Assessing the integrity of designed homomeric parallel three-stranded coiled coils in the presence of metal ions

De novo design of alpha-helical peptides that self-assemble to form helical coiled coils is a powerful tool for studying molecular recognition between peptides/proteins and determining the fundamental forces involved in their folding and structure. These amphipathic helices assemble in aqueous solution to generate the final coiled coil motif, with the hydrophobic residues in the interior and the polar/hydrophilic groups on the exterior. Considerable effort has been devoted to investigate the forces that determine the overall stability and final three-dimensional structure of the coiled coils. One of the major challenges in coiled coil design is the achievement of specificity in terms of the oligomeric state, with respect to number (two, three, four, or higher), nature (homomers vs heteromers), and strand orientation (parallel vs antiparallel). As seen in nature, metal ions play an important role in this self-organization process, and the overall structure of metalloproteins is primarily the result of two driving forces: the metal coordination preference and the fold of the polypeptide backbone. Previous work in our group has shown that metal ions such as As(III) and Hg(II) can be used to enforce different aggregation states in the Cys derivatives of the designed homotrimeric coiled-coil TRI family [Ac-G(LKALEEK)4G-CONH2]. We are now interested in studying the interplay between the metal ion and peptide preferences in controlling the specificity and relative orientation of the alpha-helices in coiled coils. For this objective, two derivatives of the TRI family, TRi L2WL9C and TRi L2WL23C, have been synthesized. Along with those two peptides, two derivatives of Coil-Ser, CSL9C and CSL19C (CS = Ac-EWEALEKKLAALESKLQALEKKLEALEHG-CONH2), a similar de novo designed three-stranded coiled coil that has the potential to form antiparallel coiled coils, have also been used. Circular dichroism, UV-vis, and 199Hg and 113Cd NMR spectroscopy results reveal that the addition of Hg(II) and Cd(II) to the different mixtures of these peptides forms preferentially homotrimeric coiled coils, over a statistical population of heterotrimeric parallel and antiparallel coiled coils.     

A heterospecific leucine zipper tetramer

Protein-protein interactions play an essential role in the assembly of the macromolecular complexes that form functional networks and control cellular behavior. Elucidating principles of molecular recognition governing potentially complex interfaces is a challenging goal for structural and systems biology. Extensive studies of alpha-helical coiled coils have provided fundamental insight into the determinants of one seemingly tractable class of oligomeric protein interfaces. We report here that two different valine-containing mutants of the GCN4 leucine zipper that fold individually as four-stranded coiled coils associate preferentially in mixtures to form an antiparallel, heterotetrameric structure. X-ray crystallographic analysis reveals that the coinciding hydrophobic interfaces of the hetero- and homotetramers differ in detail, thereby controlling their partnering and structural specificity. Equilibrium disulfide exchange and thermal denaturation experiments show that the 50-fold preference for heterospecificity is determined by interfacial van der Waals interactions and hydrophobicity. Parallel studies of two alanine-containing variants confirm the above-mentioned interpretation of the basis and mechanism of this heterospecificity. Our results suggest that coiled-coil recognition is an inherently geometric process in which heterotypic interaction specificity derives from a complementarity of both shape and chemistry.     

Highly anisotropic stability and folding kinetics of a single coiled coil protein under mechanical tension

Coiled coils are one of the most abundant protein structural motifs and widely mediate protein interactions and force transduction or sensation. They are thus model systems for protein engineering and folding studies, particularly the GCN4 coiled coil. Major single-molecule methods have also been applied to this protein and revealed its folding kinetics at various spatiotemporal scales. Nevertheless, the folding energy and the kinetics of a single GCN4 coiled coil domain have not been well determined at a single-molecule level. Here we used high-resolution optical tweezers to characterize the folding and unfolding reactions of a single GCN4 coiled coil domain and their dependence on the pulling direction. In one axial and two transverse pulling directions, we observed reversible, two-state transitions of the coiled coil in real time. The transitions equilibrate at pulling forces ranging from 6 to 12 pN, showing different stabilities of the coiled coil in regard to pulling direction. Furthermore, the transition rates vary with both the magnitude and the direction of the pulling force by greater than 1000 folds, indicating a highly anisotropic and topology-dependent energy landscape for protein transitions under mechanical tension. We developed a new analytical theory to extract energy and kinetics of the protein transition at zero force. The derived folding energy does not depend on the pulling direction and is consistent with the measurement in bulk, which further confirms the applicability of the single-molecule manipulation approach for energy measurement. The highly anisotropic thermodynamics of proteins under tension should play important roles in their biological functions.     

Design and characterization of a homodimeric antiparallel coiled coil

We report the first successful design of a self-associating antiparallel coiled coil, APH. The simultaneous application of Coulombic and hydrophobic components results in a decided preference for the antiparallel alignment as judged by HPLC, sedimentation equilibrium, and chemical denaturation data. The designed peptide is of comparable stability to naturally occurring leucine zipper peptides and can be expressed in bacteria. These properties of APH suggest potential in vivo protein fusion and biomaterials applications.     

