Pickering emulsions: Versatility of colloidal particles and recent applications

The versatility of colloidal particles endows the particle stabilized or Pickering emulsions with unique features and can potentially enable the fabrication of a wide variety of derived materials. We review the evolution and breakthroughs in the research on the use of colloidal particles for the stabilization of Pickering emulsions in recent years for the particle categories of inorganic particles, polymer-based particles, and food-grade particles. Moreover, based on the latest works, several emulsions stabilized by the featured particles and their derived functional materials, including enzyme immobilized emulsifiers for interfacial catalysis, 2D colloidal materials stabilized emulsions as templates for porous materials, and Pickering emulsions as adjuvant formulations, are also summarized. Finally, we point out the gaps in the current research on the applications of Pickering emulsions and suggest future directions for the design of particulate stabilizers and preparation methods for Pickering emulsions and their derived materials.     

Particle self-assembly at ionic liquid-based interfaces

This review presents an overview of the nature of ionic liquid (IL)-based interfaces and self-assembled particle morphologies of IL-in-water, oil- and water-in-IL, and novel IL-in-IL Pickering emulsions with emphasis on their unique phenomena, by means of experimental and computational studies. In IL-in-water Pickering emulsions, particles formed monolayers at ionic liquid–water interfaces and were close-packed on fully covered emulsion droplets or aggregated on partially covered droplets. Interestingly, other than equilibrating at the ionic liquid–water interfaces, microparticles with certain surface chemistries were extracted into the ionic liquid phase with a high efficiency. These experimental findings were supported by potential of mean force calculations, which showed large energy drops as hydrophobic particles crossed the interface into the IL phase. In the oil- and water-in-IL Pickering emulsions, microparticles with acidic surface chemistries formed monolayer bridges between the internal phase droplets rather than residing at the oil/water–ionic liquid interfaces, a significant deviation from traditional Pickering emulsion morphology. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed aspects of the mechanism behind this bridging phenomenon, including the role of the droplet phase, surface chemistry, and inter-particle film. Novel IL-in-IL Pickering emulsions exhibited an array of self-assembled morphologies including the previously observed particle absorption and bridging phenomena. The appearance of these morphologies depended on the particle surface chemistry as well as the ILs used. The incorporation of particle self-assembly with ionic liquid science allows for new applications at the intersection of these two fields, and have the potential to be numerous due to the tunability of the ionic liquids and particles incorporated, as well as the particle morphology by combining certain groups of particle surface chemistry, IL type (protic or aprotic), and whether oil or water is incorporated.     

Synergetic Effect of Reactive Surfactants and Clay Particles on Stabilization of Nonaqueous Oil-in-Oil (o/o) Emulsions

Although surfactants and particles are often used together in stabilization of aqueous emulsions, the contribution of each species to such stabilization at the oil-water interface is poorly understood. The situation becomes more complicated if we consider the nonaqueous oil-oil interface, i.e, the stabilization of nonaqueous oil-in-oil (o/o) emulsions by solid particles and reactive surfactants which, to our knowledge, has not been studied before. We have prepared Pickering nonaqueous simple (o/o) emulsions stabilized by a combination of kaolinite particles and a nonionic polymerizable surfactant Noigen RN10 (polyoxyethylene alkylphenyl ether). Different pairs of immiscible oils were used which gave different emulsion stabilities. Using kaolinite with equal volumes of paraffin oil/formamide system gave no stable emulsions at all concentrations while the addition of Noigen RN10 enhanced the emulsion stability. In contrast, addition of Noigen RN10 surfactant to silicon oil-in-glycerin emulsions stabilized by kaolinite resulted in destabilization of the system at all concentrations. For all systems studied here, no phase inversion in simple emulsion was observed by altering the volume fraction of the dispersed phase as compared to the known water-based simple Pickering emulsions.      

