of the AGC kinase group known to control processes such as tumor cell growth, protection from apoptosis, and tumor angiogenesis. In this paper, CoMFA and CoMSIA studies were carried out on a training set of 56 conformationally rigid indolinone inhibitors of PDK1. Predictive 3D QSAR models, established using atom fit alignment rule based on crystallographic-bound conformation, had cross-validated (r _cv²) values of 0.738 and 0.816 and non-cross-validated (r _ncv²) values of 0.912 and 0.949 for CoMFA and CoMSIA models, respectively. The predictive ability of the CoMFA and CoMSIA models was determined using a test set of 14 compounds, which gave predictive correlation coefficients (r _pred²) of 0.865 and 0.837, respectively. Structure-based interpretation of the CoMFA and CoMSIA field properties provided further insights for the rational design of new PDK1 inhibitors. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

A ligand-based molecular modeling study on some matrix metalloproteinase-1 inhibitors using several 3D QSAR techniques

Some three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (3D-QSAR) models have been constructed using the comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices (CoMSIA) for a series of 84 proline-based plus 12 structurally more diversified nonproline matrix metalloproteinase inhibitors. The structures of these inhibitors were built from a structure template extracted from the crystal structure of stromelysin. The structures built were divided into the training and test sets for both the CoMFA and CoMSIA analyses for each being composed of 60 and 24 inhibitors, respectively. The structures in the training set were aligned using some alignment rules derived from the analysis of the Ligplot program on a recent crystal structure of ligand-collagenase-1 complex. Some stepwise CoMSIA's were performed on the aligned training set on which the best CoMFA result was obtained. The best CoMSIA model was identified from the stepwise results, and the corresponding pharmacophore features were used for the construction of a pharmacophore hypothesis by the Catalyst 4.9 program. The training set was extended to include 11 structurally more diversified and nonproline inhibitors. To construct a pharmacophore hypothesis, the conformation of 60 structurally aligned proline-based inhibitors was fixed, while that of the 11 structurally more diversified nonproline inhibitors was allowed to vary during the hypothesis construction process. It was found that the predicted activities by the top hypothesis constructed for both the training and test sets were as good in statistics as those predicted by the best CoMSIA model from which the hypothesis was derived. The top hypothesis was mapped onto the structures of several highly active inhibitors selected from both the training and test sets. The goodness of mapping on each inhibitor was found to be correlated well with the activity of each inhibitor.     

Comparing the quality and predictiveness between 3D QSAR models obtained from manual and automated alignment

A set of 113 flexible cyclic urea inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus protease (HIV-1 PR) was used to compare the quality and predictive power of CoMFA and CoMSIA models for manually or automatically aligned inhibitor set. Inhibitors that were aligned automatically with molecular docking were in agreement with information obtained from existing X-ray structures. Both alignment methods produced statistically significant CoMFA and CoMSIA models, with the best q(2) value being 0.649 and the best predictive r(2) being 0.754. The manual alignment gave statistically higher values, whereas the automated alignment gave more robust models for predicting the activities of an external inhibitor set. Both models utilized similar amino acids in the HIV-1 PR active site, supporting the idea that hydrogen bonds form between an inhibitor and the backbone carbonyl oxygens of Gly48 and Gly48' and also the backbone NH group of Asp30, Gly48, Asp29', and Gly48' of the enzyme. These results suggest that an automated inhibitor alignment can yield predictive 3D QSAR models that are well comparable to manual methods. Thus, an automated alignment method in creating 3D QSAR models is encouragable when a well-characterized structure of the target protein is available.     

