Scheduling with controllable release dates and processing times: Total completion time minimization

The single machine scheduling problem with two types of controllable parameters, job processing times and release dates, is studied. It is assumed that the cost of compressing processing times and release dates from their initial values is a linear function of the compression amounts. The objective is to minimize the sum of the total completion time of the jobs and the total compression cost. For the problem with equal release date compression costs we construct a reduction to the assignment problem. We demonstrate that if in addition the jobs have equal processing time compression costs, then it can be solved in O(n²) time. The solution algorithm can be considered as a generalization of the algorithm that minimizes the makespan and total compression cost. The generalized version of the algorithm is also applicable to the problem with parallel machines and to a range of due-date scheduling problems with controllable processing times.     

Single-machine scheduling to minimize earliness and number of tardy jobs

This paper considers the problem of assigning a common due-date to a set of simultaneously available jobs and sequencing them on a single machine. The objective is to determine the optimal combination of the common due-date and job sequence that minimizes a cost function based on the assigned due-date, job earliness values, and number of tardy jobs. It is shown that the optimal due-date coincides with one of the job completion times. Conditions are derived to determine the optimal number of nontardy jobs. It is also shown that the optimal job sequence is one in which the nontardy jobs are arranged in nonincreasing order of processing times. An efficient algorithm of O(n logn) time complexity to find the optimal solution is presented and an illustrative example is provided. Finally, several extensions of the model are discussed.This research was supported in part by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada under Grant OPG0036424. The authors are thankful to two anonymous referees for their constructive comments.     

Setting Job-Shop Due-Dates with Service-Level Constraints

The job-shop due-date assignment problem arises when a manager needs to ‘promise’ a delivery date to a customer. Previous methods yield due-dates which are either optimistic (unlikely to be achieved) or conservative (the promise will be met, but too easily, because the date given was very pessimistic). This paper investigates the due-date assignment problem with a customer ‘service-level’ constraint, the percentage of time that promised delivery dates are honoured. We formulate a rule to attain this service level, yet maintain as short a due-date lead time as possible. Unlike previous attempts, this due-date rule considers not only the job content and instantaneous shop congestion information, but also implicitly incorporates information on how the jobs will be scheduled (or ‘loaded’) once they are in the shop. We simulate a single-machine shop for various measures of performance under several dispatching priorities, comparing our due-date rule with one reported to yield satisfactory performance. Our rule meets all requirements and is found to be superior for most measures of performance.     

A search method for optimal control of a flow shop system of traditional machines

We consider a convex and nondifferentiable optimization problem for deterministic flow shop systems in which the arrival times of the jobs are known and jobs are processed in the order they arrive. The decision variables are the service times that are to be set only once before processing the first job, and cannot be altered between processes. The cost objective is the sum of regular costs on job completion times and service costs inversely proportional to the controllable service times. A finite set of subproblems, which can be solved by trust-region methods, are defined and their solutions are related to the optimal solution of the optimization problem under consideration. Exploiting these relationships, we introduce a two-phase search method which converges in a finite number of iterations. A numerical study is held to demonstrate the solution performance of the search method compared to a subgradient method proposed in earlier work.     

On Optimal Common Due-Date Determination

Given a set of n independent jobs to be processed on a singlemachine, the problem is to determine the optimal constant flowallowance for the CON due-date assignment method and the optimaljob sequence to minimize an average missed due-date cost. Alinear programming formulation of the problem is proposed andthe optimal due-date is obtained by solving the LP dual problem.It is shown that the optimal job sequence can be determinedanalytically only under a special circumstance. Finally, a numericalexample is given to demonstrate how the results can be appliedto find the optimal solutions.     

一个非常规目标函数的单机随机调度的最优策略

本文考虑了n个工件在同一台机器上加工的调度问题 ,其中工件的加工时间和交货期都是具有任意分布的随机变量 .我们考虑了一个非常规目标函数 ,其中工件的权数与平均加工时间成比例 .在工件的交货期与加工时间满足相容条件下 ,得到了个简单的最优排序策略 .     

Control and scheduling in a two-station queueing network: Optimal policies and heuristics

Consider a two-station queueing network with two types of jobs: type 1 jobs visit station 1 only, while type 2 jobs visit both stations in sequence. Each station has a single server. Arrival and service processes are modeled as counting processes with controllable stochastic intensities. The problem is to control the arrival and service processes, and in particular to schedule the server in station 1 among the two job types, in order to minimize a discounted cost function over an infinite time horizon. Using a stochastic intensity control approach, we establish the optimality of a specific stationary policy, and show that its value function satisfies certain properties, which lead to a switching-curve structure. We further classify the problem into six parametric cases. Based on the structural properties of the stationary policy, we establish the optimality of some simple priority rules for three of the six cases, and develop heuristic policies for the other three cases.     