Effect of dispersion pH on the formation and stability of Pickering emulsions stabilized by layered double hydroxides particles

Using positively charged plate-like layered double hydroxides (LDHs) particles as emulsifier, liquid paraffin-in-water emulsions stabilized solely by such particles are successfully prepared. The effects of the pH of LDHs aqueous dispersions on the formation and stability of the emulsions are investigated here. The properties of the LDHs dispersions at different pHs are described, including particle zeta potential, particle aggregation, particle contact angle, flow behavior of the dispersions and particle adsorption at a planar oil/water interface. The zeta potential decreases with increasing pH, leading to the aggregation of LDHs particles into large flocs. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions is enhanced by increasing pH and particle concentration. The three-phase contact angle of LDHs also increases with increasing pH, but the variation is very small. Visual observation and SEM images of the interfacial particle layers show that the adsorption behavior of LDHs particles at the planar oil/water interface is controlled by dispersion pH. We consider that the particle-particle (at the interface) and particle-interface electrostatic interactions are well controlled by adjusting the dispersion pH, leading to pH-tailored colloid adsorption. The formation of an adsorbed particle layer around the oil drops is crucial for the formation and stability of the emulsions. Emulsion stability improves with increasing pH and particle concentration because more particles are available to be adsorbed at the oil/water interface. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions and the gel-like structure of emulsions also influence the stability of the emulsions, but they are not necessary for the formation of emulsions. The emulsions cannot be demulsified by adjusting emulsion pH due to the irreversible adsorption of LDHs particles at the oil/water interface. TEM images of the emulsion drops show that a thick particle layer forms around the oil drops, confirming that Pickering emulsions are stabilized by the adsorbed particle layers. The thick adsorbed particle layer may be composed of a stable inner particle layer which is in direct contact with the oil phase and a relatively unstable outer particle layer surrounding the inner layer.     

颗粒乳化剂的研究及应用

近年来,颗粒乳化剂因其在食品、采油、化妆品、医药、催化以及功能纳米材料制备等领域具有潜在应用前景而备受关注。本文综述了近来颗粒乳化剂的研究进展,归纳了颗粒乳化剂的种类,包括:无机纳米粒子、表面改性或杂化的无机粒子、有机纳米粒子以及特殊的颗粒乳化剂Janus粒子;并对颗粒乳化剂能够在油水界面稳定吸附的热力学机理和动力学行为进行了阐述,颗粒乳化剂在油水界面接触角以及粒径大小是其在界面稳定吸附的关键参数,而颗粒在油水界面的排布方式则主要受粒子之间相互作用的影响。重点介绍了颗粒乳化剂的热点应用,包括:(1)利用颗粒乳化剂制备Pickering乳液,以及通过对颗粒乳化剂的功能化,使得Pickering乳液具备环境响应性(即pH、盐浓度、温度、紫外光、磁场敏感响应性);(2)以颗粒乳化剂为构筑基元、以Pickering乳液为模板制备Janus颗粒、Colloidosome、具有多级结构的粒子或膜,以及多孔结构材料;(3) Janus粒子在催化领域的应用。     

Review of Functional Aspects of Nanocellulose-Based Pickering Emulsifier for Non-Toxic Application and Its Colloid Stabilization Mechanism

