Light four-quark states and QCD sum rule

The relations among four-quark states, diquarks and QCD sum rules are discussed. The situation of the existing, but incomplete studies of four-quark states with QCD sum rules is analyzed. Masses of some diquark clusters were attempted to be determined by QCD sum rules, and masses of some light tetraquark states were obtained in terms of the diquarks.     

Light four-quark states and QCD sum rule

The relations among four-quark states, diquarks and QCD sum rules are discussed. The situation of the existing, but incomplete studies of four-quark states with QCD sum rules is analyzed. Masses of some diquark clusters were attempted to be determined by QCD sum rules, and masses of some light tetraquark states were obtained in terms of the diquarks.     

Scalar or Vector Tetraquark State Candidate: Z_c(4100)

In this article, we separate the vector and axialvector components of the tensor diquark operators explicitly,construct the axialvector-axialvector type and vector-vector type scalar tetraquark currents and scalar-tensor type tensor tetraquark current to study the scalar, vector and axialvector tetraquark states with the QCD sum rules in a consistent way. The present calculations do not favor assigning the Zc(4100) to be a scalar or vector tetraquark state. If the Zc(4100) is a scalar tetraquark state without mixing effects, it should have a mass about 3.9 GeV or 4.0 GeV rather than4.1 GeV; on the other hand, if the Zc(4100) is a vector tetraquark state, it should have a mass about 4.2 GeV rather than 4.1 GeV. However, if we introduce mixing, a mixing scalar tetraquark state can have a mass about 4.1 GeV. As a byproduct, we obtain an axialvector tetraquark candidate for the Zc(4020).     

AdS-QCD quark–antiquark potential,meson spectrum and tetraquarks

The AdS/QCD correspondence predicts the structure of the quark–antiquark potential in the static limit. We use this piece of information together with the Salpeter equation (Schrödinger equation with relativistic kinematics) and a short range hyperfine splitting potential to determine quark masses and the quark potential parameters from the meson spectrum. The agreement between theory and experimental data is satisfactory, provided one considers only mesons comprising at least one heavy quark. We use the same potential (in the one-gluon-exchange approximation) and these data to estimate the constituent diquark masses. Using these results as input we compute tetraquark masses using a diquark–antidiquark model. The masses of the states X(3872) or Y(3940) are predicted rather accurately. We also compute tetraquark masses with open charm and strangeness. Our result is that tetraquark candidates such as D _s (2317), D _s (2457) or X(2632) can hardly be interpreted as diquark–antidiquark states within the present approach.     

The ■ tetraquark states and the structure of X(2239) observed by the BESⅢ collaboration

We investigate the mass spectrum of the■tetraquark states in the relativized quark model.By solving the Schrodinger-like equation with the relativized potential,the masses of S-and P-wave■tetraquarks are obtained.The screening effects are also taken into account.It is found that the resonant structureX(2239)observed in thee+e-→K+K-process by the BESIII collaboration can be assigned as a P-wave 1--■tetraquark state.Furthermore,the radiative transition and the strong decay behavior of this structure are also estimated,which can provide helpful information for future experimental searches.     

Possible tetraquark states in the <Emphasis Type="Italic">π</Emphasis><Superscript>+</Superscript><Emphasis Type="Italic">χ</Emphasis><Subscript><Emphasis Type="Italic">c</Emphasis>1</Subscript> invariant-mass distribution

In this article, we assume that there exist hidden charmed tetraquark states with spin–parity J ^P=1⁻, and we calculate their masses with the QCD sum rules. The numerical result indicates that the masses of the vector hidden charmed tetraquark states are about M _Z =(5.12±0.15) GeV or M _Z =(5.16±0.16) GeV, which are inconsistent with the experimental data on the π ⁺ χ _c1 invariant-mass distribution. The hidden charmed mesons Z ₁, Z ₂ or Z may be scalar hidden charmed tetraquark states, hadro-charmonium resonances or molecular states.     