A Heuristic for Common Due-date Assignment and Job Scheduling on Parallel Machines

In this paper we consider the problem of scheduling a set of simultaneously available jobs on several parallel and identical machines. The problem is to find the optimal due-date, assuming this to be the same for all jobs. We also seek to sequence the jobs such that some are early and some are late so as to minimize a penalty function. For the single-machine problem, we present a simple proof of the well-known optimality result that the optimal due-date coincides with one of the job completion times. We show that the optimal job sequence for the single-machine problem can be easily determined. We prove that the same optimal due-date result can be generalized to the parallel-machine problem. However, determination of the optimal job sequence for such a problem is much more complex, and we present a simple heuristic to find an approximate solution. On the basis of a limited experiment, we observe that the heuristic is very effective in obtaining near-optimal solutions.     

工作有到达时间且拒绝工件总个数受限的单机平行分批排序问题的近似算法

考虑了工件有到达时间且拒绝工件总个数不超过某个给定值的单机平行分批排序问题.在该问题中,给定一个工件集和一台可以进行批处理加工的机器.每个工件有它的到达时间和加工时间;对于每个工件来说要么被拒绝要么被接受安排在机器的某一个批次里进行加工;一个工件如果被拒绝,则需支付该工件对应的拒绝费用.为了保证一定的服务水平,要求拒绝工件的总个数不超过给定值.目标是如何安排被接受工件的加工批次和加工次序使得其最大完工时间与被拒绝工件的总拒绝费用之和最小.该问题是NP-难的,对此给出了伪多项式时间动态规划精确算法,2-近似算法和完全多项式时间近似方案.     

Scheduling with agreeable release times and due dates on a batch processing machine

We consider the problem of scheduling semiconductor burn-in operations, where burn-in ovens are modeled as batch processing machines. The job release times and due dates are assumed to be agreeable. Two different objective functions are considered: minimize the maximum tardiness and minimize the number of tardy jobs. We study the complexity of the problems. Efficient algorithms are also provided for the case when the job release times, due dates, and processing times are agreeable, which generalize those provided by Lee, Uzsoy and Martin-Vega (1992).     

Optimal assignment of slack due-dates and sequencing in a single-machine shop

This paper considers the problem of optimal assignment of slack due-dates to n jobs and sequencing them on a single-machine to minimize a penalty function depending on the values of the assigned slack allowance and maximum job tardiness. It is shown that the earliest due-date order yields an optimal sequence and the optimal slack allowance is a simple function of the cost per unit slack allowance.     

Due-date assignment and single machine scheduling with deteriorating jobs

We study a scheduling problem with deteriorating jobs, that is, jobs whose processing times are an increasing function of their start times. We consider the case of a single machine and linear job-independent deterioration. The problem is to determine an optimal combination of the due-date and schedule so as to minimize the sum of due-date, earliness and tardiness penalties. We give an O(n log n) time algorithm to solve this problem.     

Optimal admission policies for a finite queue with bursty arrivals

We consider a service system with a single server, a finite waiting room and two classes of customers with deterministic service time. Primary jobs arrive at random and are admitted whenever there is room in the system. At the beginning of each period, secondary jobs can be admitted from an infinite pool. A revenue is earned upon admission of each job, with the primary jobs bringing a higher contribution than the secondary jobs, the objective being to maximize the total discounted revenue over an infinite horizon. We model the system as a discrete time Markov decision process and show that a monotone admission policy is optimal when the number of primary arrivals has a fixed distribution. Moreover, when the primary arrival distribution varies with time according to a finite state Markov chain, we show that the optimal policy is conditionally monotone and that the numerical computation of an optimal policy, in this case, is substantially more difficult than in the case of stationary arrivals.This research was supported in part by the National Science Foundation, under grant ECS-8803061, while the author was at the University of Arizona.     

Minimizing weighted earliness–tardiness and due-date cost with unit processing-time jobs

The classical single-machine scheduling and due-date assignment problem of Panwalker et al. [Panwalker, S.S., Smith, M.L., Seidmann, A., 1982. Common due date assignment to minimize total penalty for the one machine scheduling problem. Operations Research 30(2) (1982) 391–399] is the following: All n jobs share a common due-date, which is to be determined. Jobs completed prior to or after the due-date are penalized according to a cost function which is linear and job-independent. The objective is to minimize the total earliness–tardiness and due-date cost. We study a generalized version of this problem in which: (i) the earliness and tardiness costs are allowed to be job dependent and asymmetric and (ii) jobs are processed on parallel identical machines. We focus on the case of unit processing-time jobs. The problem is shown to be solved in polynomial (O(n⁴)) time. Then we study the special case with no due-date cost (a classical problem known in the literature as TWET). We introduce an O(n³) solution for this case. Finally, we study the minmax version of the problem, (i.e., the objective is to minimize the largest cost incurred by any of the jobs), which is shown to be solved in polynomial time as well.     

