Effect of polarization on the opsin shift in rhodopsins. 2. Empirical polarization models for proteins

The explicit treatment of polarization as a many-body interaction in condensed-phase systems represents a current problem in empirical force-field development. Although a variety of efficient models for molecular polarization have been suggested, polarizable force fields are still far from common use nowadays. In this work, we consider interactive polarization models employing Thole's short-range damping scheme and assess them for application on polypeptides. Despite the simplicity of the model, we find mean polarizabilities and anisotropies of amino acid side chains in excellent agreement with MP2/cc-pVQZ benchmark calculations. Combined with restrained electrostatic potential (RESP) derived atomic charges, the models are applied in a quantum-mechanical/molecular-mechanical (QM/MM) approach. An iterative scheme is used to establish a self-consistent mutual polarization between the QM and MM moieties. This ansatz is employed to study the influence of the protein polarizability on calculated optical properties of the protonated Schiff base of retinal in rhodopsin (Rh), bacterio-rhodopsin (bR), and pharaonis sensory rhodopsin II (psRII). The shifts of the excitation energy due to the instantaneous polarization response of the protein to the charge transfer on the retinal chromophore are quantified using the high level ab initio multireference spectroscopy-oriented configuration interaction (SORCI) method. The results are compared with those of previously published QM1/QM2/MM models for bR and psRII.     

Incorporation of a QM/MM buffer zone in the variational double self-consistent field method

The explicit polarization (X-Pol) potential is an electronic-structure-based polarization force field, designed for molecular dynamics simulations and modeling of biopolymers. In this approach, molecular polarization and charge transfer effects are explicitly treated by a combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) scheme, and the wave function of the entire system is variationally optimized by a double self-consistent field (DSCF) method. In the present article, we introduce a QM buffer zone for a smooth transition from a QM region to an MM region. Instead of using the Mulliken charge approximation for all QM/MM interactions, the Coulombic interactions between the adjacent fragments are determined directly by electronic structure theory. The present method is designed to accelerate the speed of convergence of the total energy and charge density of the system.     

Flexible-boundary QM/MM calculations: II. Partial charge transfer across the QM/MM boundary that passes through a covalent bond

Recently, based on the principle of electronic chemical potential equalization and the principle of charge conservation, we proposed a flexible-boundary scheme that allows both partial charge transfer and self-consistent polarization between the quantum mechanical (QM) and molecular mechanical (MM) subsystems in QM/MM calculations; the scheme was applied to study the atomic charges in selected ion–solvent complexes. In the present contribution, we further extend the flexible-boundary treatment to handle the QM/MM boundary passing through covalent bonds. We find that the flexible-boundary redistributed charge and dipole schemes yield reasonable agreement with full-QM calculations for a number of molecular ions and amino acids with charged side chains. Using the full-QM results as reference, the mean unsigned deviations are computed to be 0.06 e for atomic partial charges of the QM atoms, 0.11 e for the amounts of charge transfer between the QM and MM subsystems, and 0.016 Å for the lengths of the covalent bonds that directly connect the QM and MM subsystems. The results indicate the importance of accounting for partial charge transfer across the QM/MM boundary when the QM subsystems are charged.     

Toward a consistent treatment of polarization in model QM/MM calculations

The concept of model chemistries within hybrid QM/MM calculations has been addressed through analysis of the polarization energy determined by two distinct approaches based on (i) induced charges and (ii) induced dipoles. The quantum mechanical polarization energy for four configurations of the water dimer has been determined for a range of basis sets using Morokuma energy decomposition analysis. This benchmark value has been compared to the fully classical polarization energy determined using the induced dipole approach, and the molecular mechanics polarization energy calculated using induced charges within the MM region of hybrid QM/MM calculations. From the water dimer calculations, it is concluded that the induced charge approach is consistent with medium sized basis set calculations whereas the induced dipole approach is consistent with large basis set calculations. This result is highly relevant to the concept of QM/MM model chemistries.     

Solvents effects on the mechanism of cellulose hydrolysis: A QM/MM study

This article reports a combined quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) investigation on the acid hydrolysis of cellulose in water using two different models, cellobiose and a 40‐unit cellulose chain. The explicitly treated solvent molecules strongly influence the conformations, intramolecular hydrogen bonds, and exoanomeric effects in these models. As these features are largely responsible for the barrier to cellulose hydrolysis, the present QM/MM results for the pathways and reaction intermediates in water are expected to be more realistic than those from a former density functional theory (DFT) study with implicit solvent (CPCM). However, in a qualitative sense, there is reasonable agreement between the DFT/CPCM and QM/MM predictions for the reaction mechanism. Differences arise mainly from specific solute–solvent hydrogen bonds that are only captured by QM/MM and not by DFT/CPCM. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Spectral tuning in visual pigments: an ONIOM(QM:MM) study on bovine rhodopsin and its mutants

