Repair of (6‐4) Lesions in DNA by (6‐4) Photolyase: 20 Years of Quest for the Photoreaction Mechanism

Exposure of DNA to ultraviolet (UV) light from the Sun or from other sources causes the formation of harmful and carcinogenic crosslinks between adjacent pyrimidine nucleobases, namely cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and pyrimidine(6–4)pyrimidone photoproducts. Nature has developed unique flavoenzymes, called DNA photolyases, that utilize blue light, that is photons of lower energy than those of the damaging light, to repair these lesions. In this review, we focus on the chemically challenging repair of the (6–4) photoproducts by (6–4) photolyase and describe the major events along the quest for the reaction mechanisms, over the 20 years since the discovery of (6‐4) photolyase.     

Quantum Chemical Study of the Enzymatic Repair of T(6‐4)C/C(6‐4)T UV‐Photolesions by DNA Photolyases

Several strategies have evolved to repair one of the abundant UV radiation‐induced damages caused to DNA, namely the mutagenic pyrimidine (6‐4) pyrimidone photolesions. DNA (6‐4)‐photolyases are enzymes repairing these lesions by a photoinitiated electron transfer. An important aspect of a possible repair mechanism is its generality and transferability to different (6‐4) lesions. Therefore, previously suggested mechanisms for the repair of the T(6‐4)T lesion are here transferred to the T(6‐4)C and C(6‐4)T lesions and investigated theoretically using quantum chemical methods. Despite the different functional groups of the pyrimidine bases involved, a general valid molecular mechanism was identified, in which the initial step is an electron transfer coupled to a proton transfer from the protonated HIS365 to the N3^′ nitrogen of the 3^′ pyrimidine, followed by an intramolecular OH/NH₂ transfer in one concerted step, which does not require an oxetane/azetidine or isolated water/ammonia intermediate.     

Photoreactivation of cyclobutane dimers and (6-4) photoproducts in the epidermis of the marsupial, Monodelphis domestica

Radioimmunoassays were used to investigate the repair of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and pyrimidine (6-4)pyrimidone photoproducts ((6-4] photoproducts) in the epidermis of the South American opossum, Monodelphis domestica. In the absence of photoreactivating light, both types of photodamage were excised with similar kinetics, 50% of the damage remaining 8 h after UV irradiation in vivo. Exposure of UV-irradiated skin to photoreactivating light resulted in removal of most of the cyclobutane dimers and an enhanced rate of (6-4) photoproduct repair. Photoenhanced excision repair of non-dimer damage increases the range of biologically effective lesions removed by in vivo photoreactivation.     

Insights into Light‐driven DNA Repair by Photolyases: Challenges and Opportunities for Electronic Structure Theory

Ultraviolet radiation causes two of the most abundant mutagenic and cytotoxic DNA lesions: cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and 6‐4 photoproducts. (6‐4) Photolyases are light‐activated enzymes that selectively bind to DNA and trigger repair of mutagenic 6‐4 photoproducts via photoinduced electron transfer from flavin adenine dinucleotide anion (FADH^?) to the lesion triggering repair. This review provides an overview of the sequential steps of the repair process, that is light absorption and resonance energy transfer, photoinduced electron transfer and electron‐induced splitting mechanisms, with an emphasis on the role of theory and computation. In addition, theoretical calculations and physical properties that can be used to classify specific mechanism are discussed in an effort to trace the fundamental aspects of each individual step and assist the interpretation of experimental data. The current challenges and suggested future directions are outlined for each step, concluding with a view on the future.     

