Evaluation of a method for treatment of iron gall ink corrosion on paper

Iron gall ink was the most widely used writing ink for paper from the Middle Ages to the twentieth century. Unfortunately, the ink ingredients contain corrosive transition metal ions and acids that cause severe damage to the paper carrier. New or improved paper conservation methods for iron gall ink stabilization are constantly sought. The aim of the study was evaluation of a recently proposed stabilization treatment, adapted to lower relative humidity, applied to various model and historical paper samples containing iron gall ink. The effect of stabilization treatment on paper samples during artificial thermal aging was followed by the determination of the molecular weight distribution by size exclusion chromatography and colorimetry. Migration of iron and copper compounds from the ink lines was monitored by laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. The results demonstrate that effective stabilization of iron gall ink-containing paper can be successfully achieved by interleaving with papers impregnated with the antioxidant tetrabutylammonium bromide and alkaline buffer under experimental conditions. Negative side effects of the stabilization treatment, such as migration of iron or copper ions from the ink lines and changes of color after the treatment and after accelerated thermal degradation, were limited, proving that the proposed stabilization treatment can be considered for future use by conservators.     

Chemometric tool for identification of iron–gall inks by use of visible–near infrared fibre optic reflection spectroscopy

A method has been developed for identification of corrosive iron–gall inks in historical drawings and documents. The method is based on target-factor analysis of visible–near infrared fibre optic reflection spectra (VIS–NIR FORS). A set of reference spectra was obtained from model samples of laboratory-prepared inks covering a wide range of mixing ratios of basic ink components deposited on substrates and artificially aged. As criteria for correspondence of a studied spectrum with a reference spectrum, the apparent error in target (AET) and the empirical function SPOIL according to Malinowski were used. The capability of the proposed tool to distinguish corrosive iron–gall inks from bistre and sepia inks was evaluated by use of a set of control samples of bistre, sepia, and iron–gall inks. Examples are presented of analysis of historical drawings from the 15th and 16th centuries and written documents from the 19th century. The results of analysis based on the tool were confirmed by XRF analysis and colorimetric spot analysis.

Iron gall ink-induced corrosion of cellulose: aging,degradation and stabilization. Part 1: model paper studies

Cellulose in historic paper documents is often damaged by the writing media used, especially iron gall ink or copper pigments. Degradation induced by iron gall ink is suggested to be a synergistic process comprising both hydrolytic and oxidative reactions. These processes were studied on very low sample amounts according to the CCOA and FDAM method, i.e. by fluorescence labeling of carbonyl and carboxyl groups in combination with GPC-MALLS, respectively. This study focused on preventive means to stop the deterioration induced by iron gall ink of cellulose and to prevent further damage, keeping in mind that a suitable conservation treatment has to hinder both, hydrolytic and oxidative processes, at the same time. A combination of the complexing agent calcium phytate and calcium hydrogencarbonate in aqueous solution was proved to give optimum results. To gain insight into long term stability, an aging step was performed after treatment and different ink modifications were tested. Recording the molecular weight distributions and the carbonyl group content over time GPC analysis verified for the first time the preventive effect of this treatment. This effect was not only seen for the ink-covered areas, but extended also to areas remote from the ink lines. Ink containing copper ions responded equally positively to the calcium phytate/hydrogencarbonate treatment as the iron gall ink papers did. Gelatine, sometimes used in a similar way due to an alleged cellulose-stabilizing effect did not have a beneficial influence on cellulose integrity when metal ions were present.     

Study of the copper effect in iron-gall inks after artificial ageing

Iron-gall inks consist of a mixture of vitriols (sulphates of certain metals), gall nut extracts and arabic gum. The association of the iron(II) sulphate present in vitriols, and the gallic acids present in the gall nut extracts induces, after exposure to oxygen, the formation of dark coloured compounds of ink. In addition to iron, this kind of inks contains other metals, such as copper, zinc, and nickel. Among them, copper could be considered the most important because, owing to its catalytic ability, it can be involved in the processes concerning formation and stability of iron complexes, which are responsible for the ink dark colour. For this purpose, four different iron-gall inks containing increasing amounts of copper sulphate were prepared according to a traditional receipt and applied on paper supports. The ink-stained paper specimens were subjected to an intense analytical program to investigate their chemical and physical modifications after artificial ageing (both temperature/humidity and ultraviolet light ageing). The role of copper in the iron-gall inks was evaluated using optical microscopy, colorimetric measurements, X-ray fluorescence (XRF), X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD), scanning electron microscopy coupled with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM–EDX) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). For the evaluation of the oxidation state of iron and copper, X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XANES) was used. All results indicate that the presence of copper in iron-gall ink causes colour variation, affects the migratory behaviour of iron in the paper, increases the formation of secondary products particularly when ageing process based on temperature/humidity variations is considered.     

