Interlaboratory comparison study for the determination of the Fusarium mycotoxins deoxynivalenol in wheat and zearalenone in maize using different methods

Seventeen laboratories from six different countries, using their usual in-house methods, participated in an interlaboratory comparison test for the determination of the Fusarium mycotoxins deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat and zearalenone (ZON) in maize. The toxins generally were extracted from maize and wheat employing mixtures of water, acidified water with an organic solvent or even pure water (for DON). While participants who used enzyme linked immuno sorbent assays (ELISA) for the determination of DON did not perform any clean-up, various techniques were applied for the purification of raw extracts (e.g. liquid/liquid extraction, solid phase extraction (SPE), immuno affinity chromatography (IAC)). For the final separation/quantification step either high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) (mostly for ZON), gas chromatography (GC) (for DON) or ELISA were employed by participants. The aim of this study was to obtain information about the state of the art of mycotoxin analysis in cereals and to support a knowledge and experience exchange between the participating laboratories in the field of mycotoxin analysis. For each mycotoxin 5 different sample types were distributed, standard solutions (10.10 μg/ml ZON in methanol, 10.09 μg/ml DON in ethyl acetate), blank materials, spiked samples (75.1 μg/kg and 378.3 μg/kg ZON in maize, 126.2 μg/kg and 2519 μg/kg DON in wheat) and naturally contaminated maize and wheat. Coefficients of variation (CV) between laboratory mean results (outliers excluded) ranged from 6.2 to 27.7% for ZON and from 18.9 to 30.0% for DON. Except for the maize samples spiked at 75.1 μg/kg ZON the overall means (outliers rejected) statistically could not be distinguished from the respective target values. Average recoveries of the reported results ranged from 87.7 to 96.2% for ZON and from 94.2 to 108.5% for DON.     

Imaging surface plasmon resonance for multiplex microassay sensing of mycotoxins

A prototype imaging surface plasmon resonance-based multiplex microimmunoassay for mycotoxins is described. A microarray of mycotoxin–protein conjugates was fabricated using a continuous flow microspotter device. A competitive inhibition immunoassay format was developed for the simultaneous detection of deoxynivalenol (DON) and zearalenone (ZEN), using a single sensor chip. Initial in-house validation showed limits of detection of 21 and 17 ng/mL for DON and 16 and 10 ng/mL for ZEN in extracts, which corresponds to 84 and 68 μg/kg for DON and 64 and 40 μg/kg for ZEN in maize and wheat samples, respectively. Finally, the results were critically compared with data obtained from liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry confirmatory analysis method and found to be in good agreement. The described multiplex immunoassay for the rapid screening of several mycotoxins meets European Union regulatory limits and represents a robust platform for mycotoxin analysis in food and feed samples.     

Co-isolation of deoxynivalenol and zearalenone with sol–gel immunoaffinity columns for their determination in wheat and wheat products

The paper describes a sample clean-up method for the co-isolation of deoxynivalenol (DON) and zearalenone (ZON), two mycotoxins naturally co-occurring in wheat. The method is based on immunoaffinity columns prepared by co-immobilising anti-DON and anti-ZON antibodies in a porous sol–gel glass. The main task in developing the method consisted in finding a loading medium allowing retention of both analytes as well as a common elution medium for the dissociation of both antigen–antibody complexes formed. This can be achieved by co-extracting DON and ZON with ACN–water (60:40, v/v), reducing the acetonitril concentration to 2.5% before loading an aliquot of the diluted sample extract onto the DON/ZON column. The columns are washed with 5 ml of MeOH–water (10:90, v/v) before DON and ZON are co-eluted with 4 ml of ACN–water (50:50, v/v). Concentrations of DON and ZON are determined with HPLC-UV and HPLC-fluorescence detection, respectively. The sample clean-up method was shown to be applicable to wheat and wheat products, e.g., cornflakes, milk wheat mash and rusk. Spiking experiments (spike level 500 μg DON/kg and 50 μg ZON/kg) resulted in recovery rates from 82% to 111%.     

