The impact of inspection errors,imperfect maintenance and minimal repairs on an imperfect production system

This paper develops an integrated model of production lot-sizing, maintenance and quality for considering the possibilities of inspection errors, preventive maintenance (PM) errors and minimal repairs for an imperfect production system with increasing hazard rates. In this study, a PM activity is imperfect in that a production system cannot be recovered as good as new and might cause the production system to shift to the out-of-control state with a certain probability. Numerical analyses are used to simulate the effect of changes in various parameters on the optimal solution for which the time that the process remains in the in-control state is assumed to follow a Weibull distribution. In addition, we investigate the effects of inspection errors and PM errors on the minimum total cost of the optimal inspection interval, inspection frequency and production quantity.     

Integrated production and quality model under various preventive maintenance policies

In this paper, we investigate the effect of various preventive maintenance policies on the joint optimisation of the economic production quantity (EPQ) and the economic design of control chart. This has been done for a deteriorating process where the in-control period follows a general probability distribution with increasing hazard rate. In the proposed model, preventive maintenance (PM) activities reduce the shift rate of the system to the out-of-control state proportional to the PM level. For each policy, the model determines the EPQ, the optimal design of the control chart and the optimal preventive maintenance level. The effects of the three PM policies on EPQ and quality costs are illustrated using an example of a Weibull shock model with an increasing hazard rate.     

Economic production lot-sizing for an unreliable machine under imperfect age-based maintenance policy

This paper is concerned with the joint determination of both economic production quantity and preventive maintenance (PM) schedules under the realistic assumption that the production facility is subject to random failure and the maintenance is imperfect. The manufacturing system is assumed to deteriorate while in operation, with an increasing failure rate. The system undergoes PM either upon failure or after having reached a predetermined age, whichever of them occurs first. As is often the case in real manufacturing applications, maintenance activities are imperfect and unable to restore the system to its original healthy state. In this work, we propose a model that could be used to determine the optimal number of production runs and the sequence of PM schedules that minimizes the long-term average cost. Some useful properties of the cost function are developed to characterize the optimal policy. An algorithm is also proposed to find the optimal solutions to the problem at hand. Numerical results are provided to illustrate both the use of the algorithm in the study of the optimal cost function and the latter’s sensitivity to different changes in cost factors.     

Optimal preventive maintenance for equipment with two quality states and general failure time distributions

We present an economic model for the optimization of preventive maintenance in a production process with two quality states. The equipment starts its operation in the in-control state but it may shift to the out-of-control state before failure or scheduled preventive maintenance. The time of shift and the time of failure are generally distributed random variables. The two states are characterized by different failure rates and revenues. We first derive the structure of the optimal maintenance policy, which is defined by two critical values of the equipment age that determine when to perform preventive maintenance depending on the actual (observable) state of the process. We then provide properties of the optimal solution and show how to determine the optimal values of the two critical maintenance times accurately and efficiently. The proposed model and, in particular, the behavior of the optimal solution as the model parameters and the shift and failure time distributions change are illustrated through numerical examples.     

Optimal economic production quantity policy for imperfect process with imperfect repair and maintenance

This study integrates maintenance and production programs with the economic production quantity (EPQ) model for an imperfect process involving a deteriorating production system with increasing hazard rate: imperfect repair and rework upon failure (out of control state). The imperfect repair performs some restorations and restores the system to an operating state (in-control state), but leaves its failure until perfect preventive maintenance (PM) is performed. There are two types of PM, namely imperfect PM and perfect PM. The probability that perfect PM is performed depends on the number of imperfect maintenance operations performed since the last renewal cycle. Mathematical formulas are obtained for deriving the expected total cost. For the EPQ model, the optimum run time, which minimizes the total cost, is discussed. Various special cases are considered, including the maintenance learning effect. Finally, a numerical example is presented to illustrate the effects of PM, setup, breakdown and holding costs.     

