Model cell membranes: Techniques to form complex biomimetic supported lipid bilayers via vesicle fusion

Vesicle fusion has long provided an easy and reliable method to form supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) from simple, zwitterionic vesicles on siliceous substrates. However, for complex compositions, such as vesicles with high cholesterol content and multiple lipid types, the energy barrier for the vesicle-to-bilayer transition is increased or the required vesicle–vesicle and vesicle–substrate interactions are insufficient for vesicle fusion. Thus, for vesicle compositions that more accurately mimic native membranes, vesicle fusion often fails to form SLBs. In this paper, we review three approaches to overcome these barriers to form complex, biomimetic SLBs via vesicle fusion: (i) optimization of experimental conditions (e.g., temperature, buffer ionic strength, osmotic stress, cation valency, and buffer pH), (ii) α-helical (AH) peptide-induced vesicle fusion, and (iii) bilayer edge-induced vesicle fusion. AH peptide-induced vesicle fusion can form complex SLBs on multiple substrate types without the use of additional equipment. Bilayer edge-induced vesicle fusion uses microfluidics to form SLBs from vesicles with complex composition, including vesicles derived from native cell membranes. Collectively, this review introduces vesicle fusion techniques that can be generalized for many biomimetic vesicle compositions and many substrate types, and thus will aid efforts to reliably create complex SLB platforms on a range of substrates.     

In situ photopolymerization of a polymerizable poly(ethylene glycol)-covered phospholipid monolayer on a methacryloyl-terminated substrate

We have prepared a chemically anchored monolayer of PEG (poly(ethylene glycol)) and phospholipid mixture (PEG/phospholipid) on a methacryloyl-terminated substrate by in situ photopolymerization. Both monoacryloyl phospholipid (acryloyl-PC, 1-palmitoyl-2-[12-(acryloyloxy)dodecanoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) and monoacryloyl PEG (acryloyl-PEG, 12-(acryloyloxy)dodecanoyl-PEG) were synthesized by modifyingphospholipid and PEGwith 12-(acryloyloxy)-1-dodecanoic acid and 12-(acryloyloxy)-1-dodecanol, respectively. The surface pressure-area (pi-A) isotherm showed that acryloyl-PEG molecules were stable in the phospholipid monolayer and that they could be evenly inserted into a phospholipid monolayer at the air/water interface. By adding 10 mol % acryloyl-PEG into phosholipid vesicles, we could produce a PEG/phosholipid monolayer on methacryloyl-terminated substrates using vesicle fusion for 3 h. Then, this polymerizable PEG/phospholipid monolayer was in situ photopolymerized onto a methacryloyl-terminated substrate with eosin Y/triethanolamine as co-initiators. Optimal vesicle fusion and irradiation condition were determined with respect to the vesicle fusion time and duration of irradiation. As confirmed by atomic force microscopy and X-ray reflectivity studies, the polymerized PEG/phosholipid surface formed a PEG-covered phospholipid monolayer with thicknesses of 3 and 6 nm for the base phospholipid monolayer and the covering PEG layer, respectively. The chemical anchoring efficiency ofpolymerized PEG and phospholipid molecules, which was calculated by the relative carbon ratio of each surface before and after methanol washing using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, was 98%. This polymerized PEG/phosholipid monolayer showed good stability in organic solution due to firm chemical anchoring to a solid surface.     

pH-driven assembly of various supported lipid platforms: a comparative study on silicon oxide and titanium oxide