In the past few years, the research on particle-stabilized emulsion (Pickering emulsion) has mainly focused on the usage of inorganic particles with well-defined shapes, narrow size distributions, and chemical tunability of the surfaces such as silica, alumina, and clay. However, the presence of incompatibility of some inorganic particles that are non-safe to humans and the ecosystem and their poor sustainability has led to a shift towards the development of materials of biological origin. For this reason, nano-dimensional cellulose (nanocellulose) derived from natural plants is suitable for use as a Pickering material for liquid interface stabilization for various non-toxic product formulations (e.g., the food and beverage, cosmetic, personal care, hygiene, pharmaceutical, and biomedical fields). However, the current understanding of nanocellulose-stabilized Pickering emulsion still lacks consistency in terms of the structural, self-assembly, and physio-chemical properties of nanocellulose towards the stabilization between liquid and oil interfaces. Thus, this review aims to provide a comprehensive study of the behavior of nanocellulose-based particles and their ability as a Pickering functionality to stabilize emulsion droplets. Extensive discussion on the characteristics of nanocelluloses, morphology, and preparation methods that can potentially be applied as Pickering emulsifiers in a different range of emulsions is provided. Nanocellulose’s surface modification for the purpose of altering its characteristics and provoking multifunctional roles for high-grade non-toxic applications is discussed. Subsequently, the water–oil stabilization mechanism and the criteria for effective emulsion stabilization are summarized in this review. Lastly, we discuss the toxicity profile and risk assessment guidelines for the whole life cycle of nanocellulose from the fresh feedstock to the end-life of the product.     

Influence of microgel architecture and oil polarity on stabilization of emulsions by stimuli-sensitive core-shell poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-methacrylic acid) microgels: Mickering versus Pickering behavior?

Charged poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-methacrylic acid) [P(NiPAM-co-MAA)] microgels can stabilize thermo- and pH-sensitive emulsions. By placing charged units at different locations in the microgels and comparing the emulsion properties, we demonstrate that their behaviors as emulsion stabilizers are very different from molecular surfactants and rigid Pickering stabilizers. The results show that the stabilization of the emulsions is independent of electrostatic repulsion although the presence and location of charges are relevant. Apparently, the charges facilitate emulsion stabilization via the extent of swelling and deformability of the microgels. The stabilization of these emulsions is linked to the swelling and structure of the microgels at the oil-water interface, which depends not only on the presence of charged moieties and on solvent polarity but also on the microgel (core-shell) morphology. Therefore, the internal soft and porous structure of microgels is important, and these features make microgel-stabilized emulsions characteristically different from classical, rigid-particle-stabilized Pickering emulsions, the stability of which depends on the surface properties of the particles.     

Pickering emulsions stabilized solely by layered double hydroxides particles: the effect of salt on emulsion formation and stability

The formation and stability of liquid paraffin-in-water emulsions stabilized solely by positively charged plate-like layered double hydroxides (LDHs) particles were described here. The effects of adding salt into LDHs dispersions on particle zeta potential, particle contact angle, particle adsorption at the oil-water interface and the structure strength of dispersions were studied. It was found that the zeta potential of particles gradually decreased with the increase of salt concentration, but the variation of contact angle with salt concentration was very small. The adsorption of particles at the oil-water interface occurred due to the reduction of particle zeta potential. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions was strengthened with the increase of salt and particle concentrations. The effects of particle concentration, salt concentration and oil phase volume fraction on the formation, stability and type of emulsions were investigated and discussed in relation to the adsorption of particles at the oil-water interface and the structural strength of LDHs dispersions. Finally, the possible stabilization mechanisms of emulsions were put forward: the decrease of particle zeta potential leads to particle adsorption at the oil-water interface and the formation of a network of particles at the interface, both of which are crucial for emulsion formation and stability; the structural strength of LDHs dispersions is responsible for emulsion stability, but is not necessary for emulsion formation.     

Particle self-assembly in oil-in-ionic liquid Pickering emulsions

We have studied polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)-in-1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate ([BMIM][PF(6)]) Pickering emulsions stabilized by polystyrene microparticles with different surface chemistry. Surprisingly, in contrast to the consensus originating from oil/water Pickering emulsions in which the solid particles equilibrate at the oil-water droplet interfaces and provide effective stabilization, here the polystyrene microparticles treated with sulfate, aldehyde sulfate, or carboxylate dissociable groups mostly formed monolayer bridges among the oil droplets rather than residing at the oil-ionic liquid interfaces. The bridge formation inhibited individual droplet-droplet coalescence; however, due to low density and large volume (thus the buoyant effect), the aggregated oil droplets actually promoted oil/ionic liquid phase separation and distressed emulsion stability. Systems with binary heterogeneous polystyrene microparticles exhibited similar, even enhanced (in terms of surface chemistry dependence), bridging phenomenon in the PDMS-in-[BMIM][PF(6)] Pickering emulsions.     

