Consequences of Pure Point Diffraction Spectra for Multiset Substitution Systems

Abstract. There is a growing body of results in the theory of discrete point sets and tiling systems giving conditions under which such systems are pure point diffractive. Here we look at the opposite direction: what can we infer about a discrete point set or tiling, defined through a primitive substitution system, given that it is pure point diffractive? Our basic objects are Delone multisets and tilings, which are self-replicating under a primitive substitution system of affine mappings with a common expansive map Q . Our first result gives a partial answer to a question of Lagarias and Wang: we characterize repetitive substitution Delone multisets that can be represented by substitution tilings using a concept of ``legal cluster.' This allows us to move freely between both types of objects. Our main result is that for lattice substitution multiset systems (in arbitrary dimensions), being a regular model set is not only sufficient for having pure point spectrum—a known fact—but is also necessary. This completes a circle of equivalences relating pure point dynamical and diffraction spectra, modular coincidence, and model sets for lattice substitution systems begun by the first two authors of this paper.     

Pure Point Diffractive Substitution Delone Sets Have the Meyer Property

We prove that a primitive substitution Delone set, which is pure point diffractive, is a Meyer set. This answers a question of J.C. Lagarias. We also show that for primitive substitution Delone sets, being a Meyer set is equivalent to having a relatively dense set of Bragg peaks. The proof is based on tiling dynamical systems and the connection between the diffraction and dynamical spectra. The first author acknowledges support from the NSERC post-doctoral fellowship and thanks the University of Washington and the University of Victoria for being the host universities of the fellowship. The second author is grateful to the Weizmann Institute of Science where he was a Rosi and Max Varon Visiting Professor when this work was completed. He was also supported in part by NSF Grant DMS 0355187.     

Pseudo-self-affine tilings in ℝ<Superscript>d</Superscript>

It is proved that every pseudo-self-affine tiling in ?^d is mutually locally derivable with a self-affine tiling. A characterization of pseudo-self-similar tilings in terms of derived Voronoï tessellations is a corollary. Previously, these results were obtained in the planar case, jointly with Priebe Frank. The new approach is based on the theory of graph-directed iterated function systems and substitution Delone sets developed by Lagarias and Wang. Bibliography: 18 titles.     

Invariant measures for non-primitive tiling substitutions

We consider self-affine tiling substitutions in Euclidean space and the corresponding tiling dynamical systems. It is well known that in the primitive case, the dynamical system is uniquely ergodic. We investigate invariant measures when the substitution is not primitive and the tiling dynamical system is non-minimal. We prove that all ergodic invariant probability measures are supported on minimal components, but there are other natural ergodic invariant measures, which are infinite. Under some mild assumptions, we completely characterize σ-finite invariant measures which are positive and finite on a cylinder set. A key step is to establish recognizability of non-periodic tilings in our setting. Examples include the “integer Sierpiński gasket and carpet” tilings. For such tilings, the only invariant probability measure is supported on trivial periodic tilings, but there is a fully supported σ-finite invariant measure that is locally finite and unique up to scaling.     

Lattice substitution systems and model sets

This paper studies ways in which the sets of a partition of a lattice in \Bbb R ⁿ become regular model sets. The main theorem gives equivalent conditions which assure that a matrix substitution system on a lattice in \Bbb R ⁿ gives rise to regular model sets (based on p -adic-like internal spaces), and hence to pure point diffractive sets. The methods developed here are used to show that the n -dimensional chair tiling and the sphinx tiling are pure point diffractive. Received January 13, 2000, and in revised form May 30, 2000. Online publication January 17, 2001.     

Fusion: a general framework for hierarchical tilings of \mathbb{R }^d

We introduce a formalism for handling general spaces of hierarchical tilings, a category that includes substitution tilings, Bratteli–Vershik systems, S-adic transformations, and multi-dimensional cut-and-stack transformations. We explore ergodic, spectral and topological properties of these spaces. We show that familiar properties of substitution tilings carry over under appropriate assumptions, and give counter-examples where these assumptions are not met. For instance, we exhibit a minimal tiling space that is not uniquely ergodic, with one ergodic measure having pure point spectrum and another ergodic measure having mixed spectrum. We also exhibit a 2-dimensional tiling space that has pure point measure-theoretic spectrum but is topologically weakly mixing.     

Crystallography and Riemann surfaces

The level set of an elliptic function is a doubly periodic point set in ℂ. To obtain a wider spectrum of point sets, we consider, more generally, a Riemann surface S immersed in ℂ² and its sections (“cuts”) by ℂ More specifically, we consider surfaces S defined in terms of a fundamental surface element obtained as a conformai map of triangular domains in ℂ. The discrete group of isometries of ℂ² generated by reflections in the triangle edges leaves S invariant and generalizes double-periodicity. Our main result concerns the special case of maps of right triangles, with the right angle being a regular point of the map. For this class of maps we show that only seven Riemann surfaces, when cut, form point sets that are discrete in ℂ. Their isometry groups all have a rank 4 lattice subgroup, but only three of the corresponding point sets are doubly periodic in ℂ. The remaining surfaces form quasiperiodic point sets closely related to the vertex sets of quasiperiodic tilings. In fact, vertex sets of familiar tilings are recovered in all cases by applying the construction to a piecewise flat approximation of the corresponding Riemann surface. The geometry of point sets formed by cuts of Riemann surfaces is no less “rigid” than the geometry determined by a tiling, and has the distinct advantage in having a regular behavior with respect to the complex parameter which specifies the cut.     