Supported lipid platforms are versatile cell membrane mimics whose structural properties can be tailored to suit the application of interest. By identifying parameters that control the self-assembly of these platforms, there is potential to develop advanced biomimetic systems that overcome the surface specificity of lipid vesicle interactions under physiological conditions. In this work, we investigated the adsorption kinetics of vesicles onto silicon and titanium oxides as a function of pH. On each substrate, a planar bilayer and a layer of intact vesicles could be self-assembled in a pH-dependent manner, demonstrating the role of surface charge density in the self-assembly process. Under acidic pH conditions where both zwitterionic lipid vesicles and the oxide films possess near-neutral electric surface charges, vesicle rupture could occur, demonstrating that the process is driven by nonelectrostatic interactions. However, we observed that the initial rupturing process is insufficient for propagating bilayer formation. The role of electrostatic interactions for propagating bilayer formation differs for the two substrates; electrostatic attraction between vesicles and the substrate is necessary for complete bilayer formation on titanium oxide but is not necessary on silicon oxide. Conversely, in the high pH regime, repulsive electrostatic interactions can result in the irreversible adsorption of intact vesicles on silicon oxide and even a reversibly adsorbed vesicle layer on titanium oxide. Together, the results show that pH is an effective tool to modulate vesicle-substrate interactions in order to create various self-assembled lipid platforms on hydrophilic substrates.     

Soft lithographic patterning of supported lipid bilayers onto a surface and inside microfluidic channels

We present simple soft lithographic methods for patterning supported lipid bilayer (SLB) membranes onto a surface and inside microfluidic channels. Micropatterns of polyethylene glycol (PEG)-based polymers were fabricated on glass substrates by microcontact printing or capillary moulding. The patterned PEG surfaces have shown 97 +/- 0.5% reduction in lipid adsorption onto two dimensional surfaces and 95 +/- 1.2% reduction inside microfluidic channels in comparison to glass control. Atomic force microscopy measurements indicated that the deposition of lipid vesicles led to the formation of SLB membranes by vesicle fusion due to hydrophilic interactions with the exposed substrate. Furthermore, the functionality of the patterned SLBs was tested by measuring the binding interactions between biotin (ligand)-labeled lipid bilayer and streptavidin (receptor). SLB arrays were fabricated with spatial resolution down to approximately 500 nm on flat substrate and approximately 1 microm inside microfluidic channels, respectively.     

Simulations of lipid vesicle adsorption for different lipid mixtures

Numerous experimental studies of lipid vesicle adsorption on solid surfaces show that electrostatic interactions play an important role for the kinetics and end result. The latter can, e.g., be intact vesicles or supported lipid bilayers (SLB). Despite an accumulated quite large experimental data base, the understanding of the underlying processes is still poor, and mathematical models are scarce. We have developed a phenomenological model of a vesicle adsorbing on a substrate, where the charge of the surface and the charge and polar state of the lipid headgroup can be varied. With physically reasonable assumptions and input parameters, we reproduce many key experimental observations, clarify the details of some experiments, and give predictions and suggestions for future experiments. Specifically, we have investigated the influence of different lipid mixtures (different charges of the headgroups) in the vesicle on the outcome of a vesicle adsorption event. For different mixtures of zwitterionic lipids with positive and negative lipids, we investigated whether the vesicle adsorbs or not, and--if it adsorbs--to what extent it gets deformed and when it ruptures spontaneously. Diffusion of neutral vesicles on different types of negatively charged substrates was also simulated. The mean surface charge density of the substrate was varied, including or excluding local fluctuations in the surface charge density. The simulations are compared to available experiments. A consistent picture of the influence of different lipid mixtures in the vesicle on adsorption, and the influence of different types of substrates on vesicle diffusion, appear as a result of the simulation data.     

Silica-supported biomimetic membranes

The hybridization of lipid membranes with inorganic silica-based framework results in mechanically stable biomembrane mimics. This account describes three types of silica-based biomimetic membranes. As the first example, a Langmuir monolayer of dialkylalkoxysilane was polymerized and immobilized onto a porous glass plate. Permeability through the monolayer-immobilized glass was regulated by phase transition of the immobilized monolayer. In the second example, spherical vesicles covalently attached to a silica cover layer (Cerasome) were prepared. The Cerasome was stable enough to be assembled into layer-by-layer films without destruction of its vesicular structure. This material could be an example of the multicellular assembly. Mesoporous silica films densely filling peptide assemblies (Proteosilica) are introduced as the third example. The Proteosilica was synthesized as a transparent film through template sol-gel reaction using amphiphilic peptides.     