Two-stage generalized age maintenance of a queue-like production system

In general, the initiation of preventive maintenance should be based on the technical state as well as the operating state of a production system. Since the operating state of a production system is often subject to fluctuations in time, the planning of preventive maintenance at preset points in time (e.g. age/block replacement) cannot be optimal. Therefore, we propose a so-called two-stage maintenance policy, which - in a first stage - uses the technical state of the production system to determine a finite interval [t, t + At] during which preventive maintenance must be carried out, and - in a second stage - uses the operating state of the production system to determine the optimal starting time t̂ for preventive maintenance within that interval. A generalized age maintenance policy optimizing both t and At is formulated in the first stage. To this end, the actual starting time of preventive maintenance is modelled in terms of a uniform distribution over the maintenance interval. Moreover, the expected costs of preventive maintenance are modelled as a decreasing function of the interval size. An efficient algorithm is developed to demonstrate the optimal strategy for a queue-like production system, via numerical results that offer useful insights.     

Age-dependent production planning and maintenance strategies in unreliable manufacturing systems with lost sale

In this paper, we formulate an analytical model for the joint determination of an optimal age-dependent buffer inventory and preventive maintenance policy in a production environment that is subject to random machine breakdowns. Traditional preventive maintenance policies, such as age and periodic replacements, are usually studied based on simplified and non-realistic assumptions, as well as on the expected costs criterion. Finished goods inventories and the age-dependent likelihood of machine breakdowns are usually not considered. As a result, these policies could significantly extend beyond the anticipated financial incomes of the system, and lead to crises. In order to solve this problem, a more realistic analysis model is proposed in this paper to consider the effects of both preventive maintenance policies and machine age on optimal safety stock levels. Hence, a unified framework is developed, allowing production and preventive maintenance to be jointly considered. We use an age-dependent optimization model based on the minimization of an overall cost function, including inventory holdings, lost sales, preventive and corrective maintenance costs. We provide optimality conditions for the manufacturing systems considered, and use numerical methods to obtain an optimal preventive maintenance policy and the relevant age-dependent threshold level production policy. In this work, this policy is called the multiple threshold levels hedging point policy. We include numerical examples and sensitivity analyses to illustrate the importance and the effectiveness of the proposed methodology. Compared with other available optimal production and maintenance policies, the numerical solution obtained shows that the proposed age-dependent optimal production and maintenance policies significantly reduce the overall cost incurred.     

A periodic review production and maintenance model with random demand,deteriorating equipment,and binomial yield

In many environments, product yield is heavily influenced by equipment condition. Despite this fact, previous research has either focused on the issue of maintenance, ignoring the effect of equipment condition on yield, or has focused on the issue of production, omitting the possibility of actively changing the machine state. We formulate a Markov decision process model of a single-stage production system in which demand is random. The product yield has a binomial distribution that depends on the equipment condition, which deteriorates over time. The objective is to choose simultaneously the equipment maintenance schedule as well as the quantity to produce in a way that minimizes the sum of expected production, backorder, and holding costs. After proving some results about the structural properties of the optimal policy, numerical problems are used to compare this method to the typical approach of solving the maintenance and production problems sequentially. The results show that the simultaneous solution provides substantial gains over the sequential approach. In the cases studied, the proposed method resulted in an average cost savings of approximately 18%.     

Optimal threshold values of age and two-phase maintenance policy for leased equipments using age reduction method

This paper investigates the optimal threshold values of age to perform preventive maintenance (PM) actions for leased equipment within the lease period. In this paper, we use age reduction method to describe the degree of PM and construct the maintenance cost function. For repairable leased equipment, two maintenance models are proposed: (i) maintenance policy of single-phase and (ii) maintenance policy of two-phase. During the lease period, PM actions are carried out when the age of equipment reaches a certain threshold value. Any failure of the leased equipment is rectified by a minimal repair within the lease period. Under these maintenance schemes, the mathematical models of the expected total cost for maintenance policies of single-phase and two-phase are established, and the optimal maintenance policies are derived such that the expected total cost is minimized. Finally, the features of the optimal maintenance policy are illustrated through numerical examples.     

The relationship between preventive maintenance and manufacturing system performance

A common lament of the preventive maintenance (PM) crusaders is that production supervisors are often unwilling to lose valuable machine time when there are job waiting to be processed and do not assign high enough priority to PM. Maintenance activities that depend dynamically on system state are too complicated to implement and their overall impact on system performance, measured in terms of average tardiness or work-in-process (WIP) inventory, is difficult to predict. In this article, we present some easy to implement state-dependent PM policies that are consistent with the realities of production environment. We also develop polling models based analyses that could be used to obtain system performance metrics when such policies are implemented. We show that there are situations in which increased PM activity can lower total expected WIP (and overall tardiness) on its own, i.e., without accounting for the lower unplanned downtime. We also include examples that explain the interaction between duration of PM activity and switchover times. We identify cases in which a simple state-independent PM policy outperforms the more sophisticated state-dependent policies.     

