Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve Electrophysiologic Monitoring in Thyroid Surgery: The Standard of Care?

Reports in the literature suggest that the rate of transient and permanent vocal fold immobility (VFI) after thyroid surgery is 4% to 7% and 1% to 4%. The intraoperative use of nerve integrity monitors has been advocated to reduce the incidence of VFI during thyroid surgery. The purpose of this study was to compare postoperative VFI after unmonitored and monitored thyroid surgical procedures. The charts of 136 consecutive patients who underwent thyroid surgery from 1998 to 2003 were retrospectively surveyed. Fifty-four patients had total thyroidectomies, bringing the total recurrent laryngeal nerves (RLNs) dissected to 190. Three of 190 (1.6%) and 7 of 190 (3.7%) RLNs dissected had permanent and transient vocal fold dysfunction. Overall, 107 RLNs were unmonitored compared with 83 RLNs that were monitored. Unmonitored and monitored RLNs had a 4 of 83 (4.8%) versus 3 of 107 (2.8%) rate of transient VFI (P > 0.05). Unmonitored and monitored RLNs had a 1 of 107 (0.9%) versus 2 of 83 (2.4%) rate of permanent VFD (P > 0.05). Electrophysiologic RLN monitoring was not demonstrated in this study to reduce the incidence of transient or permanent VFI after thyroid surgery. Electrophysiologic RLN integrity does not always translate into clinical postoperative vocal fold mobility. Electrophysiologic RLN monitoring may support that the RLN was not severed in the patient with postoperative VFI.     

Comparing the Long-Term Outcome of Immediate Postoperative Facial Nerve Dysfunction and Vocal Fold Immobility After Parotid and Thyroid Surgery

SUMMARY: Hypothesis: The long-term recovery rate of immediate postoperative facial nerve dysfunction with an electrophysiologically and anatomically intact facial nerve is higher than the long-term recovery rate of immediate postoperative vocal fold immobility with an electrophysiologically and anatomically intact recurrent laryngeal nerve. Methods: A retrospective review of parotid and thyroid surgery with electrophysiologic monitoring of the facial and recurrent laryngeal nerves, respectively. Results: Forty-five consecutive patients had electrophysiologic and anatomic integrity of the facial nerve at the conclusion of the parotidectomy. Eight of 45 (18%) patients developed a postoperative facial nerve dysfunction. All eight patients with facial nerve dysfunction had complete return of facial nerve function within 3 months. A total of 102 consecutive patients underwent dissection of the recurrent laryngeal nerve during thyroid surgery. Seven of 102 (7%) had immediate unilateral vocal fold dysfunction. All 102 had electrophysiologic and anatomic integrity of the recurrent laryngeal nerve at the conclusion of the procedure. Two of 102 (2%) have clinically complete permanent vocal fold dysfunction. Five of seven (71%) with immediate complete vocal fold immobility had complete return of mobility. Conclusions: A higher immediate postoperative rate of transient facial nerve dysfunction is reported compared with vocal fold immobility in parotid and thyroid surgery, respectively (P < 0.05). Immediate postoperative facial nerve dysfunction with an electrophysiologically response at 1 mA and an anatomically intact facial nerve during parotid surgery resulted in a complete return of function in all cases in this series. Immediate postoperative vocal fold immobility with an electrophysiological response at 1 mA and an anatomically intact recurrent laryngeal nerve had a 30% rate of being permanent in this series.     

Sarcoidosis Presenting as Bilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis

Sarcoidosis with cranial polyneuritis and mediastinal granulomatous compression as a cause of unilateral left vocal fold paralysis has been reported infrequently. No case of sarcoidosis causing bilateral vocal fold paralysis in the abducted position has been reported in the Otolaryngology/Voice literature. Vocal fold function can be impacted in sarcoidosis by direct laryngeal involvement or by neural pathways. In the patient described in this case, sarcoid cranial polyneuritis coupled with bilateral paratracheal and mediastinal adenopathy resulted in bilateral vocal fold paralysis. This patient had a dramatic response to treatment with steroids. Sarcoidosis should be included in the differential diagnosis of unilateral or bilateral vocal fold paralysis.     

