The relationship between nanobubbles and the hydrophobic force

The formation of nanobubbles on hydrophobic self-assembled monolayers has been examined in a binary ethanol/water titration using small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and atomic force microscopy (AFM). The AFM data demonstrates a localized force effect attributed to nanobubbles on an immersed hydrophobic surface. This evidence is arguably compromised by the possibility that the AFM tip actually nucleates nanobubbles. As a complementary noninvasive technique, SAXS has been used to investigate the interfacial region of the immersed hydrophobic surface. SAXS measurements reveal an electron density depletion layer at the hydrophobic interface, with changing air solubility in the immersing liquid, due to the formation of nanobubbles.     

Physical properties of nanobubbles on hydrophobic surfaces in water and aqueous solutions

In recent years there has been an accumulation of evidence for the existence of nanobubbles on hydrophobic surfaces in water, despite predictions that such small bubbles should rapidly dissolve because of the high internal pressure associated with the interfacial curvature and the resulting increase in gas solubility. Nanobubbles are of interest among surface scientists because of their potential importance in the long-range hydrophobic attraction, microfluidics, and adsorption at hydrophobic surfaces. Here we employ recently developed techniques designed to induce nanobubbles, coupled with high-resolution tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (TM-AFM) to measure some of the physical properties of nanobubbles in a reliable and repeatable manner. We have reproduced the earlier findings reported by Hu and co-workers. We have also studied the effect of a wide range of solutes on the stability and morphology of these deliberately formed nanobubbles, including monovalent and multivalent salts, cationic, anionic, and nonionic surfactants, as well as solution pH. The measured physical properties of these nanobubbles are in broad agreement with those of macroscopic bubbles, with one notable exception: the contact angle. The nanobubble contact angle (measured through the denser aqueous phase) was found to be much larger than the macroscopic contact angle on the same substrate. The larger contact angle results in a larger radius of curvature and a commensurate decrease in the Laplace pressure. These findings provide further evidence that nanobubbles can be formed in water under some conditions. Once formed, these nanobubbles remain on hydrophobic surfaces for hours, and this apparent stability still remains a well-recognized mystery. The implications for sample preparation in surface science and in surface chemistry are discussed.     

Characterization of nanobubbles on hydrophobic surfaces in water

The aim of this paper is to quantitatively characterize the appearance, stability, density, and shape of surface nanobubbles on hydrophobic surfaces under varying conditions such as temperature and temperature variation, gas type and concentration, surfactants, and surface treatment. The method we adopt is atomic force microscopy (AFM) operated in the tapping mode. In particular, we show (i) that nanobubbles can slide along grooves under the influence of the AFM tip, (ii) that nanobubbles can spontaneously form by substrate heating, allowing for a comparison of the surface topology with and without the nanobubble, (iii) that a water temperature increase leads to a drastic increase in the nanobubble density, (iv) that pressurizing the water with CO2 also leads to a larger nanobubble density, but typically to smaller nanobubbles, (v) that alcohol-cleaning of the surface is crucial for the formation of surface nanobubbles, (vi) that adding 2-butanol as surfactant leads to considerably smaller surface nanobubbles, and (vii) that flushing water over alcohol-covered surfaces strongly enhances the formation of surface nanobubbles.     

Nanobubbles give evidence of incomplete wetting at a hydrophobic interface

The appearance of a hydrophobic surface, namely a crystalline (111) Si wafer coated with a thick soft polystyrene film, and the morphological changes along this interface depending on the polarity of an adjoining liquid phase were studied with magnetic tapping mode atomic force microscopy. Interfacially associated nanobubbles of decreasing size and number are observed as the hydrophobicity of the subphase increases. The disturbance of the water structure in the contact region induces the formation of nanobubbles. The topology of the interface is visualized, starting with the dry polymer under normal atmosphere conditions and observing the changes as air is replaced by a series of liquids. With water, the surface coverage of the substrate with bubbles is almost a close-packed configuration. The bubble shape is well approximated by spherical caps of a rather low aspect ratio. The Gaussian size distributions of bubble shape parameters are discussed. The contact angle of the nanobubbles is substantially smaller than the corresponding number measured for a macroscopic droplet. This apparent discrepancy might be resolved if the nanobubbles were assumed to exist along the interface as a connecting sublayer between a depleted water film at the hydrophobic polymer surface and an adsorbed macrodroplet.     