Photoreactivating Enzyme for (6–4) Photoproducts in Cultured Goldfish Cells

We previously reported that when cultured goldfish cells are illuminated with fluorescent light, photorepair ability for both cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and (6–4) photoproducts increased. In the present study, it was found that the duration of the induced photorepair ability for cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers was longer than that for (6–4) photoproducts, suggesting the presence of different photolyases for repair of these two major forms of DNA damage. A gel shift assay was then performed to show the presence of protein(s) binding to (6–4) photoproducts and its dissociation from (6–4) photoproducts under fluorescent light illumination. In addition, at 8 h after fluorescent light illumination of the cell, the binding of pro-tein(s) to (6–4) photoproducts increased. The restriction enzymes that have recognition sites containing TT or TC sequences failed to digest the UV-irradiated DNA pho-toreactivated by using Escherichia coli photolyase for cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers, indicating that restriction enzymes could not function because (6–4) photoproducts remained in recognition sites. But, when UV-irradiated DNA depleted of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers was incubated with extract of cultured goldfish cells under fluorescent light illumination, it was digested with those restriction enzymes. These results suggested the presence of (6–4) photolyase in cultured goldfish cells as in Dro-sophila, Xenopus and Crotalus.     

N4‐Methylation of Cytosine Drastically Favors the Formation of (6‐4) Photoproducts in a TCG Context

Methylation of cytosine is a common biological process both in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. In addition to 5‐methylcytosine (5mC), some bacterial species contain in their genome N⁴‐methylcytosine (N4mC). Methylation at C5 has been shown to enhance the formation of pyrimidine dimeric photoproducts but nothing is known of the effect of N4 methylation on UV‐induced DNA damage. In the present work, we compared the yield and the nature of bipyrimidine photoproducts induced in a series of trinucleotides exhibiting a TXG sequence where X is either T, C, 5mC or N4mC. HPLC associated to tandem mass spectrometry was used to quantify cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD), (6‐4) photoproducts (64PP) and their Dewar valence isomer. Methylation at position N4 was found to drastically increase the reactivity of C upon exposure to both UVC and UVB and to favor the formation of 64PP. In contrast methylation at C5 increased the yield of CPD at the expense of 64PP. In addition, enhancement of photoreactivity by C5 methylation was much higher in the UVB than in the UVC range. These results show the drastic effect of the methylation site on the photochemistry of cytosine.     

The relative cytotoxicity of (6-4) photoproducts and cyclobutane dimers in mammalian cells

Abstract— The significance of the pyrimidine(6-4)pyrimidone photoproduct in mammalian cell killing is considered. Photochemical data indicate that the(6–4) photoproduct is induced at a substantial frequency compared to the cyclobutane dimer and that the action spectra for the induction of both lesions are equivalent. The repair of(6–4) photoproducts in various normal and UV-hypcrsensitive mammalian cell lines, including several recently derived somatic cell hybrids and transformants, is presented. The sensitivity of these cells to ultraviolet irradiation correlates better with the capacity to repair(6–4) photoproducts than cyclobutane dimers. These data are used to support that idea that the(6–4) photoproduct is one of the major cytotoxic lesions induced in DNA by ultraviolet light.     

The (6–4) Dimeric Lesion as a DNA Photosensitizer

The front cover artwork is provided by Miguel A. Miranda and co‐workers at Instituto de Tecnología Química (UPV‐CSIC). The image shows that (6–4) photoproducts, primary UVB dimeric lesions, act as photosensitizers of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers that are produced as secondary DNA lesions. Read the full text of the article at 10.1002/cphc.201600154 .     

Targeted Inactivation of DNA Photolyase Genes in Medaka Fish (Oryzias latipes)

Proteins of the cryptochrome/photolyase family (CPF) exhibit sequence and structural conservation, but their functions are divergent. Photolyase is a DNA repair enzyme that catalyzes the light‐dependent repair of ultraviolet (UV)‐induced photoproducts, whereas cryptochrome acts as a photoreceptor or circadian clock protein. Two types of DNA photolyase exist: CPD photolyase, which repairs cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs), and 6‐4 photolyase, which repairs 6‐4 pyrimidine–pyrimidone photoproducts (6‐4PPs). Although the Cry‐DASH protein is classified as a cryptochrome, it also has light‐dependent DNA repair activity. To determine the significance of the three light‐dependent repair enzymes in recovering from solar UV‐induced DNA damage at the organismal level, we generated mutants in each gene in medaka using the CRISPR genome editing technique. The light‐dependent repair activity of the mutants was examined in vitro in cultured cells and in vivo in skin tissue. Light‐dependent repair of CPD was lost in the CPD photolyase‐deficient mutant, whereas weak repair activity against 6‐4PPs persisted in the 6‐4 photolyase‐deficient mutant. These results suggest the existence of a heretofore unknown 6‐4PP repair pathway and thus improve our understanding of the mechanisms of defense against solar UV in vertebrates.     