Size effects of discoidal PLGA nanoconstructs in Pickering emulsion stabilization

Solid particle stabilized emulsions, using unique shape defined particles, are receiving increasing research interest due to ease of formulation and interesting physiochemical characteristics. There is, however, a need to systematically investigate the effect of anisotropic discoidal microparticles, realized with top-down fabrication approaches, in emulsion stabilization. Here, the effect of poly(d ,l -lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) discoidal polymeric nanoconstruct (DPN) size on the formation and stability of oil-in-water emulsions is studied. Particles with a diameter of 1, 2, and 5 μm are fabricated with a lithographic templating technique, and used to stabilize medium chain triglyceride (MCT) oil emulsions. Three phase contact angles decreased from 85° ± 7° to 68° ± 12° moving from 1 to 5 μm DPN stabilized emulsions, showing a particle “hydrophilicity” increase with size. Microscopy imaging showed that the mean droplet diameter and dispersity increased with particle size, and that DPNs were present at the oil–water interface. DPN based emulsions were stable for about 24 h or less in the case of 1 and 2 μm DPNs. Emulsion stability was shorter than 12 h in case of 5 μm DPNs. Finally, calculations of DPN detachment free energies ΔG_dw and excess surface coverages C_excess demonstrated that, despite the significantly high adhesion energy of the discoidal DPN, emulsion stability was mostly affected by gravitational forces for DPN sizes above 2 μm. The use of PLGA and MCT oil in this study is relevant for future use of Pickering emulsions in pharmaceutical and drug delivery applications.     

Pickering Emulsions as Vehicles for Bioactive Compounds from Essential Oils

Pickering emulsions are emulsion systems stabilized by solid particles at the interface of oil and water. Pickering emulsions are considered to be natural, biodegradable, and safe, so their applications in various fields—such as food, cosmetics, biomedicine, etc.—are very promising, including as a vehicle for essential oils (EOs). These oils contain volatile and aromatic compounds and have excellent properties, such as antifungal, antibacterial, antiviral, and antioxidant activities. Despite their superior properties, EOs are prone to evaporation, decompose when exposed to light and oxygen, and have low solubility, limiting their industrial applications. Several studies have shown that EOs in Pickering emulsions displays less sensitivity to evaporation and oxidation, stronger antibacterial activity, and increased solubility. In brief, the application of Pickering emulsions for EOs is interesting to explore. This review discusses recent progress in the application of Pickering emulsions, particularly as EO carriers, drug carriers, antioxidant and antimicrobial carriers, and in active packaging.     

Pickering stabilization of foams and emulsions with particles of biological origin

The focus in the study of Pickering foams and emulsions has recently been shifting from using inorganic particles to adopting particles of biological origin for stabilization. This shift is motivated by the incompatibility of some inorganic particles for food and biomedical applications, as well as their poor sustainability. This review focuses on major developments in foams and emulsions stabilized by particles of biological origin from the last 5 years. Recent reports in the literature have demonstrated the ability of particles derived from cellulose, lignin, chitin, starch, proteins (soy, zein, ferritin), as well as hydrophobic cells to stabilize biphasic dispersions. We review the use of such nano- and micron-sized particles of biological origin for the stabilization of foams and emulsions, summarize the current knowledge of how such particles stabilize these dispersions, provide an outlook for future work to improve our understanding of bio-derived particle-stabilized foams and emulsions, and touch upon how these systems can be used to create novel materials.     

