New approach to molecular docking and its application to virtual screening of chemical databases

This paper describes the validation of a molecular docking method and its application to virtual database screening. The code flexibly docks ligand molecules into rigid receptor structures using a tabu search methodology driven by an empirically derived function for estimating the binding affinity of a protein-ligand complex. The docking method has been tested on 70 ligand-receptor complexes for which the experimental binding affinity and binding geometry are known. The lowest energy geometry produced by the docking protocol is within 2.0 A root mean square of the experimental binding mode for 79% of the complexes. The method has been applied to the problem of virtual database screening to identify known ligands for thrombin, factor Xa, and the estrogen receptor. A database of 10,000 randomly chosen "druglike" molecules has been docked into the three receptor structures. In each case known receptor ligands were included in the study. The results showed good separation between the predicted binding affinities of the known ligand set and the database subset.     

毒蕈碱型M1受体的同源模建和分子对接

采用同源模建方法对M1受体的三维结构进行了模拟, 将得到的模型分别与M受体完全激动剂乙酰胆碱和M1受体选择性激动剂占诺美林进行分子对接, 形成非特异性激动和特异性激动的受体-配体复合物. 用分子动力学模拟方法分别将未与小分子对接的M1受体、M1受体-乙酰胆碱复合物、M1受体-占诺美林复合物置于磷脂双膜中模拟10 ns. 将模拟后的蛋白质结构与包含活性分子的测试库对接并将结果打分, 以top5%富集因子(EF)作为评价依据, 用占诺美林优化后的M1受体模型的EF为8.0, 用乙酰胆碱优化后M1受体模型的EF为6.5, 非复合物的EF为1.5. 说明M1受体选择性激动剂复合物进行分子动力学模拟后得到的三维结构模型比较合理, 可以作为化合物虚拟筛选的模型对新化合物进行虚拟筛选, 为找到新的选择性M1受体激动剂奠定了基础.     

Protein-ligand docking against non-native protein conformers

In the validation of protein-ligand docking protocols, performance is mostly measured against native protein conformers, i.e. each ligand is docked into the protein conformation from the structure that contained that ligand. In real-life applications, however, ligands are docked against non-native conformations of the protein, i.e. the apo structure or a structure of a different protein-ligand complex. Here, we have constructed an extensive test set for assessing docking performance against non-native protein conformations. This new test set is built on the Astex Diverse Set (which we recently constructed for assessing native docking performance) and contains 1112 non-native structures for 65 drug targets. Using the protein-ligand docking program GOLD, the Astex Diverse Set and the new Astex Non-native Set, we established that, whereas docking performance (top-ranked solution within 2 A rmsd of the experimental binding mode) is approximately 80% for native docking, this drops to 61% for non-native docking. A similar drop-off is observed for sampling performance (any solution within 2 A): 91% for native docking vs 72% for non-native docking. No significant differences were observed between docking performance against apo and nonapo structures. We found that, whereas small variations in protein conformation are generally tolerated by our rigid docking protocol, larger protein movements result in a catastrophic drop-off in performance. Some docking performance and nearly all sampling performance can be recovered by considering dockings produced against a small number of non-native structures simultaneously. Docking against non-native structures of complexes containing ligands that are similar to the docked ligand also significantly improves both docking performance and sampling performance.     