PREFERENTIAL INHIBITION OF NUCLEOSOME ASSEMBLY BY ULTRAVIOLET-INDUCED (6-4)PHOTOPRODUCTS

We reconstituted nucleosomes in vitro using two kinds of damaged pBR322 plasmid DNA carrying cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) or (6-4)photoproducts. The results indicate that nucleosome assembly is inhibited preferentially by (6-4)photoproducts compared with CPD, suggesting that the regions carrying (6-4)photoproducts retain their nucleosome-free form, i.e. linker-like conformation until completion of the repair processes.     

Crystal Structures of Bacterial (6‐4) Photolyase Mutants with Impaired DNA Repair Activity

PhrB from Agrobacterium fabrum is the first prokaryotic photolyase which repairs (6‐4) UV DNA photoproducts. The protein harbors three cofactors: the enzymatically active FAD chromophore, a second chromophore, 6,7‐dimethyl‐8‐ribityllumazine (DMRL) and a cubane‐type Fe‐S cluster. Tyr424 of PhrB is part of the DNA‐binding site and could provide an electron link to the Fe‐S cluster. The PhrB_Y424F mutant showed reduced binding of lesion DNA and loss of DNA repair. The mutant PhrB_I51W is characterized by the loss of the DMRL chromophore, reduced photoreduction and reduced DNA repair capacity. We have determined the crystal structures of both mutants and found that both mutations only affect local protein environments, whereas the overall fold remained unchanged. The crystal structure of PhrB_Y424F revealed a water network extending to His366, which are part of the lesion‐binding site. The crystal structure of PhrB_I51W shows how the bulky Trp leads to structural rearrangements in the DMRL chromophore pocket. Spectral characterizations of PhrB_I51W suggest that DMRL serves as an antenna chromophore for photoreduction and DNA repair in the wild type. The energy transfer from DMRL to FAD could represent a phylogenetically ancient process.     

Relative Contributions of UVB and UVA to the Photoconversion of (6‐4) Photoproducts into their Dewar Valence Isomers

Dewar valence isomers are photoisomerization products of pyrimidine (6‐4) pyrimidone photoproducts, a major class of UV‐induced DNA lesions, which exhibits a maximal absorption around 320 nm. However, Dewar isomers are not produced in significant amounts in cells exposed to biologically relevant doses of UVB. In contrast, they are readily produced when cells are exposed to a combination of UVA and UVB. The present computational work demonstrates that, on the basis of known absorption properties and formation quantum yields, the difference in Dewar formation between the two types of radiation can be explained by the role of normal bases. In the UVB range, at the low level of (6‐4) photoproducts present in cells exposed to realistic doses, normal bases are present in overwhelming amounts and absorb the vast majority of the incident photons. In contrast, the absorption of DNA bases is much weaker in the UVA range while that of (6‐4) photoproducts is still significant, making photoisomerization possible. This two‐photon process makes it difficult to define an action spectrum for the formation of Dewar isomers.     

Repair of a Dimeric Azetidine Related to the Thymine–Cytosine (6‐4) Photoproduct by Electron Transfer Photoreduction

Photolyases are intriguing enzymes that take advantage of sunlight to restore lesions like cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers or (6‐4) photoproducts. This work focused on the photoreductive process responsible for splitting of the azetidine ring proposed to occur during (6‐4) photoproduct repair at a thymine–cytosine sequence. A model compound formed by photocycloaddition between thymine and 6‐azauracil has been designed to mimic the elusive azetidine intermediate. The photoinduced electron transfer process has been investigated by means of steady‐state and time‐resolved fluorescence using photosensitizers with oxidation potentials in the singlet excited state ranging from ?3.3 to ?2.1 V vs. SCE. Azetidine ring splitting and recovery of “repaired” bases were proven by HPLC analysis.     

