Applications of nuclear analytical techniques in environmental research. Plenary lecture.

Among nuclear analytical techniques, neutron activation analysis (NAA) is particularly useful for environmental studies. It affords low detection limits for many elements, high specificity and few sources of systematic error, which means that high accuracy is attainable. Neutron activation analysis is particularly useful for trace and ultra-trace analysis of environmental samples (water, soils, rocks and biological material). In trace element work associated with pollution, instrumental NAA is a powerful technique for multi-element surveys, in particular when combined with other spectroscopic techniques. Nuclear techniques, as with most analytical techniques, cannot be used to distinguish between different physico-chemical forms of an element per se. When used in combination with appropriate separation techniques, however, nuclear techniques can provide valuable information about trace element speciation in environmental and biological systems. From dynamic tracer experiments, i.e., addition of chemically well defined labelled compounds to environmental systems, valuable information can be obtained on the distribution of species and on microchemical processes influencing the physico-chemical forms. In these laboratories, speciation studies on trace elements in natural waters have been carried out by using instrumental NAA in combination with physical separation techniques, such as dialysis and ultrafiltration, in situ and in the laboratory. Dynamic radiotracer experiments have provided important information about processes influencing the speciation of trace elements in aquatic systems. Sequential extraction techniques have proved to be useful in studies on sediments and soils when combined with NAA. Sequential extractions also provide significant information about the physico-chemical behaviour of radionuclides supplied to natural soils from the Chernobyl accident.     

Current Role of NAA in Biological and Health-Related Environmental Studies as Exemplified by Programs of the IAEA

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has many projects and activities supporting the utilization of nuclear research reactors for neutron activation analysis (NAA). Globally the number of operating nuclear research reactors has been in decline since about 1975. This contrasts with the situation in developing countries where the numbers show a modest increase over the same period. This paper reviews the current status of NAA as seen from the particular perspective of IAEA programs involving studies of biological and environmental specimens. Some of the areas in which NAA is maintaining its role as a competitive technique are briefly reviewed.     

Applications of nuclear analytical techniques in human nutrition research as exemplified by research programmes of the international atomic energy agency

In human nutrition research, nuclear analytical techniques, particularly neutron activation analysis (NAA), are used mainly for thein vitro study of trace elements. According to work sponsored by the IAEA, up to 15 trace elements and 5 minor elements of nutritional interest may be determined in biological materials by NAA with good accuracy and precision. A programme is described in which NAA was used for the determination of 14 trace elements and one minor element in human milk. NAA also plays an important role in the certification of reference materials for nutritional studies.     

A software architectural framework specification for neutron activation analysis

Neutron Activation Analysis (NAA) is a sensitive multi-element nuclear analytical technique that has been routinely applied by research reactor (RR) facilities to environmental, nutritional, health related, geological and geochemical studies. As RR facilities face calls to increase their research output and impact, with existing or reducing budgets, automation of NAA offers a possible solution. However, automation has many challenges, not the least of which is a lack of system architecture standards to establish acceptable mechanisms for the various hardware/software and software/software interactions among data acquisition systems, specialised hardware such as sample changers, sample loaders, and data processing modules. This lack of standardization often results in automation hardware and software being incompatible with existing system components, in a facility looking to automate its NAA operations. This limits the availability of automation to a few RR facilities with adequate budgets or in-house engineering resources. What is needed is a modern open system architecture for NAA, that provides the required set of functionalities. This paper describes such an “architectural framework” (OpenNAA), and portions of a reference implementation. As an example of the benefits, calculations indicate that applying this architecture to the compilation and QA steps associated with the analysis of 35 elements in 140 samples, with 14 SRM’s, can reduce the time required by over 80 %. The adoption of open standards in the nuclear industry has been very successful over the years in promoting interchangeability and maximising the lifetime and output of nuclear measurement systems. OpenNAA will provide similar benefits within the NAA application space, safeguarding user investments in their current system, while providing a solid path for development into the future.     

