Comparative Analysis of the Characteristics of the Vortex Wake behind a Flapping Wing Performing Oscillations of Different Types

The wake characteristics of a custom-designed airfoil performing pitching oscillations, heaving oscillations, and a combination of pitch and heave oscillations are compared in this study. The influence of flapping parameters are investigated at a constant Reynolds number Re\(_{c} = 2640\) and is presented for the Strouhal numbers based on the oscillation amplitude, St_A, varying in the \(0.1 \leqslant {\text{S}}{{{\text{t}}}_{A}} \leqslant 0.4\) range. The generation of vorticity above and below the airfoil depends on the airfoil’s initial direction of motion and remains the same for all types of flapping oscillations investigated. The evolution of the leading-edge and trailing-edge vortices is presented. The heaving oscillations of the airfoil are found to have a greater influence on the characteristics of the leading edge vortex. The wake behind the combined pitch-heave oscillations appears to be governed by pitching oscillations below \({\text{S}}{{{\text{t}}}_{A}} = 0.24\), whereas it is driven by heaving oscillations above \({\text{S}}{{{\text{t}}}_{A}} = 0.24\). The force computations indicate that the mere existence of the reverse von Kármán street is not sufficient to develop the thrust on the airfoil. The periodic component of velocity fluctuations significantly influences the wake characteristics. The anisotropic stress field developed around the airfoil due to the periodic fluctuations of the velocity is presented. The coherent structures developed in the wake are identified using the proper orthogonal decomposition and a qualitative comparison of the structures for different flapping oscillations is presented. The energy transfer from the flapping airfoil to the fluid for different flapping oscillations is highest for heaving oscillations followed by combined pitch-heave oscillations and pitching oscillations.