Nuclear magnetic shielding constants of liquid water: insights from hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics models

We present a gauge-origin independent method for the calculation of nuclear magnetic shielding tensors of molecules in a structured and polarizable environment. The method is based on a combination of density functional theory (DFT) or Hartree-Fock wave functions with molecular mechanics. The method is unique in the sense that it includes three important properties that need to be fulfilled in accurate calculations of nuclear magnetic shielding constants: (i) the model includes electron correlation effects, (ii) the model uses gauge-including atomic orbitals to give gauge-origin independent results, and (iii) the effect of the environment is treated self-consistently using a discrete reaction-field methodology. The authors present sample calculations of the isotropic nuclear magnetic shielding constants of liquid water based on a large number of solute-solvent configurations derived from molecular dynamics simulations employing potentials which treat solvent polarization either explicitly or implicitly. For both the (17)O and (1)H isotropic shielding constants the best predicted results compare fairly well with the experimental data, i.e., they reproduce the experimental solvent shifts to within 4 ppm for the (17)O shielding and 1 ppm for the (1)H shielding.     

Nuclear magnetic shielding of the 113Cd(II) ion in aqua solution: a combined molecular dynamics/density functional theory study

We present a combined molecular dynamics simulation and density functional theory investigation of the nuclear magnetic shielding constant of the (113)Cd(II) ion solvated in aqueous solution. Molecular dynamics simulations are carried out for the cadmium-water system in order to produce instantaneous geometries for subsequent determination of the nuclear magnetic shielding constant at the density functional theory level. The nuclear magnetic shielding constant is computed using a perturbation theory formalism, which includes nonrelativistic and leading order relativistic contributions to the nuclear magnetic shielding tensor. Although the NMR shielding constant varies significantly with respect to simulation time, the value averaged over increasing number of snapshots remains almost constant. The paramagnetic nonrelativistic contribution is found to be most sensitive to dynamical changes in the system and is mainly responsible for the thermal and solvent effects in solution. The relativistic correction features very little sensitivity to the chemical environment, and can be disregarded in theoretical calculations when a Cd complex is used as reference compound in (113)Cd NMR experiments, due to the mutual cancelation between individual relativistic corrections.     

Ab-initio SOS-CI calculations of magnetic properties of the first- and second-row hydrides

Non-empirical SOS-CI calculations based on Nakatsuji's theory are reported for the nuclear spin-spin coupling constants, (considering all the four spininteractions), magnetic shielding constants and magnetic susceptibilities of all the first- and second-row hydrides. The calculated values, except for ²J(HH), correlate satisfactorily with the available experimental data and with the corresponding CHF results, and prove that the SOS-CI model according to Nakatsuji may be a convenient alternative to the time-consuming CHF procedures in order to get accurate estimates of second-order magnetic properties.     

A theoretical and experimental study of the electric field and magnetic anisotropy effects on proton chemical shifts

Proton magnetic shielding constants are divided into different contributions using the IPPP technique (inner projections of the polarization propagator). Total magnetic shielding constants are calculated within the CHF-INDO-GIAO approach (coupled-Hartree-Fock-INDO-gauge-invariant atomic orbitals). In order to compare the electric field and magnetic anisotropy effects of neighbouring groups, two model compounds were chosen, namely, ethyl cyanoformate, I, and ethylformate, II, which show to frozen and unequally populated rotamers each at room temperature. Their proton spectra were measured and the difference in shielding of methylene protons in each pair of rotamers was theoretically analysed with the abovementioned technique. The experimental difference in chemical shifts is quantitatively reproduced with the present analysis.     

