A new measure of orthogonality for multi-dimensional chromatography

Multi-dimensional chromatographic techniques, such as (comprehensive) two-dimensional liquid chromatography and (comprehensive) two-dimensional gas chromatography, are increasingly popular for the analysis of complex samples, such as protein digests or mineral oils. The reason behind the popularity of these techniques is the superior performance, in terms of peak-production rate (peak capacity per unit time), that multi-dimensional separations offer compared to their one-dimensional counterparts. However, to fully utilize the potential of multi-dimensional chromatography it is essential that the separation mechanisms used in each dimension be independent of each other. In other words, the two separation mechanisms need to be orthogonal. A number of algorithms have been proposed in the literature for measuring chromatographic orthogonality. However, these methods have their limitations, such as reliance on the division of the separation space into bins, need for specialist software or requirement of advanced programming skills. In addition, some of the existing methods for measuring orthogonality include regions of the separation space that do not feature peaks. In this paper we introduce a number of equations which provides information on the spread of the peaks within the separation space in addition to measuring orthogonality, without the need for complex computations or division of the separation space into bins.     

The role of separation science in proteomics research.

In the last few years there has been an increased effort into the separation, quantification and identification of all proteins in a cell or tissue. This is a review of the role gel electrophoresis, high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), and capillary electrophoresis (CE) play in proteomics research. The capabilities and limitations of each separation technique have been pointed out. Instrumental strategies for the resolution of cell proteins which are based on efficient separation employing either a single high-resolution procedure or a multidimensional approach on-line or off-line, and a mass spectrometer for protein identification have been reviewed. A comparison of the advantages of multi-dimensional separations such as two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, HPLC-HPLC, and HPLC-CE to the separation of cell and tissue proteins are discussed. Also, a discussion of novel approaches to protein concentration, separation, detection, and quantification is given.     

Characterization of complex copolymers by two-dimensional Liquid Chromatography

Complex polymers were characterized by combinations of different chromatographic separation mechanisms: liquid adsorption chromatography (LAC), liquid chromatography under critical conditions (LCCC), and liquid exclusion-adsorption chromatography (LEAC). These techniques were combined off-line and on-line in two-dimensional separations. Fatty acid ethoxylates, fatty esters of polyethylene glycol (PEG) and polysorbates were analyzed by two-dimensional liquid chromatography with normal phase LAC as the first and liquid chromatography at critical conditions (LCCC) or liquid exclusion adsorption chromatography (LEAC) as the second dimension. A full separation of all oligomers to the baseline could be achieved in both dimensions. In two-dimensional separations, the offline approach is compared to comprehensive chromatography, and the scope and limitations of both techniques are discussed.     

Multi-dimensional chromatography using on-line coupled microcolumn liquid chromatography—capillary gas chromatography for quantitative pesticide residue analysis

Highly selective separations can be achieved by utilizing different separation modes in a multi-dimensional (on-line coupled) chromatographic system. The application of such a system utilizing microcolumn liquid chromatography coupled on-line to capillary gas chromatography for the determination of 2-(1,1-dimethylethyl)-5-pyrimidinol, a pesticide metabolite, in various corn matrices at the ng g^?1 level is described. A comparative quantitative study with conventional manual sample pretreatments followed by capillary gas chromatography-mass spectrometry indicated equivalence between the two techniques. The system offers the advantages of reduced sample handling steps and analysis time, high potential for automation and adequate sensitivity.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography — practical impacts of theoretical considerations. A review

A theory of comprehensive two-dimensional separations by liquid chromatographic techniques is overviewed. It includes heart-cutting and comprehensive two-dimensional separation modes, with attention to basic concepts of two-dimensional separations: resolution, peak capacity, efficiency, orthogonality and selectivity. Particular attention is paid to the effects of sample structure on the retention and advantages of a multi-dimensional HPLC for separation of complex samples according to structural correlations. Optimization of 2D separation systems, including correct selection of columns, flow-rate, fraction volumes and mobile phase, is discussed. Benefits of simultaneous programmed elution in both dimensions of LCxLC comprehensive separations are shown.     

