The role of particles in stabilising foams and emulsions

The use of particles as foam and emulsion stabilising species, with or without surfactants, has received great interest in recent years. The majority of work has studied the effects of particles as stabilisers in emulsion systems, but recent successes has widened consideration into foams, where industries such as flotation and food processing have encountered the effects of particle stabilisation for many years. This review seeks to clarify studies into emulsions, highlighting new research in this area, and relate similarities and differences to foam systems. Past research has focused on defining the interaction mechanisms of stability, such as principles of attachment energies, particle-particle forces at the interface and changes to the interfilm, with a view to ascertain conditions giving optimum stability. Studied conditions include effects of particle contact angle, aggregation formations, concentration, size and interactions of other species (i.e. surfactant). Mechanisms can be complex, but overall the principle of particles creating a steric barrier to coalescence, is a straitforward basis of interaction. Much research in emulsions can be applied to foam systems, however evidence would suggest foam systems are under a number of additional constraints, and the stability 'window' for particles is smaller, in terms of size and contact angle ranges. Also, because of increased density differences and interfilm perturbations in foam systems, retardation of drainage is often as important to stability as inhibiting coalescence.     

胶体颗粒稳定的界面及胶体颗粒在界面的相互作用

Particle-stabilized dispersions such as emulsions, foams and bubbles are catching increasing attentions across a number of research areas. The adsorption mechanism and role of these colloidal particles in stabilizing the oil-water or gas-water interfaces and how these particles interact at interfaces are vital to the practical use of these dispersion systems. Although there have been intensive investigations, problems associated with the stabilization mechanisms and particle-particle interactions at interfaces still remain to explore. In this paper, we first systematically review the historical understanding of particle-stabilized emulsions or bubbles and then give an overview of the most important and well-established progress in the understanding of particle-stabilized systems, including emulsions, foams and liquid marbles. The particle-adsorption phenomena have long been realized and been discussed in academic paper for more than one century and a quantitative model was proposed in the early 1980s. The theory can successfully explain the adsorption of solid particles onto interface from energy reduction approaches. The stability of emulsions and foams can be readily correlated to the wettability of the particles towards the two phases. And extensive researches on emulsion stability and various strategies have been developed to prepared dispersion systems with a certain trigger such as pH and temperature. After that, we discuss recent development of the interactions between particles when they are trapped at the interface and highlight open questions in this field. There exists a huge gap between theoretical approaches and experimental results on the interactions of particles adsorbed at interfaces due to demanding experimental devices and skills. In practice, it is customary to use flat surfaces/interfaces as model surfaces to investigate the particle-particle at interfaces although most of the time interfaces are produced with a certain curvature. It is shown that the introduction of particles onto interfaces can generate charges at the interfaces which could possibly account for the long range electrostatic interactions. Finally, we illustrate that particle-stabilized dispersions have been found wide applications in many fields and applications such as microcapsules, food, biomedical carriers, and dry water. One of the most investigated areas is the microencapsulation of actives based on Pickering emulsion templates. The particles adsorbed at the interface can serve as interfacial stabilizers as well as constituting components of shells of colloidal microcapsules. Emulsions stabilized by solid particles derived from natural and bio-related sources are promising platforms to be applied in food related industries. Emulsion systems stabilized by solid particles of the w/w (water-in-water) feature are discussed. This special type of emulsion is attracting increasing attentions due to their all water features. Besides of oil-water interface, particle stabilized air-water interface share similar stabilization mechanism and several applications reported in the literature are subsequently discussed. We hope that this paper can encourage more scientists to engage in the studies of particle-stabilized interfaces and more novel applications can be proposed based on this mechanism     

Pickering stabilization of foams and emulsions with particles of biological origin

The focus in the study of Pickering foams and emulsions has recently been shifting from using inorganic particles to adopting particles of biological origin for stabilization. This shift is motivated by the incompatibility of some inorganic particles for food and biomedical applications, as well as their poor sustainability. This review focuses on major developments in foams and emulsions stabilized by particles of biological origin from the last 5 years. Recent reports in the literature have demonstrated the ability of particles derived from cellulose, lignin, chitin, starch, proteins (soy, zein, ferritin), as well as hydrophobic cells to stabilize biphasic dispersions. We review the use of such nano- and micron-sized particles of biological origin for the stabilization of foams and emulsions, summarize the current knowledge of how such particles stabilize these dispersions, provide an outlook for future work to improve our understanding of bio-derived particle-stabilized foams and emulsions, and touch upon how these systems can be used to create novel materials.     

