对“湍流通用物理方程”等两篇文章的意见

本文以均匀不可压情况为例,系统地分析“湍流通用物理方程”和“湍流通用物理方程的推导及讨论”等两篇文章所提出的理论,指出“第二种平均”(“第二次平均”)的系综不存在,“湍流力假设”和“有效湍流力假设”不成立,文章采用的封闭手断也不合理,因此所推得的“湍流通用物理方程”及其一维简化,即“规范方程”均不成立;文2]从这些方程出发,对湍流特性所作的一切分析都失去依据;文中还存在大量不应有的其他错误。

COMMENTS ON TWO PAPERS CONCERNING THE UNIVERSAL PHYSICAL EQUATION OF TURBULENCE AND ITS CANONICAL FORM

In this paper, the theory proposed in two papers of Gao Ge's entitled "The universal physical equation of turbulence" and "The derivation of the universal physical equation of turbulence and relevant discussion" is analysed systematically, particular attention being paid to the part for incompressible turbulence, a representative of Gao Ge's theory. It is shown that the ensemble for the second average in those papers does not exist, both the turbulence-force hypothesis and effective-turbulence-force hypothe...