Statistical merging of rating models

In this paper we introduce and discuss statistical models aimed at predicting default probabilities of Small and Medium Enterprises (SME). Such models are based on two separate sources of information: quantitative balance sheet ratios and qualitative information derived from the opinion mining process on unstructured data. We propose a novel methodology for data fusion in longitudinal and survival duration models using quantitative and qualitative variables separately in the likelihood function and then combining their scores linearly by a weight, to obtain the corresponding probability of default for each SME. With a real financial database at hand, we have compared the results achieved in terms of model performance and predictive capability using single models and our own proposal. Finally, we select the best model in terms of out-of-sample forecasts considering key performance indicators.     

Hurdle models of loan default

Some models of loan default are binary, simply modelling the probability of default, while others go further and model the extent of default (eg number of outstanding payments; amount of arrears). The double-hurdle model, originally due to Cragg (Econometrica, 1971), and conventionally applied to household consumption or labour supply decisions, contains two equations, one which determines whether or not a customer is a potential defaulter (the ‘first hurdle’), and the other which determines the extent of default. In separating these two processes, the model recognizes that there exists a subset of the observed non-defaulters who would never default whatever their circumstances. A Box-Cox transformation applied to the dependent variable is a useful generalization to the model. Estimation is relatively easy using the Maximum Likelihood routine available in STATA. The model is applied to a sample of 2515 loan applicants for whom loans were approved, a sizeable proportion of whom defaulted in varying degrees. The dependent variables used are amount in arrears and number of days in arrears. The value of the hurdle approach is confirmed by finding that certain key explanatory variables have very different effects between the two equations. Most notably, the effect of loan amount is strongly positive on arrears, while being U-shaped on the probability of default. The former effect is seriously under-estimated when the first hurdle is ignored.     

Support vector machines for default prediction of SMEs based on technology credit

In Korea, many forms of credit guarantees have been issued to fund small and medium enterprises (SMEs) with a high degree of growth potential in technology. However, a high default rate among funded SMEs has been reported. In order to effectively manage such governmental funds, it is important to develop an accurate scoring model for selecting promising SMEs. This paper provides a support vector machines (SVM) model to predict the default of funded SMEs, considering various input variables such as financial ratios, economic indicators, and technology evaluation factors. The results show that the accuracy performance of the SVM model is better than that of back-propagation neural networks (BPNs) and logistic regression. It is expected that the proposed model can be applied to a wide range of technology evaluation and loan or investment decisions for technology-based SMEs.     

On reduced-form intensity-based model with ‘trigger’ events

Corporate defaults may be triggered by some major market news or events such as financial crises or collapses of major banks or financial institutions. With a view to develop a more realistic model for credit risk analysis, we introduce a new type of reduced-form intensity-based model that can incorporate the impacts of both observable ‘trigger’ events and economic environment on corporate defaults. The key idea of the model is to augment a Cox process with ‘trigger’ events. Both single-default and multiple-default cases are considered in this paper. In the former case, a simple expression for the distribution of the default time is obtained. Applications of the proposed model to price defaultable bonds and multi-name Credit Default Swaps are provided.     

A dynamic binomial expansion technique for credit risk measurement: a Bayesian filtering approach

Credit risk measurement and management are important and current issues in the modern finance world from both the theoretical and practical perspectives. There are two major schools of thought for credit risk analysis, namely the structural models based on the asset value model originally proposed by Merton and the intensity‐based reduced form models. One of the popular credit risk models used in practice is the Binomial Expansion Technique (BET) introduced by Moody's. However, its one‐period static nature and the independence assumption for credit entities' defaults are two shortcomings for the use of BET in practical situations. Davis and Lo provided elegant ways to ease the two shortcomings of BET with their default infection and dynamic continuous‐time intensity‐based approaches. This paper first proposes a discrete‐time dynamic extension to the BET in order to incorporate the time‐dependent and time‐varying behaviour of default probabilities for measuring the risk of a credit risky portfolio. In reality, the ‘true’ default probabilities are unobservable to credit analysts and traders. Here, the uncertainties of ‘true’ default probabilities are incorporated in the context of a dynamic Bayesian paradigm. Numerical studies of the proposed model are provided.     

