Enrichment of low-abundant serum proteins by albumin/immunoglobulin G immunoaffinity depletion under partly denaturing conditions

We present a simple protocol for affinity depletion to remove the two most abundant serum proteins, albumin and immunoglobulin G (IgG). Under native conditions, albumin/IgG were efficiently removed and several proteins were enriched as shown by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Besides that, partly denaturing conditions were established by adding 5 or 20% acetonitrile (ACN) in order to disrupt the binding of low-molecular-weight (LMW) proteins to the carrier proteins albumin/IgG. 2-DE results showed that the total number of detected LMW proteins increased under denaturing conditions when compared to native conditions. Interestingly, the presence of 5% ACN in serum revealed better enrichment of LMW proteins when compared to 20% ACN condition. Seven randomly distributed spots in albumin/IgG depleted serum samples under 5% ACN condition were picked from the 2-DE gels and identified by mass spectrometry (MS). The intensity of five LMW protein spots increased under denaturing conditions when compared to native conditions. Three of the seven identified spots (serum amyloid P, vitamin D-binding protein, and transthyretin) belong to a group of relatively low-abundant proteins, which make up only 1% of all serum proteins. The method presented here improves the resolution of the serum proteome by increasing the number of visualized spots on 2-D gels and allowing the detection and MS identification of LMW proteins and proteins of lower abundance.     

New method for prefractionation of plasma for proteomic analysis

The depth of proteome analysis is severely limited in complex samples with a wide dynamic range of protein abundance such as plasma. Removal of high‐abundance proteins should reveal the signal of lower abundance plasma proteins. However, smaller proteins may be part of larger protein complexes and hence the removal of proteins involved in complexes with high‐abundance proteins such as albumin may inhibit the search for disease biomarkers. Prefractionation of a sample divides it into fractions of reduced complexity, allowing improved detection of lower abundance proteins. Using a prefractionation device, which employs Gradiflow? technology, we were able to separate small volume plasma samples into multiple fractions based on the molecular weight and/or charge. The resulting samples of reduced complexity were directly compatible with 2‐DE. The use of this prefractionation machine may therefore be useful in the hunt for disease biomarkers.     

High‐abundance protein depletion: Comparison of methods for human plasma biomarker discovery

Affinity depletion of abundant proteins from human plasma has become a routine sample preparation strategy in proteomics used prior to protein identification and quantitation. To date, there have been limited published studies comparing the performance of commercially available depletion products. We conducted a thorough evaluation of six depletion columns using 2‐DE combined with sophisticated image analysis software, examining the following criteria: (i) efficiency of high‐abundance protein depletion, (ii) non‐specific removal of other than the targeted proteins and (iii) total number of protein spots detected on the gels following depletion. From all the products investigated, the Seppro IgY system provided the best results. It displayed the greatest number of protein spots on the depleted plasma gels, minimal non‐specific binding and high efficiency of abundant protein removal. Nevertheless, the increase in the number of detected spots compared with the second best performing and cheaper multiple affinity removal column (MARC) was not shown to be statistically significant. The ProteoPrep spin column, considered to be the “deepest” depletion technique available at the time of conducting the study, surprisingly displayed significantly fewer spots on the flow‐through fraction gels compared with both the Seppro and the MARC. The spin column format and low plasma capacity were also found to be impractical for 2‐DE. To conclude, we succeeded in providing an overview of the depletion columns performances with regard to the three examined areas. Our study will serve as a reference to other scientists when deciding on the optimal product for their particular projects.     

