Monoidal cut strengthening revisited

There are two distinct strengthening methods for disjunctive cuts with some integer variables; they differ in the way they modularize the coefficients. In this paper, we introduce a new variant of one of these methods, the monoidal cut strengthening procedure, based on the paradox that sometimes weakening a disjunction helps the strengthening procedure and results in sharper cuts. We first derive a general result that applies to cuts from disjunctions with any number of terms. It defines the coefficients of the cut in a way that takes advantage of the option of adding new terms to the disjunction. We then specialize this result to the case of split cuts for mixed integer programs with some binary variables, in particular Gomory mixed integer cuts, and to intersection cuts from multiple rows of a simplex tableau. In both instances we specify the conditions under which the new cuts have smaller coefficients than the cuts obtained by either of the two currently known strengthening procedures.     

Two dimensional lattice-free cuts and asymmetric disjunctions for mixed-integer polyhedra

In this paper, we study the relationship between 2D lattice-free cuts, the family of cuts obtained by taking two-row relaxations of a mixed-integer program (MIP) and applying intersection cuts based on maximal lattice-free sets in ${\mathbb{R}^2}$ , and various types of disjunctions. Recently Li and Richard (2008), studied disjunctive cuts obtained from t-branch split disjunctions of mixed-integer sets (these cuts generalize split cuts). Balas (Presentation at the Spring Meeting of the American Mathematical Society (Western Section), San Francisco, 2009) initiated the study of cuts for the two-row continuous group relaxation obtained from 2-branch split disjunctions. We study these cuts (and call them cross cuts) for the two-row continuous group relaxation, and for general MIPs. We also consider cuts obtained from asymmetric 2-branch disjunctions which we call crooked cross cuts. For the two-row continuous group relaxation, we show that unimodular cross cuts (the coefficients of the two split inequalities form a unimodular matrix) are equivalent to the cuts obtained from maximal lattice-free sets other than type 3 triangles. We also prove that all 2D lattice-free cuts and their S-free extensions are crooked cross cuts. For general mixed integer sets, we show that crooked cross cuts can be generated from a structured three-row relaxation. Finally, we show that for the corner relaxation of an MIP, every crooked cross cut is a 2D lattice-free cut.     

A note on the MIR closure and basic relaxations of polyhedra

Anderson et al. (2005) [1] show that for a polyhedral mixed integer set defined by a constraint system Ax≥b, along with integrality restrictions on some of the variables, any split cut is in fact a split cut for a basic relaxation, i.e., one defined by a subset of linearly independent constraints. This result implies that any split cut can be obtained as an intersection cut. Equivalence between split cuts obtained from simple disjunctions of the form x_j≤0 or x_j≥1 and intersection cuts was shown earlier for 0/1-mixed integer sets by Balas and Perregaard (2002) [4]. We give a short proof of the result of Anderson, Cornuéjols and Li using the equivalence between mixed integer rounding (MIR) cuts and split cuts.     

Generalized intersection cuts and a new cut generating paradigm

Intersection cuts are generated from a polyhedral cone and a convex set S whose interior contains no feasible integer point. We generalize these cuts by replacing the cone with a more general polyhedron C. The resulting generalized intersection cuts dominate the original ones. This leads to a new cutting plane paradigm under which one generates and stores the intersection points of the extreme rays of C with the boundary of S rather than the cuts themselves. These intersection points can then be used to generate in a non-recursive fashion cuts that would require several recursive applications of some standard cut generating routine. A procedure is also given for strengthening the coefficients of the integer-constrained variables of a generalized intersection cut. The new cutting plane paradigm yields a new characterization of the closure of intersection cuts and their strengthened variants. This characterization is minimal in the sense that every one of the inequalities it uses defines a facet of the closure.     