Vocal fold microsurgery in singers

Some singers with benign vocal fold mucosal lesions remain unacceptably impaired vocally in spite of compliance with a regimen of medical treatment and voice therapy lasting several months—or even years. I present here my experience with 62 singers who, because of this predicament, chose to undergo vocal fold microsurgery. This series is the second largest reported to date in English literature. Procedures are presented which were used for patient selection, education, and vocal retraining, as well as for surgery itself and postoperative care. Results reported here include (a) comparison of my auditory-perceptual ratings of singing voice impairment before and after surgery, (b) preoperative versus postoperative videostroboscopic findings, (c) postoperative rate of return to public singing, and (d) postoperative patient questionnaires which sought to uncover patient/singer perceptions of the results of vocal fold surgery. Excellent results were achieved overall with a very low incidence of untoward results, and no complications were encountered.     

Thyroplasty as primary and adjunctive treatment of glottic insufficiency

This study addresses the role of medialization thyroplasty in a variety of vocal fold pathological conditions manifested by glottic insufficiency. In this series, most patients had preceding or concurrent phonosurgical procedures. Success of surgery was determined by subjective, audioperceptual judgments, acoustic analysis, and vocal function measures. Vocal fold pathology played a greater role in determining success than did the presence or absence of adjunctive surgical procedures. Thyroplasty Type I was effective in treating glottic insufficiency in patients previously treated with various augmentation procedures as well as in those undergoing simultaneous reinnervation and arytenoid adduction. Technical factors predisposing to complications included violation of inner thyroid cartilage perichondrium, small shim size, sacrifice of cartilagenous window, and mucosal penetration. Thyroplasty should be considered as a primary or adjunctive treatment of patients with glottic insufficiency, especially when preservation of membranous vocal fold structure is of primary importance.     

Acute and Subacute Awake Injection Laryngoplasty for Thoracic Surgery Patients

SUMMARY: The rehabilitation of glottic incompetence by injection laryngoplasty is important in the management of thoracic surgery patients with vocal cord paralysis. This group of patients presents special considerations that favor injection under local anesthesia. The objective of this study is to characterize our experience with this minimally invasive approach in both the acute and subacute settings. The study was conducted using a retrospective chart review. From a database of 108 patients who received awake percutaneous injection laryngoplasty over a 3-year period, 15 cases were identified that underwent augmentation shortly following thoracic surgery. These records were reviewed for patient demographics, clinical characteristics, complications, and short-term outcomes. Fifteen patients were identified (12 male, 3 female); the age range for the group was 18-91 years (median=55 years). All the patients reported vocal improvement following injection; all 15 also were improved by perceptual assessment. Five of six dysphagic patients improved following injection. One patient's injection was aborted due to vocal fold edema; no significant bleeding or airway embarrassment was observed. No procedures were terminated because of patient discomfort. Awake percutaneous injection laryngoplasty for vocal paralysis can be performed safely in the postoperative thoracic surgery patient. Swallowing and voice complaints were almost universally improved following treatment. For patients who cannot tolerate or choose not to have open thyroplasty or vocal fold injection under general anesthesia, this procedure may offer a safe and effective alternative.     

The Evolving Etiology of Bilateral Vocal Fold Immobility

In the past, bilateral vocal fold immobility (BVFI) occurred most commonly after thyroidectomy. However, no large series documenting the etiology of adult BVFI has been published within the past fifteen years. This study reviews the etiologic patterns of BVFI at our institutions. We compare BVFI from before and after 1980. We also review combined studies of unilateral vocal fold immobility (UVFI) to compare and unilateral versus bilateral etiologic trends. In comparison with previously published series, fewer cases of BVFI present today as a complication of thyroid surgery and more as the result of malignancies and nonsurgical trauma. Unfortunately, BVFI caused by malignancy is not usually an initial sign of local disease, but an ominous sign of recurrence or metastases. In comparing UVFI and BVFI we found that thyroidectomy causes a higher percentage of BVFI than of UVFI. Over one-third of UVFI cases were caused by neoplasm which further underscores the potential seriousness of immobile vocal folds and the need for careful investigation.     