Identification of candidate biomarkers in ovarian cancer serum by depletion of highly abundant proteins and differential in‐gel electrophoresis

Ovarian cancer is the fifth leading cause of cancer death for women in the US, yet survival rates are over 90% when it is diagnosed at an early stage, highlighting the need for biomarkers for early detection. To enhance the discovery of tumor‐specific proteins that could represent novel serum biomarkers for ovarian cancer, we depleted serum of highly abundant proteins which can mask the detection of proteins present in serum at low concentrations. Three commercial immunoaffinity columns were used in parallel to deplete the highly abundant proteins in serum from 60 patients with serous ovarian carcinoma and 60 non‐cancer controls. Medium and low abundance serum proteins from each serum pool were then evaluated by the quantitative proteomic technique of differential in‐gel electrophoresis. The number of protein spots that were elevated in ovarian cancer sera by at least twofold ranged from 36 to 248, depending upon the depletion and separation methods. From the 33 spots picked for MS analysis, nine different proteins were identified, including the novel candidate ovarian cancer biomarkers leucine‐rich α2 glycoprotein‐1 and ficolin 3. Western blotting validated the relative increases in serum protein levels for three of the proteins identified, demonstrating the utility of this approach for the identification of novel serum biomarkers for ovarian cancer.     

Selectivity of monolithic supports under overloading conditions and their use for separation of human plasma and isolation of low abundance proteins

Human serum albumin (HSA) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) represent over 75% of all proteins present in human plasma. These two proteins frequently interfere with detection, determination and purification of low abundance proteins that can be potential biomarkers and biomarker candidates for various diseases. Some low abundance plasma proteins such as clotting factors and inhibitors are also important therapeutic agents. In this paper, the characterization of ion-exchange monolithic supports under overloading conditions was performed by use of sample displacement chromatography (SDC). If these supports were used for separation of human plasma, the composition of bound and eluted proteins in both anion- and cation-exchange mode is dependent on column loading. Under overloading conditions, the weakly bound proteins such as HSA in anion-exchange and IgG in cation-exchange mode are displaced by stronger binding proteins, and this phenomenon was not dependent on column size. Consequently, small monolithic columns with a column volume of 100 and 200 μL are ideal supports for high-throughput screening in order to develop new methods for separation of complex mixtures, and for sample preparation in proteomic technology.     

A comparative analysis of human plasma and serum proteins by combining native PAGE,whole‐gel slicing and quantitative LC‐MS/MS: Utilizing native MS‐electropherograms in proteomic analysis for discovering structure and interaction‐correlated differences

MS identification has long been used for PAGE‐separated protein bands, but global and systematic quantitation utilizing MS after PAGE has remained rare and not been reported for native PAGE. Here we reported on a new method combining native PAGE, whole‐gel slicing and quantitative LC‐MS/MS, aiming at comparative analysis on not only abundance, but also structures and interactions of proteins. A pair of human plasma and serum samples were used as test samples and separated on a native PAGE gel. Six lanes of each sample were cut, each lane was further sliced into thirty‐five 1.1 mm × 1.1 mm squares and all the squares were subjected to standardized procedures of in‐gel digestion and quantitative LC‐MS/MS. The results comprised 958 data rows that each contained abundance values of a protein detected in one square in eleven gel lanes (one plasma lane excluded). The data were evaluated to have satisfactory reproducibility of assignment and quantitation. Totally 315 proteins were assigned, with each protein assigned in 1–28 squares. The abundance distributions in the plasma and serum gel lanes were reconstructed for each protein, named as “native MS‐electropherograms”. Comparison of the electropherograms revealed significant plasma‐versus‐serum differences on 33 proteins in 87 squares (fold difference > 2 or < 0.5, p < 0.05). Many of the differences matched with accumulated knowledge on protein interactions and proteolysis involved in blood coagulation, complement and wound healing processes. We expect this method would be useful to provide more comprehensive information in comparative proteomic analysis, on both quantities and structures/interactions.     