Branching on general disjunctions

This paper considers a modification of the branch-and-cut algorithm for Mixed Integer Linear Programming where branching is performed on general disjunctions rather than on variables. We select promising branching disjunctions based on a heuristic measure of disjunction quality. This measure exploits the relation between branching disjunctions and intersection cuts. In this work, we focus on disjunctions defining the mixed integer Gomory cuts at an optimal basis of the linear programming relaxation. The procedure is tested on instances from the literature. Experiments show that, for a majority of the instances, the enumeration tree obtained by branching on these general disjunctions has a smaller size than the tree obtained by branching on variables, even when variable branching is performed using full strong branching.     

On mixed-integer sets with two integer variables

We show that every facet-defining inequality of the convex hull of a mixed-integer polyhedral set with two integer variables is a crooked cross cut (which we defined in 2010). We extend this result to show that crooked cross cuts give the convex hull of mixed-integer sets with more integer variables if the coefficients of the integer variables form a matrix of rank 2. We also present an alternative characterization of the crooked cross cut closure of mixed-integer sets similar to the one on the equivalence of different definitions of split cuts presented in Cook et al. (1990) [4]. This characterization implies that crooked cross cuts dominate the 2-branch split cuts defined by Li and Richard (2008) [8]. Finally, we extend our results to mixed-integer sets that are defined as the set of points (with some components being integral) inside a closed, bounded and convex set.     

Quasi-concave minimization subject to linear constraints

A finite algorithm is presented for solving the quasi-concave minimization problem subject to linear constraints. The concept of an extreme point is generalized to that of an extreme facet of a polyhedron. Then a search routine is developed for the detection of an extreme facet of the feasible region relative to the polyhedron defined by the current set of cuts. After identifying an extreme facet we cut it off by a cut developed for this purpose. We call this cut the facet cut. The method is both compatible with other cutting procedures and is finite..     

Higher-order cover cuts from zero–one knapsack constraints augmented by two-sided bounding inequalities

Extending our work on second-order cover cuts [F. Glover, H.D. Sherali, Second-order cover cuts, Mathematical Programming (ISSN: 0025-5610 1436-4646) (2007), doi:10.1007/s10107-007-0098-4. (Online)], we introduce a new class of higher-order cover cuts that are derived from the implications of a knapsack constraint in concert with supplementary two-sided inequalities that bound the sums of sets of variables. The new cuts can be appreciably stronger than the second-order cuts, which in turn dominate the classical knapsack cover inequalities. The process of generating these cuts makes it possible to sequentially utilize the second-order cuts by embedding them in systems that define the inequalities from which the higher-order cover cuts are derived. We characterize properties of these cuts, design specialized procedures to generate them, and establish associated dominance relationships. These results are used to devise an algorithm that generates all non-dominated higher-order cover cuts, and, in particular, to formulate and solve suitable separation problems for deriving a higher-order cut that deletes a given fractional solution to an underlying continuous relaxation. We also discuss a lifting procedure for further tightening any generated cut, and establish its polynomial-time operation for unit-coefficient cuts. A numerical example is presented that illustrates these procedures and the relative strength of the generated non-redundant, non-dominated higher-order cuts, all of which turn out to be facet-defining for this example. Some preliminary computational results are also presented to demonstrate the efficacy of these cuts in comparison with lifted minimal cover inequalities for the underlying knapsack polytope.     

Higher-level RLT or disjunctive cuts based on a partial enumeration strategy for 0-1 mixed-integer programs

In this paper, we consider the generation of disjunctive cuts for 0-1 mixed-integer programs by conducting a partial exploration of the branch-and-bound tree using quick Lagrangian primal and dual updates. We analyze alternative cut generation strategies based on formulating different disjunctions and adopting various choices of normalization techniques, and indicate how these inequalities can also be generated using a projection from a related high-order lifted formulation obtained via the Reformulation-Linearization Technique of Sherali and Adams. We conclude by presenting a brief computational study that motivates the potential benefits of this procedure.     