Positioning and alignment of lipid tubules on patterned Au substrates

This paper presents a method for positioning and aligning self-assembled tubules of 1,2-bis(tricosa-10,12-diynoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphochloline (DC(8,9)PC) by withdrawing a patterned Au substrate from tubule solution. The patterned Au substrates with alternating bare Au stripes and thiol monolayer stripes are formed by microcontact printing. We find that the lipid tubules selectively adsorb on the bare Au stripes but show no orientation order. By withdrawing the patterned Au substrates at the direction along the stripes from tubule solution, the lipid tubules are found to be aligned along the direction of the Au stripes. The angular distribution and the density of the aligned lipid tubules depend on the withdrawal rates and the adsorption time, respectively. We conclude that forces causing tubule alignment that originate in the surface tension associated with the moving meniscus dominate alignment forces exerted by the patterned Au substrates.     

Synthesis and vesicular polymerization of novel counter‐ion polymerizable/crosslinkable surfactants

Two novel two‐tail surfactants, dicetyldimethylammonium 4‐vinyl benzoate (DDVB) and dicetyldimethylammonium 3,5‐divinyl benzoate (DDDB), were synthesized by neutralizing the corresponding quaternary ammonium hydroxide with the appropriate benzoic acid. As expected, these surfactants formed both homo and mixed‐vesicles, which were readily polymerized with a suitable radical photo‐initiator. The polymerization process was followed by UV–vis spectroscopy and also reconfirmed by NMR and IR spectroscopy. Polymerization of vesicles prepared from DDVB, unlike the more commonly polymerized vesicles, in which the polymerizable group forms an integral part of the surfactant, leads to the formation of a linear polyelectrolyte chain that is only electrostatically bound to the lipid bilayer. On the other hand, polymerization of DDDB vesicles leads to the formation of a crosslinked shell (or net) that encases the vesicle bilayer. Such counterion crosslinked vesicles were shown to be resistant to destabilization both by lysis as well as in the presence of a fairly high volume fraction of an organic solvent, such as ethanol. However, although the simple polymerized (linearly) vesicles, formed from DDVB, exhibit enhanced stability toward lysis when compared to their unpolymerized counterparts, they are readily destabilized in the presence of ethanol, leading to precipitation. This sharp contrast in the behavior of linearly polymerized and crosslinked systems suggests that crosslinking is essential to arrest conformational reorganization of the polyelectrolyte chains induced by a change in the solvent medium, which in turn leads to precipitation. Such counterion crosslinked vesicular systems also have an added advantage; they may retain the fluidityof the lipid bilayer while at the same time possess enhanced stability. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 42: 5271–5283, 2004     

Giant lipid vesicles impaled with glass microelectrodes: GigaOhm seal by membrane spreading

Giant unilamellar lipid vesicles could be perfect systems to study ion channels in the environment of lipid membranes with defined chemical and physical properties. Prerequisite for electrical measurements is an intravesicular electrical contact. We describe the impalement of giant lipid vesicles by glass micropipet electrodes with a tight seal. To avoid displacement or burst during impalement, the vesicles are immobilized in relaxed conditions by microscopic picket fences of polyimide. The outer surface of the pipets is selectively coated with silanes or polylysine. Structurally, the impalement is verified by ejecting a fluorescent solution out of the pipet. For electrical characterization, current pulses are applied to the pipet and voltage transients are recorded. The data are evaluated in terms of the capacitance and effective resistance of the membrane. Directly after impalement, we observe a seal resistance up to 1.2 GOmega that continuously decays within a period of up to 20 min until it suddenly disappears without burst of the vesicle. During impalement, a spreading of the vesicle membrane along the outer surface of the pipets is observed using a fluorescent membrane-bound dye. We assign the tight pipet-vesicle contact to spreading of the lipid bilayer by a rolling mechanism and the loss of resistance to micro- and macropores that are induced by the resulting membrane tension. Limitation of spreading is attempted with barriers on the pipet.     