We have investigated geometries and excitation energies of bovine rhodopsin and some of its mutants by hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations in ONIOM scheme, employing B3LYP and BLYP density functionals as well as DFTB method for the QM part and AMBER force field for the MM part. QM/MM geometries of the protonated Schiff-base 11- cis-retinal with B3LYP and DFTB are very similar to each other. TD-B3LYP/MM excitation energy calculations reproduce the experimental absorption maximum of 500 nm in the presence of native rhodopsin environment and predict spectral shifts due to mutations within 10 nm, whereas TD-BLYP/MM excitation energies have red-shift error of at least 50 nm. In the wild-type rhodopsin, Glu113 shifts the first excitation energy to blue and accounts for most of the shift found. Other amino acids individually contribute to the first excitation energy but their net effect is small. The electronic polarization effect is essential for reproducing experimental bond length alternation along the polyene chain in protonated Schiff-base retinal, which correlates with the computed first excitation energy. It also corrects the excitation energies and spectral shifts in mutants, more effectively for deprotonated Schiff-base retinal than for the protonated form. The protonation state and conformation of mutated residues affect electronic spectrum significantly. The present QM/MM calculations estimate not only the experimental excitation energies but also the source of spectral shifts in mutants.     

51V NMR chemical shifts calculated from QM/MM models of vanadium chloroperoxidase

(51)V NMR chemical shifts calculated from QM/MM-optimized (QM=quantum mechanical; MM=molecular mechanical) models of vanadium-dependent chloroperoxidase (VCPO) are presented. An extensive number of protonation states for the vanadium cofactor (active site of the protein) and a number of probable positional isomers for each of the protonation states are considered. The size of the QM region is increased incrementally to observe the convergence behavior of the (51)V NMR chemical shifts. A total of 40 models are assessed by comparison to experimental solid-state (51)V NMR results recently reported in the literature. Isotropic chemical shifts are found to be a poor indicator of the protonation state; however, anisotropic chemical shifts and the nuclear quadrupole tensors appear to be sensitive to changes in the proton environment of the vanadium nuclei. This detailed investigation of the (51)V NMR chemical shifts computed from QM/MM models provides further evidence that the ground state is either a triply protonated (one axial water and one equatorial hydroxyl group) or a doubly protonated vanadate moiety in VCPO. Particular attention is given to the electrostatic and geometric effects of the protein environment. This is the first study to compute anisotropic NMR chemical shifts from QM/MM models of an active metalloprotein for direct comparison with solid-state MAS NMR data. This theoretical approach enhances the potential use of experimental solid-state NMR spectroscopy for the structural determination of metalloproteins.     

Reliable treatment of electrostatics in combined QM/MM simulation of macromolecules

A robust approach for dealing with electrostatic interactions for spherical boundary conditions has been implemented in the QM/MM framework. The development was based on the generalized solvent boundary potential (GSBP) method proposed by Im et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 114, 2924 (2001)], and the specific implementation was applied to the self-consistent-charge density-functional tight-binding approach as the quantum mechanics (QM) level, although extension to other QM methods is straightforward. Compared to the popular stochastic boundary-condition scheme, the new protocol offers a balanced treatment between quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) and MM/MM interactions; it also includes the effect of the bulk solvent and macromolecule atoms outside of the microscopic region at the Poisson-Boltzmann level. The new method was illustrated with application to the enzyme human carbonic anhydrase II and compared to stochastic boundary-condition simulations using different electrostatic treatments. The GSBP-based QM/MM simulations were most consistent with available experimental data, while conventional stochastic boundary simulations yielded various artifacts depending on different electrostatic models. The results highlight the importance of carefully treating electrostatics in QM/MM simulations of biomolecules and suggest that the commonly used truncation schemes should be avoided in QM/MM simulations, especially in simulations that involve extensive conformational samplings. The development of the GSBP-based QM/MM protocol has opened up the exciting possibility of studying chemical events in very complex biomolecular systems in a multiscale framework.     

Combined QM/MM study of the opsin shift in bacteriorhodopsin

Combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations and molecular dynamics simulations of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in the membrane matrix have been carried out to determine the factors that make significant contributions to the opsin shift. We found that both solvation and interactions with the protein significantly shifts the absorption maximum of the retinal protonated Schiff base, but the effects are much more pronounced in polar solvents such as methanol, acetonitrile, and water than in the protein environment. The differential solvatochromic shifts of PSB in methanol and in bR leads to a bathochromic shift of about 1800 cm(-1). Because the combined QM/MM configuration interaction calculation is essentially a point charge model, this contribution is attributed to the extended point-charge model of Honig and Nakanishi. The incorporation of retinal in bR is accompanied by a change in retinal conformation from the 6-s-cis form in solution to the 6-s-trans configuration in bR. The extension of the pi-conjugated system further increases the red-shift by 2400 cm(-1). The remaining factors are due to the change in dispersion interactions. Using an estimate of about 1000 cm(-1) in the dispersion contribution by Houjou et al., we obtained a theoretical opsin shift of 5200 cm(-1) in bR, which is in excellent agreement with the experimental value of 5100 cm(-1). Structural analysis of the PSB binding site revealed the specific interactions that make contributions to the observed opsin shift. The combined QM/MM method used in the present study provides an opportunity to accurately model the photoisomerization and proton transfer reactions in bR.     