Miniaturized sample preparation combined with liquid phase separations

Miniaturized sample preparation methods designed as the sample pretreatment for liquid phase separations, such as liquid chromatography, capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrochromatography, have been reviewed especially for the on-line coupling of the sample preparation process and the separation process. The development of the desorption interfaces for the effective combining of the sample preparation and subsequent liquid phase separations is briefly described along with the applications of the combined analytical systems to the analysis of complex sample mixtures such as biological and environmental matrices. Novel use of fine polymeric filaments as the extraction medium for microscale liquid phase separation methods are investigated and a comparison is made with other sample preparation techniques. Polymer coating onto the fibrous material is also introduced to further develop microscale sample preparation methods with improved extraction performance. Several other microscale sample preparation methods having a potential compatibility to the liquid phase separations are also described for future applications of these techniques.     

Comparison of ultra high performance supercritical fluid chromatography,ultra high performance liquid chromatography,and gas chromatography for the separation of synthetic cathinones

A comparison of ultra high performance supercritical fluid chromatography, ultra high performance liquid chromatography, and gas chromatography for the separation of synthetic cathinones has been conducted. Nine different mixtures of bath salts were analyzed in this study. The three different chromatographic techniques were examined using a general set of controlled synthetic cathinones as well as a variety of other synthetic cathinones that exist as positional isomers. Overall 35 different synthetic cathinones were analyzed. A variety of column types and chromatographic modes were examined for developing each separation. For the ultra high performance supercritical fluid chromatography separations, analyses were performed using a series of Torus and Trefoil columns with either ammonium formate or ammonium hydroxide as additives, and methanol, ethanol or isopropanol organic solvents as modifiers. Ultra high performance liquid chromatographic separations were performed in both reversed phase and hydrophilic interaction chromatographic modes using SPP C18 and SPP HILIC columns. Gas chromatography separations were performed using an Elite‐5MS capillary column. The orthogonality of ultra high performance supercritical fluid chromatography, ultra high performance liquid chromatography, and gas chromatography was examined using principal component analysis. For the best overall separation of synthetic cathinones, the use of ultra high performance supercritical fluid chromatography in combination with gas chromatography is recommended.     

Capillary electrochromatography of peptides in a microfabricated system.

Reversed-phase liquid chromatography of tryptic peptides is shown in the capillary electrochromatography mode using microfabricated columns. Although selectivity is different, a mixture of tryptic peptides from ovalbumin appears to be as easily separated in the CEC as HPLC mode. The major difference between a separation in the macrofabricated CEC column and conventional separations in the HPLC mode is that separations are more readily achieved in the isocratic mode in the lower surface area microfabricated CEC columns.     

Fully automated online multi-dimensional protein profiling system for complex mixtures

For high throughput proteome analysis of highly complex protein mixtures, we have constructed a fully automated online system for multi-dimensional protein profiling, which utilizes a combination of two-dimensional liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectrometry (2D-LC-MS-MS), based on our well-established offline system described previously [K. Fujii, T. Nakano, T. Kawamura, F. Usui, Y. Bando, R. Wang, T. Nishimura, J. Proteome Res. 3 (2004) 712]. A two-valve switching system on a programmable auto sample injector is utilized for online two-dimensional chromatography with strong cation-exchange (SCX) and reversed-phase (RP) separations. The SCX separation is carried out during the equilibration of RP chromatography and the entire sequence of analysis was performed under fully automated conditions within 4 h, based on six SCX fractionations, and 40 min running time for the two-dimensional RP chromatography. In order to evaluate its performance in the detection and identification of proteins, digests of six standard proteins and yeast 20S proteasome have been analyzed and their results were compared to those obtained by the one-dimensional reversed-phase chromatography system (ID-LC-MS-MS). The 2D-LC-MS-MS system demonstrated that both the number of peptide fragments detected and the protein coverage had more than doubled. Furthermore, this multi-dimensional protein profiling system was also applied to the human 26S proteasome, which is one of the highly complex protein mixtures. Consequently, 723 peptide fragments were identified as 31 proteasome components, together with other coexisting proteins in the sample. The identification could be comprehensively performed with a 63% sequence coverage on an average, and additionally, with modifications at the N-terminus. These results indicated that the online 2D-LC-MS-MS system being described here is capable of analyzing highly complex protein mixtures in a high throughput manner, and that it would be applicable to dynamic proteomics.     