Enumerating disjunctions and conjunctions of paths and cuts in reliability theory

Let G=(V,E) be a (directed) graph with vertex set V and edge (arc) set E. Given a set P of source-sink pairs of vertices of G, an important problem that arises in the computation of network reliability is the enumeration of minimal subsets of edges (arcs) that connect/disconnect all/at least one of the given source-sink pairs of P. For undirected graphs, we show that the enumeration problems for conjunctions of paths and disjunctions of cuts can be solved in incremental polynomial time. Furthermore, under the assumption that P consists of all pairs within a given vertex set, we also give incremental polynomial time algorithm for enumerating all minimal path disjunctions and cut conjunctions. For directed graphs, the enumeration problem for cut disjunction is known to be NP-complete. We extend this result to path conjunctions and path disjunctions, leaving open the complexity of the enumeration of cut conjunctions. Finally, we give a polynomial delay algorithm for enumerating all minimal sets of arcs connecting two given nodes s₁ and s₂ to, respectively, a given vertex t₁, and each vertex of a given subset of vertices T₂.     

Concavity cuts for disjoint bilinear programming

We pursue the study of concavity cuts for the disjoint bilinear programming problem. This optimization problem has two equivalent symmetric linear maxmin reformulations, leading to two sets of concavity cuts. We first examine the depth of these cuts by considering the assumptions on the boundedness of the feasible regions of both maxmin and bilinear formulations. We next propose a branch and bound algorithm which make use of concavity cuts. We also present a procedure that eliminates degenerate solutions. Extensive computational experiences are reported. Sparse problems with up to 500 variables in each disjoint sets and 100 constraints, and dense problems with up to 60 variables again in each sets and 60 constraints are solved in reasonable computing times. Received: October 1999 / Accepted: January 2001?Published online March 22, 2001     

Nondifferentiable reverse convex programs and facetial convexity cuts via a disjunctive characterization

Disjunctive Programs can often be transcribed as reverse convex constrained problems with nondifferentiable constraints and unbounded feasible regions. We consider this general class of nonconvex programs, called Reverse Convex Programs (RCP), and show that under quite general conditions, the closure of the convex hull of the feasible region is polyhedral. This development is then pursued from a more constructive standpoint, in that, for certain special reverse convex sets, we specify a finite linear disjunction whose closed convex hull coincides with that of the special reverse convex set. When interpreted in the context of convexity/intersection cuts, this provides the capability of generating any (negative edge extension) facet cut. Although this characterization is more clarifying than computationally oriented, our development shows that if certain bounds are available, then convexity/intersection cuts can be strengthened relatively inexpensively.     

Depth-Optimized Convexity Cuts

This paper presents a general, self-contained treatment of convexity or intersection cuts. It describes two equivalent ways of generating a cut—via a convex set or a concave function—and a partial-order notion of cut strength. We then characterize the structure of the sets and functions that generate cuts that are strongest with respect to the partial order. Next, we specialize this analytical framework to the case of mixed-integer linear programming (MIP). For this case, we formulate two kinds of the deepest cut generation problem, via sets or via functions, and subsequently consider some special cases which are amenable to efficient computation. We conclude with computational tests of one of these procedures on a large set of MIPLIB problems.     

Partial convexification cuts for 0–1 mixed-integer programs

In this research, we propose a new cut generation scheme based on constructing a partial convex hull representation for a given 0–1 mixed-integer programming problem by using the reformulation–linearization technique (RLT). We derive a separation problem that projects the extended space of the RLT formulation into the original space, in order to generate a cut that deletes a current fractional solution. Naturally, the success of such a partial convexification based cutting plane scheme depends on the process used to tradeoff the strength of the cut derived and the effort expended. Accordingly, we investigate several variable selection rules for performing this convexification, along with restricted versions of the accompanying separation problems, so as to be able to derive strong cuts within a reasonable effort. We also develop a strengthening procedure that enhances the generated cut by considering the binariness of the remaining unselected 0–1 variables. Finally, we present some promising computational results that provide insights into implementing the proposed cutting plane methodology.     

