Distribution assumptions and risk constraints in portfolio optimization

Empirical distributions are often claimed to be superior to parametric distributions, yet to also increase the computational complexity and are therefore hard to apply in portfolio optimization. In this paper, we approach the portfolio optimization problem under constraints on the portfolios Value at Risk and Expected Tail Loss, respectively, under empirical distributions for the Standard and Poors 100 stocks. We apply a heuristic optimization method which has been found to overcome the restrictions of traditional optimization techniques. Our results indicate that empirical distributions might turn into a Pandoras Box: Though highly reliable for predicting the assets risks, employing these distributions in the optimization process might result in severe mis-estimations of the resulting portfolios actual risk. It is found that even a simple mean-variance approach can be superior despite its known specification errors.AMS Classification: G11, C61Dietmar G. Maringer: Im grateful to two anonymous referees, Peter Winker, Manfred Gilli, Berç Rustem, Erricos Kontoghiorghes, Alfred Lehar, Josef Zechner, Suresh Sundaresan, and conference participants at Aix-en-Provence, Limassol, and Sydney for valuable discussions and comments on earlier versions of this paper.