Intra-mathematical connections made by high school students in performing Calculus tasks

In this article, we report the results of research that explores the intra-mathematical connections that high school students make when they solve Calculus tasks, in particular those involving the derivative and the integral. We consider mathematical connections as a cognitive process through which a person relates or associates two or more ideas, concepts, definitions, theorems, procedures, representations and meanings among themselves, with other disciplines or with real life. Task-based interviews were used to collect data and thematic analysis was used to analyze them. Through the analysis of the productions of the 25 participants, we identified 223 intra-mathematical connections. The data allowed us to establish a mathematical connections system which contributes to the understanding of higher concepts, in our case, the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus. We found mathematical connections of the types: different representations, procedural, features, reversibility and meaning as a connection.     

On the use of history of mathematics: an introduction to Galileo's study of free fall motion

In this paper, we report on an experimental activity for discussing the concepts of speed, instantaneous speed and acceleration, generally introduced in first year university courses of calculus or physics. Rather than developing the ideas of calculus and using them to explain these basic concepts for the study of motion, we led 82 first year university students through Galileo's experiments designed to investigate the motion of falling bodies, and his geometrical explanation of his results, via simple dynamic geometric applets designed with GeoGebra. Our goal was to enhance the students’ development of mathematical thinking. Through a scholarship of teaching and learning study design, we captured data from students before, during and after the activity. Findings suggest that the historical development presented to the students helped to show the growth and evolution of the ideas and made visible authentic ways of thinking mathematically. Importantly, the activity prompted students to question and rethink what they knew about speed and acceleration, and also to appreciate the novel concepts of instantaneous speed and acceleration at which Galileo arrived.     

Developing Student Understanding: Contextualizing Calculus Concepts

This study looked at the practice of one high school teacher who provided students with concrete examples from their physics class to give them a contextually rich environment in which to explore the abstractions of calculus. Students discovered connections between the physics concepts of position, velocity, and acceleration and the calculus concepts of function, derivative, and antiderivative. The qualitative study sought to describe several critical aspects of understanding: students' ability to explain concepts and procedures, to apply concepts in a physics context, and to explore their own learning. It included 32 seniors at a large, urban, comprehensive, religious school in a midwestern stale. Samples of student work and reflections were collected by the teacher, as well as by students in individual portfolios. The teacher kept a reflective journal. This study suggests that making connections between calculus and physics can yield deep understandings of semantic as well as procedural knowledge.     

The Assessment of a Complex Problem: The Bungee Jump Project

This article describes a course project used to assess students' capacity to make mathematical connections. Students created simulations of a bungee jump and applied graphic differentiation to investigate connections among the displacement, velocity, and acceleration of the bungee jumper. The responses of three groups of students are described and analyzed to portray their graphical models and characterize their ability to connect essential elements of the model. The key factor distinguishing the three student groups was the degree of completeness and consistency in their connections among the physical elements of the model—displacement, velocity, and acceleration—and its mathematical elements—algebra, geometry, and calculus. A scoring rubric generated from the thinking of the three groups illustrates a means of assessing complex problems like the bungee-jump project.     

Contextual approach in teaching mathematics: an example using the sum of series of positive integers

In this paper, a contextual approach to teaching Mathematics at the pre-university level is recommended, and an example is illustrated. A context in the form of a real common mathematical problem is presented to the students. Different approaches to tackle the problem (from topics within and outside the syllabus) can be elicited from students. The insight obtained from the various methods of solving the problem can be used to deepen students’ learnt concepts and to enhance concepts to be learnt later in the curriculum.     

What part of the concept of acceleration is difficult to understand: the mathematics, the physics, or both?