Optimum policy for a production system with major repair and preventive maintenance

This study applies periodic preventive maintenance (PM) to a repairable production system with major repairs conducted after a failure. This study considers failed PM due to maintenance workers incorrectly performing PM and damages occurring after PM. Therefore, three PM types are considered: imperfect PM, perfect PM and failed PM. Imperfect PM has the same failure rate as that before PM, whereas perfect PM makes restores the system perfectly. Failed PM results in system deterioration and major repairs are required. The probability that PM is perfect or failed depends on the number of imperfect maintenance operations conducted since the previous renewal cycle. Mathematical formulas for expected total production cost per unit time are generated. Optimum PM time that minimizes cost is derived. Various special cases are considered, including the maintenance learning effect. A numerical example is given.     

Optimal maintenance policy in a multistate deteriorating standby system

An optimal maintenance policy for a multistate deteriorating standby system is proposed in this study. Traditionally, a system could only presume two operational states: success or failure, and the maintenance policy is to determine the optimal number of standby components, subject to factors such as maintenance capability, cost of the standby items, etc., so as to minimize the operational cost. This study considers a more general production system in which progressive deterioration is incurred during the operating time, hence resulting in degrading performance. By modeling the system as a multistate deteriorating system, an optimal maintenance policy is obtained by determining the optimal number of standby components required in the system and the optimal state in which the replacement of deteriorating components shall be made.     

Age-reduction models for imperfect maintenance

Maintenance of a deteriorating system is often imperfect, withthe state of the system after maintenance being at a level somewherebetween new and its prior condition.In this paper, the conceptof reduction in virtual or effective age is used to model theeffect of both imperfect corrective maintenance (CM) and imperfectpreventive maitnenance (PM). Results from counting-process theorythen produce a likelihood function necessary for parameter estimation,and the method is tested on known maintenance data. Finally,it is shown how to evaluate, by simulation, the expected numberofsystem failures up to time t under a given periodic PM strategy.This measure is incorporated into a cost rate function whichis then minimized to find the optimal length of a PM intervaland the optimal number of PMs to carry out before system replacement     

Delay-time-based preventive maintenance modelling for a production plant: a case study in a steel mill

This paper presents a case study of delay-time-based preventive maintenance (PM) modelling for a production plant system. Since production stoppages caused by waiting for raw materials provide windows to inspect and maintain the system, these production stoppages can be incorporated into the PM model. Considering the nature of different defects that can cause failures, two types of defects are modelled: small and large defects. Small defects are normally dealt with during production stoppages, but both small and large defects can be dealt with over a longer duration during PM. The parameters of the model are estimated using the maximum-likelihood method based on the real data. The model aims to find the optimal PM interval by minimizing the expected total downtime within an overhaul cycle. Management suggestions are also recommended.     

Optimal maintenance scheduling for a complex manufacturing system subject to deterioration

We address the problem of determining inspection strategy and replacement policy for a deteriorating complex multi-component manufacturing system whose state is partially observable. We develop inspection and replacement scheduling models and other simple maintenance scheduling models via employing an imperfect repair model coupled with a damage process induced by operational conditions. The system state in performance of the imperfectly repaired system is modelled using a proportional intensity model incorporating a damage process and a virtual age process caused by repair. The system is monitored at periodic times and maintenance actions are carried out in response to the observed system state. Decisions to perform imperfect repair and replacement are based on the system state and crossing of a replacement threshold. The model proposed here aims at joint determination of a cost-optimal inspection and replacement policy along with an optimal level of maintenance which result in low maintenance cost and high operational performance and reliability of the system. To demonstrate the use of the model in practical applications a numerical example is provided. Solutions to optimal system parameters are obtained and the response of the model to these parameters is examined. Finally some features of the model are demonstrated. The approach presented provides a framework so that different scenario can be explored.     