Comparative analysis of ancient ceramics by neutron activation analysis,inductively coupled plasma-optical-emission spectrometry,inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry,and X-ray fluorescence

The accurate measurement of the maximum possible number of elements in ancient ceramic samples is the main requirement in provenance studies. For this reason neutron activation analysis (NAA) and X-ray fluorescence (XRF) have been successfully used for most of the studies. In this work the analytical performance of inductively coupled plasma-optical-emission spectrometry (ICP-OES) and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) has been compared with that of XRF and NAA for the chemical characterization of archaeological pottery. Correlation coefficients between ICP techniques and XRF or NAA data were generally better than 0.90. The reproducibility of data calculated on a sample prepared and analysed independently ten times was approximately 5% for most of the elements. Results from the ICP techniques were finally evaluated for their capacity to identify the same compositional pottery groups as results from XRF and NAA analysis, by use of multivariate statistics.     

Determination of uranium element concentration and235U isotope abundance by neutron activation analysis

A new neutron activation technique has been developed for the determination of uranium element concentration and²³⁵U isotope abundance in nuclear safeguards and reference material samples based on the activation of bare and cadmium-covered samples with different thermal to epithermal neutron flux ratios and on the combination of the two corre-sponding delayed-fission neutron measurements. The principle of the new technique can be applied also to improve multi-element neutron activation analysis.     

Application of different activation analysis techniques for determination of trace elements in human blood

One of the requirements of stable isotope tracer technique is detection of two isotopes of same element. It is preferable to use instrumental techniques in order not to contaminate the samples. Different instrumental nuclear techniques namely neutron activation analysis (NAA), photon activation analysis (IPAA), and prompt gamma ray activation analysis (PGAA) were tried on human blood samples. The techniques were found to be complementary to each other, NAA being the most sensitive of the three. Zinc is choosen for validation work among the three feasible elements (Zn, Cr, Se) for stable isotope tracer technique. As NAA was not sufficient to detect two isotopes of Zn, a radiochemical separation scheme was developed later.     

Methodological developments and applications of neutron activation analysis

The paper reviews the author’s experience acquired and achievements made in methodological developments of neutron activation analysis (NAA) of mostly biological materials. These involve epithermal neutron activation analysis, radiochemical neutron activation analysis using both single-and multi-element separation procedures, use of various counting modes, and the development and use of self-verification principle. The role of NAA in the detection of analytical errors is discussed and examples of applications of the procedures developed are given.     

Nuclear activation methods for the characterization of fossil fuels

A review is presented on the use of neutron activation analysis (NAA) for the analyses of coal, oil shale, tar sands and petroleum. Fast NAA has been widely used for the determination of oxygen, and to a limited extent, of other elements such as nitrogen and silicon. Reactor NAA followed by instrumental counting, and in specific cases, after radiochemical separations is discussed. Thermal and epithermal neutrons are both used. Limited use of the²⁵²Cf source has been made in fuel analysis. A complementary technique to NAA is the photon-activation analysis with linear accelerator. It can determine over thirty elements, many of them not possible to do by NAA. Round-robin analyses of standard coal, fly ash, or oil shale samples indicate nuclear activation methods are comparable in accuracy and precision to X-ray fluorescence or atomic spectrometric methods for most elements.     

Trendwatcher or trendsetter; 50 years of MTAA

The development on neutron activation analysis (NAA) into a technique of practical interest effectively started about 60 years ago, when nuclear reactors became available and widely accessible as intense sources of neutrons. During 50 out these 60 years, the series of Modern Trends in Activation Analysis (MTAA) Conferences acted as a true companion and facilitator of this growth. As trendwatcher they signalized the many initiatives that contributed to the development of activation analysis and its applications. A period has come to an end of impressive development resulting from sometimes revolutionary changes in radiation detection and data processing, and much improved irradiation facilities, NAA has reached a full stage of development, with emphasis on routine application and with remaining developments of in marginal impact. NAA is being challenged increasingly in the last 30 years by alternative techniques for multi trace element analysis. The MTAA Conference and with it the ICAA, the International Committee on Activation Analysis, can play an important and active role in this process of identifying and selecting key areas, and even promoting concerted action in those areas. Such an evolution of focus from retrospective to prospective, from trendwatcher to trendsetter, may well allow the MTAA Conference to continue and even expand its role in future development of NAA and its applications. The ideas about the future of the MTAA Conferences and its organization are elaborated upon and some possible subjects for focused development activities are indicated.     