In this paper, details of student difficulties in understanding the concept of acceleration and the mathematical and physical/intuitive sources of these are delineated by utilizing the teaching experiment methodology. As a result of the study, two anchoring analogies are proposed that can be used as a diagnostic tool for students’ alternative conceptions. These can be used in teaching to highlight the peculiarity of acceleration concept. This study portrays how seeing acceleration as ‘rate of change’ of a quantity (velocity) and recognizing the consequences of such a definition are hindered in certain ways which in turn negatively affect learning the concept of force. This is also an example that illustrates that a rather “simple” mathematical concept (i.e., rate of change) for the expert can become a complex phenomenon when embedded in a physical concept (i.e., acceleration) which is consistently found to be as a misconception among learners at various levels that is widely occurring and very resistant to change.     

Types of reasoning required in university exams in mathematics

Empirical research shows that students often use reasoning founded on copying algorithms or recalling facts (imitative reasoning) when solving mathematical tasks. Research also indicate that a focus on this type of reasoning might weaken the students’ understanding of the underlying mathematical concepts. It is therefore important to study the types of reasoning students have to perform in order to solve exam tasks and pass exams. The purpose of this study is to examine what types of reasoning students taking introductory calculus courses are required to perform. Tasks from 16 exams produced at four different Swedish universities were analyzed and sorted into task classes. The analysis resulted in several examples of tasks demanding different types of mathematical reasoning. The results also show that about 70% of the tasks were solvable by imitative reasoning and that 15 of the exams could be passed using only imitative reasoning.     

Structuring mathematical knowledge and skills by means of knowledge graphs

The aim of the study reported on in this paper was to develop, test and improve a cognitive tool which could help students structure their mathematical knowledge and skills. Mathematics teaching as an auxiliary subject in the context of secondary or tertiary education courses in other disciplines pays too little attention to the structure of the mathematical concepts presented. For the students, therefore, the network of relationships between these concepts does not become a part of their mathematical knowledge and skills, and is consequently not fully available for purposes of reasoning, proving, mathematicizing and solving problems. Knowledge graphs (KGs) can be used by students as a tool to visualize this structure of the concepts and the relations between them. The learning activity of structuring one's mathematical knowledge and skills can be supported by a model, the Mathematical Knowledge Graph Model (MKGM), which serves as a pre-structured heuristic framework. The elements of this model include a central concept, special cases of this concept, operations or actions on the concept, areas of application and properties of the concepts and operations. The present paper reports on a trial among five students of the Open University of the Netherlands (OUNL), who constructed a KG in accordance with the MKGM model. The paper focuses on the graphs produced by the students, their appreciation of the structuring activity and the relation between their graphs and test results.     

Assessments accompanying published textbooks: the extent to which mathematical processes are evident

Assessments accompanying published textbooks are often used by teachers in the USA as a primary means to evaluate students’ mathematical knowledge. In addition to assessing content knowledge, assessments should provide insight into students’ ability to engage with mathematical processes such as reasoning, communication, connections, and representations. We report here an analysis of the extent to which the assessments accompanying published textbooks in the USA at the elementary, middle grades, and high school levels provide opportunities for students to engage with these mathematical processes. Results indicate that in elementary grades, communication, connections, and graphics are not consistently emphasized across grade levels and publishers. In middle grades, students are rarely asked to record their reasoning or translate among representational forms of a concept. In high school geometry, students are given many opportunities to interpret and create graphics, but the same is not true for algebra. With the exception of connections, the results suggest that inconsistent emphasis is placed on the mathematical processes within assessments accompanying commercial textbooks in the USA.     

Abstract algebra students’ evoked concept images for functions and homomorphisms

Homomorphism is a critical variety of function in undergraduate Abstract Algebra (AA) courses and function is one of the unifying concepts across many mathematical subject areas. However, despite homomorphism’s important place in the curriculum and its existence as a particular type of function, little is known of a student’s concept image of functions at advanced levels and the role this concept image may play in a students’ homomorphism-related activities. In this paper, we share cases that explore students’ concept image and treatment of functions at the undergraduate AA level. In particular, we focus on coherence of prior function understanding and functions in AA (homomorphisms), and how this coherence may account for student activity in tasks related to homomorphism. Our results reflect that even at the AA level, students may have limited concept images of functions and their understanding of function (and coherence with homomorphism) can serve as a support or obstacle to task performance in AA. We suggest that both instructors and researchers explicitly attend to the role of function and function understanding in student activity at advanced levels.     