The frequency of hard glottal attacks in patients with muscle tension dysphonia, unilateral benign masses and bilateral benign masses

Hard or abrupt glottal attack (HGA) is one of the vocal behaviors often associated with benign lesion of the vocal folds. This study was designed to determine whether the frequency of HGA was different in hyperfunctional voice patients with and without vocal fold masses. One hundred and forty-seven subjects were studied. All subjects received a complete otolaryngological evaluation including strobovideolaryngoscopy, objective voice measures, and evaluation by a speech-language pathologist. Thirty-two patients were diagnosed with muscle tension dysphonia (19 male, 13 female) without vocal fold masses. Fifty-seven patients were diagnosed with unilateral vocal fold masses (29 male, 28 female), most of which were cysts. Fifty-eight patients were diagnosed with bilateral vocal fold masses (13 male, 45 female). Of the 45 females with bilateral vocal fold masses. 26 had a vocal cyst and reactive nodule and 19 had bilateral vocal fold nodules. The control group was balanced and matched based on sex and on percentage of singers and nonsingers. It consisted of 49 subjects with no vocal fold pathology (20 male, 29 female). The group was composed of professional speakers, singers, and nonprofessional speakers. All voice disordered groups demonstrated higher frequencies of HGA than the control group. Differences were found between the male and female subjects in this study. No differences were found between the various disorders. Differences were also found between the subgroups of bilateral masses, where the bilateral nodules group presented a higher frequency of HGA than the cyst and contralateral reactive nodule.     

Migration of the anterior segment following anterior commissure advancement: A case report

A 53-year-old man with severe vocal fold atrophy underwent bilateral type 1 thyroplasty and anterior commissure advancement. Postoperatively, he developed a strained voice with less projection and volume than prior to surgery. This was verified by objective assessment of vocal function. Videoendoscopy revealed bilateral false vocal fold fullness and blunting of the anterior commissure. Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated cephalic migration of the posterior ends of the implants and retrusion of the anterior commissure segment. Surgical exploration revealed that the type 1 implants had rotated and buckled. The anterior commissure segment was rotated and displaced inferiorly, and its inferior surface was tethered to the cricoid by scar tissue. The implants were removed, the anterior segment was repositioned and rigidly fixed, and bilateral lipoinjection performed. Vocal function was significantly improved, and endoscopy revealed normal tension and length of the vocal folds and restoration of the anterior commissure. This case demonstrates the importance of stable fixation during laryngeal framework surgery     

How I Do It: Miniplate Reconstruction of the Lateral Thyroid Lamina: One-Stage Restoration of Voice After Teflon Granuloma Resection

This case report describes a one-stage technique for long-term voice restoration and laryngeal reconstruction in the treatment of Teflon (Dupont, Wilmington, Delaware) granuloma. A patient who presented with severe dysphonia underwent resection of a Teflon granuloma via a lateral laryngotomy. A pedicled strap muscle flap was used to reconstruct the paraglottic space. The muscle flap was positioned through the lateral laryngotomy with direct endoscopic visualization of the endolarynx to ensure correct vertical positioning and medialization of the vocal fold. The muscle flap was secured in this position with suture fixation. The trapdoor piece of cartilage that was elevated to create the window in the lateral thyroid lamina was repositioned over the pedicled muscle flap and reinforced with a titanium miniplate, which was secured to the remaining thyroid cartilage. The patient had excellent voice results and has not required revision or augmentation. Reinforcement of the lateral thyroid lamina using titanium miniplate fixation helps to stabilize the muscle pedicle flap and the position of the vocal fold, in this case resulting in good long-term voice results after a single-stage reconstruction.     

