A construction of two distinct canonical sets of lifts of Brauer characters of a p-solvable group

In 5], Navarro defines the set , where Q is a p-subgroup of a p-solvable group G, and shows that if δ is the trivial character of Q, then Irr(G|Q, δ) provides a set of canonical lifts of IBr_p(G), the irreducible Brauer characters with vertex Q. Previously, in 2], Isaacs defined a canonical set of lifts B_π(G) of I_π(G). Both of these results extend the Fong-Swan Theorem to π-separable groups, and both construct canonical sets of lifts of the generalized Brauer characters. It is known that in the case that 2∈π, or if |G| is odd, we have B_π(G) = Irr(G|Q, 1_Q). In this note we give a counterexample to show that this is not the case when . It is known that if and χ∈B_π(G), then the constituents of χ_N are in B_π (N). However, we use the same counterexample to show that if , and χ∈Irr(G|Q, 1_Q) is such that θ ∈Irr(N) and θ, χ _N] ≠ 0, then it is not necessarily the case that θ ∈Irr(N) inherits this property. Received: 17 October 2005