Materials based on solid-stabilized emulsions

Solid-stabilized emulsions are obtained by shearing a mixture of oil, water, and solid colloidal particles. In this article, we present a large variety of materials, resulting from a limited coalescence process. Direct (o/w), inverse (w/o), and multiple (w/o/w) emulsions that are surfactant-free and monodisperse were produced in a very wide droplet size range, from micrometers to centimeters. These materials exhibit original properties compared with surfactant-stabilized emulsions: outstanding stability with respect to coalescence and unusual rheological behavior. For such systems, the elastic storage modulus G' is not controlled by interfacial tension but by the interfacial elasticity resulting from the strong adhesion between the solid particles adsorbed at the oil-water interface. Due to the wide accessible droplet size range, concentrated emulsions can be extremely fluid while emulsions with low droplet volume fraction can behave as solids.     

Pickering Interfacial Catalysis for Biphasic Systems: From Emulsion Design to Green Reactions

Pickering emulsions are surfactant‐free dispersions of two immiscible fluids that are kinetically stabilized by colloidal particles. For ecological reasons, these systems have undergone a resurgence of interest to mitigate the use of synthetic surfactants and solvents. Moreover, the use of colloidal particles as stabilizers provides emulsions with original properties compared to surfactant‐stabilized emulsions, microemulsions, and micellar systems. Despite these specific advantages, the application of Pickering emulsions to catalysis has been rarely explored. This Minireview describes very recent examples of hybrid and composite amphiphilic materials for the design of interfacial catalysts in Pickering emulsions with special emphasis on their assets and challenges for industrially relevant biphasic reactions in fine chemistry, biofuel upgrading, and depollution.     

Pickering Emulsions as Vehicles for Bioactive Compounds from Essential Oils

Pickering emulsions are emulsion systems stabilized by solid particles at the interface of oil and water. Pickering emulsions are considered to be natural, biodegradable, and safe, so their applications in various fields—such as food, cosmetics, biomedicine, etc.—are very promising, including as a vehicle for essential oils (EOs). These oils contain volatile and aromatic compounds and have excellent properties, such as antifungal, antibacterial, antiviral, and antioxidant activities. Despite their superior properties, EOs are prone to evaporation, decompose when exposed to light and oxygen, and have low solubility, limiting their industrial applications. Several studies have shown that EOs in Pickering emulsions displays less sensitivity to evaporation and oxidation, stronger antibacterial activity, and increased solubility. In brief, the application of Pickering emulsions for EOs is interesting to explore. This review discusses recent progress in the application of Pickering emulsions, particularly as EO carriers, drug carriers, antioxidant and antimicrobial carriers, and in active packaging.     

Some Emulsion Features

Traditionally, emulsions have been defined as consisting of two liquids, of which one is dispersed in the other as macroscopic drops, stabilized by mono‐molecular layer of surfactant at the interface. However, a large majority of commercial emulsions are more complex than so and the added elements are essential for the properties of the emulsions including their stability.

With this in mind, this treatment of emulsions is divided into emulsions with mono‐layers and multilayers at the interface. In addition, additional elements in emulsions are described; such as lyotropic liquid crystals, vesicles, microemulsion droplets and solid particles, and their potential influence on the emulsion properties is indicated.     

Novel lipid-based colloidal dispersions as potential drug administration systems – expectations and reality