Acoustic analysis of the speaking voice after thyroidectomy

Voices of 47 female patients were analyzed before and after thyroidectomy, with preservation of the recurrent and superior laryngeal nerves and normal vocal fold motility during the observation period. A mean decrease of the speaking fundamental frequency (SFF) of 12 Hz was found on day 4; in 8 patients the postoperative vocal pitch was more than 2 semitones lower. The distance between the highest and lowest F₀ during speaking was diminished (speech was more monotone) and the vocal jitter was elevated. In the frequency spectrum, there was a diminished prominence of the harmonics. The other spectral parameters (as the slope of the spectrum and the H1/H2 ratio) were unchanged. All changes had disappeared the fifteenth day, except for a lower SFF (>2 semitones) in 2 cases. It is concluded that after normal dissection of the laryngeal nerves, and in the absence of vocal fold paresis, other reasons for voice changes immediately after thyroidectomy remain: alterations in the neck muscles, in the laryngeal mucosa, and in the patient's general condition. Although the effects seem limited and of short duration, knowledge of them is helpful when informing the patient before thyroid surgery.     

Vocal fold augmentation with injectable calcium hydroxylapatite: short-term results.

Symptoms of unilateral vocal fold paralysis are improved significantly by augmenting the paralyzed vocal fold via vocal fold injection. In this trial, augmentation with a new calcium hydroxylapatite implant was evaluated. In addition, two different phonosurgical injection techniques were used, and these procedures were compared for accuracy and reliability. A total of 11 terminal patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis underwent vocal fold injection with calcium hydroxylapatite. Efficacy of the implant was evaluated by comparing results from the Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and mean airflow measurements before and 6 months after injection. Surgeon evaluations determined the comparative benefits of either endoscopic direct vocal fold injection or percutaneous vocal fold injection. Six-month data were obtained for a cohort of five patients. VHI scores improved for all five patients available for full evaluation and four of the five achieved improvements in mean airflow rates. Of the remaining patients, one later had a medialization laryngoplasty, two died from their terminal diseases before the 6-month follow-up, and two of the remaining three reported satisfaction with the results via telephone follow-up. Vocal fold injection via endoscopic, direct laryngoscopy was found to be a more reliable procedure for vocal fold injection than percutaneous injection. Slight overinjection (10% to 15%) was found to provide optimum results. Vocal fold injection of calcium hydroxylapatite for unilateral vocal fold paralysis improved voice quality and reduced mean airflow rates in this patient group with short-term results. Long-term studies are needed to confirm the durability of these findings.     

Allograft (Alloderm) and Autograft (Temporalis Fascia) Implantation for Glottic Insufficiency: A Novel Approach

Objective

Traditionally, glottic insufficiency because of scar, atrophy, and sulcus has been treated by injection or medialization laryngoplasty. These procedures do not reestablish the vertical height of the vocal fold margin. We propose soft tissue augmentation laryngoplasty with allograft (sheet Alloderm; LifeCell Corporation, Branchburg, NJ) or autograft (temporalis fascia) via a minithyrotomy or a transoral approach.

Study Design

A retrospective case series analysis of 21 patients treated by sheet Alloderm or temporalis fascia for correction of glottic insufficiency.

Methods

Twenty-one patients with glottic insufficiency secondary to scar, atrophy, or sulcus were treated. Ten failed prior techniques. Seventeen had minithyrotomy by a small fenestration in the thyroid cartilage. Exploration of scar or lamina propria through the fenestration allowed for the creation of a pocket for Alloderm implantation within the intermediate layer of the lamina propria. Four patients underwent a transoral approach by cordotomy with either Alloderm or temporalis fascia implantation, which also allowed for exploration of scar but required repair using sutures. These implantation approaches allowed for both restoration of the layered structure and augmentation of the middle third of the musculomembranous vocal fold. Preoperative and postoperative videostroboscopic examinations were reviewed with review of clinical outcome.

Results

With a median follow-up time of 12 months, patients demonstrated excellent long-term vocal fold augmentation and minimal absorption of the implant in 19 out of 21 patients. There is improved pliability of the vocal fold with good oscillation in scar patients.

Conclusion

Minithyrotomy with soft tissue augmentation is a novel approach for soft tissue augmentation of glottic insufficiency. It has the advantage of augmentation of the medial edge of the vocal fold with a soft tissue implant that has long-term viability. Its role should be explored further in patients with atrophy and scar.     