Incidence of Fusarium Mycotoxins in Wheat and Maize from Albania

In this study, ten Fusarium toxins were analysed in wheat and maize commodities from Albania. In total, 71 samples of wheat and 45 samples of maize were collected from different producing regions. The analytical procedure consisted of a simple one-step sample extraction followed by the determination of toxins using liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry. Fusarium toxins were found in 23% of the analysed wheat samples and in 78% of maize samples. In maize samples, most often fumonisins B₁ (FB1) and B₂ (FB2) were found. They were present in 76% of samples. They were detected in all positive samples except in one with concentrations ranging from 59.9 to 16,970 μg/kg. The sum of FB1 and FB2 exceeded the EU maximum permitted level (4000 μg/kg) in 31% of maize samples. In wheat samples, the only detected Fusarium mycotoxin was deoxynivalenol (DON), present in 23% of samples. In one sample with the concentration of 1916 μg/kg, the EU maximum permitted level (1250 μg/kg) was exceeded. This is the first report on the presence of Fusarium toxins in wheat and maize grains cultivated in Albania.     

Dynamic covalent hydrazine chemistry as a selective extraction and cleanup technique for the quantification of the Fusarium mycotoxin zearalenone in edible oils

A novel, cost-efficient method for the analytical extraction of the Fusarium mycotoxin zearalenone (ZON) from edible oils by dynamic covalent hydrazine chemistry (DCHC) was developed and validated for its application with high performance liquid chromatography-fluorescence detection (HPLC-FLD). ZON is extracted from the edible oil by hydrazone formation on a polymer resin functionalised with hydrazine groups and subsequently released by hydrolysis. Specifity and precision of this approach are superior to liquid partitioning or gel permeation chromatography (GPC). DCHC also extracts zearalanone (ZAN) but not α-/β-zearalenol or -zearalanol. The hydrodynamic properties of ZON, which were estimated using molecular simulation data, indicate that the compound is unaffected by nanofiltration through the resin pores and thus selectively extracted. The method's levels of detection and quantification are 10 and 30 μg/kg, using 0.2 g of sample. Linearity is given in the range of 10–20,000 μg/kg, the average recovery being 89%. Bias and relative standard deviations do not exceed 7%. In a sample survey of 44 commercial edible oils based on various agricultural commodities (maize, olives, nuts, seeds, etc.) ZON was detected in four maize oil samples, the average content in the positive samples being 99 μg/kg. The HPLC-FLD results were confirmed by HPLC–tandem mass spectrometry and compared to those obtained by a liquid partitioning based sample preparation procedure.     

Immuno-affinity columns versus conventional clean-up: a method-comparison study for the determination of zearalenone in corn

The efficiency of a modern analytical method employing immuno-affinity columns (IACs) is compared to a well established traditional technique with respect to the determination of zearalenone (ZON) in corn in the μg/kg range. Despite of a constant error of about 4 μg/kg in the examined working range of 10–200 μg/kg, analytical data obtained from the analysis of spiked and naturally contaminated samples showed good correspondence for the compared methods. The performance characteristics of immuno-affinity-chromatography as a new clean-up technique for the determination of ZON in corn is reported for the first time and compared to a conventional clean-up procedure Received: 25 March 1997 / Revised: 5 May 1997 / Accepted: 12 May 1997     

An enzyme-immunoassay for the detection of the mycotoxin zearalenone by use of yolk antibodies

The development of an enzyme-immunoassay (ELISA) for the detection of the Fusarium mycotoxin zearalenone (ZON) is described. In contrast to the common antibody isolation from mammal serum, chicken were immunized in order to isolate specific antibodies from the egg yolk. Five weeks after the start of the immunization a titer of 1:76 000 resulted from three injections without any adverse effects for the animals. Utilizing the indirect competitive assay format ZON could be detected in a concentration range between 10 and 200 μg/L. Received: 3 January 1998 / Revised: 16 March 1998 / Accepted: 20 March 1998     