TreeDock: a tool for protein docking based on minimizing van der Waals energies

Predicting protein-protein and protein-ligand docking remains one of the challenging topics of structural biology. The main problems are (i) to reliably estimate the binding free energies of docked states, (ii) to enumerate possible docking orientations at a high resolution, and (iii) to consider mobility of the docking surfaces and structural rearrangements upon interaction. Here we present a novel algorithm, TreeDock, that addresses the enumeration problem in a rigid-body docking search. By representing molecules as multidimensional binary search trees and by exploring a sufficient number of docking orientations such that two chosen atoms, one from each molecule, are always in contact, TreeDock is able to explore all clash-free orientations at very fine resolution in a reasonable amount of time. Due to the speed of the program, many contact pairs can be examined to search partial or complete surface areas. The deterministic systematic search of TreeDock is in contrast to most other docking programs that use stochastic searches such as Monte Carlo or simulated annealing methods. At this point, we have used the Lennard-Jones potential as the only scoring function and show that this can predict the correct docked conformation for a number of protein-protein and protein-ligand complexes. The program is most powerful if some information is known about the location of binding faces from NMR chemical-shift perturbation studies, orientation information from residual dipolar coupling, or mutational screening. The approach has the potential to include docking-site mobility by performing molecular dynamics or other randomization methods of the docking site and docking families to families of structures. The performance of the algorithm is demonstrated by docking three complexes of immunoglobulin superfamily domains, CD2 to CD58, the V(alpha) domain of a T-cell receptor to its V(beta) domain, and a T-cell receptor to a pMHC complex as well as a small molecule inhibitor to a phosphatase.     

A QXP-based multistep docking procedure for accurate prediction of protein-ligand complexes

The two great challenges of the docking process are the prediction of ligand poses in a protein binding site and the scoring of the docked poses. Ligands that are composed of extended chains in their molecular structure display the most difficulties, predominantly because of the torsional flexibility. On the basis of the molecular docking program QXP-Flo+0802, we have developed a procedure particularly for ligands with a high degree of rotational freedom that allows the accurate prediction of the orientation and conformation of ligands in protein binding sites. Starting from an initial full Monte Carlo docking experiment, this was achieved by performing a series of successive multistep docking runs using a local Monte Carlo search with a restricted rotational angle, by which the conformational search space is limited. The method was established by using a highly flexible acetylcholinesterase inhibitor and has been applied to a number of challenging protein-ligand complexes known from the literature.     

Flexible docking of ligands into synthetic receptors using a two-sided incremental construction algorithm

We present a new algorithm for the fast and reliable structure prediction of synthetic receptor-ligand complexes. Our method is based on the protein-ligand docking program FlexX and extends our recently introduced docking technique for synthetic receptors, which has been implemented in the program FlexR. To handle the flexibility of the relevant molecules, we apply a novel docking strategy that uses an adaptive two-sided incremental construction algorithm which incorporates the structural flexibility of both the ligand and synthetic receptor. We follow an adaptive strategy, in which one molecule is expanded by attaching its next fragment in all possible torsion angles, whereas the other (partially assembled) molecule serves as a rigid binding partner. Then the roles of the molecules are exchanged. Geometric filters are used to discard partial conformations that cannot realize a targeted interaction pattern derived in a graph-based precomputation phase. The process is repeated until the entire complex is built up. Our algorithm produces promising results on a test data set comprising 10 complexes of synthetic receptors and ligands. The method generated near-native solutions compared to crystal structures in all but one case. It is able to generate solutions within a couple of minutes and has the potential of being used as a virtual screening tool for searching for suitable guest molecules for a given synthetic receptor in large databases of guests and vice versa.     

Interpretation of scoring functions using 3D molecular fields. Mapping the diacyl-hydrazine-binding pocket of an insect ecdysone receptor

A method is presented for the interpretation of receptor docking score values (rough measures of binding affinities) of ligands in terms of 3D molecular field interaction contributions. The FlexX and FlexX-Pharm methods were used to dock the structures of designed sets of ligands into the ligand-binding pocket of a selected receptor. In the next step the relationship was investigated between the FlexX and CScore scores and 3D molecular fields obtained for the docked conformations of the ligands, using the CoMFA (Comparative Molecular Field Analysis) and CoMSIA (Comparative Molecular Similarity Indices Analysis) methods. The approach yielded highly significant CoMFA and CoMSIA models demonstrating that a high portion of the variance in the docking score values of the ligands can be explained by steric, electrostatic, hydrophobic, and hydrogen bond donor and acceptor molecular field interaction contributions. The approach was exemplified by using the crystal structure of the ligand-binding domain of the ecdysone receptor (EcR) of the moth Heliotis virescens as well as virtual molecule libraries of analogues of known diacyl-hydrazine (DAH) type ecdysteroid agonists. By docking appropriately designed virtual compound libraries into the DAH binding pocket of EcR followed by CoMFA and CoMSIA of the docked conformations, hitherto unexplored regions of the receptor cavity could be mapped. By mapping the significant molecular field interaction contributions onto the model of the receptor-ligand complex, important receptor-ligand interactions could be highlighted that may help the design of novel highly scored receptor ligands. An advantage of the method is that no experimental biological activity data are required to exhaustively map the receptor-binding site.     