Laryngeal Myasthenia Gravis: Report of 40 Cases

Myasthenia gravis, an autoimmune disorder of the neuromuscular junction, is usually recognized because of ocular complaints or generalized weakness. We report a series of 40 patients who presented with dysphonia as their initial and primary complaint. Diagnostic testing included strobovideolaryngoscopy, electromyography (EMG) with repetitive stimulation and Tensilon testing, and laboratory and radiographic evaluation. Strobovideolaryngoscopy most commonly revealed fluctuating impairment of vocal fold mobility, either unilateral or bilateral. EMG detected evidence of neuromuscular junction abnormalities in all patients. Only one patient had evidence of antiacetylcholine receptor (ACh-R) antibodies, but many other abnormalities suggestive of autoimmune dysfunction were present. Pyridostigmine therapy was initiated in 34 patients but was not tolerated in 4. Of the remaining 30 patients, 23 reported improvement of symptoms. We conclude that myasthenia gravis can present with symptoms confined primarily to the larynx and should be included in the differential diagnosis of dysphonia.     

Analysis of Voice and Quantitative Measurement of Glottal Gap After Thyroplasty Type I in the Treatment of Unilateral Vocal Paralysis

Thyroplasty type I is one of several surgical treatments in which improving the voice of unilateral vocal fold paralysis is the ultimate objective. The goal of the surgery is the medialization of the paralyzed vocal fold. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of thyroplasty type I through acoustical analysis, aerodynamic measures, and quantitative videostroboscopic measurements. We report on 20 patients with unilateral vocal cord paralysis who underwent thyroplasty type I. We performed preoperative and postoperative video image analysis (normalized glottal gap area) and computer-assisted voice analysis (fundamental frequency, jitter, shimmer, noise-to-harmonic ratio, mean phonation time, mean flow rate, mean subglottic pressure) in all patients. The glottal gap was significantly reduced after thyroplasty type I. Postoperative voice quality was characterized by an improved pitch and amplitude pertubation (jitter and shimmer), phonation time (mean phonation time), and subglottic pressure (mean subglottic pressure). Thyroplasty type I is an effective method for regaining glottal closure and vocal function.     

Mild Vocal Fold Paresis: Understanding Clinical Presentation and Electromyographic Findings

The implications of mild vocal fold hypomobility are incompletely understood. This study describes the clinical, electromyographic, and probable etiologic findings in patients who presented with complaints of dysphonia and whose physical examination revealed vocal fold paresis as a factor possibly contributing to their voice complaints. A retrospective chart review of all patients who presented to a tertiary laryngology referral center over a 13-month period, who had a clinical diagnosis of mild vocal fold hypomobility and who underwent laryngeal electromyography, were included in the study. A total of 22 patients completed the medical evaluation of their voice complaint. Of these patients, 19 (86.4%) were found to have evidence of neuropathy on laryngeal electromyography. The clinical picture indicated the following probable origins for the vocal fold paresis: goiter/thyroiditis (7/22 or 31.8%), idiopathic (4/22 or 18.2%), viral neuritis (4/22 or 18.2%), trauma (3/22 or 13.6%), and Lyme's disease (1/22 or 4.5%). This article describes the clinical entity of mild vocal fold hypomobility and associated flexible laryngoscopic, rigid strobovideolaryngoscopic, and laryngeal electromyographic findings.     

Quantitative assessment of voice quality following laser surgery for reinke''s edema

Although laser surgery has been widely advocated for use in the treatment of vocal fold papilloma because it does not incur bleeding, it has been questioned for use in treating Reinke's edema due to the possibility of heat dispersion to normal surrounding tissue and of scarring. We present a series of 8 cases in which laser surgery was the method of treatment for bilateral Reinke's edema. In each case, voice therapy was selected as the initial treatment; laser surgery was performed following voice therapy. Prior to and following surgery, videostroboscopic examinations were performed on the subjects. Only 4 subjects were available for assessment at the 1-month postoperative period. From the audio track of the videotape, the speaking fundamental frequency, perturbation measures for the vowel /i/, and noise-to-harmonic ratio of a completely voiced sentence were obtained. From the videostroboscopic recordings, the symmetry of the vocal folds, the presence or absence of the mucosal wave and the glottic closure pattern, prior to and after surgery, were judged independently by 3 examiners. The fundamental frequencies approximated the normal male and female ranges for those subjects seen 1 month after surgery. In addition, the noise-to-harmonic ratio and the relative average perturbation improved. Stroboscopy revealed irregularities in the symmetry of vocal folds, mucosal wave, and glottic closure 1 month after surgery.     

