Molecular electrostatic charge models: A topographical approach

Electrostatic charge models for molecules have been developed by employing the critical topographical features of the molecular electrostatic potential (MESP ) as the “fitting” criterion. These models include one or more spherical Gaussians for incorporating the continuous electron-charge distribution in addition to the positive valued point charges representing the nuclei. The model parameters (point charges, the orbital exponents, and Gaussian centers) are optimized so as to mimic the extremal characteristics of the corresponding quantum chemical MESP . The test cases reported here include methane, ethylene, and methanol molecules. The charge models developed using the present method are seen to satisfactorily reproduce the ab initio MESP and its extremal features. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Atomic forces for geometry‐dependent point multipole and Gaussian multipole models

In standard treatments of atomic multipole models, interaction energies, total molecular forces, and total molecular torques are given for multipolar interactions between rigid molecules. However, if the molecules are assumed to be flexible, two additional multipolar atomic forces arise because of (1) the transfer of torque between neighboring atoms and (2) the dependence of multipole moment on internal geometry (bond lengths, bond angles, etc.) for geometry‐dependent multipole models. In this study, atomic force expressions for geometry‐dependent multipoles are presented for use in simulations of flexible molecules. The atomic forces are derived by first proposing a new general expression for Wigner function derivatives . The force equations can be applied to electrostatic models based on atomic point multipoles or Gaussian multipole charge density. Hydrogen‐bonded dimers are used to test the intermolecular electrostatic energies and atomic forces calculated by geometry‐dependent multipoles fit to the ab initio electrostatic potential. The electrostatic energies and forces are compared with their reference ab initio values. It is shown that both static and geometry‐dependent multipole models are able to reproduce total molecular forces and torques with respect to ab initio, whereas geometry‐dependent multipoles are needed to reproduce ab initio atomic forces. The expressions for atomic force can be used in simulations of flexible molecules with atomic multipoles. In addition, the results presented in this work should lead to further development of next generation force fields composed of geometry‐dependent multipole models. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2010     

Accurate modeling of the intramolecular electrostatic energy of proteins

The (?, ψ) energy surface of blocked alanine (N-acetyl–N′-methyl alanineamide) was calculated at the Hartree-Fock (HF)/6-31G* level using ab initio molecular orbital theory. A collection of six electrostatic models was constructed, and the term electrostatic model was used to refer to (1) a set of atomic charge densities, each unable to deform with conformation; and (2) a rule for estimating the electrostatic interaction energy between a pair of atomic charge densities. In addition to two partial charge and three multipole electrostatic models, this collection includes one extremely detailed model, which we refer to as nonspherical CPK. For each of these six electrostatic models, parameters—in the form of partial charges, atomic multipoles, or generalized atomic densities—were calculated from the HF/6-31G* wave functions whose energies define the ab initio energy surface. This calculation of parameters was complicated by a problem that was found to originate from the locking in of a set of atomic charge densities, each of which contains a small polarization-induced deformation from its idealized unpolarized state. It was observed that the collective contribution of these small polarization-induced deformations to electrostatic energy differences between conformations can become large relative to ab initio energy differences between conformations. For each of the six electrostatic models, this contribution was reduced by an averaging of atomic charge densities (or electrostatic energy surfaces) over a large collection of conformations. The ab initio energy surface was used as a target with respect to which relative accuracies were determined for the six electrostatic models. A collection of 42 more complete molecular mechanics models was created by combining each of our six electrostatic models with a collection of seven models of repulsion + dispersion + intrinsic torsional energy, chosen to provide a representative sample of functional forms and parameter sets. A measure of distance was defined between model and ab initio energy surfaces; and distances were calculated for each of our 42 molecular mechanics models. For most of our 12 standard molecular mechanics models, the average error between model and ab initio energy surfaces is greater than 1.5 kcal/mol. This error is decreased by (1) careful treatment of the nonspherical nature of atomic charge densities, and (2) accurate representation of electrostatic interaction energies of types 1—2 and 1—3. This result suggests an electrostatic origin for at least part of the error between standard model and ab initio energy surfaces. Given the range of functional forms that is used by the current generation of protein potential functions, these errors cannot be corrected by compensating for errors in other energy components. © 1995 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

A partition function‐based weighting scheme in force field parameter development using ab initio calculation results in global configurational space

In force field parameter development using ab initio potential energy surfaces (PES) as target data, an important but often neglected matter is the lack of a weighting scheme with optimal discrimination power to fit the target data. Here, we developed a novel partition function‐based weighting scheme, which not only fits the target potential energies exponentially like the general Boltzmann weighting method, but also reduces the effect of fitting errors leading to overfitting. The van der Waals (vdW) parameters of benzene and propane were reparameterized by using the new weighting scheme to fit the high‐level ab initio PESs probed by a water molecule in global configurational space. The molecular simulation results indicate that the newly derived parameters are capable of reproducing experimental properties in a broader range of temperatures, which supports the partition function‐based weighting scheme. Our simulation results also suggest that structural properties are more sensitive to vdW parameters than partial atomic charge parameters in these systems although the electrostatic interactions are still important in energetic properties. As no prerequisite conditions are required, the partition function‐based weighting method may be applied in developing any types of force field parameters. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

