Protonated ethanol and its neutral counterparts

Collisionally activated dissociation and neutralization-reionization experiments reveal that protonation of ethanol leads to two distinct isomers, the classical ion CH₃CH₂OH⁺₂ and the proton-bound complex C₂H₄…H⁺…OH₂. The neutral counterpart of the latter is unstable, whereas that of the former can be produced in a bound state if the CH₃CH₂OH⁺₂ precursor ion is formed under low ion source pressure conditions and, thus, with higher internal energies. This suggests that there are substantial differences in the geometries of CH₃CH₂OH⁺₂ and the hypervalent CH₃CH₂OH₂ ·. This provides only a partial explanation for unusual isotope effects; C₂H₅OD₂ ·, CH₃CD₂OD₂ ·, and CD₃CH₂OD₂ · are substantially more stable than C₂D₅OD₂ · and C₂H₅OH₂ ·.