Vocal Fold Paralysis Following Radiotherapy for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma: Laryngeal Electromyography Findings

Laryngeal electromyography was used to study the pattern of neurological injury in three patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis following radiotherapy for nasopharyngeal carcinoma. The thyroarytenoid and cricothyroid muscles were assessed to give an indication of recurrent and superior laryngeal nerve function. Two patients demonstrated both recurrent and superior laryngeal neuropathy suggesting injury at the skull base. The other patient had only recurrent laryngeal neuropathy indicating more distal involvement. Subclinical neuropathic changes were seen in two cases on the side contralateral to the vocal fold paralysis. These patients may be at increased risk of developing bilateral vocal fold paralysis and potentially life-threatening airway obstruction. Long-term follow-up is recommended for such patients, especially if medialization thyroplasty is being considered. This is the first report describing the use of electromyography to determine the pattern of nerve injury in patients with vocal fold paralysis following head and neck radiotherapy.     

Soft tissue response in the rabbit larynx following implantation of Lactosorb (PLA/PGA copolymer) prosthesis for medialization laryngoplasty

This project is designed to provide initial data regarding the use of polylactic acid/polyglycolic acid (PLA/PGA) copolymer ("LactoSorb" [Walter Lorenz Corp]), an alloplastic, resorbable material, as a prosthesis in an animal model of vocal fold medialization. Fifteen New Zealand white rabbits were utilized for left medialization laryngoplasty with LactoSorb implants after undergoing left recurrent laryngeal nerve section. At 1, 3, 6, and 9 months, the rabbits were sacrificed and their larynges were evaluated both grossly and histologically for tissue response to, and resorption characteristics of the implant, tissue cellularity, maintenance of vocal fold medialization, and airway patency. Additionally, 4 rabbits were used as controls, implanted with silicone rubber medialization implants, and sacrificed at 9 months for comparison. One rabbit underwent no surgery and was likewise used as a control. Grossly, no airway obstruction was noted, and no extrusions of the implants occurred. The LactoSorb implant maintained medialization in each group of sacrificed rabbits. Histologic findings revealed a very discrete, fibrous capsule around the implant in the 1- and 3-month rabbits, and the LactoSorb was still grossly visible. At 6 months, the thin fibrous capsule partially remained; at 9 months, the capsule was no longer evident, and the implant was no longer grossly visible. Endoscopic findings at the time of sacrifice in those rabbits implanted with silicone rubber included grossly patent airways with maintenance of medialization. In the rabbits implanted with silicone rubber, the histologic findings are similar to those described elsewhere. LactoSorb, because of its intermittent resorption rate, could offer an ideal alternative to currently utilized temporary, or resorbable, materials, and as such will hopefully prove an invaluable tool in the laryngologist's treatment planning and surgical repair of the patient with a paralyzed vocal fold.     

Stroboscopic signs associated with benign lesions of the vocal folds

Stroboscopic signs were systematically rated for a group of 80 patients with benign vocal fold lesions, most of whom had either a nodule or a polyp. Each group revealed a characteristic pattern of ranking of signs and exhibited differences of most predominant signs. The results of the ratings were submitted to a multiple discriminant analysis to determine if post hoc stroboscopic ratings could be used to correctly classify patients into one of four diagnostic groups and into one of two treatment groups. All patients except one were correctly classified into the diagnostic groups, and all were correctly classified into the treatment groups. The important signs for classifying patients into the diagnostic groups were roughness of the edge of the affected vocal fold, phase closure pattern, and phase symmetry. The important signs for classifying patients into the treatment groups were roughness of the edge of the affected vocal fold, glottal closure configuration, and vibration characteristics of the affected (or more affected) vocal fold. The results suggest that objective evaluation of stroboscopic examinations can be valuable in correctly diagnosing patients and in selecting the proper treatment regimen for the patient.