Nuclear-magnetic-resonance shielding constants calculated by pseudospectral methods

We have developed an algorithm based upon pseudospectral (PS) ab initio electronic structure methods for evaluating nuclear magnetic shielding constants using gauge-including atomic orbitals (GIAOs) in the spin-restricted and spin-unrestricted formalisms of Hartree-Fock (HF) theory and density-functional theory (DFT). The nuclear magnetic shielding constants for both 1H and 13C calculated using PS methodology for 21 small molecules have absolute mean errors of less than 0.3 ppm in comparison with analytic integral results. CPU timing comparisons between PS methods and conventional methods carried out for seven large molecules ranging from 510 to 1285 basis functions demonstrate that the PS methods are an order of magnitude more efficient than the conventional methods. PS-HF was between 9 and 26 times faster than conventional integral technology, and PS-DFT (Becke three-parameter Lee-Yang-Parr) was between 6 and 21 times faster.     

Theoretical studies of nuclear magnetic resonance parameters for the proton-exchange pathways in porphyrin and porphycene

The nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) parameters in porphyrin and porphycene have been calculated to investigate their changes during the process of proton exchange, using density-functional theory (DFT) for both the spin-spin coupling constants and the shielding constants. In addition, in calculations on the smaller 1,3-bis(arylimino)isoindoline molecule, we have tested the performance of our computational approach against experimental data. The calculated nuclear spin-spin coupling constants and shielding constants have been analyzed as functions of the progress of the proton transfer between two nitrogen atoms. The one-bond couplings between proton and nitrogen, dominated by the Fermi-contact term, decay steeply as the internuclear distance increases. The small changes in the intramolecular J(HH) coupling between two inner protons are mainly determined by the sum of relatively large spin-orbit terms. The isotropic shielding constant shows a strong deshielding of the nitrogen nuclei as the proton migrates away. Both the isotropic shielding of the exchanged protons and the shielding anisotropy exhibit a minimum close to the transition states.     

NMR shielding constants in PH3, absolute shielding scale, and the nuclear magnetic moment of 31P

Ab initio values of the absolute shielding constants of phosphorus and hydrogen in PH(3) were determined, and their accuracy is discussed. In particular, we analyzed the relativistic corrections to nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) shielding constants, comparing the constants computed using the four-component Dirac-Hartree-Fock approach, the four-component density functional theory (DFT), and the Breit-Pauli perturbation theory (BPPT) with nonrelativistic Hartree-Fock or DFT reference functions. For the equilibrium geometry, we obtained σ(P) = 624.309 ppm and σ(H) = 29.761 ppm. Resonance frequencies of both nuclei were measured in gas-phase NMR experiments, and the results were extrapolated to zero density to provide the frequency ratio for an isolated PH(3) molecule. This ratio, together with the computed shielding constants, was used to determine a new value of the nuclear magnetic dipole moment of (31)P: μ(P) = 1.1309246(50) μ(N).     

Anharmonic effects in ammonium nitrate and hydroxylammonium nitrate clusters

The covalent and ionic clusters of ammonium nitrate and hydroxyl ammonium nitrate are characterized using density functional theory and second-order vibrational perturbation theory. The most stable structures are covalent acid-base pairs for the monomers and ionic acid-base pairs for the dimers. The hydrogen-bonding distances are greater in the ionic dimers than in the covalent monomers, and the stretching frequencies are significantly different in the covalent and ionic clusters. The anharmonicity of the potential energy surfaces is found to influence the geometries, frequencies, and nuclear magnetic shielding constants for these systems. The inclusion of anharmonic effects significantly decreases many of the calculated vibrational frequencies in these clusters and improves the agreement of the calculated frequencies with the experimental data available for the isolated neutral species. The calculations of nuclear magnetic shielding constants for all nuclei in these clusters illustrate that quantitatively accurate predictions of nuclear magnetic shieldings for comparison to experimental data require the inclusion of anharmonic effects. These calculations of geometries, frequencies, and shielding constants provide insight into the significance of anharmonic effects in ionic materials and provide data that will be useful for the parametrization of molecular mechanical force fields for ionic liquids. Anharmonic effects will be particularly important for the study of proton transfer reactions in ionic materials.     

