Reply to the Comment on “Realization of Lewis Basic Sodium Anion in the NaBH3− Cluster”

We reply to the comment by S. Pan and G. Frenking who challenged our interpretation of the Na^?:→BH₃ dative bond in the recently synthesized NaBH₃^? cluster. Our conclusion remains the same as that in our original paper ( https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201907089 and https://doi.org/10.1002/ange.201907089 ). This conclusion is additionally supported by the energetic pathways and NBO charges calculated at UCCSD and CASMP2(4,4) levels of theory. We also discussed the suitability of the Laplacian of electron density (QTAIM) and Adaptive Natural Density Partitioning (AdNDP) method for bond type assignment. It seems that AdNDP yields more sensible results. This discussion reveals that the complex realm of bonding is full of semantic inconsistencies, and we invite experimentalists and theoreticians to elaborate this topic and find solutions incorporating different views on the dative bond.     

Reply to the Comment on “Realization of Lewis Basic Sodium Anion in the NaBH3− Cluster”

We reply to the comment by S. Pan and G. Frenking who challenged our interpretation of the Na⁻:→BH₃ dative bond in the recently synthesized NaBH₃⁻ cluster. Our conclusion remains the same as that in our original paper ( https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201907089 and https://doi.org/10.1002/ange.201907089 ). This conclusion is additionally supported by the energetic pathways and NBO charges calculated at UCCSD and CASMP2(4,4) levels of theory. We also discussed the suitability of the Laplacian of electron density (QTAIM) and Adaptive Natural Density Partitioning (AdNDP) method for bond type assignment. It seems that AdNDP yields more sensible results. This discussion reveals that the complex realm of bonding is full of semantic inconsistencies, and we invite experimentalists and theoreticians to elaborate this topic and find solutions incorporating different views on the dative bond.     

Chalcogen Bonding Ion-Pair Cryptand Host Discrimination of Potassium Halide Salts

A series of chalcogen, halogen and hydrogen bonding heteroditopic macrobicyclic cryptands are reported and their potassium halide ion-pair recognition properties investigated. Saliently, the co-bound potassium cation was determined to be crucial in switching on the bromide and iodide recognition properties of the respective cryptand receptor. Importantly, the nature of the sigma-hole mediated interaction employed in the anion recognition component is demonstrated to significantly augment the ion-pair binding behaviour, markedly so for the halogen bonding analogue. Most notably the incorporation of a chelating chalcogen bonding donor motif significantly improves the selectivity towards KBr over KI, relative to halogen and hydrogen bonding analogues.     

Realization of Lewis Basic Sodium Anion in the NaBH3− Cluster

We report a Na:^?→B dative bond in the NaBH₃^? cluster, which was designed on the principle of minimum‐energy rupture, prepared by laser vaporization, and characterized by a synergy of anion photoelectron spectroscopy and electronic structure calculations. The global minimum of NaBH₃^? features a Na?B bond. Its preferred heterolytic dissociation conforms with the IUPAC definition of dative bond. The lone electron pair revealed on Na and the negative Laplacian of electron density at the bond critical point further confirm the dative nature of the Na?B bond. This study represents the first example of a Lewis adduct with an alkalide as the Lewis base.