Phase quantization of chaos in the semiclassical regime

Since the early stage of the study of Hamilton chaos, semiclassical quantization based on the low-order Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin theory, the primitive semiclassical approximation to the Feynman path integrals (or the so-called Van Vleck propagator), and their variants have been suffering from difficulties such as divergence in the correlation function, nonconvergence in the trace formula, and so on. These difficulties have been hampering the progress of quantum chaos, and it is widely recognized that the essential drawback of these semiclassical theories commonly originates from the erroneous feature of the amplitude factors in their applications to classically chaotic systems. This forms a clear contrast to the success of the Einstein-Brillouin-Keller quantization condition for regular (integrable) systems. We show here that energy quantization of chaos in semiclassical regime is, in principle, possible in terms of constructive and destructive interference of phases alone, and the role of the semiclassical amplitude factor is indeed negligibly small, as long as it is not highly oscillatory. To do so, we first sketch the mechanism of semiclassical quantization of energy spectrum with the Fourier analysis of phase interference in a time correlation function, from which the amplitude factor is practically factored out due to its slowly varying nature. In this argument there is no distinction between integrability and nonintegrability of classical dynamics. Then we present numerical evidence that chaos can be indeed quantized by means of amplitude-free quasicorrelation functions and Heller's frozen Gaussian method. This is called phase quantization. Finally, we revisit the work of Yamashita and Takatsuka [Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 161, 56 (2007)] who have shown explicitly that the semiclassical spectrum is quite insensitive to smooth modification (rescaling) of the amplitude factor. At the same time, we note that the phase quantization naturally breaks down when the oscillatory nature of the amplitude factor is comparable to that of the phases. Such a case generally appears when the Planck constant of a large magnitude pushes the dynamics out of the semiclassical regime.