Calculation of spin-densities within the context of density functional theory. The crucial role of the correlation functional

It is demonstrated that the LYP correlation functional is not suited to be used for the calculation of electron spin resonance hyperfine structure (HFS) constants, nuclear magnetic resonance spin-spin coupling constants, magnetic, shieldings and other properties that require a balanced account of opposite- and equal-spin correlation, especially in the core region. In the case of the HFS constants of alkali atoms, LYP exaggerates opposite-spin correlation effects thus invoking too strong in-out correlation effects, an exaggerated spin-polarization pattern in the core shells of the atoms, and, consequently, too large HFS constants. Any correlation functional that provides a balanced account of opposite- and equal-spin correlation leads to improved HFS constants, which is proven by comparing results obtained with the LYP and the PW91 correlation functional. It is suggested that specific response properties are calculated with the PW91 rather than the LYP correlation functional.     

Nuclear shieldings with the SSB-D functional

The recently reported SSB-D functional [J. Chem. Phys. 2009, 131, 094103] is used to check the performance for obtaining nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) shielding constants. Four different databases were studied, which contain a diversity of molecules and nuclear shielding constants. The SSB-D functional is compared with its "parent" functionals (PBE, OPBE), the KT2 functional that was designed specially for NMR applications and the coupled cluster CCSD(T) method. The best performance for the experimentally most-used elements ((1)H, (13)C) is obtained for the SSB-D and KT2 functionals.     

Zero-point vibrational effects on proton shieldings: functional-group contributions from ab initio calculations.

We investigate the effects of zero-point vibrational motion on the nuclear magnetic shielding constants of a large number of organic molecules. The vibrational corrections include anharmonic contributions from the potential energy surface and harmonic contributions from the curvature of the property surface. Particular attention is paid to vibrational corrections to hydrogen shielding constants where we show that vibrational corrections may be substantial, ranging from about +0.50 to -0.70 ppm, and thus demonstrating that ignoring these effects may give errors in the chemical shifts by more than 1 ppm in certain extreme cases. These effects can therefore not be neglected when comparing calculated results with experiment, not even for the chemical shifts. However, we also demonstrate that the vibrational corrections to the hydrogen shieldings are to a large extent transferable from one molecule to another. We have tabulated functional vibrational corrections to the hydrogen shieldings, based on results for more than 35 molecules. Unfortunately, no similar transferability has been observed for the vibrational corrections to shielding constants of other nuclei such as carbon, nitrogen, or oxygen.     

A comparison of two-component and four-component approaches for calculations of spin-spin coupling constants and NMR shielding constants of transition metal cyanides

Relativistic density functional theory (DFT) calculations of nuclear spin-spin coupling constants and shielding constants have been performed for selected transition metal (11th and 12th group of periodic table) and thallium cyanides. The calculations have been carried out using zeroth-order regular approximation (ZORA) Hamiltonian and four-component Dirac-Kohn-Sham (DKS) theory with different nonrelativistic exchange-correlation functionals. Two recent approaches for representing the magnetic balance (MB) between the large and small components of four-component spinors, namely, mDKS-RMB and sMB, have been employed for shielding tensor calculations and their results have been compared. Relativistic effects have also been analysed in terms of scalar and spin-orbit contributions at the two-component level of theory, including discussion of heavy-atom-on-light-atom effects for (1)J(CN), σ(C), and σ(N). The results for molecules containing metals from 4th row of periodic table show that relativistic effects for them are small (especially for spin-spin coupling constants). The biggest effects are observed for the 6th row where nonrelativistic theory reproduces only about 50%-70% of the two-component ZORA results for (1)J(MeC) and about 75% for heavy metal shielding constants. It is important to employ a full Dirac picture for calculations of heavy metal shielding constants, since ZORA reproduces only 75%-90% of the DKS results. Smaller discrepancies between ZORA-DFT and DKS are observed for nuclear spin-spin coupling constants. No significant differences are observed between the results obtained using mDKS-RMB and sMB approaches for magnetic balance in four-component calculations of the shielding constants.     