Practical strategies for generating rank-1 split cuts in mixed-integer linear programming

In this paper we propose practical strategies for generating split cuts, by considering integer linear combinations of the rows of the optimal simplex tableau, and deriving the corresponding Gomory mixed-integer cuts; potentially, we can generate a huge number of cuts. A key idea is to select subsets of variables, and cut deeply in the space of these variables. We show that variables with small reduced cost are good candidates for this purpose, yielding cuts that close a larger integrality gap. An extensive computational evaluation of these cuts points to the following two conclusions. The first is that our rank-1 cuts improve significantly on existing split cut generators (Gomory cuts from single tableau rows, MIR, Reduce-and-Split, Lift-and-Project, Flow and Knapsack cover): on MIPLIB instances, these generators close 24% of the integrality gap on average; adding our cuts yields an additional 5%. The second conclusion is that, when incorporated in a Branch-and-Cut framework, these new cuts can improve computing time on difficult instances.     

Gentzen’s consistency proof without heightlines

This paper gives a Gentzen-style proof of the consistency of Heyting arithmetic in an intuitionistic sequent calculus with explicit rules of weakening, contraction and cut. The reductions of the proof, which transform derivations of a contradiction into less complex derivations, are based on a method for direct cut-elimination without the use of multicut. This method treats contractions by tracing up from contracted cut formulas to the places in the derivation where each occurrence was first introduced. Thereby, Gentzen’s heightline argument, which introduces additional cuts on contracted compound cut formulas, is avoided. To show termination of the reduction procedure an ordinal assignment based on techniques of Howard for Gödel’s T is used.     

A precise correspondence between lift-and-project cuts, simple disjunctive cuts, and mixed integer gomory cuts for 0-1 programming

 We establish a precise correspondence between lift-and-project cuts for mixed 0-1 programs, simple disjunctive cuts (intersection cuts) and mixed-integer Gomory cuts. The correspondence maps members of one family onto members of the others. It also maps bases of the higher-dimensional cut generating linear program (CGLP) into bases of the linear programming relaxation. It provides new bounds on the number of facets of the elementary closure, and on the rank, of the standard linear programming relaxation of the mixed 0-1 polyhedron with respect to the above families of cutting planes. Based on the above correspondence, we develop an algorithm that solves (CGLP) without explicitly constructing it, by mimicking the pivoting steps of the higher dimensional (CGLP) simplex tableau by certain pivoting steps in the lower dimensional (LP) simplex tableau. In particular, we show how to calculate the reduced costs of the big tableau from the entries of the small tableau and based on this, how to identify a pivot in the small tableau that corresponds to one or several improving pivots in the big tableau. The overall effect is a much improved lift-and-project cut generating procedure, which can also be interpreted as an algorithm for a systematic improvement of mixed integer Gomory cuts from the small tableau. Received: October 5, 2000 / Accepted: March 19, 2002 Published online: September 5, 2002 Research was supported by the National Science Foundation through grant #DMI-9802773 and by the Office of Naval Research through contract N00014-97-1-0196.     

Translations from natural deduction to sequent calculus

Gentzen's “Untersuchungen” [1] gave a translation from natural deduction to sequent calculus with the property that normal derivations may translate into derivations with cuts. Prawitz in [8] gave a translation that instead produced cut‐free derivations. It is shown that by writing all elimination rules in the manner of disjunction elimination, with an arbitrary consequence, an isomorphic translation between normal derivations and cut‐free derivations is achieved. The standard elimination rules do not permit a full normal form, which explains the cuts in Gentzen's translation. Likewise, it is shown that Prawitz' translation contains an implicit process of cut elimination.     

Excluding a Simple Good Pair Approach to Directed Cuts

In 1972, Mader proved that every undirected graph has a good pair, that is, an ordered pair (u,v) of nodes such that the star of v is a minimum cut separating u and v. In 1992, Nagamochi and Ibaraki gave a simple procedure to find a good pair as the basis of an elegant and very efficient algorithm to find minimum cuts in graphs. This paper rules out the simple good pair approach for the problem of finding a minimum directed cut in a digraph and for the more general problem of minimizing submodular functions. In fact, we construct a digraph with no good pair. Note that if a graph has no good pair, then it may not possess a so-called cut-equivalent tree. Benczúr constructed a digraph with no cut-equivalent tree; our counterexample thus extends Benczúr's one. Received: March 12, 1999 Final version received: June 19, 2000