An enzyme linked immunoassay for the determination of deoxynivalenol in wheat based on chicken egg yolk antibodies

An indirect competitive enzyme linked immunoassay (ELISA) for the detection of the Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat was developed. Instead of the much more common antibody isolation from mammal serum, DON specific antibodies were, for the first time, isolated from the eggs of previously immunized hens. The limit of detection was 2 μg/L for standard curves and spiked wheat extracts. Recoveries for naturally contaminated samples (200–525 μg/kg) were between 80 and 125% compared with GC-ECD data. Concentrations for naturally contaminated samples were chosen with regard to current Austrian guidelines concerning DON levels in produce intended for human consumption, recommending a maximum of 500 μg DON/kg.     

Development and validation of a liquid chromatography/atmospheric pressure photoionization-tandem mass spectrometric method for the analysis of mycotoxins subjected to commission regulation (EC) No. 1881/2006 In cereals

A sensitive and reliable liquid chromatography/photoionization (APPI) tandem mass spectrometry method has been developed for determining nine selected mycotoxins in wheat and maize samples. The analytes were chosen on the basis of the mycotoxins under EU Commission Regulation (EC) No. 1881/2006, i.e., deoxynivalenol (DON), zearalenone (ZON), aflatoxins (AFs), and ochratoxin A (OTA), and considering the possibility of a near future regulation for T-2 and HT-2 toxins. Mycotoxins were extracted from samples by means of an one-step solvent extraction without any cleanup. The developed multi-mycotoxin method permits simultaneous, simple, and rapid determination of several co-existing toxins separated in a single chromatographic run, in which AFs, T-2 and HT-2 toxin are acquired in positive, while OTA, DON and ZON in negative mode. Although a moderate signal suppression was noticeable, matrix effect did not give significant differences at p = 0.05. Then, calibration in standard solution were used for quantitation. Based on the EU Commission Decision 2002/657/EC, the method was in-house validated in terms of ruggedness, specificity, linearity, trueness, within-laboratory reproducibility, decision limit (CCα) and detection capability (CCβ). For all the analytes, the regression coefficient r ranged between 0.8752 (DON in wheat) and 0.9465 (ZON in maize), biases related to mean concentrations were from −13% to +12% of the nominal spiking level, and the overall within-laboratory reproducibility ranged 3–16%; finally, CCα values did not differ more than 20% and CCβ not more than 42% from their respective maximum limit. Method quantification limits ranged from 1/20 (AFG1) to 1/4 (AFG2 and OTA) the maximum limit established by European Union in the Commission Regulation (EC) No. 1881/2006 and its subsequent amendments.     

Production of a calibrant certified reference material for determination of the estrogenic mycotoxin zearalenone

Several previous interlaboratory studies in the field of mycotoxin analysis have revealed considerable problems, apparent as high between-laboratory standard deviations, or rather non-comparable and non-traceable results. A major reason is lack of proper calibrants for external calibration. Public awareness of substances that mimic or interfere with the activity of natural hormones (endocrine disrupters) has led to increased interest in mycotoxins with estrogenic potential, e.g. zearalenone (ZON). During a large-scale standard measurement and testing (SMT) project of the European Commission (EC) dealing with the preparation and certification of reference materials for determination of the mycotoxin ZON in maize, a ZON calibrant in acetonitrile was prepared and intensively checked for purity, homogeneity, and stability. Preparation of the material, study of its homogeneity and stability, and characterisation of the calibrant on the basis of its preparation, with discussion of the results obtained, are described in this paper. The certified value of 9.95 µg mL^–1 for ZON in acetonitrile and its corresponding expanded uncertainty of ±0.30 µg mL^–1 were calculated in compliance with the Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement (GUM).     