THE BIOLOGY OF THE (6–4) PHOTOPRODUCT

The (6-4) photoproduct is an important determinant of the lethal and mutagenic effects of UV irradiation of biological systems. The removal of this lesion appears to correlate closely with the early DNA repair responses of mammalian cells, including DNA incision events, repair synthesis and removal of replication blocks. The processing of (6-4) photoproducts and cyclobutane dimers appears to be enzymatically coupled in bacteria and most mammalian cell lines examined (i.e. a mutation affecting the repair of one lesion also often affects the other), although exceptions exist in which repair capacity may be evident for one photoproduct and not the other (e.g. UV61 and the XP revertant cell line). These differences in the processing of the two photoproducts in some cell lines of human and rodent origin suggest that in mammalian cells, different pathways for the repair of (6-4) photoproducts and cyclobutane dimers may be used. This observation is further supported by pleiotropic repair phenotypes such as those observed in CHO complementation class 2 mutants (e.g., UV5, UVL-1, UVL-13, and V-H1). Indirect data, from HCR of UV irradiated reported genes and the cytotoxic responses of UV61, suggest that the (6-4) photoproduct is cytotoxic in mammalian cells and may account for 20 to 30% of the cell killing after UV irradiation of rodent cells. Cytotoxicity of the (6-4) photoproduct may be important in the etiology of sunlight-induced carcinogenesis, affecting mutagenesis as well as tumorigenesis. The intricate photochemistry of the (6-4) photoproduct, its formation and photoisomerization, is in itself extremely interesting and may also be relevant to sunlight carcinogenesis. The data reviewed in this article support the notion that the (6-4) photoproduct and its Dewar photoisomer are important cytotoxic determinants of UV light. The idea that the (6-4) photoproduct is an important component in the spectrum of UV-induced cytotoxic damage may help clarify our understanding of why rodent cells survive the effects of UV irradiation as well as human cells, without apparent cyclobutane dimer repair in the bulk of their DNA. The preferential repair of cyclobutane dimers in essential genes has been proposed to account for this observation (Bohr et al., 1985, 1986; Mellon et al., 1986). The data reviewed here suggest that understanding the repair of a prominent type of noncyclobutane dimer damage, the (6-4) photoproduct, may also be important in resolving this paradox.     

THE EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE AND WAVELENGTH ON PRODUCTION AND PHOTOLYSIS OF A UV-INDUCED PHOTOSENSITIVE DNA LESION WHICH IS NOT REPAIRED IN XERODERMA PIGMENTOSUM VARIANT CELLS

Abstract— Ultraviolet light causes a type of damage to the DNA of human cells that results in a DNA strand break upon subsequent irradiation with wavelengths around 300 nm. This DNA damage disappears from normal human fibroblasts within 5 h, but not from pyrimidine dimer excision repair deficient xeroderma pigmentosum group A cells or from excision proficient xeroderma pigmentosum variant cells. The apparent lack of repair of the ultraviolet light DNA damage described here may contribute to the cancer prone nature of xeroderma pigmentosum variant individuals. These experiments show that the same amount of damage was produced at 0^°C and 37^°C indicating a photodynamic effect and not an enzymatic reaction. The disappearance of the photosensitive lesions from the DNA is probably enzymatic since none of the damage was removed at 0^°C. Both the formation of the lesion and its photolysis by near ultraviolet light were wavelength dependent. An action spectrum for the formation of photosensitive lesions was similar to that for the formation of pyrimidine dimers and(6–4) photoproducts and included wavelengths found in sunlight. The DNA containing the lesions was sensitive to wavelengths from 304 to 340 nm with a maximum at 313 to 317 nm. This wavelength dependence of photolysis is similar to the absorption and photolysis spectra of the pyrimidine(6–4) photoproducts     

