Evaluation of finite-plasticity theories for torsion-tension members made of tresca materials

Finite-incremental Tresca and von Mises theories are developed for solid circular-section torsion-tension members subjected to proportionate and nonproportionate loading. The materials are assumed to be isotropic and even. Two Tresca theories and a von Mises theory are compared with test data obtained from torsion-tension members. Three different kinds of steels were tested; they are hot-rolled mild steel, annealed mild steel, and hot-rolled SAE 1017 steel. The fully plastic values of axial load and torque predicted by the Tresca theories agree with the experimental results; however, the deformations, in the strain-hardening region, predicted by both of the Tresca theories were greater than observed. The von Mises theory is nonconservative in predicting the fully plastic loads of torsion members and torsion-tension members and in predicting the deformations of torsion members in the strain-hardening region, but gives good correlation between predicted and experimental deformations for the torsion-tension members in the strain-hardening region.