胶体颗粒稳定的界面及胶体颗粒在界面的相互作用

Particle-stabilized dispersions such as emulsions, foams and bubbles are catching increasing attentions across a number of research areas. The adsorption mechanism and role of these colloidal particles in stabilizing the oil-water or gas-water interfaces and how these particles interact at interfaces are vital to the practical use of these dispersion systems. Although there have been intensive investigations, problems associated with the stabilization mechanisms and particle-particle interactions at interfaces still remain to explore. In this paper, we first systematically review the historical understanding of particle-stabilized emulsions or bubbles and then give an overview of the most important and well-established progress in the understanding of particle-stabilized systems, including emulsions, foams and liquid marbles. The particle-adsorption phenomena have long been realized and been discussed in academic paper for more than one century and a quantitative model was proposed in the early 1980s. The theory can successfully explain the adsorption of solid particles onto interface from energy reduction approaches. The stability of emulsions and foams can be readily correlated to the wettability of the particles towards the two phases. And extensive researches on emulsion stability and various strategies have been developed to prepared dispersion systems with a certain trigger such as pH and temperature. After that, we discuss recent development of the interactions between particles when they are trapped at the interface and highlight open questions in this field. There exists a huge gap between theoretical approaches and experimental results on the interactions of particles adsorbed at interfaces due to demanding experimental devices and skills. In practice, it is customary to use flat surfaces/interfaces as model surfaces to investigate the particle-particle at interfaces although most of the time interfaces are produced with a certain curvature. It is shown that the introduction of particles onto interfaces can generate charges at the interfaces which could possibly account for the long range electrostatic interactions. Finally, we illustrate that particle-stabilized dispersions have been found wide applications in many fields and applications such as microcapsules, food, biomedical carriers, and dry water. One of the most investigated areas is the microencapsulation of actives based on Pickering emulsion templates. The particles adsorbed at the interface can serve as interfacial stabilizers as well as constituting components of shells of colloidal microcapsules. Emulsions stabilized by solid particles derived from natural and bio-related sources are promising platforms to be applied in food related industries. Emulsion systems stabilized by solid particles of the w/w (water-in-water) feature are discussed. This special type of emulsion is attracting increasing attentions due to their all water features. Besides of oil-water interface, particle stabilized air-water interface share similar stabilization mechanism and several applications reported in the literature are subsequently discussed. We hope that this paper can encourage more scientists to engage in the studies of particle-stabilized interfaces and more novel applications can be proposed based on this mechanism     

Structure of microparticles in solid-stabilized emulsions

Emulsions of oil and water stabilized by adsorbed solid particles are known as solid-stabilized emulsions (often referred to as Pickering emulsions). Using confocal microscopy, we have studied the assembly of colloidal-sized polystyrene particles in poly(dimethylsiloxane)-in-water solid-stabilized emulsions. Monodisperse polystyrene particles, when included in the emulsions at low concentrations, were found to form small patches with local "hexagonal" order, separated by other particle-free domains. Polystyrene particles with different sizes (1 and 4 microm) and different wettability could simultaneously segregate to the emulsion interface; even mixtures of hydrophobic and hydrophilic solid particles were found to simultaneously segregate to the same interface.     

CO2-triggered switchable Pickering emulsion stabilized by guanidine-functionalized silica particles

The guanidine group-modified silica particles were used as emulsifier to obtain a CO₂-responsive Pickering emulsion. To compare the wettability effect of the particles on the stability of the emulsion, both guanidine and alkyl chain were attached on the surface of silica particles. The influences of tension, particles concentration, oil-water fraction, NaCl concentration, and CO₂ on Pickering emulsion properties were investigated. Although the particles did not decrease the surface and interfacial tensions of the air/oil-water interfaces, they attached on the oil–water interfaces and stabilized the emulsions at room temperature for at least 4 weeks. Addition of salt increased the emulsion stability and induced phase inversion at high salt concentration. The stabilization–destabilization cycles of the emulsion could be successively controlled by alternative CO₂/heating triggers due to the protonation-deprotonation of guanidine groups on the particle surfaces.     