固液界面纳米气泡的研究进展

根据经典热力学理论,在水中纳米级的气泡难以长期稳定存在.近年来却有大量的实验结果表明固液界面存在纳米气泡,原子力显微镜也直接观察到了纳米气泡.有关纳米气泡的研究具有巨大的理论和实际意义,它对表面科学、流体动力学、生物科学以及一些应用领域都有深远的影响.纳米气泡会引起流体在界面的滑移,减少流动阻力,并与表面粘附、胶体分散、矿石浮选、废渣处理等方面密切相关.目前关于纳米气泡的研究才刚刚开始,对于它的基本物化性质的了解还不多,但其重要性已经引起相关领域的极大关注.本文综述了从提出纳米气泡存在一直到实验证明的过程、纳米气泡的形成机制和形貌、分布特征等基本性质以及纳米气泡的存在对疏水长程作用和流体滑移的影响,并阐述了生物学中一些与纳米气泡存在有关的问题.     

Hydrophilic Domains Enhance Nanobubble Stability

Highly stable nanoscale gas states at solid/liquid interfaces, referred to as nanobubbles, have been widely studied for over a decade. In this study, nanobubbles generated on a hydrophobic Teflon amorphous fluoroplastic thin film in the presence and absence of hydrophilic carbon domains are investigated by peak force quantitative nanomechanics. On the hydrophobic surface without hydrophilic domains, a small number of nanobubbles are generated and then rapidly decrease in size. On the hydrophobic surface with hydrophilic domains, the hydrophilic domains have a significant effect on the generation and stability of nanobubbles, with bubbles remaining on the surface for up to three days.     

Water and ice in contact with octadecyl-trichlorosilane functionalized surfaces: a high resolution x-ray reflectivity study

We present a high energy x-ray reflectivity study of the density profiles of water and ice at hydrophobic and hydrophilic substrates. At the hydrophobic water/octadecyl-trichlorosilane (water-OTS) interface, we find clear evidence for a thin density depletion layer with an integrated density deficit corresponding to approximately 40% of a monolayer of water molecules. We discuss the experimental results in terms of a simple model of hydrophobic/hydrophilic solid-liquid interfaces. Our results also exclude the presence of nanobubbles. A detailed study of possible radiation damage induced by the intense x-ray beam at the dry OTS surface and at the ice-OTS, as well as at water-OTS interfaces, discloses that noticeable damage is only induced at the water-OTS interface, and thus points to the dominant role of highly mobile radicals formed in bulk water close to the interface.     

Effects of pH and ionic strength on the stability of nanobubbles in aqueous solutions of alpha-cyclodextrin

Formation of stable nanobubbles in aqueous solutions of water-soluble organic molecules is a spontaneous process. Using a combination of laser light scattering (LLS) and zeta-potential measurements, we investigated the effects of salt concentration and pH on their stability in alpha-cyclodextrin (alpha-CD) aqueous solutions. Our results reveal that the nanobubbles are unstable in solution with a higher ionic strength, just like colloidal particles in an aqueous dispersion, but become more stable in alkaline solutions. The zeta-potential measurement shows that the nanobubbles are negatively charged with an electric double layer, presumably due to adsorption of negative OH- ions at the gas/water interface. It is this double layer that plays a critical dual role in the formation of stable nanobubbles in aqueous solutions of water-soluble organic molecules, namely, it not only provides a repulsive force to prevent interbubble aggregation and coalescence but also reduces the surface tension at the gas/water interface to decrease the internal pressure inside each bubble.     