Why static bound-state calculations of tetraquarks should be met with scepticism

Recent experimental signals have led to a revival of tetraquarks,the hypothetical q~2q~2 hadronic states proposed by Jaffe in 1976 to explain the light scalar mesons.Mesonic structures with exotic quantum numbers have indeed been observed recently,though a controversy persists as to whether these are true resonances and not merely kinematical threshold enhancements,or otherwise states not of a true q~2q~2 nature.Moreover,puzzling non-exotic mesons are also often claimed to have a tetraquark configuration.However,the corresponding model calculations are practically always carried out in pure and static bound-state approaches,ignoring completely the coupling to asymptotic two-meson states and unitarity,especially the dynamical effects thereof.In this short paper we argue that these static predictions of real tetraquark masses are highly unreliable and provide little evidence of the very existence of such states.     

Reanalysis of the Z_c(4020), Z_c(4025), Z(4050) and Z(4250) as Tetraquark States with QCD Sum Rules

In this article, we calculate the contributions of the vacuum condensates up to dimension-10 in the operator product expansion, and study the C γμ- Cγνtype scalar, axial-vector and tensor tetraquark states in details with the QCD sum rules. In calculations, we use the formula μ = (M 2X/ Y /Z-(2Mc)2)~(1/2) to determine the energy scales of the QCD spectral densities. The predictions MJ =2=(4.02+0.09-0.09) GeV, MJ =1=(4.02+0.07-0.08) GeV favor assigning the Zc(4020) and Zc(4025) as the JP C= 1+-or 2++diquark-antidiquark type tetraquark states, while the prediction M++J =0=(3.85+0.15-0.09) GeV disfavors assigning the Z(4050) and Z(4250) as the JP C= 0diquark-antidiquark type tetraquark states. Furthermore, we discuss the strong decays of the 0++, 1+-, 2++diquark-antidiquark type tetraquark states in details.     

Analysis of the Z(4430) as the First Radial Excitation of the Z_c(3900)

In this article,we take the Zc(3900) and Z(4430) as the ground state and the first radial excited state of the axial-vector tetraquark states with J~(PC) = 1~(+-),respectively,and study their masses and pole residues with the QCD sum rules by calculating the contributions of the vacuum condensates up to dimension-10 in a consistent way in the operator product expansion.The numerical result favors assigning the Z_c(3900) and Z(4430) as the ground state and first radial excited state of the axial-vector tetraquark states,respectively.     

Reanalysis of the mass spectrum of the scalar hidden charm and hidden bottom tetraquark states

In this article, we study the mass spectrum of the scalar hidden charm and hidden bottom tetraquark states which consist of the axial-vector–axial-vector type and the vector–vector type diquark pairs with the QCD sum rules.     

Axialvector tetraquark candidates for Z_c(3900), Z_c(4020),Z_c(4430), and Z_c(4600)

We construct the axialvector and tensor current operators to systematically investigate the ground and first radially excited tetraquark states with quantum numbers J~(PC)= 1~(+-)using the QCD sum rules. We observe one axialvector tetraquark candidate for Z_c(3900) and Z_c(4430), two axialvector tetraquark candidates for the Z_c(4020), and three axialvector tetraquark candidates for Z_c(4600).     

QCD Coulomb gauge approach to exotic hadrons

The Coulomb gauge Hamiltonian model is used to calculate masses for selected J^PC states consisting of exotic combinations of quarks and gluons: ggg glueballs (oddballs), qˉg hybrid mesons and qˉqˉ tetraquark systems. An odderon Regge trajectory is computed for the J^- glueballs with intercept much smaller than the pomeron, explaining its nonobservation. The lowest 1^-+ hybrid-meson mass is found to be just above 2.2GeV while the lightest tetraquark state mass with these exotic quantum numbers is predicted around 1.4GeV consistent with the observed π(1400).     

Relativistic description of heavy tetraquarks

The masses of the ground-state and excited heavy tetraquarks with hidden charm and bottom are calculated within the relativistic diquark-antidiquark picture. The dynamics of the light quark in a heavy-light diquark is treated completely relativistically. The diquark structure is taken into account by calculating the diquark-gluon form factor. New experimental data on charmonium-like states above the open charm threshold are discussed. The obtained results indicate that X(3872), Y(4260), Y(4360), Z(4433), and Y(4660) can be tetraquark states with hidden charm. The text was submitted by the authors in English.     

Three-body force and the tetraquark interpretation of light scalar mesons

We study the possible tetraquark interpretation of light scalar meson states a0(980), f0(980), κ,σ within the framework of the non-relativistic potential model. The wave functions of tetraquark states are obtained in a space spanned by multiple Gaussian functions. We find that the mass spectra of the light scalar mesons can be well accommodated in the tetraquark picture if we introduce a three-body quark interaction in the quark model. Using the obtained multiple Gaussian wave functions, the decay constants of tetraquarks are also calculated within the "fall apart" mechanism.     