Development and evaluation of a generic evolutionary method for protein-ligand docking

We have developed a generic evolutionary method with an empirical scoring function for the protein-ligand docking, which is a problem of paramount importance in structure-based drug design. This approach, referred to as the GEMDOCK (Generic Evolutionary Method for molecular DOCKing), combines both continuous and discrete search mechanisms. We tested our approach on seven protein-ligand complexes, and the docked lowest energy structures have root-mean-square derivations ranging from 0.32 to 0.99 A with respect to the corresponding crystal ligand structures. In addition, we evaluated GEMDOCK on crossdocking experiments, in which some complexes with an identical protein used for docking all crystallized ligands of these complexes. GEMDOCK yielded 98% docked structures with RMSD below 2.0 A when the ligands were docked into foreign protein structures. We have reported the validation and analysis of our approach on various search spaces and scoring functions. Experimental results show that our approach is robust, and the empirical scoring function is simple and fast to recognize compounds. We found that if GEMDOCK used the RMSD scoring function, then the prediction accuracy was 100% and the docked structures had RMSD below 0.1 A for each test system. These results suggest that GEMDOCK is a useful tool, and may systematically improve the forms and parameters of a scoring function, which is one of major bottlenecks for molecular recognition.     

BALLDock/SLICK: a new method for protein-carbohydrate docking

Protein-ligand docking is an essential technique in computer-aided drug design. While generally available docking programs work well for most drug classes, carbohydrates and carbohydrate-like compounds are often problematic for docking. We present a new docking method specifically designed to handle docking of carbohydrate-like compounds. BALLDock/SLICK combines an evolutionary docking algorithm for flexible ligands and flexible receptor side chains with carbohydrate-specific scoring and energy functions. The scoring function has been designed to identify accurate ligand poses, while the energy function yields accurate estimates of the binding free energies of these poses. On a test set of known protein-sugar complexes we demonstrate the ability of the approach to generate correct poses for almost all of the structures and achieve very low mean errors for the predicted binding free energies.     

Sensitivity of molecular docking to induced fit effects in influenza virus neuraminidase

Many proteins undergo small side chain or even backbone movements on binding of different ligands into the same protein structure. This is known as induced fit and is potentially problematic for virtual screening of databases against protein targets. In this report we investigate the limits of the rigid protein approximation used by the docking program, GOLD, through cross-docking using protein structures of influenza neuraminidase. Neuraminidase is known to exhibit small but significant induced fit effects on ligand binding. Some neuraminidase crystal structures caused concern due to the bound ligand conformation and GOLD performed poorly on these complexes. A `clean' set, which contained unique, unambiguous complexes, was defined. For this set, the lowest energy structure was correctly docked (i.e. RMSD < 1.5 Å away from the crystal reference structure) in 84% of proteins, and the most promiscuous protein (1mwe) was able to dock all 15 ligands accurately including those that normally required an induced fit movement. This is considerably better than the 70% success rate seen with GOLD against general validation sets. Inclusion of specific water molecules involved in water-mediated hydrogen bonds did not significantly improve the docking performance for ligands that formed water-mediated contacts but it did prevent docking of ligands that displaced these waters. Our data supports the use of a single protein structure for virtual screening with GOLD in some applications involving induced fit effects, although care must be taken to identify the protein structure that performs best against a wide variety of ligands. The performance of GOLD was significantly better than the GOLD implementation of ChemScore and the reasons for this are discussed. Overall, GOLD has shown itself to be an extremely good, robust docking program for this system.     