Scanning of silicon wafers in contact with aqueous CTAB solutions below the CMC

Hydrophilic silicon wafers are studied against aqueous solutions of hexadecyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB) at concentrations between 0.05 mM up to 1 mM (CMC). AFM studies show that nanobubbles are formed at concentrations up to 0.4 mM. From 0.5 mM upward, no bubbles could be detected. This is interpreted as the formation of hydrophobic domains of surfactant aggregates, becoming hydrophilic at about 0.5 mM. The high contact angle of the nanobubbles (140-150° through water) indicates that the nanobubbles are located on the surfactant domains. A combined imaging and colloidal probe AFM study serves to highlight the surfactant patches adsorbed at the surface via nanobubbles. The nanobubbles have a diameter between 30 and 60 nm (after tip deconvolution), depending on the surfactant concentration. This corresponds to a Laplace pressure of about 30 atm. The presence of the nanobubbles is correlated with force measurements between a silica probe and a silicon wafer surface. The study is a contribution to the better understanding of the short-range attraction between hydrophilic surfaces exposed to a surfactant solution.     

Influence of nanobubbles on the adsorption of nanoparticles

A quartz crystal microbalance was used to study the influence of nanobubbles on the adsorption of polystyrene nanoparticles onto surfaces coated with gold, or coated with dodecanethiol or mercaptoundecanoic acid self-assembled monolayers (SAMs). Adsorption of the nanoparticles onto the surface causes the resonant frequency of the quartz crystal to decrease. We found that particles were adsorbed onto the gold-coated quartz crystal in air-rich water, but not in degassed water. This finding supports the long-standing hypothesis that nanobubbles play a key role in the long-range attractive force between hydrophobic surfaces in aqueous solutions. When the experiments were conducted using quartz crystals coated with a hydrophobic dodecanethiol SAM, the nanoparticles were adsorbed onto the surface even in degassed water due to the short-range hydrophobic interactions between the nanoparticles and the dodecanethiol molecules. In contrast, the nanoparticles were adsorbed to a lesser degree onto the hydrophilic mercaptoundecanoic acid-coated crystals due to electrostatic repulsive forces.     

Adhesion forces in liquid media: effect of surface topography and wettability

This work was motivated by the unexpected values of adhesion forces measured between an atomic force microscopy tip and the hydrophobic surface of ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene. Two types of samples with different roughness but similar wettability were tested. Adhesion forces of similar magnitude were obtained in air and in polar liquids (water and Hank's Balanced Salt Solution, a saline solution) with the rougher sample. In contrast, the adhesion forces measured on the smoother sample in air were much higher than those measured in water or in the aqueous solution. Those experimental results suggested the presence of nanobubbles at the interface between the rough sample and the polar liquids. The existence of the nanobubbles was further confirmed by the images of the interface obtained in noncontact tapping mode. The adhesion forces measured in a nonpolar liquid (hexadecane) were small and of the same order of magnitude for both samples and their values were in good agreement with the predictions of the London-Hamaker approach for the van der Waals interactions. Finally, we correlate the appearance of nanobubbles with surface topography. The conclusion of this work is that adhesion forces measured in aqueous media may be strongly affected by the presence of nanobubbles if the surface presents topographical accidents.     

The model of hydrophobic attraction in the framework of classical DLVO forces

The present article focuses on the analysis of experimental data and interpreting of the influence of water depletion near hydrophobic particles and nanobubbles formed on their surface or in the space between them on van der Waals and electrostatic components of interparticle interaction. It is shown that the difference between simplified and more detailed models of DLVO forces explains the nature and main characteristics of hydrophobic attraction.     

Removal of induced nanobubbles from water/graphite interfaces by partial degassing

Nanobubbles at an interface between a hydrophobic solid and water have a wide range of implications, but the evidence for their existence is still being debated. Here we artificially induced nanobubbles on freshly cleaved HOPG substrates in water using the protocol developed previously and subjected the system to moderate levels of degassing (approximately 0.1 atm for 0.5 to 3 h). The AFM images after the partial degassing revealed that some nanobubbles had coalesced and detached from the substrate because of buoyancy, whereas others apparently remained unaffected. The size and spatial distributions of the nanobubbles after the partial degassing suggest that there is a critical size for a nanobubble above which it may grow. The contact angle of water next to nanobubbles (approximately 160 degrees) is much larger than the advancing contact angle of a macroscopic water droplet on the same substrate (approximately 80 degrees) both before and after the partial degassing and concomitant growth and shrinkage of the nanobubbles. The contact angle of a nanobubble also remained unchanged as the nanobubble was moved along the substrate by the AFM tip. The apparent lack of contact angle hysteresis in the nanobubble systems may suggest that the very large contact angle may correspond to a local minimum of the free-energy landscape.     