An Analysis of Math Congress in an Eighth Grade Classroom

A “math congress” is a pedagogical approach in which students present their solutions from their mathematical work completed individually, in pairs, or in small groups, and share and defend their mathematical thinking. Mathematical artifacts presented during math congress remain on display as community records of practice. Math congress has four key functions: To highlight and document key mathematical concepts, to emphasize connections between different mathematical strategies, to facilitate conceptual development, and to scaffold learning by drawing attention to the efficiency of particular strategies. The goal of the research was to analyze the role of the math congress in eighth-grade students' development of mathematical thinking. Results suggest that while math congress was helpful for some students, other students articulated continued uncertainty about their mathematical thinking. Pedagogical recommendations as well as future research direction are discussed.     

Mathematical Connections and Their Relationship to Mathematics Knowledge for Teaching Geometry

Effective competition in a rapidly growing global economy places demands on a society to produce individuals capable of higher‐order critical thinking, creative problem solving, connection making, and innovation. We must look to our teacher education programs to help prospective middle grades teachers build the mathematical habits of mind that promote a conceptually indexed, broad‐based foundation of mathematics knowledge for teaching which encompasses the establishment and strengthening of mathematical connections. The purpose of this concurrent exploratory mixed methods study was to examine prospective middle grades teachers' mathematics knowledge for teaching geometry and the connections made while completing open and closed card sort tasks meant to probe mathematical connections. Although prospective middle grades teachers' mathematics knowledge for teaching geometry was below average, they were able to make over 280 mathematical connections during the card sort tasks. Curricular connections made had a statistically significant positive impact on mathematics knowledge for teaching geometry.     

Efficient remainder rule

Understanding the solution of a problem may require the reader to have background knowledge on the subject. For instance, finding an integer which, when divided by a nonzero integer leaves a remainder; but when divided by another nonzero integer may leave a different remainder. To find a smallest positive integer or a set of integers following the given conditions, one may need to understand the concept of modulo arithmetic in number theory. The Chinese Remainder Theorem is a known method to solve these types of problems using modulo arithmetic. In this paper, an efficient remainder rule has been proposed based on basic mathematical concepts. These core concepts are as follows: basic remainder rules of divisions, linear equation in slope intercept form, arithmetic progression and the use of a graphing calculator. These are easily understood by students who have taken prealgebra or intermediate algebra.     

Moving toward shared realities through empathy in mathematical modeling: An ecological systems theory approach

The mathematics education community has routinely called for mathematics tasks to be connected to the real world. However, accomplishing this in ways that are relevant to students’ lived experiences can be challenging. Meanwhile, mathematical modeling has gained traction as a way for students to learn mathematics through real-world connections. In an open problem to the mathematics education community, this paper explores connections between the mathematical modeling and the nature of what is considered relevant to students. The role of empathy is discussed as a proposed component for consideration within mathematical modeling so that students can further relate to real-world contexts as examined through the lens of Ecological Systems Theory. This is contextualized through a classroom-tested example entitled “Tiny Homes as a Solution to Homelessness” followed by implications and conclusions as they relate to mathematics education.     

Focuses of awareness in the process of learning the fundamental theorem of calculus with digital technologies

This paper brings together three themes: the fundamental theorem of the calculus (FTC), digital learning environments in which the FTC may be taught, and what we term “focuses of awareness.” The latter are derived from Radford’s theory of objectification: they are nodal activities through which students become progressively aware of key mathematical ideas structuring a mathematical concept. The research looked at 13 pairs of 17-year-old students who are not yet familiar with the concept of integration. Students were asked to consider possible connections between multiple-linked representations, including function graphs, accumulation function graphs, and tables of values of the accumulation function. Three rounds of analysis yielded nine focuses in the process of students’ learning the FTC with a digital tool as well as the relationship between them. In addition, the activities performed by the students to become aware of the focuses are described and theoretical and pedagogical implementations are also discussed.     

