Snx[BPO4]1−x composites as negative electrodes for lithium ion cells: Comparison with amorphous SnB0.6P0.4O2.9 and effect of composition

A comparative study of two Sn-based composite materials as negative electrode for Li-ion accumulators is presented. The former SnB_0.6P_0.4O_2.9 obtained by in-situ dispersion of SnO in an oxide matrix is shown to be an amorphous tin composite oxide (ATCO). The latter Sn_0.72BPO₄]_0.28 obtained by ex-situ dispersion of Sn in a borophosphate matrix consists of Sn particles embedded in a crystalline BPO₄ matrix. The electrochemical responses of ATCO and Sn_0.72BPO₄]_0.28 composite in galvanostatic mode show reversible capacities of about 450 and 530 mAh g⁻¹, respectively, with different irreversible capacities (60% and 29%). Analysis of these composite materials by ¹¹⁹Sn Mössbauer spectroscopy in transmission (TMS) and emission (CEMS) modes confirms that ATCO is an amorphous Sn^II composite oxide and shows that in the case of Sn_0.72BPO₄]_0.28, the surface of the tin clusters is mainly formed by Sn^II in an amorphous interface whereas the bulk of the clusters is mainly formed by Sn⁰. The determination of the recoilless free fractions f (Lamb-Mössbauer factors) leads to the effective fraction of both Sn⁰ and Sn^II species in such composites. The influence of chemical composition and especially of the surface-to-bulk tin species ratio on the electrochemical behaviour has been analysed for several Sn_xBPO₄]_1−x composite materials (0.17<x<0.91). The cell using the compound Sn_0.72BPO₄]_0.28 as active material exhibits interesting electrochemical performances (reversible capacity of 500 mAh g⁻¹ at C/5 rate).