毛细管电泳法基于Fe(Ⅱ)与Fe(Ⅲ)的比值识别签字笔字迹的相对书写时间

可疑文件中墨水笔迹的相对时间鉴定对法庭科学、刑事案件的侦破和历史文献的整理都具有重要意义。该文建立了一种识别墨迹相对年代的毛细管电泳（CE）新方法。采用络合剂邻菲罗啉（1,10-phen）和反式-1,2-环己二胺四乙酸（CDTA）分别与Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）络合,然后用CE测定Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）的峰面积,通过比较从可疑笔迹中提取的Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）的峰面积比与从整个文档中提取出的Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）的峰面积比,判断整篇文字是否同时书写。实验首先对两种络合剂与两种价态铁离子的特异性络合进行了研究,结果表明1,10-phen与Fe（Ⅱ）、CDTA与Fe（Ⅲ）具有特异性络合。初步研究还表明：由于商用墨水pH值较低,墨水中的Fe（Ⅱ）在墨水瓶中比较稳定,因此Fe（Ⅱ）在墨水瓶中的氧化可以忽略不计;但当墨水书写在纸张上时,墨水中的硫酸会逐渐被纸张的纤维素所消耗,从而导致Fe（Ⅱ）在纸张中被逐渐氧化;在老化过程中Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）的峰面积比发生了变化,书写的时间越长,Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）的峰面积比就越小。该技术的成功应用依赖于找到一种合适的提取笔迹墨水的方法和CE分离测定Fe（Ⅱ）和Fe（Ⅲ）的方法。样品前处理程序如下：剪取1 cm长的墨水迹线,剪碎后放入2 mL的EP管中,加入0.5 mL 5 mmol/L的1,10-phen萃取1 min,再加入0.5 mL 20 mmol/L的CDTA振荡10 min,10000 r/min离心15 min,取上清液进行CE分离检测。CE条件如下：熔融石英毛细管（40.2 cm（有效长度30 cm）×75 μm i.d.）,100 mmol/L硼酸-硼砂缓冲溶液（pH 9.2）,压力上样（1.379 kPa,上样时间5 s）,分离电压20 kV,检测波长254 nm,温度控制在25℃。最后,对两种不同的墨水进行了测定,以评价所建方法的适用性,结果表明所建方法对于鉴别可疑文件中真伪笔迹的相对年代具有重要的指导意义。     

A Review of Instrumental Approaches for Studying Historical Inks

In the last 10 years researchers have adapted a number of instrumental techniques for studying various aspects of historical inks that have been used in historical documents. In this paper, the applications of atomic spectroscopy such as GFAAS, ICP-MS, XRF, PIXE, and XANES are described for identifying and quantifying metals that are found in historical inks. Applications of vibrational spectroscopy, primarily Raman and near/mid-IR spectroscopy, are described for detecting organic and inorganic compounds in ink and paper.     

Studies into the Early Degradation Stages of Cellulose by Different Iron Gall Ink Components

Selective fluorescence labelling of oxidized cellulose functionalities followed by GPC-MALLS was used to get a deeper insight into ink-induced degradation processes. As the method is very sensitive towards oxidation and molecular weight changes, slight variations at the very beginning of aging processes, e.g. during ink corrosion of cellulose, can be studied. Five different ink modifications were applied on model papers and underwent mild accelerated aging at 55 °C and cycling humidity (7 days) followed by a short period of static humid aging at 80 °C (2 days). Pure ink constituents like tannic acid or iron sulphate do not result in the same degree of oxidation or chain scission as complete inks. Balanced ink degrades paper more than single compounds, but less than unbalanced inks. Interestingly, some degradation occurs already during or shortly after the application process of unbalanced inks on paper. It could be demonstrated that this oxidation proceeded in a rather high Mw area, while the subsequent aging steps affected predominantly regions of shorter cellulose chains.     