Methodological aspects in the calculation of parity-violating effects in nuclear magnetic resonance parameters

We examine the quantum chemical calculation of parity-violating (PV) electroweak contributions to the spectral parameters of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) from a methodological point of view. Nuclear magnetic shielding and indirect spin-spin coupling constants are considered and evaluated for three chiral molecules, H2O2, H2S2, and H2Se2. The effects of the choice of a one-particle basis set and the treatment of electron correlation, as well as the effects of special relativity, are studied. All of them are found to be relevant. The basis-set dependence is very pronounced, especially at the electron correlated ab initio levels of theory. Coupled-cluster and density-functional theory (DFT) results for PV contributions differ significantly from the Hartree-Fock data. DFT overestimates the PV effects, particularly with nonhybrid exchange-correlation functionals. Beginning from third-row elements, special relativity is of importance for the PV NMR properties, shown here by comparing perturbational one-component and various four-component calculations. In contrast to what is found for nuclear magnetic shielding, the choice of the model for nuclear charge distribution--point charge or extended (Gaussian)--has a significant impact on the PV contribution to the spin-spin coupling constants.     

Benchmarking the multipole shielding polarizability/reaction field approach to solvation against QM/MM: applications to the shielding constants of N-methylacetamide

We present a benchmark study of a combined multipole shielding polarizability/reaction field (MSP/RF) approach to the calculation of both specific and bulk solvation effects on nuclear magnetic shielding constants of solvated molecules. The MSP/RF scheme is defined by an expansion of the shielding constants of the solvated molecule in terms of electric field and field gradient property derivatives derived from single molecule ab initio calculations. The solvent electric field and electric field gradient are calculated based on data derived from molecular dynamics simulations, thereby accounting for solute-solvent dynamical effects. The MSP/RF method is benchmarked against polarizable quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations. The best agreement between the MSP/RF and QM/MM approaches is found by truncating the electric field expansion in the MSP/RF approach at the linear electric field level which is due to the cancelation of errors. In addition, we investigate the sensitivity of the results due to the choice of one-electron basis set in the ab initio calculations of the property derivatives and find that these derivatives are affected by the basis set in a way similar to the shielding constants themselves.     

Correlated and gauge origin independent calculations of magnetic properties

Summary We have applied a gauge origin invariant method for calculations of nuclear magnetic shielding constants to the singly bonded molecules BF, F₂, BH₃, CH₄, NH₃, H₂O, and HF as well as to the¹H shielding constants of HCN and C₂H₂. The calculations were performed at the RPA and second order polarization propagator (SOPPA) level of theory. For most molecules the correlation contribution in SOPPA is less diamagnetic than in the comparable MP2 calculations. For F₂, SOPPA gives a large paramagnetic correlation correction whereas the MP2 method gives a very small correlation contribution. For all molecules agreement with experimental results is generally improved at the SOPPA level compared to RPA. We have also demonstrated that second order gauge origin invariant, common and local origin (SOLO) methods do not necessarily give the same shielding even in the limit of a converged basis set.     

A fully relativistic method for calculation of nuclear magnetic shielding tensors with a restricted magnetically balanced basis in the framework of the matrix Dirac-Kohn-Sham equation

A new relativistic four-component density functional approach for calculations of NMR shielding tensors has been developed and implemented. It is founded on the matrix formulation of the Dirac-Kohn-Sham (DKS) method. Initially, unperturbed equations are solved with the use of a restricted kinetically balanced basis set for the small component. The second-order coupled perturbed DKS method is then based on the use of restricted magnetically balanced basis sets for the small component. Benchmark relativistic calculations have been carried out for the (1)H and heavy-atom nuclear shielding tensors of the HX series (X=F,Cl,Br,I), where spin-orbit effects are known to be very pronounced. The restricted magnetically balanced basis set allows us to avoid additional approximations and/or strong basis set dependence which arises in some related approaches. The method provides an attractive alternative to existing approximate two-component methods with transformed Hamiltonians for relativistic calculations of chemical shifts and spin-spin coupling constants of heavy-atom systems. In particular, no picture-change effects arise in property calculations.     