Preparation of dehydrated powder of hemoglobin vesicles

The carbonyl hemoglobin (CO-Hb), which was used to prevent denaturation (metHb) during the preparation of samples, was encapsulated into lipid vesicles constituted from unsaturated phospholipid, cholesterol and unsaturated fatty acid. Unsaturated components were polymerized by γ-irradiation to enhance the stability of bilayer membrane. An aqueous dispersion of resulting Hb vesicles was freeze-dried in the presence of saccharides (50–200 mM) to obtain a dehydrated powder of Hb vesicles. Change in the vesicle size, the leakage of encapsulated Hb and the oxidation of Hb to metHb were not observed. Therefore, the long-term storage of Hb vesicles can be realized as a dry powder.     

Mechanical stability of micropipet-aspirated giant vesicles with fluid phase coexistence

Micropipet aspiration of phase-separated lipid bilayer vesicles can elucidate physicochemical aspects of membrane fluid phase coexistence. Recently, we investigated the composition dependence of line tension at the boundary between liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered phases of giant unilamellar vesicles obtained from ternary lipid mixtures using this approach. Here we examine mechanical equilibria and stability of dumbbell-shaped vesicles deformed by line tension. We present a relationship between the pipet aspiration pressure and the aspiration length in vesicles with two coexisting phases. Using a strikingly simple mechanical model for the free energy of the vesicle, we predict a relation that is in almost quantitative agreement with experiment. The model considers the vesicle free energy to be proportional to line tension and assumes that the vesicle volume, domain area fraction, and total area are conserved during aspiration. We also examine a mechanical instability encountered when releasing a vesicle from the pipet. We find that this releasing instability is observed within the framework of our model that predicts a change of the compressibility of a pipet-aspirated membrane cylinder from positive (i.e., stable) to negative (unstable) values, at the experimental instability. The model furthermore includes an aspiration instability that has also previously been experimentally described. Our method of studying micropipet-induced shape transitions in giant vesicles with fluid domains could be useful for investigating vesicle shape transitions modulated by bending stiffness and line tension.     

Size-dependent properties of small unilamellar vesicles formed by model lipids

The size-dependent behavior of small unilamellar vesicles is explored by dissipative particle dynamics, including the membrane characteristics and mechanical properties. The spontaneously formed vesicles are in the metastable state and the vesicle size is controlled by the concentration of model lipids. As the vesicle size decreases, the bilayer gets thinner and the area density of heads declines. Nonetheless, the area density in the inner leaflet is higher than that in the outer. The packing parameters are calculated for both leaflets. The result indicates that the shape of lipid in the outer leaflet is like a truncated cone but that in the inner leaflet resembles an inverted truncated cone. Based on a local order parameter, our simulations indication that the orientation order of lipid molecules decreases as the size of the vesicle reduces and this fact reveals that the bilayer becoming thinner for smaller vesicle is mainly attributed to the orientation disorder of the lipids. The membrane tension can be obtained through the Young-Laplace equation. The tension is found to grow with reducing vesicle size. Therefore, small vesicles are less stable against fusion. Using the inflation method, the area stretching and bending moduli can be determined and those moduli are found to grow with reducing size. Nonetheless, a general equation with a single numerical constant can relate bending modulus, area stretching modulus, and bilayer thickness irrespective of the vesicle size. Finally, a simple metastable model is proposed to explain the size-dependent behavior of bilayer thickness, orientation, and tension.     

Novel method for measuring the adhesion energy of vesicles

Adhering vesicles with osmotically stabilized volume are studied with Monte Carlo simulations and optical microscopy. The simulations are used to determine the dependence of the adhesion area on the vesicle volume, the surface area, the bending rigidity, the adhesion energy per membrane area, and the adhesion potential range. The simulation results lead to a simple functional expression that is supplemented by a correction term for gravity effects. The obtained equation provides a new tool to analyze optical microscopy data and, thus, to measure the adhesion energy per area by analyzing the geometry of the adhering vesicle. The method can be applied in the weak and ultra-weak adhesion regime, where the adhesion energy per area is below 10(-6) J/m(2). By comparing the shapes of adhering vesicles with different reduced volumes, the bending rigidity can be estimated as well. The new approach is applied to experimental data for lipid vesicles on (i) an untreated and (ii) a monolayer-coated glass surface, providing ultra-weak and weak adhesion strength, respectively.     