Using buriedness to improve discrimination between actives and inactives in docking

A continuing problem in protein-ligand docking is the correct relative ranking of active molecules versus inactives. Using the ChemScore scoring function as implemented in the GOLD docking software, we have investigated the effect of scaling hydrogen bond, metal-ligand, and lipophilic interactions based on the buriedness of the interaction. Buriedness was measured using the receptor density, the number of protein heavy atoms within 8.0 A. Terms in the scaling functions were optimized using negative data, represented by docked poses of inactive molecules. The objective function was the mean rank of the scores of the active poses in the Astex Diverse Set (Hartshorn et al. J. Med. Chem., 2007, 50, 726) with respect to the docked poses of 99 inactives. The final four-parameter model gave a substantial improvement in the average rank from 18.6 to 12.5. Similar results were obtained for an independent test set. Receptor density scaling is available as an option in the recent GOLD release.     

Fully automated flexible docking of ligands into flexible synthetic receptors using forward and inverse docking strategies

The prediction of the structure of host-guest complexes is one of the most challenging problems in supramolecular chemistry. Usual procedures for docking of ligands into receptors do not take full conformational freedom of the host molecule into account. We describe and apply a new docking approach which performs a conformational sampling of the host and then sequentially docks the ligand into all receptor conformers using the incremental construction technique of the FlexX software platform. The applicability of this approach is validated on a set of host-guest complexes with known crystal structure. Moreover, we demonstrate that due to the interchangeability of the roles of host and guest, the docking process can be inverted. In this inverse docking mode, the receptor molecule is docked around its ligand. For all investigated test cases, the predicted structures are in good agreement with the experiment for both normal (forward) and inverse docking. Since the ligand is often smaller than the receptor and, thus, its conformational space is more restricted, the inverse docking approach leads in most cases to considerable speed-up. By having the choice between two alternative docking directions, the application range of the method is significantly extended. Finally, an important result of this study is the suitability of the simple energy function used here for structure prediction of complexes in organic media.     

Pose prediction accuracy in docking studies and enrichment of actives in the active site of GSK-3beta

We present molecular docking studies on the inhibitors of GSK-3beta kinase in the enzyme binding sites of the X-ray complexes (1H8F, 1PYX, 1O9U, 1Q4L, 1Q5K, and 1UV5) using the Schr?dinger docking tool Glide. Cognate and cross-docking studies using standard precision (SP) and extraprecision (XP) algorithms have been carried out. Cognate docking studies demonstrate that docked poses similar to X-ray poses (root-mean-square deviations of less than 2 A) are found within the top four ranks of the GlideScore and E-model scores. However, cross-docking studies typically produce poses that are significantly deviated from X-ray poses in all but a couple of cases, implying potential for induced fit effects in ligand binding. In this light, we have also carried out induced fit docking studies in the active sites of 1O9U, 1Q4L, and 1Q5K. Specifically, conformational changes have been effected in the active sites of these three protein structures to dock noncognate ligands. Thus, for example, the active site of 1O9U has been induced to fit the ligands of 1Q4L, 1Q5K, and 1UV5. These studies produce ligand docked poses which have significantly lower root-mean-square deviations relative to their X-ray crystallographic poses, when compared to the corresponding values from the cross-docking studies. Furthermore, we have used an ensemble of the induced fit models and X-ray structures to enhance the retrieval of active GSK-3beta inhibitors seeded in a decoy database, normally used in Glide validation studies. Thus, our studies provide valuable insights into computational strategies useful for the identification of potential GSK-3beta inhibitors.     