A pentatonic classification of extreme events

In this paper we present a classification of the extreme events – very small and very large outcomes – of positive-valued random variables. The classification distinguishes five different categories of randomness, ranging from the very ‘mild’ to the very ‘wild’. In analogy with the common five-tone musical scale we term the classification ‘pentatonic’. The classification is based on the analysis of the inherent Gibbsian ‘forces’ and ‘temperatures’ existing on the logarithmic scale of the random variables under consideration, and provides a statistical-physics insight regarding the nature of these random variables. The practical application of the pentatonic classification is remarkably straightforward, it can be performed by non-experts, and it is demonstrated via an array of examples.     

基于信用利差与Logistic回归的公司违约概率测算模型与实证研究

用Logistic模型计算公司违约概率在实际应用中存在两个问题:一是在缺乏公司违约记录数据库或违约记录数据库不典型的情况下,无法应用该模型或模型计算结果不准确;二是现有Logistic违约概率模型忽视了不同行业财务指标分布特征的差异性,导致公司违约概率计算结果的准确性降低。针对问题一,本文通过公司债券信用利差计算市场隐含的公司违约概率,在Logistic变换的基础上进一步确定Logistic线性回归的参数,使得公司违约概率的计算结果符合债券市场的实际状况。针对问题二,通过不同行业关键财务指标的单因子方差分析,证实了行业间财务指标的分布特征具有显著性差异,通过拟合优度证实了区分行业建立Logistic违约概率模型可显著提高违约概率测算的准确性。本文Logistic违约概率模型的构建过程如下:通过初选财务指标的相关性分析,删除反映信息重复的财务指标;通过Logistic回归中财务指标系数的显著性检验,删除对违约概率解释能力弱的财务指标;以Logistic回归的拟合优度为标准,选取各样本行业Logistic违约概率模型的关键财务指标,建立了机械设备等5个样本行业的Logistic违约概率模型,为样本内行业公司违约概率的准确测算提供模型与方法。本文的创新与特色:一是在无套利条件下,通过公司债券信用利差计算市场隐含的公司违约概率,并对其进行Logistic变换,作为Logistic线性回归的被解释变量,解决了在缺乏公司违约记录数据情况下Logistic违约概率模型的参数估计问题;二是通过单因子方差分析方法,证实了行业间财务指标的分布特征具有显著性差异,说明应区分行业建立Logistic违约概率模型;三是通过财务指标间的相关分析删除反映信息重复的财务指标,通过财务指标系数的显著性检验删除对公司违约概率解释能力弱的财务指标,保证了Logistic违约概率模型中关键财务指标选取的合理性;四是实证研究结果表明,不同行业的Logistic违约概率模型的关键财务指标不同,同一财务指标的参数也存在显著差异。实证研究结果还表明,区分行业建立Logistic违约概率模型与不区分行业相比,前者可将拟合优度及调整后的拟合优度提高近1倍。本文研究结果对于提高公司违约概率测算的准确性具有重要参考意义,对于商业银行贷款定价、公司债券发行定价、银行信用风险管理具有重要参考意义。     

Efficient frontier cutoff policies in credit portfolios

Historically, account acquisition in scored retail credit and loan portfolios has focused on risk management in the sense of minimizing default losses. We believe that acquisition policies should focus on a broader set of business measures that explicitly recognize tradeoffs between conflicting objectives of losses, volume and profit. Typical business challenges are: ‘How do I maximize portfolio profit while keeping acceptance rate (volume, size) at acceptable levels?’ ‘How do I maximize profit without incurring default losses above a given level?’ ‘How do I minimize the risk of large loss exposures for a given market share?’ In this paper we are not concerned with which combination of objectives are appropriate, but rather focus on the cutoff policies that allow us to capture a number of different portfolio objectives. When there are conflicting objectives we show that optimal policies yield meaningful tradeoffs and efficient frontiers and that optimal shadow prices allow us to develop risk-adjusted tradeoffs between profit and market share. Some of the graphical solutions that we obtain are simple to derive and easy to understand without explicit mathematical formulations but even simple constraints may require formal use of non-linear programming techniques. We concentrate on models and insights that yield decision strategies and cutoff policies rather than the techniques for developing good predictors.     