The d'--d--d' vertical triad is less discriminating than the a'--a--a' vertical triad in the antiparallel coiled-coil dimer motif

Elucidating relationships between the amino-acid sequences of proteins and their three-dimensional structures, and uncovering non-covalent interactions that underlie polypeptide folding, are major goals in protein science. One approach toward these goals is to study interactions between selected residues, or among constellations of residues, in small folding motifs. The α-helical coiled coil has served as a platform for such studies because this folding unit is relatively simple in terms of both sequence and structure. Amino acid side chains at the helix-helix interface of a coiled coil participate in so-called "knobs-into-holes" (KIH) packing whereby a side chain (the knob) on one helix inserts into a space (the hole) generated by four side chains on a partner helix. The vast majority of sequence-stability studies on coiled-coil dimers have focused on lateral interactions within these KIH arrangements, for example, between an a position on one helix and an a' position of the partner in a parallel coiled-coil dimer, or between a--d' pairs in an antiparallel dimer. More recently, it has been shown that vertical triads (specifically, a'--a--a' triads) in antiparallel dimers exert a significant impact on pairing preferences. This observation provides impetus for analysis of other complex networks of side-chain interactions at the helix-helix interface. Here, we describe a combination of experimental and bioinformatics studies that show that d'--d--d' triads have much less impact on pairing preference than do a'--a--a' triads in a small, designed antiparallel coiled-coil dimer. However, the influence of the d'--d--d' triad depends on the lateral a'--d interaction. Taken together, these results strengthen the emerging understanding that simple pairwise interactions are not sufficient to describe side-chain interactions and overall stability in antiparallel coiled-coil dimers; higher-order interactions must be considered as well.     

Design of a functional protein for molecular recognition: specificity of ligand binding in a metal-assembled protein cavity probed by 19f NMR

A metal-assembled homotrimeric coiled coil based on the GCN4-p1 sequence has been designed that noncovalently binds hexafluorobenzene and other similar ligands in a hydrophobic cavity, created by making the core substitution Asn16Ala ([Fe(bpyGCN4-N16A)3]2+). The KD of binding of hexafluorobenzene with [Fe(bpyGCN4-N16A)3]2+ was observed to be 1.1(9) x 10(-4) M by diffusion NMR experiments. A control coiled coil with the core substitution Asn16Val ([Fe(bpyGCN4-N16V)3]2+) exhibited a significantly weaker association with hexafluorobenzene, providing evidence that even in the absence of structural data, benzene-like ligands bind in the cavity created by the Asn16Ala substitution. 19F NMR was employed to observe hexafluorobenzene binding and to monitor titrations with competing hydrophobic and polar ligands similar in size and shape to hexafluorobenzene. All hydrophobic ligands bound with greater affinity than the polar ligands in the hydrophobic core, although the cavity seems to be somewhat flexible in terms of the sizes of molecules it can accommodate. Thus 19F NMR has proved to be a useful spectral tool to probe molecular recognition in a hydrophobic cavity of a metal-assembled coiled coil.     

Design and application of basic amino acids displaying enhanced hydrophobicity

Three noncoding basic amino acids, mono-, di-, and trimethyldiaminopropionic acid (mmdap, dmdap, and tmdap), have been synthesized for use in protein design. Covalent modification of a diaminopropionic acid (dap) side chain with an increasing number of methyl moieties results in a family of residues displaying short basic side chains with varying degrees of enhanced hydrophobic character. These residues may be used to introduce charged/polar interactions into the confining hydrophobic interior or interfacial spaces of proteins. As a demonstration of their utility, the ability of these residues to promote interior salt bridge formation at the helix/helix interface of GCN4-p1, a dimeric two-stranded coiled coil, was assessed. Heterodimerization mediated by buried salt bridge formation between a GCN4-based peptide containing either mmdap, dmdap, or tmdap at position 16 and an analogous peptide containing aspartic acid at the same position was studied. Mmdap-derived heterodimers are 0.5 kcal/mol more stable than the corresponding dap-derived heterodimers. This result indicates that the addition of one methyl group to the dap side chain can stabilize the heterodimeric fold. The stabilization can most likely be attributed to a decrease in the desolvation penalty incurred upon folding as well as enhanced van der Waals contacts in the folded state. The addition of three methyl groups to the dap side chain results in heterodimers that are significantly less stable than the corresponding dap-derived heterodimers, suggesting that increased steric bulk is not well accommodated in the interior of this protein. Unexpectedly, the addition of two methyl groups leads to homotrimerization of the dmdap-peptide. The resulting trimer is relatively stable (DeltaG(37)( degrees )(C) degrees = 11.8 kcal/mol) and undergoes cooperative thermal unfolding. The GCN4-p1 system exemplifies how small incremental changes in size and hydrophobicity can alter the folding preferences of a protein. Generally, this versatile suite of residues can be utilized in any protein and offer new options to the protein chemist.     