Classification and dating of black gel pen ink by ion-pairing high-performance liquid chromatography

A novel approach for classification and dating of the black gel pen ink entries on document was developed based on ion-pairing high-performance liquid chromatography (IP-HPLC). Ninety-three black gel pens were collected and divided into two groups, dye-based and pigment-based, by preliminary solubility test. The chromatographic conditions for separation of the dye-based black gel pen inks were optimized and the dye components in inks were satisfactorily separated by using 40 mmol/L tetrabutylammonium bromide as ion-pairing reagent. According to the number and the chromatographic retention times of the main dye components, the 50 dye-based inks were categorized into four classes. The inks within a class can be further identified by the percentage of each dye component. The compositional changes of the dye components in the black gel pen ink entries on paper were investigated in light and natural aging conditions and it has been found that the dye components in the ink entries underwent obvious decomposition, and the decomposing extent of the dye components was related to the aging time. The results can provide scientific evidences for dating of the suspicious black gel pen ink entries on documents.     

Emission of reactive oxygen species during degradation of iron gall ink

Iron gall inks are characterised by high contents of acids and transition metals, promoting degradation of cellulose due to hydrolysis and oxidation, respectively. Their chemical interaction with the environment is not well understood, especially in view of emissions of degradation products which could lead to spread of degradation processes.In order to study the emissions, we employed gas chromatography/mass spectrometry following headspace micro-extraction, and liquid chromatography following hydroxyl radical scavenging with appropriate probes. We also studied chemiluminescence of cellulose affected by ink degradation.We show that while the emissions of organic volatile degradation compounds by inks are less intense than those of surrounding paper, ink does promote the degradation of cellulose across big distances (from object to object). We were able to link this to emission of reactive oxygen species, probably hydrogen peroxide. Its emission from ink is considerably more intensive than from paper.     

Study of 19th century inks from archives in the Palazzo Ducale (Venice, Italy) using various analytical techniques

Inks and paper are the main materials and components of library and archive collections. Since the Third century B.C. there has been a continual succession of ink recipes from all over the world, with varying levels of documentation of the recipes used; however, it was only in the 19th century that Europe became the main producer and industrial leader in the discovery of new products. The aim of this study is to find out more about this last historical period, when new inks were created that had never been known or used in the past. In this study we chose four inks: they belong to documents preserved in the archive of the Superintendence Beni architettonici per il paesaggio e per il patrimonio storico artistico ed etnoantropologico (BAPPDAD) of Venice Lagoon, held in the Palazzo Ducale (Ducal Palace) of Venice.Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (ATR), Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM-EDS) and pyrolysis coupled to a gas chromatograph with mass spectrometric detector (Py–GC–MS) allowed us to obtain a qualitative characterization of organic and inorganic elements in three different ink typologies.     

A fluorescence labeling approach to assess the deterioration state of aged papers

Deterioration of historical papers is caused by several processes, such as acid hydrolysis or autoxidation due to the presence of metal ions contained in inks or pigments. Both processes can be studied by fluorescence labeling of carbonyl and carboxyl groups in combination with GPC-MALLS. This technique allows to determine not only the extent of hydrolysis, but also the concentration of oxidized functionalities within very low sample amounts.The thermally induced aging of rag papers with lines of copper pigment has been investigated, simulating green or blue copper pigments in historic wall papers. The cellulose parts with pigment coverage and adjacent pigment-free regions were analyzed separately and compared to paper parts not affected by metal ions. The cellulose underneath and close to the applied pigment strokes was severely affected. Although there was no difference in the molecular weight distribution, distinct differences in the carbonyl and carboxyl content were observed. Copper ion migration is suggested to be one possible explanation for this observation as a strong correlation between distribution of copper ions and carbonyl groups was found. For the first time, a detailed examination of cellulose damage in spatial proximity to metal-containing pigment lines is thus presented.     

Iron gall ink-induced corrosion of cellulose: aging,degradation and stabilization. Part 2: application on historic sample material

Degradation of cellulose in historic paper by iron gall ink is a synergistic process of both, acid hydrolysis caused by acidic ink ingredients and oxidation catalyzed by free iron and/or copper ions. The interplay of both reactions was studied according to the CCOA method on historic paper samples. Only minute amounts (few mg) of the samples were required to obtain profiles of naturally present and oxidatively introduced carbonyl groups, which was done by group-selective fluorescence labeling in combination with determination of the molecular weight distribution by GPC-MALLS. In the present study naturally occurring degradation pathways in historic sample papers have been investigated. Different extents of oxidatitive degradation were shown for paper with and without ink. A typical pattern of the molecular weight distribution in naturally aged papers was identified, the peculiar feature being a distinctive shoulder in the region of low molecular weight, roughly between 25,000 and 5,000 g/mol corresponding to a DP between 150 and 30. This pattern was a typical attribute of degraded natural samples: any artificial aging procedures aimed at modeling natural aging processes must thus attempt to reproduce this feature. Although the historic samples had been more severely oxidized than model papers, the inhibition of further oxidation and hydrolysis by the calcium phytate/hydrogen carbonate treatment was evident and could be proven for the first time on the molecular level. Also on plain paper without ink application the oxidation was suppressed and the molecular weight was stabilized on a high level.     