Combining systemic and non-systemic risk scores

This paper proposes a proportional odds model to combine systemic and non-systemic risk for prediction of default and prepay performance in cohorts of booked loan accounts. We assume that performance odds is proportional to two independent factors, one based on age-dependent systemic, possibly external, global disruptions to a cohort of individual accounts, the other on traditional non-systemic information odds based on demographic, behavioural and financial payment patterns of the individual accounts. A proportional odds model provides a natural formulation that can combine hazard rate predictions of baseline defaults, prepayments and active accounts with traditional non-systemic risk scores of individuals within the cohort. Theoretical comparisons with proportional hazard models are illustrated. Although our model is developed in terms of Good/Bad performance, it can include late payments, prepayments, defaults, as well as responses to offers and other classifications. We make 60-month default and prepay forecasts under two different systemic risk scenarios for a portfolio of Alt A mortgages with 24-month ‘teaser rates’ originated in 2004.     

上市公司远期财务危机预测研究

尽管各界对预测企业远期财务危机有着很大需求,该领域的研究一直被这个问题所困惑:究竟哪些指标含有预测企业远期财务危机的重要信息?本文利用财务报表时间序列数据和贝叶斯统计方法设计出了一个这样的指标,用该指标建立的上市公司财务危机预模型具有较高的远期预测正确率。     

Random effects logistic regression model for default prediction of technology credit guarantee fund

Korean government has been funding the small and medium enterprises (SME) with superior technology based on scorecard. However high default rate of funded SMEs has been reported. In order to effectively manage such governmental fund, it is important to develop accurate scoring model for SMEs. In this paper, we provide a random effects logistic regression model to predict the default of funded SMEs based on both financial and non-financial factors. Advantage of such a random effects model lies in the ability of accommodating not only the individual characteristics of each SME but also the uncertainty that cannot be explained by such individual factors. It is expected that our study can contribute to effective management of government funds by proposing the prediction models for defaults of funded SMEs.     

基于不均衡数据的小企业信用风险评价

小企业信用风险评价既是银行风险管理问题,又事关经济社会稳定。针对小企业贷款实践中,违约样本远少于非违约样本、且违约客户误判对银行影响较大的现实,采用不均衡支持向量机对小企业信用风险评价指标进行赋权,进而构建了能有效区分违约客户、非违约客户的评价模型。根据有无特定评价指标、特定评价指标数值变化对贷款小企业违约状态的影响程度赋权;反映了对违约状态影响越大、评价指标权重越大的赋权思路。将违约样本正确识别率、违约样本的准确率与查全率等因素作为支持向量机赋权模型中客户识别率的度量标准,改变了样本数据不均衡所导致的样本总体精度很高、违约样本精度反而不高的现象。研究结果表明:行业景气指数、资本固定化比率、净利润现金含量、恩格尔系数、营业利润率等评价指标对小企业信用风险的影响较大。     

基于混合模型的利润驱动违约判别临界点研究

违约判别临界点是金融机构是否接受客户贷款申请的重要参考,合适的违约判别临界点对减少金融机构贷款损失实现稳健经营具有重要意义。本文研究的问题是如何保证计算客户违约概率的准确性,并找到利润最大化的违约判别临界点。本文的创新与特色:一是通过将多个不同类型的违约判别模型计算的客户违约概率进行加权平均,保证了计算客户违约概率的的整体准确性,避免了使用单一模型计算客户违约概率不准确的弊端;二是通过定义金融机构从贷款中获得利润的计算公式,以利润最大为目标,求解违约判别临界点,避免了现有计算临界点的方法如广义对称点估计和经验似然法等方法得到的临界点利润不是最大的弊端。研究发现:混合模型比单一模型的准确性高,AUC值显著提高;在人人贷数据集中本文的违约判别临界点下贷款利润远高于其他方法下临界点的利润。     

Cure events in default prediction

This paper evaluates the resurrection event regarding defaulted firms and incorporates observable cure events in the default prediction of SME. Due to the additional cure-related observable data, a completely new information set is applied to predict individual default and cure events. This is a new approach in credit risk that, to our knowledge, has not been followed yet. Different firm-specific and macroeconomic default and cure-event-influencing risk drivers are identified. The significant variables allow a firm-specific default risk evaluation combined with an individual risk reducing cure probability. The identification and incorporation of cure-relevant factors in the default risk framework enable lenders to support the complete resurrection of a firm in the case of its default and hence reduce the default risk itself. The estimations are developed with a database that contains 5930 mostly small and medium-sized German firms and a total of more than 23000 financial statements over a time horizon from January 2002 to December 2007. Due to the significant influence on the default risk probability as well as the bank’s possible profit prospects concerning a cured firm, it seems essential for risk management to incorporate the additional cure information into credit risk evaluation.     