Production of large quantities of “Janus” nanoparticles using wax-in-water emulsions

For the first time, large amount of Janus silica particles as small as 100 nm in diameter were prepared through a simple method based on the elaboration of Pickering emulsions of wax-in-water. Controlling the kinetic stabilization of wax droplets allows the fabrication of gram-sized quantities of regular asymmetric inorganic particles with high yield. In fact, our method is based on a limited coalescence process, which allows one to predict the quantity of interface which is produced when working with a known mass of wax, and thus to be sure that all introduced silica particles are adsorbed on the wax surface. To this end, the hydrophilic surface of the silica particles was made partially hydrophobic by adsorbing a known amount of surfactant: cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB). Varying the concentration in surfactant results in tuning the penetration rate of the particles in the wax droplets, leading to various dimension of the modified area. The broken spherical symmetry of the particle surface was thereafter revealed by the selective adsorption of gold nanoparticles on the amino-modified surface.     

SiO2纳米颗粒与聚氧乙烯对Pickering乳液的协同稳定作用简

研究了聚氧乙烯(PEO)与SiO2纳米颗粒对水/二甲苯体系Pickering乳液的协同稳定作用. 实验发现,PEO的存在减小了乳液液滴的平均直径,抑制了乳液的相反转,有效阻止了乳液的熟化,使乳液具有更好的稳定性. 进一步对纳米颗粒膜的流变性质进行研究,结果表明,PEO高分子促进了纳米颗粒形成更大尺寸的聚集结构,提高了其在界面上的吸附性,增强了颗粒膜的力学性能,在较小颗粒用量条件下使得Gibbs稳定性判据得到满足.     

Trends in structuring edible emulsions with Pickering fat crystals

The pace of development of edible Pickering emulsions has recently soared, as interest in their potential for texture modification, calorie reduction and bioactive compound encapsulation and delivery has risen. In the broadest sense, Pickering emulsions are defined as those stabilized by interfacially-adsorbed solid particles that retard and ideally prevent emulsion coalescence and phase separation. Numerous fat-based species have been explored for their propensity to stabilize edible emulsions, including triglyceride and surfactant-based crystals and solid lipid nanoparticles. This review explores three classes of fat-based Pickering stabilizers, and proposes a microstructure-based nomenclature to delineate them: Type I (surfactant-mediated interfacial crystallization), Type II (interfacially-adsorbed nano- or microparticles) and Type III (shear-crystallized droplet encapsulation matrices). Far from simply reporting the latest findings on these modes of stabilization, challenges associated with these are also highlighted. Finally, though emphasis is placed on food emulsions, the fundamental precepts herein described are equally applicable to non-food multicomponent emulsion systems.     

On the thermodynamics of particle-stabilized emulsions: curvature effects and catastrophic phase inversion

The flexural properties of a particle adsorption monolayer are investigated theoretically. If the particles are not densely packed, the interfacial bending moment and the spontaneous curvature (due to the particles) are equal to zero. The situation changes if the particles are closely packed. Then the particle adsorption monolayer possesses a significant bending moment, and the interfacial energies of bending and dilatation become comparable. In this case, the bending energy can either stabilize or destabilize the Pickering emulsion, depending on whether the particle contact angle is smaller or greater than 90 degrees . Theoretical expressions are derived for the bending moment, for the curvature elastic modulus, and for the work of interfacial deformation and emulsification. The latter is dominated by the work for creation of a new oil-water interface and by the work for particle adsorption. The curvature effects give a contribution of second order, which is significant only for emulsification at 50:50 water/oil volume fractions. A thermodynamic criterion for the type of the formed emulsion is proposed. It predicts the existence of a catastrophic phase inversion in particle-stabilized emulsions, in agreement with the experimental observations. The derived theoretical expressions could find application for interpretation of experimental data on production and stability of Pickering emulsions.