Trends in countercurrent chromatography

Since the early 1970s countercurrent chromatography has achieved a remarkable advance and is currently yielding rapid and efficient chromatographic separations that are comparable with those obtained with preparative high-performance liquid chromatography. The method further provides unique applications such as partition with polymer phase systems, foam separation and liquid—liquid dual countercurrent chromatography.     

Enhanced‐fluidity liquid chromatography using mixed‐mode hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography/strong cation‐exchange retention mechanisms

The potential of enhanced‐fluidity liquid chromatography, a subcritical chromatography technique, in mixed‐mode hydrophilic interaction/strong cation‐exchange separations is explored, using amino acids as analytes. The enhanced‐fluidity liquid mobile phases were prepared by adding liquefied CO₂ to methanol/water mixtures, which increases the diffusivity and decreases the viscosity of the mixture. The addition of CO₂ to methanol/water mixtures resulted in increased retention of the more polar amino acids. The “optimized” chromatographic performance (achieving baseline resolution of all amino acids in the shortest amount of time) of these methanol/water/CO₂ mixtures was compared to traditional acetonitrile/water and methanol/water liquid chromatography mobile phases. Methanol/water/CO₂ mixtures offered higher efficiencies and resolution of the ten amino acids relative to the methanol/water mobile phase, and decreased the required isocratic separation time by a factor of two relative to the acetonitrile/water mobile phase. Large differences in selectivity were also observed between the enhanced‐fluidity and traditional liquid mobile phases. A retention mechanism study was completed, that revealed the enhanced‐fluidity mobile phase separation was governed by a mixed‐mode retention mechanism of hydrophilic interaction/strong cation‐exchange. On the other hand, separations with acetonitrile/water and methanol/water mobile phases were strongly governed by only one retention mechanism, either hydrophilic interaction or strong cation exchange, respectively.     

Ultrathin layer chromatography on nanostructured thin films

Ultrathin layer chromatography (UTLC) is a relatively new variant of thin layer chromatography, with a 10mum thick monolithic silica sorbent layer that gives faster separations with lower limits of detection and reduced analyte and solvent volumes. We have produced UTLC plates with controllable nanostructure and thickness, and show that the layer separation characteristics depends on the film nanostructure. We also show that layers made with in-plane anisotropic nanostructures will exhibit a decoupling effect, where the analyte spots do not develop in the same direction as the solvent front movement. The added layer morphology and material selection adds a degree of freedom to UTLC, and may have applications in multi-dimensional TLC.     

Two‐dimensional separation techniques using supercritical fluid chromatography

High‐resolution separation systems are essential for the analysis of complex mixtures in a wide variety of application areas. To increase resolution, multidimensional chromatographic techniques have been one key solution. Supercritical fluid chromatography provides a unique opportunity in these multidimensional separations based on its potential for high solvent compatibility, rapid duty cycles, and orthogonality to other separation modes. This review focuses on two‐dimensional chromatography methods from the past decade that use supercritical fluid chromatography because of these advantages. Valving schemes and modulation strategies used to interface supercritical fluid chromatography with other liquid chromatography and gas chromatography techniques are described. Particular applications of multidimensional separations using supercritical fluid chromatography for the analysis of oils and chiral separations of pharmaceutical compounds are highlighted. Limitations of and a potential trajectory for supercritical fluid chromatography in this field are also discussed.     

Stationary and mobile phases in hydrophilic interaction chromatography: a review

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) is valuable alternative to reversed-phase liquid chromatography separations of polar, weakly acidic or basic samples. In principle, this separation mode can be characterized as normal-phase chromatography on polar columns in aqueous-organic mobile phases rich in organic solvents (usually acetonitrile). Highly organic HILIC mobile phases usually enhance ionization in the electrospray ion source of a mass spectrometer, in comparison to mobile phases with higher concentrations of water generally used in reversed-phase (RP) LC separations of polar or ionic compounds, which is another reason for increasing popularity of this technique. Various columns can be used in the HILIC mode for separations of peptides, proteins, oligosaccharides, drugs, metabolites and various natural compounds: bare silica gel, silica-based amino-, amido-, cyano-, carbamate-, diol-, polyol-, zwitterionic sulfobetaine, or poly(2-sulphoethyl aspartamide) and other polar stationary phases chemically bonded on silica gel support, but also ion exchangers or zwitterionic materials showing combined HILIC-ion interaction retention mechanism. Some stationary phases are designed to enhance the mixed-mode retention character. Many polar columns show some contributions of reversed phase (hydrophobic) separation mechanism, depending on the composition of the mobile phase, which can be tuned to suit specific separation problems. Because the separation selectivity in the HILIC mode is complementary to that in reversed-phase and other modes, combinations of the HILIC, RP and other systems are attractive for two-dimensional applications. This review deals with recent advances in the development of HILIC phase separation systems with special attention to the properties of stationary phases. The effects of the mobile phase, of sample structure and of temperature on separation are addressed, too.     