Detecting Combinatorial Hierarchy in Tilings Using Derived Voronoi Tessellations

   Abstract. Tilings of R ² can display hierarchy similar to that seen in the limit sequences of substitutions. Self-similarity for tilings has been used as the standard generalization, but this viewpoint is limited because such tilings are analogous to limit points of constant-length substitutions. To generalize limit points of non-constant-length substitutions, we define hierarchy for infinite, labelled graphs, then extend this definition to tilings via their dual graphs. Examples of combinatorially substitutive tilings that are not self-similar are given. We then find a sufficient condition for detecting combinatorial hierarchy that is motivated by the characterization by Durand of substitutive sequences. That characterization relies upon the construction of the ``derived sequence'—a recoding in terms of reappearances of an initial block. Following this, we define the ``derived Vorono? tiling'—a retiling in terms of reappearances of an initial patch of tiles. Using derived Vorono? tilings, we obtain a sufficient condition for a tiling to be combinatorially substitutive.     

Detecting Combinatorial Hierarchy in Tilings Using Derived Voronoi Tessellations

Abstract. Tilings of R ² can display hierarchy similar to that seen in the limit sequences of substitutions. Self-similarity for tilings has been used as the standard generalization, but this viewpoint is limited because such tilings are analogous to limit points of constant-length substitutions. To generalize limit points of non-constant-length substitutions, we define hierarchy for infinite, labelled graphs, then extend this definition to tilings via their dual graphs. Examples of combinatorially substitutive tilings that are not self-similar are given. We then find a sufficient condition for detecting combinatorial hierarchy that is motivated by the characterization by Durand of substitutive sequences. That characterization relies upon the construction of the ``derived sequence'—a recoding in terms of reappearances of an initial block. Following this, we define the ``derived Vorono? tiling'—a retiling in terms of reappearances of an initial patch of tiles. Using derived Vorono? tilings, we obtain a sufficient condition for a tiling to be combinatorially substitutive.     

Geometric Models for Quasicrystals I. Delone Sets of Finite Type

This paper studies three classes of discrete sets X in ⁿ which have a weak translational order imposed by increasingly strong restrictions on their sets of interpoint vectors X-X . A finitely generated Delone set is one such that the abelian group [X-X] generated by X-X is finitely generated, so that [X-X] is a lattice or a quasilattice. For such sets the abelian group [X] is finitely generated, and by choosing a basis of [X] one obtains a homomorphism . A Delone set of finite type is a Delone set X such that X-X is a discrete closed set. A Meyer set is a Delone set X such that X-X is a Delone set. Delone sets of finite type form a natural class for modeling quasicrystalline structures, because the property of being a Delone set of finite type is determined by ``local rules.' That is, a Delone set X is of finite type if and only if it has a finite number of neighborhoods of radius 2R , up to translation, where R is the relative denseness constant of X . Delone sets of finite type are also characterized as those finitely generated Delone sets such that the map ϕ satisfies the Lipschitz-type condition ||ϕ (x) - ϕ (x')|| < C ||x - x'|| for x, x' ∈X , where the norms || . . . || are Euclidean norms on ^s and ⁿ , respectively. Meyer sets are characterized as the subclass of Delone sets of finite type for which there is a linear map and a constant C such that ||ϕ (x) - (x)|| for all x∈X . Suppose that X is a Delone set with an inflation symmetry, which is a real number η > 1 such that . If X is a finitely generated Delone set, then η must be an algebraic integer; if X is a Delone set of finite type, then in addition all algebraic conjugates | η ' | η; and if X is a Meyer set, then all algebraic conjugates | η ' | 1. Received May 9, 1997, and in revised form March 5, 1998.     

Algorithm for determining pure pointedness of self-affine tilings

Overlap coincidence in a self-affine tiling in Rd is equivalent to pure point dynamical spectrum of the tiling dynamical system. We interpret the overlap coincidence in the setting of substitution Delone set in Rd and find an efficient algorithm to check the pure point dynamical spectrum. This algorithm is easy to implement into a computer program. We give the program and apply it to several examples. In the course of the proof of the algorithm, we show a variant of the conjecture of Urbański (Solomyak (2006) [40]) on the Hausdorff dimension of the boundaries of fractal tiles.     

Substitution tilings with statistical circular symmetry

Two new series of substitution tilings are introduced in which the tiles appear in infinitely many orientations. It is shown that several properties of the well-known pinwheel tiling do also hold for these new examples, and, in fact, for all primitive substitution tilings showing tiles in infinitely many orientations.     

