A CNDO-MO calculation of VCl4

The electronic structure of the tetrahedral molecule VCL₄ is investigated within the CNDO-MO approximations. The metal and ligand valence orbitals, 3d, 4s, 4p; and 3s, 3p; respectively, have been systematically varied in an attempt to minimize the total energy; “optimum” V 4s(χ₄ = 1.10) and 4p(d ³ p ²) orbitals have been established, but V 3d(d ⁿ ) and Cl(-δ) valence orbitals are only seen to favor lower energy for expanded orbitals. Since determining the one-electron molecular orbital level which is occupied by the vanadium lone electron is a major aspect of this investigation, all calculations have been performed in triplicate: calculations assuming the unpaired electron occupies the 3a ₁, 2 _e and 4t ₂ molecular orbital (ground state electronic configurations² A ₁,² E, and² T ₂, respectively). The Hartree-Fock equations have been solved by Roothaan's SCF method for open shells, but off-diagonal multipliers between filled and partly filled molecular orbitals of the same symmetry have been neglected. As a qualitative estimate of the error introduced by this simplification, the pertinent overlap integrals between the eigenfunctions from calculations for the three possible configurations,² A ₁,² E, and² T ₂, are investigated as functions of the component 3d(d ⁿ ) and Cl(-δ) valence orbitals. The overlap integrals from the relevant² A ₁ and² T ₂ calculations are reasonably small, but the neglect of off-diagonal multipliers in calculations on the² E state is found to be a poor approximation. An ordering of the non-filled molecular orbitals in VCl₄ of 4t ₂ < 3a ₁ < 2e < 5t ₂ seems most consistent with the numerous calculations. This suggested ground state electronic configuration of² T ₂ introduces new aspects to the consideration of a (dynamic) Jahn-Teller effect in VCl₄. Experimental data pertinent to the electronic structure of VCl₄ has been briefly summarized, but unfortunately it is inadequate to confirm or deny the present calculations.