Equalizer technology followed by DIGE‐based proteomics for detection of cellular proteins in artificial peritoneal dialysis effluents

Peritoneal dialysis effluent (PDE) represents a rich pool of potential biomarkers for monitoring disease and therapy. Until now, proteomic studies have been hindered by the plasma‐like composition of the PDE. Beads covered with a peptide library are a promising approach to remove high abundant proteins and concentrate the sample in one step. In this study, a novel approach for proteomic biomarker identification in PDEs consisting of a depletion and concentration step followed by 2D gel based protein quantification was established. To prove this experimental concept a model system of artificial PDEs was established by spiking unused peritoneal dialysis (PD) fluids with cellular proteins reflecting control conditions or cell stress. Using this procedure, we were able to reduce the amount of high abundant plasma proteins and concentrate low abundant proteins while preserving changes in abundance of proteins with cellular origin. The alterations in abundance of the investigated marker for cell stress, the heat shock proteins, showed similar abundance profiles in the artificial PDE as in pure cell culture samples. Our results demonstrate the efficacy of this system in detecting subtle changes in cellular protein expression triggered by unphysiological stress stimuli typical in PD, which could serve as biomarkers. Further studies using patients’ PDE will be necessary to prove the concept in clinical PD and to assess whether this technique is also informative regarding enriching low abundant plasma derived protein biomarker in the PDE.     

Searching for serum tumor markers for colorectal cancer using a 2‐D DIGE approach

Identification of specific protein markers for colorectal cancer (CRC) could provide a basis for its early diagnosis and detection, as well as clues to the molecular mechanisms governing cancer progression. In the present study, 2‐D DIGE coupled with MS was used to screen for biomarker candidates in the serum proteome of ten human CRC samples and ten healthy control samples. After pooling identical amounts of serum proteins (based on total protein concentration), albumin/IgG was depleted under partially denaturing conditions. Subsequently, the serum samples were labeled with three different CyDyes, and separated by 2‐D DIGE. After analysis with the biological variation analysis module of the DeCyder software, only three spots were found to be significantly elevated in all patient groups (with ratios from 1.52 to 9.08), whereas five spots were significantly down‐regulated in patients (with ratios from ?1.23 to ?10.21) (t‐test; p<0.05). Finally, two potential biomarkers, Transaldolase 1 and thyroid receptor interactor, were chosen for validation and analysis by ELISA with the serum of 30 CRC patients and 30 healthy controls. The serum levels of the two proteins correlated well with the 2‐D DIGE results. Thus, 2‐D DIGE approaches show great promise for biomarker discovery in CRC.     

Selective enrichment and sensitive detection of peptide and protein biomarkers in human serum using polymeric reverse micelles and MALDI-MS

Reverse-micelle forming amphiphilic homopolymers with carboxylic acid and quaternary amine substituents are used to selectively enrich biomarker peptides and protein fragments from human serum prior to matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) analysis. After depletion of human serum albumin (HSA) and immunoglobulin G (IgG), low abundance peptide biomarkers can be selectively enriched and detected by MALDI-MS at clinically relevant concentrations by using the appropriate homopolymer(s) and extraction pH value(s). Three breast cancer peptide biomarkers, bradykinin, C4a, and ITIH(4), were chosen to test this new approach, and detection limits of 0.5 ng mL(-1), 0.08 ng mL(-1), and 0.2 ng mL(-1), respectively, were obtained. In addition, the amphiphilic homopolymers were used to detect prostate specific antigen (PSA) at concentrations as low as 0.5 ng mL(-1) by targeting a surrogate peptide fragment of this protein biomarker. Selective enrichment and sensitive MS detection of low abundance peptide/protein biomarkers by these polymeric reverse micelles should be a sensitive and straightforward approach for biomarker screening in human serum.     