On a semiclassical interpretation of inter- and intramolecular interactions

The semiclassical models considered here are composed by charge distributions coming from ab initio quantum-mechanical calculations on actual molecular systems. These charge distributions interact with one another according to the laws of classical electrostatics. This article describes some results of a systematic examination of the performances of this model in a variety of cases, with the aim of putting in evidence the usefulness and the limits of this inherently approximate representation of chemical interactions. Intermolecular interactions are examined first; the test cases are interactions of neutral molecules with H⁺, Li⁺, and C1^?, and the formation of H-bonded complexes. Attention is paid mainly to the energetics of the processes; each interacting molecule is considered as a unique entity and classical molecular reactivity indexes (electrostatic potential V, polarization term P) are introduced to compute the interaction energy, to interpret the details of the interaction process, and then to elaborate on less expensive computational procedures. Intramolecular interactions are considered. Attention is paid to the question of defining chemical groups starting from SCF molecular wavefunctions. The transferability and conservation degree of groups derived from localized orbitals of actual molecules is examined in detail, taking as tests their ability to reproduce charge distribution, one-electron observables, and energy. The effect of classical fields on these groups is then examined, taking into consideration external fields originated either by a point charge or by a solvent, and internal fields deriving from substitution of chemical groups. The intergroup analysis is then extended to the case of bimolecular reaction acts by considering the whole system as a supermolecule. Approximate computational procedures able to reproduce the main features of these interactions are proposed and tested. All through the article the performances of the classical models are compared with ab initio SCF calculations (mainly of low or intermediate quality).     

Geometry-dependent atomic charges: Methodology and application to alkanes,aldehydes, ketones,and amides

A general methodology for deriving geometry-dependent atomic charges is presented. The main ingredient of the method is a model that describes the molecular dipole moment in terms of geometry-dependent point charges. The parameters of the model are determined from ab initio calculations of molecular dipole moments and their Cartesian derivatives at various molecular geometries. Transferability of the parameters is built into the model by fitting ab initio calculations for various molecules simultaneously. The results show that charge flux along the bonds is a major contributing factor to the geometry dependence of the atomic charges, with additional contributions from fluxes along valence angles and adjacent bonds. Torsion flux is found to be smaller in magnitude than the bond and valence angle fluxes but is not always unimportant. A set of electrostatic parameters is presented for alkanes, aldehydes, ketones, and amides. Transferability of these parameters for a host of molecules is established to within 3 ?5% error in the predicted dipole moments. A possible extension of the method to include atomic dipoles is outlined. With the inclusion of such atomic dipoles and with the set of transferable point charges and charge flux parameters, it is demonstrated that molecular electrostatic potentials as well as electrostatic forces on nuclei can be reproduced much better than is possible with other models (such as potential derived charges). © 1995 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Prelude to molecular dynamics: Topography-driven gaussian charge models

A new strategy to develop Gaussian charge models (GCMs) for molecules like ammonia, water, ethene, hydrogen sulfide, formaldehyde and benzene is presented. These molecular models comprising of positive point charges and negative Gaussian charge distributions (GCDs), which represent nuclei and continuous electron charge distribution, are found to correctly represent the ab initio Molecular Electrostatic Potential (MESP) and reproduce its essential topographical features of corresponding molecules. The models use optimized parameters: positive charges at nuclei, negative charges on GCDs, Gaussian exponent and centers. The Potential Energy Surface (PES) of water dimer has been explored using water GCMs. A good agreement has been found between PES obtained using GCMs and wave function. The Gaussian models correctly predict structure of benzene-water complex. It is thus recommended to use GCMs for molecular dynamic simulations.     

Conformational preferences for hydroxyl groups in substituted tetrahydropyrans

Quantum mechanical (ab initio and semiempirical) and force field calculations are reported for representative torsion potentials in several tetrahydropyran derivatives. The overall agreement between the various methods is quite good except that the AMBER torsion profiles are sensitive to the choice of atomic point charges. Using electrostatic potential (ESP) derived atomic point charges determined with the STO-3G basis set we find that AMBER is able to match the best quantum mechanical results quite well. However, when the point charges are derived using the 6-31G* basis set we find that scaling the intramolecular electrostatic nonbond interactions is necessary. AM1 does not work very well for these compounds when compared to the ab initio methods and, therefore, should only be used in cases when ab initio calculations would be prohibitive. Based upon our results we feel that any force field that makes use of 6-31G* ESP derived atomic point charges will need to scale intramolecular interactions. Implications of scaling intramolecular interactions to the development of force fields based on 6-31G* ESP derived atomic point charges are discussed. © 1992 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.