A critical evaluation of different QM/MM frontier treatments with SCC-DFTB as the QM method

The performance of different link atom based frontier treatments in QM/MM simulations was evaluated critically with SCC-DFTB as the QM method. In addition to the analysis of gas-phase molecules as in previous studies, an important element of the present work is that chemical reactions in realistic enzyme systems were also examined. The schemes tested include all options available in the program CHARMM for SCC-DFTB/MM simulation, which treat electrostatic interactions due to the MM atoms close to the QM/MM boundary in different ways. In addition, a new approach, the divided frontier charge (DIV), has been implemented in which the partial charge associated with the frontier MM atom ("link host") is evenly distributed to the other MM atoms in the same group. The performance of these schemes was evaluated based on properties including proton affinities, deprotonation energies, dipole moments, and energetics of proton transfer reactions. Similar to previous work, it was found that calculated proton affinities and deprotonation energies of alcohols, carbonic acids, amino acids, and model DNA bases are very sensitive to the link atom scheme; the commonly used single link atom approach often gives error on the order of 15 to 20 kcal/mol. Other schemes give better and, on average, mutually comparable results. For proton transfer reactions, encouragingly, both activation barriers and reaction energies are fairly insensitive (within a typical range of 2-4 kcal/mol) to the link atom scheme due to error cancellation, and this was observed for both gas-phase and enzyme systems. Therefore, the effect of using different link atom schemes in QM/MM simulations is rather small for chemical reactions that conserve the total charge. Although the current study used an approximate DFT method as the QM level, the observed trends are expected to be applicable to QM/MM methods with use of other QM approaches. This observation does not mean to encourage QM/MM simulations without careful benchmark in the study of specific systems, rather it emphasizes that other technical details, such as the treatment of long-range electrostatics, tend to play a more important role and need to be handled carefully.     

On the effect of a variation of the force field, spatial boundary condition and size of the QM region in QM/MM MD simulations

During the past years, the use of combined quantum-classical, QM/MM, methods for the study of complex biomolecular processes, such as enzymatic reactions and photocycles, has increased considerably. The quality of the results obtained from QM/MM calculations is largely dependent on five aspects to be considered when setting up a molecular model: the QM Hamiltonian, the MM Hamiltonian or force field, the boundary and coupling between the QM and MM regions, the size of the QM region and the boundary condition for the MM region. In this study, we systematically investigate the influence of a variation of the molecular mechanics force field and the size of the QM region in QM/MM MD simulations on properties of the photoactive part of the blue light photoreceptor protein AppA. For comparison, we additionally performed classical MD simulations and studied the effect of a variation of the type of spatial boundary condition. The classical boundary conditions and the force field used in a QM/MM MD simulation are shown to have non-neglegible effects upon the structural and energetic properties of the protein which makes it advisable to minimize computational artifacts in QM/MM MD simulations by application of periodic boundary conditions and a thermodynamically calibrated force field. A comparison of the structural and energetic properties of MD simulations starting from two alternative, different X-ray structures for the blue light utilizing flavin protein in its dark state indicates a slight preference of the two force fields used for the so-called Anderson structure over the Jung structure.     

Importance of accurate charges in molecular docking: quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) approach

The extent to which accuracy of electric charges plays a role in protein-ligand docking is investigated through development of a docking algorithm, which incorporates quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations. In this algorithm, fixed charges of ligands obtained from force field parameterization are replaced by QM/MM calculations in the protein environment, treating only the ligands as the quantum region. The algorithm is tested on a set of 40 cocrystallized structures taken from the Protein Data Bank (PDB) and provides strong evidence that use of nonfixed charges is important. An algorithm, dubbed "Survival of the Fittest" (SOF) algorithm, is implemented to incorporate QM/MM charge calculations without any prior knowledge of native structures of the complexes. Using an iterative protocol, this algorithm is able in many cases to converge to a nativelike structure in systems where redocking of the ligand using a standard fixed charge force field exhibits nontrivial errors. The results demonstrate that polarization effects can play a significant role in determining the structures of protein-ligand complexes, and provide a promising start towards the development of more accurate docking methods for lead optimization applications.