Sample complexity reduction aids efficient detection of low‐abundant proteins from human amniotic fluid

Working with biological fluids poses a challenge of visualizing proteins present in lower concentrations. This study describes a batch‐mode chromatographic method for the fractionation of human amniotic fluid (AF). This method is easy to use with minimal sample quantity, resin volume and sample processing time. For albumin depletion, two methods were evaluated. The results demonstrated that specific depletion of albumin, using affinity‐ligand‐based resin, is more efficient than the conventional dye‐based method. The albumin‐depleted human AF was fractionated by strong anion‐exchange resin in spin devices, for sample, complexity reduction and enrichment of low‐abundant proteins. Analysis of four eluate fractions generated after this step shows enrichment of few low‐abundant proteins. Two novel low‐abundant proteins, Rab GDP dissociation inhibitor β and peptide methionine sulfoxide reductase, were identified from human AF. α‐1‐B Glycoprotein was successfully identified by this strategy, whereas the published literature reports that it was not identified by strong anion‐exchange FPLC followed by SDS‐PAGE. Therefore, the current method has distinct advantages over the conventional column‐based chromatography. This study also reports altered expression of some proteins in Rh‐isoimmunized AF samples in comparison with normal AF.     

Serum proteomic pattern in female stress urinary incontinence

The pathophysiology of Stress Urinary Incontinence (SUI) is poorly understood. The aim of this study was to identify the serum proteomic profile in patients with SUI and to replicate findings from a preceding study in which a significant difference in the urinary proteome was identified. Serum samples were collected from 38 patients (19 SUI; 19 matched, continent controls). Sample preparation included serum albumin depletion, in‐solution enzymatic digestion of proteins applying a combination of Gluc‐C and trypsin and peptide separation using nano High Performance Liquid Chromatography. Label‐free quantitation of peptides and proteins was performed after triplicate measurements using quadrupole time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry. Peptide identification was achieved by searching the Human SwissProt Database using Mascot and X!Tandem. Main outcome measure was the relative abundance of each detected protein in serum. Of 7012 identified proteins, 33 proteins were induced (detected in SUI, not in controls) and five proteins were depleted (detected in controls, not in SUI). All depleted proteins play a role in immune/DNA damage response. Induced proteins are involved in inflammatory response, response to cellular stress, coagulation and cytoskeleton stability/ motility. Plasma serine protease inhibitor (SERPINA5) was found induced and previously also showed a higher abundance in urine samples of SUI patients. Data are available via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD008553.     

Synthesis of magnetic dual‐template molecularly imprinted nanoparticles for the specific removal of two high‐abundance proteins simultaneously in blood plasma

Novel core–shell dual‐template molecularly imprinted superparamagnetic nanoparticles were synthesized using bovine hemoglobin and bovine serum albumin as the templates for the efficient depletion of these two high‐abundance proteins from blood plasma for the first time. The preparation process combined surface imprinting technique and a two‐step immobilized template strategy. The obtained polymers were fully characterized by transmission electron microscopy, X‐ray diffraction, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and vibrating sample magnetometry. The results showed that the as‐synthesized nanomaterials possessed homogeneous and thin imprinted shells with a thickness of about 5 nm, stable crystalline phase, and superparamagnetism. The binding performance of the imprinted polymers was investigated through a series of adsorption experiments, which indicated that the products had satisfactory recognition ability for bovine hemoglobin and bovine serum albumin. The resultant nanoparticles were also successfully applied to simultaneously selective removal of two proteins from a real bovine blood sample.     

A modified protein precipitation procedure for efficient removal of albumin from serum

Proteomic analysis of sera and the quest for identifying serum proteins as disease markers have often been hampered by the predominance of several highly abundant proteins including albumin and immunoglobulins. Prior albumin depletion so as to enrich for otherwise undetectable serum components is therefore a prerequisite in mining the serum proteome. In the course of evaluating several available methods and commercial kits, we have been able to refine the albumin depletion protocols and establish a modified albumin removal method using trichloroacetic acid (TCA)/acetone. Changes in major protein bands were monitored by one-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (1-D SDS-PAGE) and used as the first screening strategy to evaluate and optimize for the precipitation experimental conditions. Our method showed better performance in efficiency, specificity, and costs in comparison with two commercially available albumin removal kits, and provides a simple pre-fractionation step for the proteomic analysis of serum biomarkers. Albumin isolated by the modified method is in the native state. Our method may offer a rapid method for purifying serum albumin in large scale.     