Orthogonal recognition in dimeric coiled coils via buried polar-group modulation

We describe the design and exploration of new buried polar groups to control coiled-coil dimerization. Employing our recently described method for on-resin guanidinylation, we have prepared coiled-coil peptides with a single core guanidine, spaced from the backbone by 1-3 methylene groups. Heterodimeric mixtures of these sequences with guanidine, amide, and carboxylic acid binding partners form a large number of reasonably stable coiled coils (T(m) > or = 60 degrees C). A detailed stability trend examination reveals that asparagine/acid pairs are sharply sensitive to acid residue chain length (Asn/Asp much worse than Asn/Glu), while guanidine/acid pairs are largely insensitive. This has been exploited to create orthogonal recognition pairs which establish the capacity to form two distinct heterodimeric coiled coils by simple mixing of four different peptides. One dimer has buried core asparagines, while the other pairs aspartic acid with any of three guanidinylated side chains. Specificity of this behavior is underscored by failure of glutamic acid substituted sequences to perform accordingly. The successful alternate pairs are further characterized by various biophysical methods (circular dichroism, ultracentrifugation, thermal and chemical denaturation, affinity tags).     

Conformational stability of helical peptides containing a thioamide linkage

[structure: see text] Thioxo peptide analogues of the alpha-helical peptide GCN4-p1 were synthesized and evaluated for helicity and oligomeric state. Sedimentation equilibrium and CD measurements indicate that the thioxo peptides fold into parallel alpha-helical coiled coil structures essentially identical to the native structure. This work marks the first incorporation of a thioamide linkage into the backbone of an alpha-helix and demonstrates that a thioamide linkage is compatible with positions within the helix as well as near the C-terminus.     

Simultaneous directed assembly of three distinct heterodimeric coiled coils

We describe simultaneous formation of three distinct heterodimeric coiled coils from a mixture of six different peptides. The choice among electrostatically viable complexes is governed by alignment of buried core residues, including a fundamentally new interaction that exploits urea-terminated side chains. Buried urea/urea contacts lead to extremely stable dimeric coiled coils, with T(m) values between 63 and 79 degrees C. Core ureas can also form stable complexes with a variety of other polar groups, including guanidines, acids, and amides.     

Oxime Side‐Chain Cross‐Links in an α‐Helical Coiled‐Coil Protein: Structure,Thermodynamics, and Folding‐Templated Synthesis of Bicyclic Species

Covalent side‐chain cross‐links are a versatile method to control peptide folding, particularly when α‐helical secondary structure is the target. Here, we examine the application of oxime bridges, formed by the chemoselective reaction between aminooxy and aldehyde side chains, for the stabilization of a helical peptide involved in a protein–protein complex. A series of sequence variants of the dimeric coiled coil GCN4‐p1 bearing oxime bridges at solvent‐exposed positions were prepared and biophysically characterized. Triggered unmasking of a side‐chain aldehyde in situ and subsequent cyclization proceed rapidly and cleanly at pH 7 in the folded protein complex. Comparison of folding thermodynamics among a series of different oxime bridges show that the cross links are consistently stabilizing to the coiled coil, with the extent of stabilization sensitive to the exact size and structure of the macrocycle. X‐ray crystallographic analysis of a coiled coil with the best cross link in place and a second structure of its linear precursor show how the bridge is accommodated into an α‐helix. Preparation of a bicyclic oligomer by simultaneous formation of two linkages in situ demonstrates the potential use of triggered oxime formation to both trap and stabilize a particular peptide folded conformation in the bound state.     

Self-assembly of peptide porphyrin complexes: toward the development of smart biomaterials

The anionic porphyrin, meso-tetrakis(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphine, is found to tightly bind to an engineered 14-residue peptide, resulting in induced alpha-helix formation when mixed in aqueous solutions. The small porphyrin-peptide dissociation constant (2 muM) observed is related to the energetics of peptide helix formation coupled with electrostatic interactions between the anionic porphyrin and cationic residues in the coiled peptide. Analytical ultracentrifugation measurements indicate the porphyrin-peptide complexes dimerize, probably into a coiled coil, and weakly associate to form even higher order structures.     

De novo design of fibrils made of short alpha-helical coiled coil peptides.