Mobile phase effects on the retention on polar columns with special attention to the dual hydrophilic interaction–reversed‐phase liquid chromatography mechanism,a review

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography on polar columns in aqueous–organic mobile phases has become increasingly popular for the separation of many biologically important compounds in chemical, environmental, food, toxicological, and other samples. In spite of many new applications appearing in literature, the retention mechanism is still controversial. This review addresses recent progress in understanding of the retention models in hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography. The main attention is focused on the role of water, both adsorbed by the column and contained in the bulk mobile phase. Further, the theoretical retention models in the isocratic and gradient elution modes are discussed. The dual hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography reversed‐phase retention mechanism on polar columns is treated in detail, especially with respect to the practical use in one‐ and two‐dimensional liquid chromatography separations.     

Thermotropic Liquid Crystalline Side Group Polymers as Stationary Phases in High Performance Liquid Chromatography. II. the Mechanism of Separation

Abstract

Liquid crystalline side group polymers support coated on silica gels have been applied as stationary phases in high performance liquid chromatography. It has been possible to show that also in liquid chromatography, separations based on the mesophase structure can be observed in analogy to gas chromatography. From results of separations in which temperature, flow rate, sample concentration and the solvent strength of the mobile phase were varied, this work derives views on the fundamental mechanisms involved. In addition, it will be shown that different mechanisms are probably involved in the separation of steroids and dinitrobenzene isomers on these stationary phases.     

A thermodynamic approach to understanding liquid crystal selectivity in gas chromatography

Summary The thermodynamics of four new liquid crystals were investigated in order to understand their selectivity as stationary phases in gas chromatography. In this case study, liquid crystals with a benzoyloxy azobenzene mesogenic core substituted with heptyloxy (C7) and/or dioxyethylene ether (DOE) groups, were used. The chromatographic separations of linalool and citronellal, and of xylene, tetraethylbenzene and cresol isomers, which were achieved with the liquid crystal stationary phases, have been related to the dissolution thermodynamics of the solutes. The results gave us an insight into the mechanism of the molecular recognition involved in the separation processes.     

Facile and predictable means of separating the enantiomers of 5-arylhydantoins

The enantiomers of each member of a series of fifty-four 5-arylhydantoins of systematically varied structure are readily separated by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) on CSP 1 (commercially available as the Whelk-O 1) and elute in a consistent order. The separation factors for these enantiomers of the hydantoins typically exceed two, thus rendering preparative scale separations facile. When used with subcritical carbon dioxide containing 10% methanol, enantioselectivity is reduced but resolution, R_s, increases. A chiral recognition mechanism accounting for these separations is presented.     

Liquid chromatography techniques for characterizing poly(Vinyl Alcohol)

Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVOH) samples may contain several heterogeneities requiring the development of chromatographic techniques for characterization. Size exclusion separations have been carried out using a number of aqueous eluents, incorporating electrolyte, or electrolyte/organic modifier, or surfactant. The most favourable molecular size separation was obtained using 0.25% w/v sodium lauryl sulfate as eluent. Reasonable values for molecular weights of PVOH samples have been determined. Compositional distributions in copolymer systems can be assessed using high-performance liquid chromatography employing a reversed-phase separation mechanism. For poly(vinyl alcohol), gradient elution with water/tetrahydrofuran (THF) with a wide pore polystyrene-based packing produced separations dependent on degree of hydrolysis and sequence length distribution. The elution results were verified with a column packed with non-porous beads. Partially hydrolysed PVOH samples appeared to have a broad distribution of composition.