Phospho‐l‐tyrosine‐agarose chromatography: Adsorption of human IgG and its proteolytic fragments

The behavior of human immunoglobulin G (IgG) and antigen‐binding fragment (Fab fragment) adsorption onto phospho‐l ‐tyrosine immobilized on agarose (P‐Tyr‐agarose) was evaluated by pseudoaffinity chromatography. The effects of buffer systems MES, MOPS, Bis–Tris, Tris–HCl and sodium phosphate (NaP) and pH on IgG adsorption were studied and high purity values were obtained (96%, based on ELISA analysis of albumin, transferrin and immunoglobulins A, G and M) when IgG was purified from human plasma diluted in 10 mmol L^?1 NaP buffer at pH 6.0. The capture of IgG by the P‐Tyr‐agarose was also promising, since 91% of the IgG was adsorbed when plasma was diluted in 25 mmol L^?1 MES buffer at pH 5.5, recommending its use for IgG depletion from human plasma under this condition. The experimental data on IgG adsorption kinetics were in agreement with the pseudo‐second‐order model. The adsorption isotherm data were well described by the Langmuir–Freundlich model with the value of parameter n being <1 (0.72), indicating negative cooperativity. Selectivity was achieved on P‐Tyr‐agarose from digested human IgG in HEPES 25 mmol L^?1 buffer at pH 7.0 where Fab fragments were obtained in eluted fractions without Fc fragments (but with uncleaved IgG) with 86.2% recovery.     

Humoral response against sialyl‐Lea glycosylated protein species in esophageal cancer: Insights for immunoproteomic studies

Esophageal cancers (ECs) show poor prognosis and decreased overall survival due to late diagnosis and ineffective therapeutics, urging the introduction of novel biomarkers to aid disease management. The levels of sialyl‐Lewis(a) antigen (sLe^a) are frequently increased in digestive tumours, which has been explored in serological non‐invasive prognostication (CA19‐9 test); however, with low sensitivity and specificity. Autoantibodies against cancer antigens are considered the next generation biomarkers, as they are present in circulation long before tumour‐associated proteins. Based on these observations we have mined the serum of EC patients (n = 7) for antibodies against sLe^a‐glycosylated protein species. All EC were positive for sLe^a, irrespectively of their histological nature but only two patients showed elevated CA19‐9. Moreover, IgG titers, with emphasis on IgG1, were elevated in EC patients in comparison to the control group. SLe^a‐glycoproteins were then extracted from tumours of patients with negative CA19‐9, isolated by immunoprecipitation and blotted with patients IgG. Autoantibodies against sLe^a‐glycosylated proteins were detected in all cases. Different SLe^a‐glycoproteins were observed for tumours of distinct histological natures, which now require identification and validation in larger patient sets. This preliminary data suggests that antoantibodies against sLe^a glycosylated proteins hold potential for non‐invasive diagnosis in CA19‐9 negative cases and sets the rational for future immunoproteomic studies envisaging highly specific EC biomarkers.     

Global mapping of rat plasma proteins with a native proteomic approach using nondenaturing micro 2DE and quantitative LC‐MS/MS

Plasma samples from adult male rats were separated by nondenaturing micro 2DE and a reference gel was selected, on which 136 CBB‐stained spots were numbered and subjected to in‐gel digestion and quantitative LC‐MS/MS. The analysis provided the assignment of 1–25 (average eight) non‐redundant proteins in each spot and totally 199 proteins were assigned in the 136 spots. About 40% of the proteins were detected in more than one spot and 15% in more than ten spots. We speculate this complexity arose from multiple causes, including protein heterogeneity, overlapping of protein locations and formation of protein complexes. Consequently, such results could not be appropriately presented as a conventional 2DE map, i.e. a list or a gel pattern with one or a few proteins annotated to each spot. Therefore, the LC‐MS/MS quantity data was used to reconstruct the gel distribution of each protein and a library containing 199 native protein maps was established for rat plasma. Since proteins that formed a complex would migrate together during the nondenaturing 2DE and thus show similar gel distributions, correlation analysis was attempted for similarity comparison between the maps. The protein pairs showing high correlation coefficients included some well‐known complexes, suggesting the promising application of native protein mapping for interaction analysis. With the importance of rat as the most commonly used laboratory animal in biomedical research, we expect this work would facilitate relevant studies by providing not only a reference library of rat plasma protein maps but a means for functional and interaction analysis.     