A novel ant colony optimization approach for on-line scheduling and due date determination

This paper aims to develop an on-line Ant Colony Optimization (ACO) framework, where jobs arrive over time, and at any time we lack knowledge concerning future jobs. A due date is determined upon job arrival, and jobs are sequenced on the machine to optimize the sum of weighted lead times with all due dates met. We propose that each ant is associated with a sequence of waiting jobs with quoted due dates. This waiting sequence is constantly updated over time (whenever a job is selected to be processed or a new job arrives). The on-line schedule is constructed by selecting the first job in the waiting list of the “best” ant to process (along with its due date) as the machine becomes available. However, for the ant where this job is not the first one in the list, processing it pushes back the waiting jobs positioned before it. If such push back results in a due date violation, this ant will be eliminated. Further, our ACO framework does not include the iterative procedure due to the characteristics of the on-line problem; this is one difference from the traditional ACO framework besides ant elimination. The computational testing on generated instances shows that our ACO algorithm outperforms an existing effective on-line algorithm in the literature. Also, with local search incorporated using the EDD (Earliest Due Date) rule, improvements can be obtained in both computational outcome and time.     

On the Assignment of Optimal Due Dates

In a recent paper, Quaddus presents a linear programming analysis for assigning an optimal due date to n independent jobs. The criterion treated in the model is the minimization of total penalty cost, where, for each job, penalties are assessed on earliness, tardiness and due-date allowance. Quaddus considers job-dependent penalties, thereby generalizing models addressed by other authors, but neglects the sequencing aspect of the problem. As a consequence, the examples are not completely optimized. In this note we offer an alternative proof of the Quaddus result, without relying on duality theory, and we show how Quaddus' examples fall short of optimizing the total penalty.     

Scheduling arrivals to a production system in a fuzzy environment

A frequently encountered scheduling problem is to determine a material and job ready time while simultaneously finding a production sequence given customer-specified due dates. Often the production times and due dates are vague. This paper presents an investigation of scheduling ready times for a set of jobs with fuzzy service times and due dates. The ready time is constrained in that the possibility that a job is late must not exceed a predefined value. The objective in such an instance is to maximize the ready time without violating these constraints. The steps necessary to determine the maximum ready time and cases in which this effort may be significantly reduced are presented for single machine and flow shop production systems. Finally, a branch and bound technique is developed for cases in which the optimal job sequence cannot be determined a priori.     

Optimal load sharing in soft real-time systems using likelihood ratios

We consider a load-sharing problem for a multiprocessor system in which jobs have real-time constraints: if the waiting time of a job exceeds a given random amount (called the laxity of the job), then the job is considered lost. To minimize the steady-state probability of loss with respect to the load-sharing parameters, we propose to use the likelihood ratio derivative estimate approach, which has recently been studied for sensitivity analysis of stochastic systems. We formulate a recursive stochastic optimization algorithm using likelihood ratio estimates to solve the optimization problem and provide a proof for almost sure convergence of the algorithm. The algorithm can be used for on-line optimization of the real-time system and does not require a priori knowledge of the arrival rate of customers to the system or the service time and laxity distributions. To illustrate our results, we provide simulation examples.This research was partially supported by an IBM Graduate Fellowship and by the National Science Foundation through Grant No. ECS-87-15217.     

A branch and bound algorithm for scheduling jobs with controllable processing times on a single machine to meet due dates

In most deterministic scheduling problems, job-processing times are regarded as constant and known in advance. However, in many realistic environments, job-processing times can be controlled by the allocation of a common resource to jobs. In this paper, we consider the problem of scheduling jobs with arbitrary release dates and due dates on a single machine, where job-processing times are controllable and are modeled by a non-linear convex resource consumption function. The objective is to determine simultaneously an optimal processing permutation as well as an optimal resource allocation, such that no job is completed later than its due date, and the total resource consumption is minimized. The problem is strongly NP\mathcal{NP}-hard. A branch and bound algorithm is presented to solve the problem. The computational experiments show that the algorithm can provide optimal solution for small-sized problems, and near-optimal solution for medium-sized problems in acceptable computing time.     

Minmax scheduling problems with common flow-allowance

In due-date assignment problems with a common flow-allowance, the due-date of a given job is defined as the sum of its processing time and a job-independent constant. We study flow-allowance on a single machine, with an objective function of a minmax type. The total cost of a given job consists of its earliness/tardiness and its flow-allowance cost components. Thus, we seek the job schedule and flow-allowance value that minimize the largest cost among all the jobs. Three extensions are considered: the case of general position-dependent processing times, the model containing an explicit cost for the due-dates, and the setting of due-windows. Properties of optimal schedules are fully analysed in all cases, and all the problems are shown to have polynomial time solutions.