QXP: Powerful, rapid computer algorithms for structure-based drug design

New methods for docking, template fitting and building pseudo-receptors are described. Full conformational searches are carried out for flexible cyclic and acyclic molecules. QXP (quick explore) search algorithms are derived from the method of Monte Carlo perturbation with energy minimization in Cartesian space. An additional fast search step is introduced between the initial perturbation and energy minimization. The fast search produces approximate low-energy structures, which are likely to minimize to a low energy. For template fitting, QXP uses a superposition force field which automatically assigns short-range attractive forces to similar atoms in different molecules. The docking algorithms were evaluated using X-ray data for 12 protein–ligand complexes. The ligands had up to 24 rotatable bonds and ranged from highly polar to mostly nonpolar. Docking searches of the randomly disordered ligands gave rms differences between the lowest energy docked structure and the energy-minimized X-ray structure, of less than 0.76 Å for 10 of the ligands. For all the ligands, the rms difference between the energy-minimized X-ray structure and the closest docked structure was less than 0.4 Å, when parts of one of the molecules which are in the solvent were excluded from the rms calculation. Template fitting was tested using four ACE inhibitors. Three ACE templates have been previously published. A single run using QXP generated a series of templates which contained examples of each of the three. A pseudo-receptor, complementary to an ACE template, was built out of small molecules, such as pyrrole, cyclopentanone and propane. When individually energy minimized in the pseudo-receptor, each of the four ACE inhibitors moved with an rms of less than 0.25 Å. After random perturbation, the inhibitors were docked into the pseudo-receptor. Each lowest energy docked structure matched the energy-minimized geometry with an rms of less than 0.08 Å. Thus, the pseudo-receptor shows steric and chemical complementarity to all four molecules. The QXP program is reliable, easy to use and sufficiently rapid for routine application in structure-based drug design.     

DOCK 4.0: Search strategies for automated molecular docking of flexible molecule databases

In this paper we describe the search strategies developed for docking flexible molecules to macomolecular sites that are incorporated into the widely distributed DOCK software, version 4.0. The search strategies include incremental construction and random conformation search and utilize the existing Coulombic and Lennard-Jones grid-based scoring function. The incremental construction strategy is tested with a panel of 15 crystallographic testcases, created from 12 unique complexes whose ligands vary in size and flexibility. For all testcases, at least one docked position is generated within 2 Å of the crystallographic position. For 7 of 15 testcases, the top scoring position is also within 2 Å of the crystallographic position. The algorithm is fast enough to successfully dock a few testcases within seconds and most within 100 s. The incremental construction and the random search strategy are evaluated as database docking techniques with a database of 51 molecules docked to two of the crystallographic testcases. Incremental construction outperforms random search and is fast enough to reliably rank the database of compounds within 15 s per molecule on an SGI R10000 cpu.     

A_1腺苷受体的同源模建及其结构验证

采用同源模建的方法构建了A1腺苷受体的三维结构,并与拮抗剂分子DPCPX对接,将得到的复合物结构进行5 ns的分子动力学模拟,以最后2 ns的平均结构和平衡后抽取的11帧构象共12个蛋白结构为研究对象,用包含52个活性分子和1000个诱饵分子的测试库,分别通过DOCK、VINA和GOLD三种对接软件进行评价,最终得出合理的蛋白质模型.根据top10%的富集因子(EF)和ROC曲线下面积(AU-ROC)的计算结果,我们认为GOLD是最适合A1腺苷受体的对接软件,而12个蛋白质结构中F5和Favg的三维结构模型比较合理,可以作为进一步大规模虚拟筛选的模型.     

The sensitivity of the results of molecular docking to induced fit effects: Application to thrombin, thermolysin and neuraminidase