Development of mycotoxin reference materials

Summary The analytical difficulties in mycotoxin determination have given rise to the development of mycotoxin reference materials by the European Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) in cooperation with several European Laboratories, among them the National Institute of Public Health and Environmental Protection. The first project undertaken concerned four milk powders certified for their aflatoxin M₁ content (concentrations 0, 0.1, 0.3 and 0.8 g/ kg). Projects that are well-advanced include two peanut meals (aflatoxin B₁ contents 0 and ca. 200 g/kg) and two compounded animal feedingstuffs (aflatoxin B₁ contents 0 and 10 g/kg). Mycotoxin reference materials are also under development for zearalenone in wheat and maize, and for ochratoxin A in wheat.The general approach followed in the development and certification of mycotoxin reference materials (preparation, testing for homogeneity and stability, intercomparisons of methods and certification exercise) will be discussed and exemplified with the help of the completed project on aflatoxin M₁ in milk powder.

---

Entwicklung von Mycotoxin-Referenzmaterialien

     

An enzyme linked immunoassay for the determination of deoxynivalenol in wheat based on chicken egg yolk antibodies

An indirect competitive enzyme linked immunoassay (ELISA) for the detection of the Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat was developed. Instead of the much more common antibody isolation from mammal serum, DON specific antibodies were, for the first time, isolated from the eggs of previously immunized hens. The limit of detection was 2 microg/L for standard curves and spiked wheat extracts. Recoveries for naturally contaminated samples (200-525 microg/kg) were between 80 and 125% compared with GC-ECD data. Concentrations for naturally contaminated samples were chosen with regard to current Austrian guidelines concerning DON levels in produce intended for human consumption, recommending a maximum of 500 microg DON/kg.     

Simultaneous determination of deoxynivalenol,zearalenone, and their major masked metabolites in cereal-based food by LC–MS–MS

Cereals and cereal-based food have often been found to be contaminated with the mycotoxins deoxynivalenol (DON) and zearalenone (ZON), after infection of the grain with the pathogenic fungus Fusarium. Both the pathogen and the infected plants can chemically modify DON and ZON, including acetylation, glucosidation, and sulfation. Analytical strategies for detection and quantification of DON and ZON are well known and established but often fail to recognize the respective metabolites, which are, therefore, also referred to as “masked” mycotoxins. However, several masked forms are also known to be harmful to mammals. Failure to detect these could lead to significant underestimation of the toxic potential of a particular sample. To monitor the levels of DON and ZON metabolites in cereals and cereal-based food, we have developed a LC–MS–MS method capable of simultaneous determination of DON, ZON, and eight of their masked metabolites, namely deoxynivalenol-3-glucoside (D3G), 3-acetyl-deoxynivalenol (3ADON), zearalenone-4-glucoside (Z4G), α-zearalenol (α-ZOL), β-zearalenol (β-ZOL), α-zearalenol-4-glucoside (α-ZG), β-zearalenol-4-glucoside (β-ZG), and zearalenone-4-sulfate (Z4S). The suitability of several cleanup strategies including C₁₈-SPE, primary and secondary amines (PSA), MycoSep push-through columns, and immunoaffinity columns was evaluated. The final method used no sample cleanup and was successfully validated for four cereal-based food matrices, namely cornflour, porridge, beer, and pasta, showing good recoveries and precision for all analytes.     

Validation of a screening method for rapid control of macrocyclic lactone mycotoxins in maize flour samples

A procedure for the analytical validation of a rapid supercritical fluid extraction amperometric screening method for controlling macrocyclic lactone mycotoxins in maize flour samples has been developed. The limit established by European legislation (0.2 mg kg⁻¹), in reference to zearalenone (ZON) mycotoxin, was taken as the reference threshold to validate the proposed method. Natural ZON metabolites were also included in this study to characterize the final screening method. The objective was the reliable classification of samples as positive or negative samples. The cut-off level was fixed at a global concentration of mycotoxins of 0.17 mg kg⁻¹. An expanded unreliability zone between 0.16 and 0.23 mg kg⁻¹ characterized the screening method for classifying the samples. A set of 30 samples was used for the final demonstration of the reliability and usefulness of the method.     