Stability of self-assembled hydrophobic surfactant layers in water

Using contact angle measurements, surface force balance experiments, and AFM imaging, we have investigated the process of self-assembly of surfactants onto mica and the subsequent stability of those layers in pure water. In the case of cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), the stability of a monolayer when immersed in pure water is found to be dependent on initial immersion time in surfactant, which is likely to be caused by an increase in the proportion of ion-exchange to ion-pair adsorption when incubated in surfactant for longer periods of time. Infinite dilution of the surfactant solution before withdrawal of the sample is found to have little effect on the stability of the resulting layer in pure water. The nature of the counterion is found to affect dramatically the stability of a self-assembled surfactant monolayer: cetyltrimethylammonium fluoride (CTAF) forms a layer that is much more stable in water than CTAB, which is likely to be due to faster and more complete ion-exchange with the mica surface for CTAF. Surface force balance experiments show that when the hydrophobic monolayer is immersed in pure water it does not simply dissolve into the water; instead it rearranges, possibly to patches of bilayer or hemimicelles. The time scale of this rearrangement agrees well with the time scale of the change from a hydrophobic to more hydrophilic surface observed using contact angle measurements. AFM imaging has also in some cases shown an evolution from an even monolayer to patches of bilayer.     

Effects of degassing on the long-range attractive force between hydrophobic surfaces in water

The long-ranged attractions between hydrophobic amorphous fluoropolymer surfaces are measured in water with and without dissolved air. An atomic force microscope is used to obtain more than 500 measured jump-in distances, which yields statistically reliable results. It is found that the range of the attraction and its variability is generally significantly decreased in deaerated water as compared to normal, aerated water. However, the range and strength of the attraction in deaerated water remain significantly greater than the van der Waals attraction for this system. The experimental observations are consistent with (1) nanobubbles being primarily responsible for the long-ranged attraction in normal water, (2) nanobubbles not being present in deaerated water when the surfaces are not in contact, and (3) the attraction in the absence of nanobubbles being most probably due to the approach to the separation-induced spinodal cavitation of the type identified by Bérard et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 1993, 98, 7236]. It is argued that the measurements in deaerated water reveal the bare or pristine hydrophobic attraction unobscured by nanobubbles.     

Electrochemically controlled formation and growth of hydrogen nanobubbles

Electrogenerated microscale bubbles that are confined at the electrode surface have already been extensively studied because of their significant influence on electrochemistry. In contrast, as far as we know, whether nanoscale bubbles exist on the electrode surface has not been experimentally confirmed yet. Here, we report the observation of electrochemically controlled formation and growth of hydrogen nanobubbles on bare highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) surface via in-situ tapping mode atomic force microscopy (TMAFM). By using TMAFM imaging, we observed that electrochemically generated hydrogen gas led to the formation of nanobubbles at the HOPG surface. We then employed a combination of techniques, including phase imaging, ex-situ degassing, and tip perturbation, to confirm the gas origin of such observed nanobubbles. We further demonstrated that the formation and growth of nanobubbles could be well controlled by tuning either the applied voltage or the reaction time. Remarkably, we could also monitor the evolution process of nanobubbles, that is, formation, growth, coalescence, as well as the eventual release of merged microbubbles from the HOPG surface.     