Combinatorial peptide ligand libraries: the conquest of the 'hidden proteome' advances at great strides

The combinatorial peptide ligand library (CPLL) is compared here with the immuno-depletion method for evaluating their respective abilities in digging deeper and deeper into the low-abundance proteome. A recent report suggested in fact that immuno-subtraction for biomarkers discovery in sera does not perform so well, since it results in a meagre 25% increase in identified proteins compared with unfractionated plasma, leaving little capacity to sample lower abundance proteins. On the contrary, CPLLs permit from 300 to 600% increments in detection abilities, as amply demonstrated in several reports. Moreover, when dealing with large sample volumes, an amplification factor of up to four orders of magnitude for trace proteins could be demonstrated, with 80% capture efficiencies even in large (up to 1?L) sample volumes. At present, the lower detection ability of CPLLs has been evaluated at 1?ng/mL (traces of casein additives in white wines).     

Enrichment of low molecular weight serum proteins using acetonitrile precipitation for mass spectrometry based proteomic analysis

A rapid acetonitrile (ACN)-based extraction method has been developed that reproducibly depletes high abundance and high molecular weight proteins from serum prior to mass spectrometric analysis. A nanoflow liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (nano-LC/MS/MS) multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) method for 57 high to medium abundance serum proteins was used to characterise the ACN-depleted fraction after tryptic digestion. Of the 57 targeted proteins 29 were detected and albumin, the most abundant protein in serum and plasma, was identified as the 20th most abundant protein in the extract. The combination of ACN depletion and one-dimensional nano-LC/MS/MS enabled the detection of the low abundance serum protein, insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I), which has a serum concentration in the region of 100 ng/mL. One-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analysis of the depleted serum showed no bands corresponding to proteins of molecular mass over 75 kDa after extraction, demonstrating the efficiency of the method for the depletion of high molecular weight proteins. Total protein analysis of the ACN extracts showed that approximately 99.6% of all protein is removed from the serum. The ACN-depletion strategy offers a viable alternative to the immunochemistry-based protein-depletion techniques commonly used for removing high abundance proteins from serum prior to MS-based proteomic analyses.     

High-resolution 2-DE for resolving proteins, protein adducts and complexes in plasma

A 2-DE system has been devised in which proteins are first separated in their native state followed by separation according to mass under denaturing conditions (Nat/SDS-PAGE). Hydrophilic properties of the gel and the presence of dihydroxybisacrylamide in the first dimension allowed a good resolution for high-molecular-weight proteins and maintained interactions. With this method 252 plasma spots have been resolved and 140 have been characterized by MS as isoforms of 60 proteins, a relevant part of which (12) were not detected by traditional 2-D gels or by other nondenaturing 2-D techniques. The list includes complement factors (C4d, C7), coagulation factors (coagulation factor II, fibrin beta), apolipoproteins (apolipoprotein B) and cell debris (vinculin, gelsolin, tropomyosin, dystrobrevin beta, fibrinectin I). Nat/SDS PAGE also allowed separation of nicked forms of albumin, Apo B100 and alpha2-macroglobulin and showed the presence of atypical albumin adducts corresponding to post-translational and oxidation products. Our system provides therefore new tools for resolving proteins, protein aggregates and complexes and amplifies the potentiality of traditional electrophoretic analysis.