AFM characterization of spin-coated multilayered dry lipid films prepared from aqueous vesicle suspensions

We present a detailed AFM study on multilayered dry lipid films prepared from aqueous vesicle suspensions. Different preparation techniques were applied in order to optimize the preparation of homogeneous lipid films of various film thicknesses. Suspensions of preformed DOPC/DPPC vesicles were adsorbed onto indium tin oxide-coated glass coverslips, a substrate also commonly employed for the formation of giant liposomes. We found that the homogeneity of the lipid films could substantially be improved when applying a spin-coating step during the film preparation. These films were much more homogeneous than those prepared by conventional drop-casting and in addition the film thickness could be controlled. When using a combination of vesicle adsorption and spin-coating the quality and thickness of the films depended crucially on the lipid concentration of the vesicle suspension, the adsorption temperature and the adsorption time. For lipid films prepared by direct spin-coating the lipid concentration and the applied spin-coating sequence were critical parameters for the quality and thickness of the deposited lipid films.     

Surface response methodology for the study of supported membrane formation

We report on the investigations of the formation of the tethered lipid bilayer by vesicle deposition on amine-functionalized surfaces. The tethered bilayer was created by the deposition of egg-PC vesicles containing 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-poly-(ethyleneglycol)-N-hydroxysuccinimide as anchoring molecules on an amine-coated surface. This approach is an easy route for the formation of a biomimetic-supported membrane. A Doelhert experimental design was applied to determine the conditions leading to the formation of a continuous and defect-free tethered bilayer on different surfaces (gold and glass). Doehlert designs allow modeling of the experimental responses by second-order polynomial equations as a function of experimental factors. Four factors expected to influence bilayer formation were studied: the lipid concentration in the vesicle suspension, the mass percentage of anchoring molecules in the vesicles, the contact time between the vesicles and the surface, and the resting time of the membrane after buffer rinse. The optimization of the membrane preparation parameters was achieved by monitoring lipid assembly formation using surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy on gold and by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching on glass. Three characteristic responses were systematically measured: the bilayer thickness, the lipid diffusion coefficient, and the lipid mobile fraction. The simultaneous inspection of the three characteristics revealed that a restricted experimental domain leads to properties that are in accordance with a bilayer presence. The factors of this domain are a lipid concentration from 0.1 to 1 mg/mL, 4-8% of anchoring molecules in the vesicles, 1-4 h of contact time between vesicles and surface, and 21-24 h of resting time after buffer rinse. Under these conditions, a membrane having a lipid mass per surface between 545 +/- 5 and 590 +/- 10 ng/cm2, a diffusion coefficient of between 2.5 +/- 0.3 x 10(-8) and 3.60 +/- 0.5 x 10(-8) cm2/s, and a mobile fraction between 94 +/- 2 and 99 +/- 1% was formed. These findings were confirmed by atomic force microscopy observations, which showed the presence of a continuous and homogeneous bilayer in the determined experimental domain. This formation procedure presents many advantages; it provides an easily obtainable biomimetic membrane model for proteins studies and offers a versatile tethered bilayer because it can be adapted easily to various types of supports.     

Nanometre-sized molecular oxygen sensors prepared from polymer stabilized phospholipid vesicles

Nanometre-sized, chemically-stabilized phospholipid vesicle sensors have been developed for detection of dissolved molecular oxygen. Sensors were prepared by forming 150 nm phospholipid vesicles from 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) or DOPC doped with small (<1%) mole percentages of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanol amine-N-(7-nitro-2-1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl) (NBD-PE). Sensors were stabilized via cross-linking polymerization of hydrophobic methacrylate monomers partitioned into the hydrophobic interior of the DOPC bilayer. The resultant unilamellar, nanometre-sized, polymer-lipid vesicles are spherical, biocompatible and protect sensing components that are loaded into the aqueous interior of the vesicle from interfering species in the exterior environment. For O(2) detection, the oxygen-sensitive fluorescent dye, tris(1,10-phenanthroline)ruthenium(II) chloride (Ru(phen)(3)) was encapsulated into the aqueous interior of the polymerized phospholipid vesicle. NBD-PE was introduced into the phospholipid bilayer of the sensor as a reference dye, allowing ratiometric sensors to be constructed. The resultant sensors show high sensitivity, excellent reversibility and excellent linearity over a physiological range of dissolved oxygen concentrations. These results suggest that polymerized phospholipid vesicle sensors can be used for monitoring intracellular O(2) dynamics.     