REPAIR OF CYCLOBUTANE DIMERS AND (6–4) PHOTOPRODUCTS IN ICR 2A FROG CELLS

Abstract— The removal of cyclobutane dimers and Pyr(6–4)Pyo photoproducts from the DNA of UV-irradiated ICR 2A frog cells was determined by radioimmunoassay. In the absence of photoreactivat-ing light, 15% of the cyclobutane dimers and 60% of the (6–4) photoproducts were removed 24 h post-irradiation with 10 J m⁻², Exposure to 30 kJ m⁻² photoreactivating light resulted in removal of 80% of the cyclobutane dimers and an enhanced rate of repair of (6–4) photoproducts, resulting in a loss of 50% of these lesions in 3 h. The preferential removal of (6–4) photoproducts by excision repair resembles previously published data for mammalian cells.     

Photolyase: Dynamics and Mechanisms of Repair of Sun‐Induced DNA Damage

Photolyase, a photomachine discovered half a century ago for repair of sun‐induced DNA damage of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) and pyrimidine (6‐4) pyrimidone photoproducts (6‐4PPs), has been characterized extensively in biochemistry (function), structure and dynamics since 1980s. The molecular mechanism and repair photocycle have been revealed at the most fundamental level. Using femtosecond spectroscopy, we have mapped out the entire dynamical evolution and determined all actual timescales of the catalytic processes. Here, we review our recent efforts in studies of the dynamics of DNA repair by photolyases. The repair of CPDs in three life kingdoms includes seven electron transfer (ET) reactions among 10 elementary steps through initial bifurcating ET pathways, a direct tunneling route and a two‐step hopping path both through an intervening adenine from the cofactor to CPD, with a conserved folded structure at the active site. The repair of 6‐4PPs is challenging and requires similar ET reactions and a new cyclic proton transfer with a conserved histidine residue at the active site of (6‐4) photolyases. Finally, we also summarize our efforts on multiple intraprotein ET of photolyases in different redox states and such mechanistic studies are critical to the functional mechanism of homologous cryptochromes of blue‐light photoreceptors.     

2‐Amino‐4‐chloro‐5‐formyl‐6‐[methyl(2‐methylphenyl)amino]pyrimidine and 2‐amino‐4‐chloro‐5‐formyl‐6‐[(2‐methoxyphenyl)methylamino]pyrimidine are isostructural and form hydrogen‐bonded sheets of R22(8) and R66(32) rings

2‐Amino‐4‐chloro‐5‐formyl‐6‐[methyl(2‐methylphenyl)amino]pyrimidine, C₁₃H₁₃ClN₄O, (I), and 2‐amino‐4‐chloro‐5‐formyl‐6‐[(2‐methoxyphenyl)methylamino]pyrimidine, C₁₃H₁₃ClN₄O₂, (II), are isostructural and essentially isomorphous. Although the pyrimidine rings in each compound are planar, the ring‐substituent atoms show significant displacements from this plane, and the bond distances provide evidence for polarization of the electronic structures. In each compound, a combination of N—H...N and N—H...O hydrogen bonds links the molecules into sheets built from centrosymmetric R₂²(8) and R₆⁶(32) rings. The significance of this study lies in its observation of the isostructural nature of (I) and (II), and in the comparison of their crystal and molecular structures with those of analogous compounds.     

UV INDUCED (6-4) PHOTOPRODUCTS ARE DISTRIBUTED DIFFERENTLY THAN CYCLOBUTANE DIMERS IN NUCLEOSOMES

We have compared the distributions of two stable UV photoproducts in nucleosome core DNA at the single-nucleotide level using a T4 polymerase-exonuclease mapping procedure. The distribution of pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) dimers was uncovered by reversing the major UV photo-product, cis-syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer, with E. coli DNA photolyase and photoreactivating light. Whereas the distribution of total UV photoproducts in nucleosome core DNA forms a striking 10.3 base periodic pattern, the distribution of (6-4) dimers is much more random throughout the nucleosome core domain. Therefore, histone-DNA interactions in nucleosomes strongly modulate formation of the major class of UV-induced photoproducts, while having either a constant effect or no effect on (6-4) dimer formation.