A comparison of strategies to develop a customer default scoring model

Behavioural scoring models are generally used to estimate the probability that a customer of a financial institution who owns a credit product will default on this product in a fixed time horizon. However, one single customer usually purchases many credit products from an institution while behavioural scoring models generally treat each of these products independently. In order to make credit risk management easier and more efficient, it is interesting to develop customer default scoring models. These models estimate the probability that a customer of a certain financial institution will have credit issues with at least one product in a fixed time horizon. In this study, three strategies to develop customer default scoring models are described. One of the strategies is regularly utilized by financial institutions and the other two will be proposed herein. The performance of these strategies is compared by means of an actual data bank supplied by a financial institution and a Monte Carlo simulation study.     

Question selection responding to information on customers from heterogeneous populations to select offers that maximize expected profit

The advent of Internet broking pages allows customers to ‘apply’ to a number of different companies at one time, leading to multiple offers made to a customer. The saturated condition of the personal financial products has led to falling ‘take’ rates. Financial institutions are trying to increase the ‘take’ rates of their personal financial products. Applicants for credit will have to provide information for risk assessment, which can be used to assess the probability of a customer accepting an offer. Interactive channels such as the Internet and telephone allow questions that are asked to depend on previous answers. The questions selected need to provide information to assess the probability of acceptance of a particular variant of financial product. In this paper, we investigate a model to predict the best offer to extend next to a customer based on the response for the questions, as well as the question selection itself.     

Multivariate analysis using ‘and’ and ‘or’

The connectives ‘and’ and ‘or’ are potentially useful in multivariate analysis and theory construction. They are simple, logical ways to connect two or more variables together. However, until recently there has been no framework for operationalizing these connectives for continuous variables, and this lack has severely limited their use. Using fuzzy set theory as a basis for such a framework, this paper lays out the necessary tools and models to permit the use of ‘and’ and ‘or’ in multivariate analysis.Section 1 introduces conventional operators for ‘and’ and ‘or’, and Section 2 provides suitable extensions and generalizations of them. Section 3 sets out the required least-squares techniques for fitting these generalized operators to data, first in the context of ANOVA problems and then in regression contexts, for single-connective (three-variable) models. The theoretical developments and examples from real data-sets demonstrate the utility of ‘and’ and ‘or’ as a means to cell-specific interpretations of interaction effects which can also readily be translated into English. Section 4 extends these developments to multivariate, multiple-connective models and discusses issues of generalizability. The paper concludes (Section 5) with a brief discussion of remaining unsolved problems, future prospects for more sophisticated models, and computer programs.     

European generic scoring models using survival analysis

Credit scoring discriminates between ‘good’ and ‘bad’ credit risks to assist credit-grantors in making lending decisions. Such discrimination may not be a good indicator of profit, while survival analysis allows profit to be modelled. The paper explores the application of parametric accelerated failure time and proportional hazards models and Cox non-parametric model to the data from the retail card (revolving credit) from three European countries. The predictive performance of three national models is tested for different timescales of default and then compared to that of a single generic model for a timescale of 25 months. It is found that survival analysis national and generic models produce predictive quality, which is very close to the current industry standard—logistic regression. Stratification is investigated as a way of extending Cox non-parametric proportional hazards model to tackle heterogeneous segments in the population.     

Evaluation of credit risk based on firm performance

This paper investigates whether productive inefficiency measured as the distance from the industry’s ‘best practice’ frontier is an important ex-ante predictor of business failure. We use samples of French textiles, wood and paper products, computers and R&D companies to obtain efficiency estimates for individual firms in each industry. These efficiency measures are derived from a directional technology distance function constructed empirically using non-parametric data envelopment analysis (DEA) methods. Estimating binary and ordered logit regression models we find that productive efficiency has significant explanatory power in predicting the likelihood of default over and above the effect of standard financial indicators.     

Chebyshev reduced basis function applied to option valuation

We present a numerical method for the frequent pricing of financial derivatives that depends on a large number of variables. The method is based on the construction of a polynomial basis to interpolate the value function of the problem by means of a hierarchical orthogonalization process that allows to reduce the number of degrees of freedom needed to have an accurate representation of the value function. In the paper we consider, as an example, a GARCH model that depends on eight parameters and show that a very large number of contracts for different maturities and asset and parameters values can be valued in a small computational time with the proposed procedure. In particular the method is applied to the problem of model calibration. The method is easily generalizable to be used with other models or problems.