Interactions in iron gall inks

Simple iron gall inks composed of gallic acid, ferrous sulfate, and gum arabic and in some cases also of copper(II) sulfate were prepared. The process of iron ion complex formation with gallic acid was investigated using UV-VIS spectroscopy, pH measurements, and by monitoring the concentration changes of Fe(II) ions. The admixture of Fe(II) ions to gallic acid induced a bathochromic shift of absorption bands at 215 nm and 265 nm in the UV-VIS spectra. Formation of a new absorbance band in the visible area was also observed and used to calculate the initial rate of complex formation. Concurrently, the pH values and the concentration of Fe(II) ions in the solution decreased. Gum arabic significantly enhanced the complex formation and its stability. On the contrary, the addition of Cu(II) ions to the solution decelerated the complex formation considerably. Dedicated to Professor L’ubomír Lapčík, DrSc., in honor of his 70th birthday     

Establishing the irradiation dose for paper decontamination

Museums, libraries and archives are preserving documents that are slowly degrading due to the inherent ageing of the cellulose substrate or to the technological errors of the past (acid paper, iron gall ink). Beside this, large quantities of paper are rapidly damaged by biological attacks following natural disasters and improper storage conditions.The treatment of paper documents with ionizing radiation can be used for mass decontamination of cultural heritage items but conservators and restaurators are still reserved because of the radiation induced degradation.We conducted a study for establishing the dose needed for the effective treatment of paper documents, taking into account the biological burden and the irradiation effects on paper structure. We used physical testing specific to paper industry and less destructive analytical methods (thermal analysis).Our results show that an effective treatment can be performed with doses lower than 10 kGy. Old paper appears to be less affected by gamma radiation than recent paper but the sampling is highly affected by the non-uniform degree of the initial degradation status. The extent of testing for degradation and the magnitude of acceptable degradation should take into account the biological threat and the expected life time of the paper documents.     

Chemical and statistical characterization of selected documents from the archives of the Palazzo Ducale (Venice, Italy)

Inks and paper are the main materials and components of library and archive collections. Since the beginning of paper and ink production empirical recipes have been followed, but in the 19th century with the transformation of Europe during the Industrial Revolution, the continent became the main leader for the discovery of new products and new industrial production processes. The aim of this study is to shed light on paper and ink production processes during this key historical period. In this study we have chosen some documents preserved in the archive of the Soprintendenza dei Beni Architettonici e Paesaggistici (B.A.P.) di Venezia e Laguna, held in the Palazzo Ducale (Ducal Palace) of Venice. Attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FT-IR), and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) allowed us to obtain a qualitative and quantitative characterization of the organic and inorganic components in both paper and inks. Cluster analysis and principal component analysis (PCA) were employed for statistical analysis of the results.     

Paper conservation methods: a literature review

The main paper conservation methods are presented, classified in the following categories: preparation of the intervention, disinfestation and disinfection/sterilization, surface/dry cleaning, wet cleaning, chemical stabilization, paper repairs, consolidation and strengthening. Treatment documentation is also discussed. The targets, the historical aspects, the general principles, the materials and equipment, the acceptance and criticism pertaining to each method are briefly reviewed, and the most important research for their evaluation is presented. Several paper stabilization strategies, such as deacidification and iron gall ink stabilization, applicable to paper are elucidated. Specific consolidation and strengthening methods for paper, such as lamination and paper splitting are also discussed. The review mainly focuses on the established methods, but experimental, abandoned or insufficiently documented methods are also included. Shortcomings and limitations of several methods were found in the literature, concerning health issues, limited effectiveness, adverse side-effects on the treated artefacts and restricted applicability.     

Applications of electrospray laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry for document examination

We have employed electrospray laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry (ELDI‐MS) to rapidly characterize certain classes of compounds – the inks within the characters made by inks and inkjet printer on regular paper and the chemical compounds within thermal papers. This ELDI‐MS approach allowed the ink and paper samples to be distinguished in terms of their chemical compositions. Sample pretreatment was unnecessary and the documents were practically undamaged after examination. The ink chemicals on the documents were desorbed through laser irradiation (sampling spot area: <100 µm²); the desorbed molecules then entered an electrospray plume – prepared from an acidic methanol/water solution (50%) – where they became ionized through fusion or ion‐molecule reactions with the charged solvent species and droplets in the plume. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.