Possible Heavy Tetraquarks qQqQ,qqQQ and qQQQ

Assuming X(3872) is a qcqc tetraquark and using its mass as input, we perform a schematic study of the masses of possible heavy tetraquarks using the color-magnetic interaction with the flavor symmetry breaking corrections.     

Excited heavy tetraquarks with hidden charm

The masses of the excited heavy tetraquarks with hidden charm are calculated within the relativistic diquark–antidiquark picture. The dynamics of the light quark in a heavy–light diquark is treated completely relativistically. The diquark structure is taken into account by calculating the diquark–gluon form factor. New experimental data on charmonium-like states above open charm threshold are discussed. The obtained results indicate that X(3872), Y(4260), Y(4360), Z(4248), Z(4433) and Y(4660) could be tetraquark states with hidden charm.     

Analysis of the tetraquark and hexaquark molecular states with the QCD sum rules

In this article, we construct the color-singlet-color-singlet type currents and the color-singlet-colorsinglet-color-singlet type currents to study the scalar D*■*, D*D* tetraquark molecular states and the vector D*D*■*, D*D*D* hexaquark molecular states with the QCD sum rules in details. In calculations, we choose the pertinent energy scales of the QCD spectral densities with the energy scale formula ■for the tetraquark and hexaquark molecular states respectively in a consistent way. We obtain stable QCD sum rules for the scalar D*■*, D*D*tetraquark molecular states and the vector D*D*■* hexaquark molecular state, but cannot obtain stable QCD sum rules for the vector D*D*D* hexaquark molecular state. The connected(nonfactorizable)Feynman diagrams at the tree level(or the lowest order) and their induced diagrams via substituting the quark lines make positive contributions for the scalar D*D* tetraquark molecular state, but make negative or destructive contributions for the vector D*D*D* hexaquark molecular state. It is of no use or meaningless to distinguish the factorizable and nonfactorizable properties of the Feynman diagrams in the color space in the operator product expansion so as to interpret them in terms of the hadronic observables, we can only obtain information about the short-distance and long-distance contributions.     

Vector tetraquark state candidates: <Emphasis Type="Italic">Y</Emphasis>(4260 / 4220), <Emphasis Type="Italic">Y</Emphasis>(4360 / 4320), <Emphasis Type="Italic">Y</Emphasis>(4390) and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Y</Emphasis>(4660 / 4630)

In this article, we construct the \(C \otimes \gamma _\mu C\) and \(C\gamma _5 \otimes \gamma _5\gamma _\mu C\) type currents to interpolate the vector tetraquark states, then carry out the operator product expansion up to the vacuum condensates of dimension-10 in a consistent way, and obtain four QCD sum rules. In calculations, we use the formula \(\mu =\sqrt{M^2_{Y}-(2{\mathbb {M}}_c)^2}\) to determine the optimal energy scales of the QCD spectral densities, moreover, we take the experimental values of the masses of the Y(4260 / 4220), Y(4360 / 4320), Y(4390) and Y(4660 / 4630) as input parameters and fit the pole residues to reproduce the correlation functions at the QCD side. The numerical results support assigning the Y(4660 / 4630) to be the \(C \otimes \gamma _\mu C\) type vector tetraquark state \(c\bar{c}s\bar{s}\), assigning the Y(4360 / 4320) to be \(C\gamma _5 \otimes \gamma _5\gamma _\mu C\) type vector tetraquark state \(c\bar{c}q\bar{q}\), and disfavor assigning the Y(4260 / 4220) and Y(4390) to be the pure vector tetraquark states.     

可能的qQqQ,qqQQ和qQQQ重四夸克态

假设X(3872)是一个qcqc四夸克态, 并用它的质量作为输入, 用具有味对称性破坏的色磁相互作用系统研究了可能的重四夸克态的质量谱.     

Mass spectrum of the axial-vector hidden charmed and hidden bottom tetraquark states

In this article, we perform a systematic study of the mass spectrum of the axial-vector hidden charmed and hidden bottom tetraquark states using the QCD sum rules, and identify the Z ⁺(4430) as an axial-vector tetraquark state tentatively.