On maintenance scheduling of production units

A typical maintenance scheduling problem is presented as a large-scale mixed integer nonlinear programming case. Several relaxations of the conditions of variables and constraints are discussed. The optimal solution of the models based on these relaxations is viewed as the lower bound of the optimal solution in the original problem. A combined implicit enumeration and branch-and-bound algorithm is used. Typical dimension of the problems for which computational experience is reported is 25 production units in the system. 19 of these are to be maintained and a planning horizon of 52 weeks with 5 types of hours per week. The corresponding dimensions of the model are about 5700 constraints, 700 binary variables and 6500 nonlinear separable variables.     

A stochastic model for joint spare parts inventory and planned maintenance optimisation

Spare parts demands are usually generated by the need of maintenance either preventively or at failures. These demands are difficult to predict based on historical data of past spare parts usages, and therefore, the optimal inventory control policy may be also difficult to obtain. However, it is well known that maintenance costs are related to the availability of spare parts and the penalty cost of unavailable spare parts consists of usually the cost of, for example, extended downtime for waiting the spare parts and the emergency expedition cost for acquiring the spare parts. On the other hand, proper planned maintenance intervention can reduce the number of failures and associated costs but its performance also depends on the availability of spare parts. This paper presents the joint optimisation for both the inventory control of the spare parts and the Preventive Maintenance (PM) inspection interval. The decision variables are the order interval, PM interval and order quantity. Because of the random nature of plant failures, stochastic cost models for spare parts inventory and maintenance are derived and an enumeration algorithm with stochastic dynamic programming is employed for finding the joint optimal solutions over a finite time horizon. The delay-time concept developed for inspection modelling is used to construct the probabilities of the number of failures and the number of the defective items identified at a PM epoch, which has not been used in this type of problems before. The inventory model follows a periodic review policy but with the demand governed by the need for spare parts due to maintenance. We demonstrate the developed model using a numerical example.     

Supply chain model for a deteriorating product with time-varying demand and production rate

The paper develops a two-echelon supply chain model with a single-buyer and a single-vendor. The buyer sells a seasonal product over a short selling period and its inventory is subject to deterioration at a constant rate over time. The vendor's production rate is dependent on the buyer's demand rate, which is a linear function of time. Also, the vendor's production process is not perfectly reliable; it may shift from an in-control state to an out-of-control state at any time during a production run and produce some defective (non-conforming) items. Assuming that the vendor follows a lot-for-lot policy for replenishment made to the buyer, the average total cost of the supply chain is derived and an algorithm for finding the optimal solution is developed. The numerical study shows that the supply chain coordination policy is more beneficial than those policies obtained separately from the buyer's and the vendor's perspectives.     

Optimal clustering of frequency-constrained maintenance jobs with shared set-ups

Since maintenance jobs often require one or more set-up activities, joint execution or clustering of maintenance jobs is a powerful instrument to reduce shut-down costs. We consider a clustering problem for frequency-constrained maintenance jobs, i.e. maintenance jobs that must be carried out with a prescribed (or higher) frequency. For the clustering of maintenance jobs with identical, so-called common set-ups, several strong dominance rules are provided. These dominance rules are used in an efficient dynamic programming algorithm which solves the problem in polynomial time. For the clustering of maintenance jobs with partially identical, so-called shared set-ups, similar but less strong dominance rules are available. Nevertheless, a surprisingly well-performing greedy heuristic and a branch and bound procedure have been developed to solve this problem. For randomly generated test problems with 10 set-ups and 30 maintenance jobs, the heuristic was optimal in 47 out of 100 test problems, with an average deviation of 0.24% from the optimal solution. In addition, the branch and bound method found an optimal solution in only a few seconds computation time on average.     

Optimal preventive maintenance of a production system with an intermediate buffer

In this paper we consider a model consisting of a deteriorating installation that transfers a raw material to a production unit and a buffer which has been built between the installation and the production unit. The deterioration process of the installation is considered to be nonstationary, i.e. the transition probabilities may depend not only on the working conditions of the installation but on its age as well. The problem of the optimal preventive maintenance of the installation is considered. Under a suitable cost structure it is shown that, for fixed age of the installation and fixed buffer level, the optimal policy is of control-limit type. When the deterioration process is stationary, an efficient Markov decision algorithm operating on the class of control-limit policies is developed. There is strong numerical evidence that the algorithm converges to the optimal policy. Two generalizations of this model are also discussed.