An outline of the nuclear activation system at the Atominstitut

The process of nuclear activation analysis is rather complex compared to other analytical techniques. For improvement it is necessary to analyse performance of all individual components and to establish a list of requirements for further development of the system. The analysis of short-lived radionuclides offers a number of benefits to the analyst, but on the other hand calls for an analytical system, the organization of which is rather different from that of conventional NAA systems. This paper presents a summary of the Atominstituts nuclear activation system, its layout and organization. Sample preparation, activation, detection and computer action are described in their present form and in their intended future development.     

Dietary intakes of essential trace elements: Results from total diet studies supported by the IAEA

Summary The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has, for many years, supported research on human dietary intakes of trace elements taking advantage, for analysis, of the possibilities offered by nuclear techniques, particularly neutron activation analysis (NAA). This paper summarizes the results obtained from studies in more than 20 countries in which special emphasis was placed on the application of reliable methodologies (written protocols, special equipment, analytical quality control, etc.). Considerable variation was observed among dietary intakes of essential minor and trace elements though most elements showed a pattern of adequate nutrition in most countries. However, for some elements such as calcium, iodine, iron and zinc, the intakes in many countries were lower than the dietary requirements.     

Determination of alkali metals in control and AD brain samples by different techniques

Several metals are suspected or known to be involved in neurological disorders such as Alzheimer's disease (AD), therefore, elemental distribution studies have received intense attention for years. The present work focuses on a group of lesser studied elements in this context, alkali metals.Previously, an adequate neutron activation analysis (NAA) method has been developed and applied successfully for the determination of Na, K, Rb and Cs in brain samples of control subjects. This work has been extended to include AD patients, so that average values, distribution patterns and interpersonal variability could be compared and possible correlation between control and AD data could be studied.Despite the merits of the technique, its drawbacks are evident. Therefore, applicability of rapid spectrochemical methods as alternatives has been investigated. ICP-AES has been used for analysis of Li, Na and K. No interferences were observed, but ultrasonic nebulisation was needed for Li quantification. Rb and Cs were measured by ICP-MS with In as internal standard. Agreement between different techniques is found to be good for Na, K and Rb, while Cs values show somewhat higher differences.     

Intercomparison of moss reference material by different multi-element techniques

An intercomparison of data obtained for a moss reference material (Hylocomium splendens) used as biomonitor of atmospheric deposition by different multi-element techniques is presented. In total 43 elements (Na, Mg, Al, Cl, K, Ca, Sc, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Se, Br, Rb, Sr, Zr, Ag, Sn, Sb, I, Cs, Ba, La, Ce, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Tm, Yb, Lu, Hf, Ta, W, Au, Th, U) were determined using inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), conventional instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA), epithermal neutron activation analysis (ENAA) and as well as shorttime neutron activation analysis without and with a⁶LiD-converter. Advantages and drawbacks of each method are discussed. The introduction of moss reference materials for atmospheric multi-element deposition studies involving nuclear analytical techniques is strongly recommended.     

Neutron activation analysis without multi-element standards

The paper shows how, from the neutron irradiation of multi-element standards, one can derive neutron flux parameters for the irradiation position and, at the same time, greatly improve knowledge of nuclear data parameters, such as thermal cross sections, resonance integrals and gamma raz emission probabilities, for the nuclides concerned. It is then shown how the resulting neutron flux parameters and nuclear data parameters can be used to carry out neutron activation analysis without further irradiation of multi-element standards. The technique is applied to the analysis of Chinese geochemical reference material     

Review of neutron activation analysis in the standardization and study of reference materials, including its application to radionuclide reference materials

Summary Neutron activation analysis (NAA) plays a very important role in the certification of reference materials (RMs) and their characterization, including homogeneity testing. The features of the method are briefly reviewed, particularly aspects relating to its completely independent nuclear basis, its virtual freedom from blank problems, and its capacity for self-verification. This last aspect, arising from the essentially isotopic character of NAA, can be exploited by using different nuclear reactions and induced nuclides, and the possibility of employing two modes, one instrumental (nondestructive), the other radiochemical (destructive). This enables the derivation of essentially independent analytical information and the unique capacity of NAA for self-validation. The application of NAA to quantify natural or man-made radionuclides such as uranium, thorium, ²³⁷Np, ¹²⁹I and ²³⁰Th is discussed, including its advantages over conventional radiometric methods, and its usefulness in providing independent data for nuclides where other confirmatory analyses are impossible, or are only recently becoming available through newer atom counting techniques. Certain additional, prospective uses of NAA in the study of RMs and potential RMs are mentioned, including transmutation reactions, creation of endogenously radiolabelled matrices for production and study of RMs (such as dissolution and leaching tests, use as incorporated radiotracers for chemical recovery correction), and the possibility of molecular activation analysis for speciation.     