New challenges in the 2011 revised middle school curriculum of South Korea: mathematical process and mathematical attitude

The ‘future-oriented middle school mathematics curriculum focused on creativity and personality’ was revised in August of 2011 with the aim of nurturing students’ mathematical creativity and sound personalities. The curriculum emphasizes: contextual learning from which students can grasp mathematical concepts and make connections with their everyday lives; manipulation activities through which students may attain an intuitive idea of what they are learning and enhance their creativity; and reasoning to justify mathematical results based on their knowledge and experience. Since students will not be able to engage in the intended mathematical process with the study-load imposed by the current curriculum, the newly revised curriculum modifies or deletes some parts of the contents that have been traditionally taught mechanically. This paper provides a detailed overview of the main points of the revised curriculum.     

A questionnaire to elicit the mathematical concept images of engineering students

As part of a study into the mathematical understanding of engineering students, a questionnaire has been developed which seeks to elicit from students their concept images attached to key mathematical concepts. The questionnaire seeks to address both the level of understanding of the students and the mode in which the students hold the concept image. The instrument has been used on over 200 students in the schools of mathematics and engineering at the University of Plymouth, and while the details may not be exactly suited to other groups, it is suggested that the method may be helpful to other researchers in the field. Initial results suggest that engineering and mathematics students do have different concept images, and in particular that engineering students gradually adopt mathematical ideas into their engineering knowledge in a way which makes sense of them.     

On the construction of set-based meanings for the truth of mathematical conditionals

This paper presents a case study of Hugo’s construction of Euler diagrams to develop set-based meanings for the truth of mathematical conditionals. We use this case to set forth a framework of three stages of activity in students’ guided reinvention of mathematical logic: reading activity, connecting activity, and fluent activity. The framework also categorizes various forms of connecting activity by which students may reflect on their reading activity: connecting tasks, connecting representations, and connecting conditions for truth and falsehood (which we call meanings). We argue that coordinating such connections is necessary to justify logical equivalences, such as why contrapositive statements share truth-values. Through the case study, we document the representations and meanings that Hugo called upon to assign truth-values to conditionals. The framework should help clarify and advance future research on the teaching and learning of logic rooted in students’ mathematical activity.     

Mathematical Level Raising Through Collaborative Investigations with the Computer

Investigations with the computer can have different functions in the mathematical learning process, such as to let students explore a subject domain, to guide the process of reinvention, or to give them the opportunity to apply what they have learned. Which function has most effect on mathematical level raising?We investigated that question in the context of developing learning materials for 16-year-old students in the domain of probability theory,consisting of computer simulations based on a gambling game and investigation tasks about these games. We compared the difference in level raising between three versions of the learning materials: investigations with the computer before, during or after the learning of a mathematical concept. It was shown that there was no significant difference in the final mathematical level that students attained in the three conditions (the product). However, there were differences in the level on which students approached the investigation tasks (the process). Furthermore,we found evidence of new categories in the students' answers, lying between the perceptual and conceptual levels, which may give important insight into the process of level raising. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Motion, speed, and other ideas that “should be put in books”

This paper focuses on a portion of a research project involving a group of inner-city middle school students who used SimCalc simulation software over the course of an entire school year to investigate ideas relating to graphical representations of motion and speed. The classroom environment was one in which students openly defended and justified their thinking as they actively explored and solved rich mathematical problems. The activities, generally speaking, involved functions that were intended to tap students’ real world intuitions as well as prior mathematical skills and understandings about speed, motion, and other graphical representations that underlie the mathematics of motion. Results indicate that these students did build ideas related to those concepts. This paper will provide documentation of the ways in which these students interpreted graphical representations involving linear and quadratic functions that are associated with constant and linearly changing velocities, respectively.