 Colloidal drug carriers offer a number of potential advantages as delivery systems for, for example, poorly soluble compounds. The first generation of colloidal carriers, in particular liposomes and sub-micron-sized lipid emulsions, are, however, associated with several drawbacks which so far have prevented the extensive use of these carriers in drug delivery. As an alternative colloidal delivery system melt-emulsified nanoparticles based on solid lipids have been proposed. Careful physicochemical characterization has demonstrated that these lipid-based nanosuspensions (solid lipid nanoparticles) are not just “emulsions with solidified droplets”. During the development process of these systems interesting phenomena have been observed, such as gel formation on solidification and upon storage, unexpected dynamics of polymorphic transitions, extensive annealing of nanocrystals over significant periods of time, stepwise melting of particle fractions in the lower-nanometer-size range, drug expulsion from the carrier particles on crystallization and upon storage, and extensive supercooling. These phenomena can be related to the crystalline nature of the carrier matrix in combination with its colloidal state. Observation of the supercooling effect has led to the development of a second new type of carrier system: nanospheres of supercooled melts. This novel type of colloidal lipidic carrier represents an intermediate state between emulsions and suspensions. Moreover, these dispersions are particularly suited to the study of the basic differences between colloidal triglyceride emulsions and suspensions. For many decades drug carriers have represented the only group of colloidal drug administration systems. Nowadays a fundamentally different group of dispersions is also under investigation: drug nanodispersions. They overcome a number of carrier-related drawbacks, such as limitations in drug load as well as side effects due to the matrix material of the carrier particles. Utilizing this concept virtually insoluble drugs can be formulated as colloidal particles, of solid or supercooled nature. For example, coenzyme Q₁₀ (Q₁₀) has been successfully processed into a dispersion of a supercooled melt. Droplet sizes in the lower nanometer range and shelf lives of more than 3 years can easily be achieved for Q₁₀ dispersions. The drug load of the emulsion particles reaches nearly 100%. Received: 15 July 1999/Accepted: 11 November 1999     

Encapsulation,protection, and release of hydrophilic active components: Potential and limitations of colloidal delivery systems

There have been major advances in the development of edible colloidal delivery systems for hydrophobic bioactives in recent years. However, there are still many challenges associated with the development of effective delivery systems for hydrophilic bioactives. This review highlights the major challenges associated with developing colloidal delivery systems for hydrophilic bioactive components that can be utilized in foods, pharmaceuticals, and other products intended for oral ingestion. Special emphasis is given to the fundamental physicochemical phenomena associated with encapsulation, stabilization, and release of these bioactive components, such as solubility, partitioning, barriers, and mass transport processes. Delivery systems suitable for encapsulating hydrophilic bioactive components are then reviewed, including liposomes, multiple emulsions, solid fat particles, multiple emulsions, biopolymer particles, cubosomes, and biologically-derived systems. The advantages and limitations of each of these delivery systems are highlighted. This information should facilitate the rational selection of the most appropriate colloidal delivery systems for particular applications in the food and other industries.     

Effect of oil soluble surfactant in emulsions stabilised by clay particles

Although surfactants and particles are often mixed together in emulsions, the contribution of each species to the stabilisation of the oil-water interface is poorly understood. We report the results of investigations into the formation of emulsions from solutions of surfactant in oil and aqueous suspensions of laponite. Depending on the salt concentration in the aqueous suspensions, the laponite dispersed as individual disc-shaped particles, 30 nm in diameter, or flocculated into aggregates tens of micrometres in diameter. At the concentrations studied, the flocculated particles alone stabilized oil-in-water emulsions. Synergistic interactions between the particles and octadecylamine at the oil-water interface reduced the average emulsion drop size, while antagonistic interactions with octadecanoic acid enhanced coalescence processes in the emulsions. The state of particle dispersion had dramatic effects on the emulsions formed. Measurements of the oil-water interfacial tension revealed the origins of the interactions between the surfactants and particles.     

Pickering emulsions with stimulable particles: from highly- to weakly-covered interfaces

We study oil-in-water emulsions stabilised by pH-sensitive colloidal silica or latex particles. Depending on the composition of the continuous phase, the same type of particles and the same emulsification process lead to emulsions characterised either by large drops densely covered by the particles, or to small droplets which are weakly covered. The two kinetically stable states can be tuned reversibly by using pH or salinity as compositional stimuli. We examine the emulsions' behaviour in these two limiting cases and we discuss the possible mechanisms allowing stabilisation, especially in the case of low surface coverage.     