BACKGROUND: The alpha-helical coiled coil structures formed by 25-50 residues long peptides are recognized as one of Nature's favorite ways of creating an oligomerization motif. Known de novo designed and natural coiled coils use the lateral dimension for oligomerization but not the axial one. Previous attempts to design alpha-helical peptides with a potential for axial growth led to fibrous aggregates which have an unexpectedly big and irregular thickness. These facts encouraged us to design a coiled coil peptide which self-assembles into soluble oligomers with a fixed lateral dimension and whose alpha-helices associate in a staggered manner and trigger axial growth of the coiled coil. Designing the coiled coil with a large number of subunits, we also pursue the practical goal of obtaining a valuable scaffold for the construction of multivalent fusion proteins. RESULTS: The designed 34-residue peptide self-assembles into long fibrils at slightly acid pH and into spherical aggregates at neutral pH. The fibrillogenesis is completely reversible upon pH change. The fibrils were characterized using circular dichroism spectroscopy, sedimentation diffusion, electron microscopy, differential scanning calorimetry and X-ray fiber diffraction. The peptide was deliberately engineered to adopt the structure of a five-stranded coiled coil rope with adjacent alpha-helices, staggered along the fibril axis. As shown experimentally, the most likely structure matches the predicted five-stranded arrangement. CONCLUSIONS: The fact that the peptide assembles in an expected fibril arrangement demonstrates the credibility of our conception of design. The discovery of a short peptide with fibril-forming ability and stimulus-sensitive behavior opens new opportunities for a number of applications.     

Activating an enzyme by an engineered coiled coil switch

We designed a de novo protein based on a circular permutant of RNaseT1, in which the enzymatic activity can be manipulated by engineered peptide binding. The circular permutant of RNaseT1 was obtained by tethering the original C- and N-termini with a GPAG linker and cleaving the molecule between Glu82 and Asn83. This mutant lacked enzymatic activity, due to the destabilization of entire protein structure. We previously reported the construction of ABC-type heterotrimeric coiled coil peptides, in which the A- and B-type peptides cannot form the folded trimeric structure without the C-type peptide. The introduction of the A- and B-type coiled coil peptides to the C- and N-termini of the circular permutant of RNaseT1, respectively, and the subsequent addition of the C-type coiled coil peptide enabled the RNaseT1 domain to refold properly, thus, restoring the enzymatic activity. The formation of the trimeric coiled coil structure should bring the cleaved sites of RNaseT1 close enough to refold the RNaseT1 domain spontaneously.     

Kinetics of helix-coil transition in all sizes of polypeptides.

The relaxation behavior of the helix-coil transition has been investigated for all sizes of polypeptides. Unlike previously reported results, regardless of the size of polypeptides, the first-order kinetics plays a principal role in the relaxation process when a helical state is relaxed to a half-coiled state [i.e. s(f) is congruent to 1, where s(f) is the helix stability parameter at the final state]. On the other hand, when a helical state is relaxed to a coiled state [i.e., s(f) is less than 1], the zeroth-order kinetics plays a major role. In addition, the range of the validity of a kinetic version of the zipper model has been investigated. We have found that when a helical state is relaxed to a state where s(f) is less than or equal to 1, the zipper model is valid for polypeptides with chain length N satisfying the relation N is less than 1/(sigmagammaC)1/2 where sigma is the cooperativity parameter and gammaC is the coil nucleation rate parameter.     

An Antibody with a Variable‐Region Coiled‐Coil “Knob” Domain

The X‐ray crystal structure of a bovine antibody (BLV1H12) revealed a unique structure in its ultralong heavy chain complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3H) that folds into a solvent‐exposed β‐strand “stalk” fused to a disulfide crosslinked “knob” domain. We have substituted an antiparallel heterodimeric coiled‐coil motif for the β‐strand stalk in this antibody. The resulting antibody (Ab‐coil) expresses in mammalian cells and has a stability similar to that of the parent bovine antibody. MS analysis of H–D exchange supports the coiled‐coil structure of the substituted peptides. Substitution of the knob‐domain of Ab‐coil with bovine granulocyte colony‐stimulating factor (bGCSF) results in a stably expressed chimeric antibody, which proliferates mouse NFS‐60 cells with a potency comparable to that of bGCSF. This work demonstrates the utility of this novel coiled‐coil CDR3 motif as a means for generating stable, potent antibody fusion proteins with useful pharmacological properties.     

Advanced approaches for the characterization of a de novo designed antiparallel coiled coil peptide

We report here an advanced approach for the characterization of the folding pattern of a de novo designed antiparallel coiled coil peptide by high-resolution methods. Incorporation of two fluorescence labels at the C- and N-terminus of the peptide chain as well as modification of two hydrophobic core positions by Phe/[15N,13C]Leu enable the study of the folding characteristics and of distinct amino acid side chain interactions by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and NMR spectroscopy. Results of both experiments reveal the antiparallel alignment of the helices and thus prove the design concept. This finding is also supported by molecular dynamics simulations. Electrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (ESI-FTICR-MS) in combination with NMR experiments was used for verification of the oligomerization equilibria of the coiled coil peptide.