This paper describes the application of PRO_–LEADS to the flexible docking of ligands into crystallographically derived enzyme structures that are assumed to be rigid. PRO_–LEADS uses a Tabu search methodology to perform the flexible search and an empirically derived estimate of the binding affinity to drive the docking process. The paper tests the extent to which the assumption of a rigid enzyme compromises the accuracy of the results. All-pairs docking experiments are performed for three enzymes (thrombin, thermolysin and influenza virus neuraminidase) based on six or more ligand-enzyme crystal structures for each enzyme. In 76% of the cases, PRO_–LEADS can successfully identify the correct ligand conformation as the lowest energy configuration when the enzyme structure is derived from that ligand's crystal structure, but the methodology only docks 49% of the cases successfully when the ligand is docked against enzyme crystal structures derived from other ligands. Small movements in the enzyme structure lead to an under-prediction in the energy of the correct binding mode by up to 14 kJ/mol and in some cases this under-prediction can lead to the native mode not being recognised as the lowest energy solution. The type of movements responsible for mis-docking are: the movement of sidechains as a result of changes in C position; the movement of sidechains without changes in C position; the movement of flexible portions of main chains to facilitate the formation of hydrogen bonds; and the movement of metal atoms bound to the enzyme active site. The work illustrates that the assumption of a rigid active site can lead to errors in identification of the correct binding mode and the assessment of binding affinity, even for enzymes which show relatively small shift in atomic positions from one ligand to the next. A good docking code, such as PRO_–LEADS, can usually dock successfully if there is induced fit in relatively rigid enzymes but there remains the need to develop improved strategies for dealing with enzyme flexibility. The work implies that treatments of enzyme flexibility which focus only on sidechain rotations will not deal with the critical shifts responsible for mis-docking of ligands in thrombin, thermolysin and neuraminidase. The paper demonstrates the utility of all pairs docking experiments as a method of assessing the effectiveness of docking methodologies in dealing with enzyme flexibility.     

MCDOCK: A Monte Carlo simulation approach to the molecular docking problem

Prediction of the binding mode of a ligand (a drug molecule) to its macromolecular receptor, or molecular docking, is an important problem in rational drug design. We have developed a new docking method in which a non-conventional Monte Carlo (MC) simulation technique is employed. A computer program, MCDOCK, was developed to carry out the molecular docking operation automatically. The current version of the MCDOCK program (version 1.0) allows for the full flexibility of ligands in the docking calculations. The scoring function used in MCDOCK is the sum of the interaction energy between the ligand and its receptor, and the conformational energy of the ligand. To validate the MCDOCK method, 19 small ligands, the binding modes of which had been determined experimentally using X-ray diffraction, were docked into their receptor binding sites. To produce statistically significant results, 20 MCDOCK runs were performed for each protein–ligand complex. It was found that a significant percentage of these MCDOCK runs converge to the experimentally observed binding mode. The root-mean-square (rms) of all non-hydrogen atoms of the ligand between the predicted and experimental binding modes ranges from 0.25 to 1.84 Å for these 19 cases. The computational time for each run on an SGI Indigo2/R10000 varies from less than 1 min to 15 min, depending upon the size and the flexibility of the ligands. Thus MCDOCK may be used to predict the precise binding mode of ligands in lead optimization and to discover novel lead compounds through structure-based database searching.     

A comprehensive docking study on the selectivity of binding of aromatic compounds to proteins

Generally, computer-aided drug design is focused on screening of ligand molecules for a single protein target. The screening of several proteins for a ligand is a relatively new application of molecular docking. In the present study, complexes from the Brookhaven Protein Databank were used to investigate a docking approach of protein screening. Automated molecular docking calculations were applied to reproduce 44 protein-aromatic ligand complexes (31 different proteins and 39 different ligand molecules) of the databank. All ligands were docked to all different protein targets in altogether 12090 docking runs. Based on the results of the extensive docking simulations, two relative measures, the molecular interaction fingerprint (MIF) and the molecular affinity fingerprint (MAF), were introduced to describe the selectivity of aromatic ligands to different proteins. MIF and MAF patterns are in agreement with fragment and similarity considerations. Limitations and future extension of our approach are discussed.     

Unsupervised guided docking of covalently bound ligands

Summary An approach for docking covalently bound ligands in protein enzymes or receptors was implemented in MacDOCK, a similarity-driven docking program based on DOCK 4.0. This approach was tested with a small number of covalent ligand–protein structures, using both native and non-native protein structures. In all cases, MacDOCK was able to generate orientations consistent with the known covalent binding mode of these complexes, with a performance similar to that of other docking programs. This method was also applied to search for known covalent thrombin inhibitors in a medium-sized molecular database (ca. 11,000 compounds). Detection of functional groups suitable for covalent docking was carried out automatically. A significant enrichment in known active molecules in the first 5% of the database was obtained, showing that MacDOCK can be used efficiently for the virtual screening of covalently bound ligands.