Nuclear-related analytical techniques: Literature retrieval from the INIS database

The applicability of the INIS database for literature retrieval on nuclear-related analytical techniques [e.g. neutron activation analysis (NAA), X-ray fluorescence (XRF), particle-induced X-ray emission (PIXE)] has been studied. There exist about 9700 documents on NAA and other forms of activation analysis, about 3500 documents on XRF and about 1200 documents on PIXE in the database collected from 1976 until July 1988. They cover a variety of elements and matrices in the fields of biology, geochemistry and the physical sciences. Some technical notes and comments on the practical use of this database are also included.     

Occupational nuclear medicine: Trace element analysis of living human subjects

Summary Several trace elements are toxic when present in excessive amounts. Such overloads occur most commonly in the occupational setting, although some environmental exposures are also of concern. The relationship between chronic exposure and health effects is best explored with the aid of knowledge of the quantity of element in question stored in the body. In vivo elemental analysis can provide this knowledge non-invasively for a number of elements of toxicological importance. In vivo analysis presents specific challenges, particularly the fact that the body is an extended medium, giving rise to extensive scattering and absorption. Also of primary importance, the radiation dose must be kept as low as reasonably possible and must in every case be within the range of other diagnostic procedures. Both the incident radiation and the detected signal must have an adequate mean free path in human tissue. This means that neutron activation analysis (NAA) and X-ray fluorescence (XRF) are the two most studied techniques. For some elements, analytical methods are established while others are under active development. For still others, no promising technique is currently available. The most fully developed techniques are for lead and cadmium. For lead three different XRF approaches have been put forward, although one, ¹⁰⁹Cd excited K XRF is most widely used. For cadmium, both prompt gamma NAA and XRF have been developed to the extent of full human studies. Amongst elements for which application to human studies has begun or is likely to begin shortly are aluminum and manganese, both using NAA.     

New Developments in Activation Analysis for Material and Environmental Sciences

Activation analysis in general and mainly reactor neutron activation analysis (NAA) has been used extensively for measuring trace elements in high purity materials, particularly semiconductor materials. The advantages of NAA in determination of trace elements differ from one semiconductor material to another. For all of them the inherent properties of activation analysis especially those of non contamination with the reagents, low blanks and high sensitivity are the reasons for the choice of NAA as the main analytical procedure. These inherent properties are essential for analysis of high-purity materials where concentrations of ppb's and sub ppb's have to be measured. NAA is specially suitable for the determination of trace elements in silicon due to the very short lived very low activity induced by neutron reaction in silicon. This enables easy instrumental (i.e. without chemical separations) determination of trace elements in silicon. In the HFR reactor at Peten, Netherlands, a special facility was constructed for irradiation of silicon samples of Philips, in which silicon wafers of up to 15 cm diameter can be irradiated with 4 × 10¹³n. cm^?2. sec^?1 and the irradiation is done for 72–96 hours. using large Ge(Li) detectors (100 to 150cc) and long counting time (8–16 hours) they measured 22 elements in concentrations below ppb and 10 others between ppb and 300 ppm. Trace elements in germanium have been determined both instrumentally after very long decay time (100 days) or after short decay time removing the activities from the matrix by chemical separation. Trace elements in GaAs are determined only after chemical separtion. Several other semiconductor material such as Sc, Te, GaP and CuInS₂ were also determined by NAA. Some trace elements cannot be determined by neutron activation. Carbon, nitrogen and oxygen are determined by activation with protons, alphas or ³He particles. Boron and hydrogen are determined by prompt emission induced by charged particle activation, which gives not only the total concentration but also the depth profile. Carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and phosphorus were also determined by prompt proton activation analysis. The environmental samples studied by activation analysis can be divided into three categories: atmospheric aerosols, water samples and solid wastes. NAA of atmospheric aerosols have been used for their posible toxicological hazards, their source identification and for studies of atmospheric transport processes.