Receptor-based modeling and 3D-QSAR for a quantitative production of the butyrylcholinesterase inhibitors based on genetic algorithm

Three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (3D-QSAR) models have been constructed using the comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) for a series of structurally related steroidal alkaloids as butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) inhibitors. Docking studies were employed to position the inhibitors into the BuChE active site to determine the most probable binding mode. The strategy was to explore multiple inhibitor conformations in producing a more reliable 3D-QSAR model. These multiple conformations were derived using the FlexS program. The conformation selection step for CoMFA was done by genetic algorithm. The genetic algorithm based CoMFA approach was found to be the best. Both CoMFA and CoMSIA yielded significant cross-validated q(2) values of 0.701 and 0.627 and the r(2) values of 0.979 and 0.982, respectively. These statistically significant models were validated by a test set of five compounds. Comparison of CoMFA and CoMSIA contour maps helped to identify structural requirements for the inhibitors and serves as a basis for the design of the next generation of the inhibitor analogues. The results demonstrate that the combination of ligand-based and receptor-based modeling with use of a genetic algorithm is a powerful approach to build 3D-QSAR models. These data can be used for the lead optimization process with respect to inhibition enhancement which is important for the drug discovery and development for Alzheimer's disease.     

A 3D-QSAR CoMSIA study on 3-azolylmethylindoles as anti-leishmanial agents

A three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (3D-QSAR) study using Comparative Molecular Similarity Indices Analysis (CoMSIA) was conducted on a series of 3-azolylmethylindoles as anti-leishmanial agents. Evaluation of 24 compounds synthesized in our laboratory served to establish the model. A random search was performed on the library of compounds, and molecules of the training set were aligned on common elements of template molecule 13, one of the most active compounds. The best predictions were obtained from multifit procedure with a CoMSIA model combining steric, electrostatic, hydrophobic and hydrogen bond acceptor fields (q2 = 0.594, r2 = 0.897). The model was validated using an external test set of 7 compounds giving a satisfactory predictive r2 value of 0.649. Information obtained from CoMSIA contour maps could be used for further design of more promising inhibitors.     

Molecular Modeling Studies of Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor Receptor Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitors Combining Molecular Docking and 3D-QSAR Methods

The vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and its receptor tyrosine kinases VEGFR-2 or kinase insertdomain receptor (KDR) have emerged as attractive targets for the design of novel anticancer agents. In the present work, molecular docking method combined with three dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationships (comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indice analysis (CoMSIA)) to analyze the possible interactions between KDR and those derivatives which acted as selective inhibitors. The CoMFA and CoMSIA models gave a cross-validated coefficient Q2 of 0.713 and 0.549, non-cross-validated R2 values of 0.974 and 0.878, and predicted R2 values of 0.966 and 0.823, respectively. The 3D contour maps generated by the CoMFA and CoMSIA models were used to identify the key structural requirements responsible for the biological activity. The information obtained from 3D-QSAR and docking studies were very helpful to design novel selective inhibitors of KDR with desired activity and good chemical property.     

Comparison of 3D quantitative structure-activity relationship methods: Analysis of the in vitro antimalarial activity of 154 artemisinin analogues by hypothetical active-site lattice and comparative molecular field analysis

Two three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (3D-QSAR) methods, comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and hypothetical active site lattice (HASL), were compared with respect to the analysis of a training set of 154 artemisinin analogues. Five models were created, including a complete HASL and two trimmed versions, as well as two CoMFA models (leave-one-out standard CoMFA and the guided-region selection protocol). Similar r2 and q2 values were obtained by each method, although some striking differences existed between CoMFA contour maps and the HASL output. Each of the four predictive models exhibited a similar ability to predict the activity of a test set of 23 artemisinin analogues, although some differences were noted as to which compounds were described well by either model.     

Exploring the molecular basis for selective cytotoxicity of lamellarins against human hormone-dependent T47D and hormone-independent MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells

Abstract  

The common structural requirements for cytotoxicity of lamellarins against two human breast cancer cell lines were determined using comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) techniques. Twenty lamellarins were selected to serve as the training set, whereas another group of six compounds were used as the test set. The best CoMFA and CoMSIA models for both cell lines yielded satisfactory predictive ability with r _cv² values in the range of 0.659–0.728. Additionally, the contour maps obtained from both the CoMFA and CoMSIA models agreed well with the experimental results and may be used in the design of more potent cytotoxic compounds for human breast cancers. Both analyses not only suggested structural requirements of various substituents around the lamellarin skeleton for their cytotoxic activity against both human breast cancer cell lines but also revealed the molecular basis for the differences between the saturated and unsaturated D-rings of the lamellarins.