Direct quantification of deoxynivalenol glucuronide in human urine as biomarker of exposure to the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Fusarium</Emphasis> mycotoxin deoxynivalenol

The direct quantification of deoxynivalenol glucuronide (DON-GlcA) by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) and its application as a biomarker of exposure to the Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (DON) is reported. Usually, DON exposure is estimated from dietary average intakes or by measurement of the native toxin in urine after enzymatic hydrolysis with β-glucuronidase. These methods are time-consuming, expensive, and fail to determine the ratio of DON to DON-GlcA in a simple one-step procedure. One of the main reasons for the use of indirect methods is the unavailability of DON-GlcA standards. Consequently, DON-3-O-glucuronide (D3GlcA) was synthesized and used to develop a method allowing quantification of both DON and D3GlcA by a simple “dilute and shoot” approach without the need for any cleanup. Limit of detection and apparent recovery of D3GlcA was 3 μg l⁻¹ and 88%, respectively. The identity of D3GlcA in human urine was confirmed by comparison with LC-MS/MS measurements of the synthetically produced D3GlcA standard which was also used for external calibration. The applicability of the method was demonstrated through the analysis of urine samples obtained from a volunteer during regular and cereal-restricted diet, respectively. In regular-diet urine samples, D3GlcA was quantified in concentrations >30 μg l⁻¹ by this approach.     

Suitability of a fully 13C isotope labeled internal standard for the determination of the mycotoxin deoxynivalenol by LC-MS/MS without clean up

Very often, the accuracy of quantitative analytical methods for the determination of mycotoxins by liquid chromatography (LC)-mass spectrometry (MS) and LC-MS/MS is limited by matrix effects during the ionization process in the MS source. Stable isotope labeled standards are best suited to correct for matrix effects and to improve both the trueness and the precision of analytical methods employing LC-MS and LC-MS/MS. This paper describes the successful use of fully ¹³C isotope labeled deoxynivalenol [(¹³C₁₅)DON] as an internal standard (IS) for the accurate determination of DON in maize and wheat by LC electrospray ionization MS/MS. To show the full potential of (¹³C₁₅)DON as IS, maize and wheat extracts were analyzed without further cleanup. Subsequent to calibration for the LC-MS end determination, DON was quantified in matrix reference materials (wheat and maize). Without consideration of the IS, apparent recoveries of DON were 29±6% (n=7) for wheat and 37±5% (n=7) for maize. However, the determination of DON in the reference materials yielded 95±3% (wheat) and 99±3% (maize) when (¹³C₁₅)DON was used as an IS for data evaluation.     

Enzymatic hydrolysis of T-2 toxin for the quantitative determination of total T-2 and HT-2 toxins in cereals

The selective enzymatic deacetylation of T-2 toxin to give HT-2 toxin has been investigated in aqueous crude extracts of different cereals and exploited to develop an analytical method for the determination of the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins. The method has been validated for the analysis of total T-2 and HT-2 toxins in maize, wheat, and oats, showing recoveries from 72 to 97% for maize, from 67 to 84% for wheat, and from 61% to 87% for oats, at spiking levels of 20–400 μg/kg, with relative standard deviation lower than 10%. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry was used for quantitative toxin determination. The potential biological role of this enzymatic conversion and its perspectives for application in the development of antibody-based analytical techniques are discussed.      

