Comparison of polymer resolution in thermal field-flow fractionation and size-exclusion chromatography

A comparison of the resolving power of themal field-flow fractionation (thermal FFF) and size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) has been made by the experimental operation of a high-resolution system from each category. For the experimental systems used, the measured resolution for thermal FFF was found to be higher than that for SEC for three different binary polymer mixtures. Only for a single low-molecular-weight mixture falling outside the optimal operating range of thermal FFF did SEC show better resolution. The experimental resolution values were broken down into selectivity and column efficiency parameters. While selectivity was easily obtained, column efficiency required a correction for polydispersity effects. With the polydispersity correction made on the basis of thermal FFF data, true resolution values were calculated to replace the apparent or experimental resolution levels. Overall, the corrected resolution values showed that thermal FFF had a significant advantage over SEC. Prospects for future advances in these two techniques are discussed.