Effect of dispersion pH on the formation and stability of Pickering emulsions stabilized by layered double hydroxides particles

Using positively charged plate-like layered double hydroxides (LDHs) particles as emulsifier, liquid paraffin-in-water emulsions stabilized solely by such particles are successfully prepared. The effects of the pH of LDHs aqueous dispersions on the formation and stability of the emulsions are investigated here. The properties of the LDHs dispersions at different pHs are described, including particle zeta potential, particle aggregation, particle contact angle, flow behavior of the dispersions and particle adsorption at a planar oil/water interface. The zeta potential decreases with increasing pH, leading to the aggregation of LDHs particles into large flocs. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions is enhanced by increasing pH and particle concentration. The three-phase contact angle of LDHs also increases with increasing pH, but the variation is very small. Visual observation and SEM images of the interfacial particle layers show that the adsorption behavior of LDHs particles at the planar oil/water interface is controlled by dispersion pH. We consider that the particle-particle (at the interface) and particle-interface electrostatic interactions are well controlled by adjusting the dispersion pH, leading to pH-tailored colloid adsorption. The formation of an adsorbed particle layer around the oil drops is crucial for the formation and stability of the emulsions. Emulsion stability improves with increasing pH and particle concentration because more particles are available to be adsorbed at the oil/water interface. The structural strength of LDHs dispersions and the gel-like structure of emulsions also influence the stability of the emulsions, but they are not necessary for the formation of emulsions. The emulsions cannot be demulsified by adjusting emulsion pH due to the irreversible adsorption of LDHs particles at the oil/water interface. TEM images of the emulsion drops show that a thick particle layer forms around the oil drops, confirming that Pickering emulsions are stabilized by the adsorbed particle layers. The thick adsorbed particle layer may be composed of a stable inner particle layer which is in direct contact with the oil phase and a relatively unstable outer particle layer surrounding the inner layer.     

Multiple pickering emulsions stabilized by microbowls

Some researchers have focused on the adsorption of solid particles at fluid-fluid interfaces and prepared emulsions and foams called "Pickering emulsions/foams". However, while several reports exist on simple spherical emulsions, few reports are available on the formation of more complex structures. Here, we show that holes on particle surfaces are a key factor in establishing the variety and complexity of mesoscale structures. Microbowls, which are hollow particles with holes on their surfaces, form multiple emulsions (water-in-oil-in-water and oil-in-water-in-oil emulsions) by simply mixing them with water and oil. Furthermore, stable potato-like or coffee-bean-like emulsions are also obtained, although nonspherical emulsions are usually unstable because of their larger interfacial energies. These findings are useful in designing the building blocks of complex supracolloidal systems for pharmaceutical, food, and cosmetic products.     

Analysis of dielectric relaxations of w/o emulsions in the light of theories of interfacial polarization

An attempt is made to apply dielectric theories of interfacial polarization to observations of dielectric relaxations for W/O emulsions. Approximate formulas for disperse systems in a W/O type were derived from the two theories: one proposed by Maxwell and Wagner for dilute disperse systems of spherical particles, and the other developed by Hanai for concentrated disperse systems. Dielectric measurements were carried out on concentrated W/O emulsions prepared from kerosene and distilled water or KCl aqueous solutions by minimal use of emulsifiers. Marked dielectric relaxations were observed with the emulsions, the dielectric parameters having been determined to characterize the relaxation data. Phase parameters such as relative permittivity, electric conductivity and volume fraction of the disperse phase were evaluated from the dielectric parameters by use of the approximate formulas of the respective theories. The phase parameters evaluated and the frequency dependence of complex permittivity of the W/O emulsions deduced from the theory for concentrated disperse systems are in excellent agreement with the observed data in comparison to that for dilute disperse systems. It is concluded that the dielectric relaxations due to the interfacial polarization of disperse systems of spheres are explained satisfactorily by the theory for concentrated disperse systems.     

Synergetic Effect of Reactive Surfactants and Clay Particles on Stabilization of Nonaqueous Oil-in-Oil (o/o) Emulsions

Although surfactants and particles are often used together in stabilization of aqueous emulsions, the contribution of each species to such stabilization at the oil-water interface is poorly understood. The situation becomes more complicated if we consider the nonaqueous oil-oil interface, i.e, the stabilization of nonaqueous oil-in-oil (o/o) emulsions by solid particles and reactive surfactants which, to our knowledge, has not been studied before. We have prepared Pickering nonaqueous simple (o/o) emulsions stabilized by a combination of kaolinite particles and a nonionic polymerizable surfactant Noigen RN10 (polyoxyethylene alkylphenyl ether). Different pairs of immiscible oils were used which gave different emulsion stabilities. Using kaolinite with equal volumes of paraffin oil/formamide system gave no stable emulsions at all concentrations while the addition of Noigen RN10 enhanced the emulsion stability. In contrast, addition of Noigen RN10 surfactant to silicon oil-in-glycerin emulsions stabilized by kaolinite resulted in destabilization of the system at all concentrations. For all systems studied here, no phase inversion in simple emulsion was observed by altering the volume fraction of the dispersed phase as compared to the known water-based simple Pickering emulsions.      