Quantification of deoxynivalenol in wheat using an immunoaffinity column and liquid chromatography

A simple and accurate method to quantify the mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat is described. The method uses immunoaffinity chromatography for DON isolation and liquid chromatography (LC) for toxin detection and quantification. Wheat samples are extracted in water, filtered twice and applied to an immunoaffinity column. Following a water wash, DON is eluted from the column with methanol and injected onto an LC system with a UV detector for quantification. Test performance was evaluated in terms of antibody specificity, limit of detection, percentage recovery, precision, column capacity, assay linearity and comparison with the GC-electron-capture detection (ECD) method of Tacke and Casper. Specificity of the immunoaffinity column cleanup procedure was confirmed with only DON (>80%) and its 15-C derivatives (40-50%) being recognized by the antibody while 3-C DON derivatives, nivalenol, T-2 and fusarenon-X did not bind. The limit of detection is at least 0.10 microg/g. Percentage recovery for the entire assay range averages 90% with an average relative standard deviation of 8.3%. Naturally contaminated samples showed comparable precision. Column capacity was determined to be 3.3 microg. The assay showed a high degree of linearity (r2=0.999) and an optimum assay range of 0.10 to 10.0 microg/g. Comparative analysis of 28 naturally or artificially contaminated wheat samples using DONtest-HPLC and the GC-ECD method of Tacke and Casper showed that DONtest-HPLC is a statistically significant predictor of the GC-ECD method (r2=0.982).     

Determination of zearalenone in barley, maize and wheat flour, polenta, and maize-based baby food by immunoaffinity column cleanup with liquid chromatography: interlaboratory study

An interlaboratory study was performed on behalf of the UK Food Standards Agency to evaluate the effectiveness of an affinity column cleanup liquid chromatography (LC) method for the determination of zearalenone (ZON) in a variety of cereals and cereal products at proposed European regulatory limits. The test portion is extracted with acetonitrile:water. The sample extract is filtered, diluted, and applied to an affinity column. The column is washed, and ZON is eluted with acetonitrile. ZON is quantified by reversed-phase LC with fluorescence detection. Barley, wheat and maize flours, polenta, and a maize-based baby food naturally contaminated, spiked, and blank (very low level) were sent to 28 collaborators in 9 European countries and 1 collaborator in New Zealand. Participants were asked to spike test portions of all samples at a ZON concentration equivalent to 100 microg/kg. Average recoveries ranged from 91-111%. Based on results for 4 artificially contaminated samples (blind duplicates) and 1 naturally contaminated sample (blind duplicate), the relative standard deviation for repeatability (RSDr) ranged from 6.9-35.8%, and the relative standard deviation for reproducibility (RSDR) ranged from 16.4-38.2%. The method showed acceptable within- and between-laboratory precision for all 5 matrixes, as evidenced by HorRat values <1.7.     

A comparative study of mid-infrared diffuse reflection (DR) and attenuated total reflection (ATR) spectroscopy for the detection of fungal infection on RWA2-corn

An investigation into the rapid detection of mycotoxin-producing fungi on corn by two mid-infrared spectroscopic techniques was undertaken. Corn samples from a single genotype (RWA2, blanks, and contaminated with Fusarium graminearum) were ground, sieved and, after appropriate sample preparation, subjected to mid-infrared spectroscopy using two different accessories (diffuse reflection and attenuated total reflection). The measured spectra were evaluated with principal component analysis (PCA) and the blank and contaminated samples were classified by cluster analysis. Reference data for fungal metabolites were obtained with conventional methods. After extraction and clean-up, each sample was analyzed for the toxin deoxynivalenol (DON) by gas chromatography with electron capture detection (GC-ECD) and ergosterol (a parameter for the total fungal biomass) by high-performance liquid chromatography with diode array detection (HPLC-DAD). The concentration ranges for contaminated samples were 880–3600 g/kg for ergosterol and 300–2600 g/kg for DON. Classification efficiency was 100% for ATR spectra. DR spectra did not show as obvious a clustering of contaminated and blank samples. Results and trends were also observed in single spectra plots. Quantification using a PLS1 regression algorithm showed good correlation with DON reference data, but a rather high standard error of prediction (SEP) with 600 g/kg (DR) and 490 g/kg (ATR), respectively, for ergosterol. Comparing measurement procedures and results showed advantages for the ATR technique, mainly owing to its ease of use and the easier interpretation of results that were better with respect to classification and quantification.