Leading-order relativistic effects on nuclear magnetic resonance shielding tensors

We present perturbational ab initio calculations of the nuclear-spin-dependent relativistic corrections to the nuclear magnetic resonance shielding tensors that constitute, together with the other relativistic terms reported by us earlier, the full leading-order perturbational set of results for the one-electron relativistic contributions to this observable, based on the (Breit-)Pauli Hamiltonian. These contributions are considered for the H(2)X (X = O,S,Se,Te,Po) and HX (X = F,Cl,Br,I,At) molecules, as well as the noble gas (Ne, Ar, Kr, Xe, Rn) atoms. The corrections are evaluated using the relativistic and magnetic operators as perturbations on an equal footing, calculated using analytical linear and quadratic response theory applied on top of a nonrelativistic reference state provided by self-consistent field calculations. The (1)H and heavy-atom nuclear magnetic shielding tensors are compared with four component, nearly basis-set-limit Dirac-Hartree-Fock calculations that include positronic excitations, as well as available literature data. Besides the easy interpretability of the different contributions in terms of familiar nonrelativistic concepts, the accuracy of the present perturbational scheme is striking for the isotropic part of the shielding tensor, for systems including elements up to Xe.     

Gauge invariance of the nuclear spin/electron orbit interaction and NMR spectral parameters

A gauge transformation of the vector potential A(m(I) ), associated to the magnetic dipole m(I) of nucleus I in a molecule, has been studied. The conditions for gauge invariance of nuclear magnetic shielding, nuclear spin/electron orbit contribution to spin-spin coupling between two nuclei, I and J, and electronic current density induced by m(I), have been expressed via quantum mechanical sum rules that are identically satisfied for exact and optimal variational wavefunctions. It is shown that separate diamagnetic and paramagnetic contributions to the properties transform into one another in the gauge transformation, whereas their sum is invariant. Therefore, only total response properties have a physical meaning. In particular, the disjoint diamagnetic and paramagnetic components of nuclear spin/electron orbit contributions to coupling constants are not uniquely defined. The diamagnetic contribution to the nuclear spin-spin coupling tensor, evaluated as an expectation value in the Ramsey theory, can alternatively be expressed as a sum-over-states formula, by rewriting the second-order Hamiltonian in commutator form a? la Geertsen, as previously reported by Sauer. Other sum-over-states formulae are obtained via a gauge transformation, by a procedure formally allowing for a continuous translation of the origin of the m(I)-induced current density, analogous to those previously proposed for magnetizabilities and nuclear magnetic shielding.     

Weak intermolecular interactions in gas-phase nuclear magnetic resonance

Gas-phase nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra demonstrating the effect of weak intermolecular forces on the NMR shielding constants of the interacting species are reported. We analyse the interaction of the molecular hydrogen isotopomers with He, Ne, and Ar, and the interaction in the He-CO(2) dimer. The same effects are studied for all these systems in the ab initio calculations. The comparison of the experimental and computed shielding constants is shown to depend strongly on the treatment of the bulk susceptibility effects, which determine in practice the pressure dependence of the experimental values. Best agreement of the results is obtained when the bulk susceptibility correction in rare gas solvents is evaluated from the analysis of the He-rare gas interactions, and when the shielding of deuterium in D(2)-rare gas systems is considered.     

Direct chiral discrimination in NMR spectroscopy

Conventional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy is unable to distinguish between the two mirror-image forms (enantiomers) of a chiral molecule. This is because the NMR spectrum is determined by the chemical shifts and spin–spin coupling constants which – in the absence of a chiral solvent – are identical for the two enantiomers. We discuss how chirality may nevertheless be directly detected in liquid-state NMR spectroscopy: In a chiral molecule, the rotating nuclear magnetic moment induces an electric dipole moment in the direction perpendicular to itself and to the permanent magnetic field of the spectrometer. We present computations of the precessing electric polarization following a π/2 pulse. Our estimates indicate that the electric polarization should be detectable in favourable cases. We also predict that application of an electrostatic field induces a chirally sensitive magnetization oscillating in the direction of the permanent magnetic field. We show that the electric-field-perturbed chemical shift tensor, the nuclear magnetic shielding polarizability, underlies these chiral NMR effects.