固体粒子稳定的乳状液研究进展

综述了固体粒子对乳状液稳定性影响的有关研究进展。微细不溶的固体粒子构成重要的一类乳化剂,被水相和油相部分润湿的固体粒子能够有效地稳定乳状液。固体粒子稳定乳状液的效果取决于以下因素:粒子大小、粒子间相互作用和粒子的润湿性质。固体粒子存在的油-水界面表现出粘弹行为,这种粘弹界面膜可大大地提高空间位阻,减缓乳状液液珠间液膜变薄的速率,从而提高乳状液地稳定性。原油中的粘土、胶质、沥青质和石蜡等胶体粒子被证明对乳状液的稳定性起很大的作用。     

Fabrication of a composite colloidal particle with unusual janus structure as a high-performance solid emulsifier

Core-shell particles with cross-linked core and shell were used as seed particles to produce composite Janus particles. It was found that when the shell has distinctly higher cross-linking degree than the core, Janus particles with very unusual structures can be obtained. These particles have two parts, with one part embraced partially or entirely by the other part, adjustable by parameters such as phase ratio or cross-linking degree. On the basis of experimental observations, a possible mechanism for the formation of such unusual Janus particles has been proposed. Janus particles with arms are used to emulsify water-toluene mixtures, forming oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions at very high internal phase content with rather low concentration of particles. Nonspherical emulsion droplets were observed, indicating that these Janus particles are likely to jam at the interface, forming a strong protecting layer to stabilize emulsions.     

Thermosensitive pickering emulsion stabilized by poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-carrying particles

Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM)-carrying particles were characterized as thermosensitive Pickering emulsifiers. Emulsions were prepared from various oils, such as heptane, hexadecane, trichloroethylene, and toluene, with PNIPAM-carrying particles. PNIPAM-carrying particles preferentially formed oil-in-water (O/W)-type emulsions with a variety of oils. All the emulsions stabilized by PNIPAM-carrying particles were stable for more than 3 months as long as they were stored at room temperature. However, when the emulsions were heated from room temperature to 40 degrees C, at which point the PNIPAM layer caused a coil-to-globule transition, phase separation occurred. Thus, by using thermosensitive PNIPAM-carrying particles as emulsifiers, the stability of the Pickering emulsions could be controlled by a slight change in temperature.     

Water-in-water (W/W) emulsions

Water-in-water (W/W) emulsions are colloidal dispersions of an aqueous solution into another aqueous phase. Such dispersions can be formed in mixtures of at least two hydrophilic macromolecules, which are thermodynamically incompatible in solution, generating two immiscible aqueous phases. W/W emulsions are much less known than conventional oil-in-water or water-in-oil emulsions, despite the fact that phase separation in aqueous mixtures is highly common. The thermodynamics and the phase behavior of segregative phase separation in mixtures of hydrophilic polymers have focused a great attention, with many excellent scientific reports in the literature. However, the kinetic stability of water-in-water emulsions is generally difficult to control, since amphiphilic molecules do not adsorb on water-water interfaces. Consequently, surfactants are not good stabilizers for W/W emulsions, and until recently, only a limited number of scientific studies have dealt with the formation and stabilization of emulsions in aqueous two-phase systems. Recent advances and successful results in the stabilization of these emulsions, by alternative mechanisms, have triggered a renewed interest. Nowadays, fast progress is being made in formation and stabilization methods, and new knowledge is rapidly acquired, opening a wide range of novel possibilities for practical applications. Interestingly, highly stable water-in-water emulsions can be formulated using fully biocompatible and edible components, and consequently, these emulsions can be used in food formulations, among many other interesting applications. This review describes the general background of research in the field, and focuses on recent scientific advances, including phase behavior, formation, stability and kinetic aspects, as well as applications such as formation of microgels, encapsulation and drug delivery.