The Origin of the “Snap‐In” in the Force Curve between AFM Probe and the Water/Gas Interface of Nanobubbles

The long‐range attractive force or “snap‐in” is an important phenomenon usually occurring when a solid particle interacts with a water/gas interface. By using PeakForce quantitative nanomechanics the origin of snap‐in in the force curve between the atomic force microscopy (AFM) probe and the water/gas interface of nanobubbles has been investigated. The snap‐in frequently happened when the probe was preserved for a certain time or after being used for imaging solid surfaces under atmospheric conditions. In contrast, imaging in liquids rarely induced a snap‐in. After a series of control experiments, it was found that the snap‐in can be attributed to hydrophobic interactions between the water/gas interface and the AFM probe, which was either modified or contaminated with hydrophobic material. The hydrophobic contamination could be efficiently removed by a conventional plasma‐cleaning treatment, which prevents the occurring of the snap‐in. In addition, the adsorption of sodium dodecyl sulfate onto the nanobubble surface changed the water/gas interface into hydrophilic, which also eliminated the snap‐in phenomenon.     

State and structure of water in vicinity of hydrophobic surfaces

Criterial values of the specific heat of water wetting, surface pressure, and contact angle classifying surfaces into hydrophilic and hydrophobic are proposed based on the analysis of own and published data. The most characteristic properties of hydrophobic surfaces, i.e., large surface area per water molecule in the conventional adsorption monolayer and the absence of continuous two-layer water film on the adsorbent surface at vapor pressure close to saturation, are discussed using nonporous carbon-based materials as example. The presence of residual hydrophilic groups that act as sites of the clusterization of polar molecules on the surface of graphitized carbon black is confirmed by gas chromatography and the concentration of these sites is calculated. The amount of water molecules in the surface cluster is determined at different stages of adsorption. Procedures for preparing organically modified layered silicates and silica as basic objects of the study of the interaction between water molecules and hydrophobic surfaces are considered. It is proven that the boundary water layer in the vicinity of hydrophobic surface consists of a thin (∼0.5 nm) depletion layer with a density of 0.4 g/cm³ and a considerable amount (25–30%) of water molecules with free OH groups and thicker (∼35 nm) layer, which is characterized by a more ordered network of hydrogen bonds compared to liquid water. Data obtained by X-ray scattering and neutron and reflection methods, and sum-frequency vibrational spectroscopy are compared with the results of calorimetric study of the interaction between water and hydrophobic surface, as well as with the data of molecular-statistical calculations of the state of water molecules in the surface layer.     

Stable Encapsulated Air Nanobubbles in Water

The dispersion into water of nanocapsules bearing a highly hydrophobic fluorinated internal lining yielded encapsulated air nanobubbles. These bubbles, like their micrometer‐sized counterparts (microbubbles), effectively reflected ultrasound. More importantly, the nanobubbles survived under ultrasonication 100‐times longer than a commercial microbubble sample that is currently in clinical use. We justify this unprecedented stability theoretically. These nanobubbles, owing to their small size and potential ability to permeate the capillary networks of tissues, may expand the applications of microbubbles in diagnostic ultrasonography and find new applications in ultrasound‐regulated drug delivery.     

Removal of nanoparticles from plain and patterned surfaces using nanobubbles

It is the aim of this paper to quantitatively characterize the capability of surface nanobubbles for surface cleaning, i.e., removal of nanodimensioned polystyrene particles from the surface. We adopt two types of substrates: plain and nanopatterned (trench/ridge) silicon wafer. The method used to generate nanobubbles on the surfaces is the so-called alcohol-water exchange process (use water to flush a surface that is already covered by alcohol). It is revealed that nanobubbles are generated on both surfaces, and have a remarkably high coverage on the nanopatterns. In particular, we show that nanoparticles are-in the event of nanobubble occurrence-removed efficiently from both surfaces. The result is compared with other bubble-free wet cleaning techniques, i.e., water rinsing, alcohol rinsing, and water-alcohol exchange process (use alcohol to flush a water-covered surface, generating no nanobubbles) which all cause no or very limited removal of nanoparticles. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and helium ion microscopy (HIM) are employed for surface inspection. Nanobubble formation and the following nanoparticle removal are monitored with atomic force microscopy (AFM) operated in liquid, allowing for visualization of the two events.