Substitution Delone Sets

   Abstract. Substitution Delone set families are families of Delone sets X =(X ₁ , . . ., X _n ) which satisfy the inflation functional equation

Lattice triangulations of $\mathbb{E}^3 $ and of the 3-torus

This paper gives answers to a few questions concerning tilings of Euclidean spaces where the tiles are topological simplices with curvilinear edges. We investigate lattice triangulations of Euclidean 3-space in the sense that the vertices form a lattice of rank 3 and such that the triangulation is invariant under all translations of that lattice. This is the dual concept of a primitive lattice tiling where the tiles are not assumed to be Euclidean polyhedra but only topological polyhedra. In 3-space there is a unique standard lattice triangulation by Euclidean tetrahedra (and with straight edges) but there are infinitely many non-standard lattice triangulations where the tetrahedra necessarily have certain curvilinear edges. From the view-point of Discrete Differential Geometry this tells us that there are such triangulations of 3-space which do not carry any flat discrete metric which is equivariant under the lattice. Furthermore, we investigate lattice triangulations of the 3-dimensional torus as quotients by a sublattice. The standard triangulation admits such quotients with any number n ≥ 15 of vertices. The unique one with 15 vertices is neighborly, i.e., any two vertices are joined by an edge. It turns out that for any odd n ≥ 17 there is an n-vertex neighborly triangulation of the 3-torus as a quotient of a certain non-standard lattice triangulation. Combinatorially, one can obtain these neighborly 3-tori as slight modifications of the boundary complexes of the cyclic 4-polytopes. As a kind of combinatorial surgery, this is an interesting construction by itself.     

Linearly repetitive Delone sets are rectifiable

We show that every linearly repetitive Delone set in the Euclidean d  -space R^d${\mathbb{R}}^d$, with d?2$d?2$, is equivalent, up to a bi-Lipschitz homeomorphism, to the integer lattice Z^d${\mathbb{Z}}^d$. In the particular case when the Delone set X   in R^d${\mathbb{R}}^d$ comes from a primitive substitution tiling of R^d${\mathbb{R}}^d$, we give a condition on the eigenvalues of the substitution matrix which ensures the existence of a homeomorphism with bounded displacement from X   to the lattice βZ^d$\beta {\mathbb{Z}}^d$ for some positive β. This condition includes primitive Pisot substitution tilings but also concerns a much broader set of substitution tilings.     

Atomic surfaces, tilings and coincidence I. irreducible case

An irreducible Pisot substitution defines a graph-directed iterated function system. The invariant sets of this iterated function system are called the atomic surfaces. In this paper, a new tiling of atomic surfaces, which contains Thurston’sβ-tiling as a subclass, is constructed. Related tiling and dynamical properties are studied. Based on the coincidence condition defined by Dekking [Dek], we introduce thesuper-coincidence condition. It is shown that the super-coincidence condition governs the tiling and dynamical properties of atomic surfaces. We conjecture that every Pisot substitution satisfies the super-coincidence condition. The second author is supported by a JSPS Postdoc Fellowship.     

Tilings,substitution systems and dynamical systems generated by them

The object of this work is to study the properties of dynamical systems defined by tilings. A connection to symbolic dynamical systems defined by one- and two-dimensional substitution systems is shown. This is used in particular to show the existence of a tiling system such that its corresponding dynamical system is minimal and topological weakly mixing. We remark that for one-dimensional tilings the dynamical system always contains periodic points.     

Investigation of the <1,q> point systems

Delone introduced the concept of the (r,R) point system. In this paper we investigate the thickness of 〈1,q〉 point systems in the d-dimensional Euclidean spaces. We determine the maximum of the thickness of 〈1,q〉 point systems for some q in the non lattice case when the dimension of the space is equal to 2,3,...,7, resp This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Spotlight Tiling

This article introduces spotlight tiling, a type of covering which is similar to tiling. The distinguishing aspects of spotlight tiling are that the “tiles” have elastic size, and that the order of placement is significant. Spotlight tilings are decompositions, or coverings, and can be considered dynamic as compared to typical static tiling methods. A thorough examination of spotlight tilings of rectangles is presented, including the distribution of such tilings according to size, and how the directions of the spotlights themselves are distributed. The spotlight tilings of several other regions are studied, and suggest that further analysis of spotlight tilings will continue to yield elegant results and enumerations.     

Characterization of Planar Pseudo-Self-Similar Tilings

A pseudo-self-similar tiling is a hierarchical tiling of Euclidean space which obeys a nonexact substitution rule: the substitution for a tile is not geometrically similar to itself. An example is the Penrose tiling drawn with rhombi. We prove that a nonperiodic repetitive tiling of the plane is pseudo-self-similar if and only if it has a finite number of derived Vorono\"{\i} tilings up to similarity. To establish this characterization, we settle (in the planar case) a conjecture of E. A. Robinson by providing an algorithm which converts any pseudo-self-similar tiling of R ² into a self-similar tiling of R ² in such a way that the translation dynamics associated to the two tilings are topologically conjugate. Received June 20, 2000, and in revised form January 25, 2001. Online publication July 25, 2001.