Liposomes from α,ω-dipolar amphiphiles with a polymerizable diyne moiety in the hydrophobic chain

Symmetric polymerizable α,ω-dipolar C₂₂-diacetylenes were prepared by oxidative coupling of 10-undecynoic acid and 10-undecynol, respectively, by means of copper II salts in ethanolic solution. 10,12-Docosadiyne-1,22-diphosphate ( 3 )—by reaction of 10,12-docosadiyne-1,22-diol ( 2 ) with POCl₃—was polymerized in aqueous solution using UV irradiation to form deep blue, thermochromic solutions. By consonication of 3 with cholesterol, monolayer vesicles were formed. This was proven by encapsulation of 6-carboxyfluorescein. These monomeric vesicles were polymerized by UV light to yield stable, deep blue polymeric vesicle suspensions.     

Covalently anchored lipid structures on amine-enriched polystyrene

The study of the adhesion of lipid vesicles on surfaces is of increasing interest in the field of medical implants and tissue engineering (protein-resistant surfaces), drug delivery, biosensors, and biochips. In this work, lipid coverage was developed from PEG-coated vesicles (with sizes from 100 to 300 nm) by covalently binding poly(ethylene glycol)-alpha-disteroylphosphatidylethanolamine-omega-benzotriazole carbonate (DSPE-PEG-BTC) molecules onto the surface amine groups by carbamate chemistry. Lipid surface density and the surface structure of multilamellar (MLVs) and extruded unilamellar (LUVs) vesicles deposited on three types of polystyrene (PS) well-plates were probed by fluorescence and atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging. A significant difference in the vesicle surface coverage of PS substrates was observed with a substantial increase in lipid multilayers on the amine-enriched PS surface using both unilamellar and multilamellar vesicles.     

Supported lipid bilayers on biocompatible polysaccharide multilayers

Formation of supported lipid bilayers on soft polymer cushions is a useful approach to decouple the membrane from the substrate for applications involving membrane proteins. We prepared biocompatible polymer cushions by the layer-by-layer assembly of two polysaccharide polyelectrolytes, chitosan (CHI) and hyaluronic acid, on glass and silicon substrates. (CHI/HA)(5) films were characterized by atomic force microscopy, giving an average thickness of 57 nm and roughness of 25 nm in aqueous solution at pH 6.5. Formation of zwitterionic lipid bilayers by the vesicle fusion method was attempted using DOPC vesicles at pH 4 and 6.5 on (CHI/HA)(5) films. At higher pH adsorbed lipids had low mobility and large immobile lipid fractions; a combination of fluorescence and AFM indicated that this was attributable to formation of poor quality membranes with defects and pinned lipids rather than to a layer of surface-adsorbed vesicles. By contrast, more uniform bilayers with mobile lipids were produced at pH 4. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching gave diffusion coefficients that were similar to those for bilayers on PEG cushions and considerably higher than those measured on other polyelectrolyte films. The results suggest that the polymer surface charge is more important than the surface roughness in controlling formation of mobile supported bilayers. These results demonstrate that polysaccharides provide a useful alternative to other polymer cushions, particularly for applications where biocompatibility is important.     

A polydiacetylene-based fluorescent sensor chip

Self-assembled diacetylene vesicles were spotted and immobilized on aldehyde-modified glass substrates using conventional microarray technology. Irradiation of the immobilized diacetylenes allowed generation of nonfluorescent "blue-phase" polydiacetylene (PDA) arrays. Specific interaction of the PDA vesicle arrays with carbohydrates or poly(acrylic acid) solutions afforded fluorescent profiles.