Analytical Model for CO2 Injection into Brine Aquifers-Containing Residual CH4

During CO₂ injection into brine aquifers-containing residual and/or dissolved CH₄, three distinct regions develop: (1) a single-phase, dry-out region around the well-bore filled with pure supercritical CO₂; (2) a two-phase, two-component system containing CO₂ and brine; and (3) a two-phase, two-component system containing CH₄, and brine. This article extends an existing analytical solution, for pressure buildup during CO₂ injection into brine aquifers, by incorporating dissolved and/or residual CH₄. In this way, the solution additionally accounts for partial miscibility of the CO₂?CCH₄?Cbrine system and the relative permeability hysteresis associated with historic imbibition of brine and current drainage due to CO₂ injection and CH₄ bank development. Comparison of the analytical solution results with commercial simulator, CMG-GEM, shows excellent agreement among a range of different scenarios. The presence of residual CH₄ in a brine aquifer summons two competing phenomena, (1) reduction in relative permeability (phase interference), which increases pressure buildup by reducing total mobility, and (2) increase in bulk compressibility which decreases pressure buildup of the system. If initial CH₄ is dissolved (no free CH₄), these effects are not as important as they are in the residual gas scenario. Relative permeability hysteresis increased the CH₄ bank length (compared to non-hysteretic relative permeability), which led to further reduction in pressure buildup. The nature of relative permeability functions controls whether residual CH₄ is beneficial or disadvantageous to CO₂ storage capacity and injectivity in a candid brine aquifer.     

Pressure Buildup During CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Injection into a Closed Brine Aquifer

CO₂ injected into porous formations is accommodated by reduction in the volume of the formation fluid and enlargement of the pore space, through compression of the formation fluids and rock material, respectively. A critical issue is how the resulting pressure buildup will affect the mechanical integrity of the host formation and caprock. Building on an existing approximate solution for formations of infinite radial extent, this article presents an explicit approximate solution for estimating pressure buildup due to injection of CO₂ into closed brine aquifers of finite radial extent. The analysis is also applicable for injection into a formation containing multiple wells, in which each well acts as if it were in a quasi-circular closed region. The approximate solution is validated by comparison with vertically averaged results obtained using TOUGH2 with ECO2N (where many of the simplifying assumptions are relaxed), and is shown to be very accurate over wide ranges of the relevant parameter space. The resulting equations for the pressure distribution are explicit, and can be easily implemented within spreadsheet software for estimating CO₂ injection capacity.     

Impact of Capillary Pressure, Salinity and In situ Conditions on CO2 Injection into Saline Aquifers

This article presents a numerical investigation of the combined effects of capillary pressure, salinity and in situ thermodynamic conditions on CO₂-brine-rock interactions in a saline aquifer. We demonstrate that the interrelations between capillary pressure, salinity, dissolution and drying-out affect CO₂ injectivity and storage capacity of a saline aquifer. High capillary forces require a high injection pressure for a given injection rate. Depending on salinity, the increase in injection pressure due to capillary forces can be offset by the dissolution of CO₂ in formation water and its compressibility. Higher capillary forces also reduce gravity segregation, and this gives a more homogeneous CO₂ plume which improves the dissolution of CO₂. The solubility of CO₂ in formation water decreases with increasing salinity which requires an increased injection pressure. Higher salinity and capillary pressure can even block the pores, causing an increased salt precipitation. Simulations with various pressure-temperature conditions and modified salinity and capillary pressure curves demonstrate that, with the injection pressures similar for both cold and warm basins at a given injection rate, CO₂ dissolves about 10% more in the warm basin water than in the cold basin. The increase in dissolution lowers the injection pressure compensating the disadvantage of low CO₂ density and compressibility for storage in warm basins.     

CO2 Injection into Saline Carbonate Aquifer Formations II: Comparison of Numerical Simulations to Experiments

Sequestration of carbon dioxide in geological formations is an alternative way of managing extra carbon. Although there are a number of mathematical modeling studies related to this subject, experimental studies are limited and most studies focus on injection into sandstone reservoirs as opposed to carbonate ones. This study describes a fully coupled geochemical compositional equation-of-state compositional simulator (STARS) for the simulation of CO₂ storage in saline aquifers. STARS models physical phenomena including (1) thermodynamics of sub- and supercritical CO₂, and PVT properties of mixtures of CO₂ with other fluids, including (saline) water; (2) fluid mechanics of single and multiphase flow when CO₂ is injected into aquifers; (3) coupled hydrochemical effects due to interactions between CO₂, reservoir fluids, and primary mineral assemblages; and (4) coupled hydromechanical effects, such as porosity and permeability change due to the aforementioned blocking of pores by carbonate particles and increased fluid pressures from CO₂ injection. Matching computerized tomography monitored laboratory experiments showed the uses of the simulation model. In the simulations dissolution and deposition of calcite as well as adsorption of CO₂ that showed the migration of CO₂ and the dissociation of CO₂ into HCO₃ and its subsequent conversion into carbonate minerals were considered. It was observed that solubility and hydrodynamic storage of CO₂ is larger compared to mineral trapping.     

Investigation of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Plume Behavior for a Large-Scale Pilot Test of Geologic Carbon Storage in a Saline Formation

The hydrodynamic behavior of carbon dioxide (CO₂) injected into a deep saline formation is investigated, focusing on trapping mechanisms that lead to CO₂ plume stabilization. A numerical model of the subsurface at a proposed power plant with CO₂ capture is developed to simulate a planned pilot test, in which 1,000,000 metric tons of CO₂ is injected over a 4-year period, and the subsequent evolution of the CO₂ plume for hundreds of years. Key measures are plume migration distance and the time evolution of the partitioning of CO₂ between dissolved, immobile free-phase, and mobile free-phase forms. Model results indicate that the injected CO₂ plume is effectively immobilized at 25 years. At that time, 38% of the CO₂ is in dissolved form, 59% is immobile free phase, and 3% is mobile free phase. The plume footprint is roughly elliptical, and extends much farther up-dip of the injection well than down-dip. The pressure increase extends far beyond the plume footprint, but the pressure response decreases rapidly with distance from the injection well, and decays rapidly in time once injection ceases. Sensitivity studies that were carried out to investigate the effect of poorly constrained model parameters permeability, permeability anisotropy, and residual CO₂ saturation indicate that small changes in properties can have a large impact on plume evolution, causing significant trade-offs between different trapping mechanisms.     

Effect of Well Orientation (Vertical vs. Horizontal) and Well Length on the Injection of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> in Deep Saline Aquifers

Simulations of CO₂ injection into confined saline aquifers were conducted for both vertical and horizontal injection wells. The metrics used in quantifying the performances of different injection scenarios included changes in pressure near the injection well, mass of CO₂ dissolved into brine (solubility trapping), and storage efficiency, all evaluated with an assumed injection period of 50 years. Metrics were quantified as functions of well length, well orientation, CO₂ injection rate, and formation anisotropy (ratio of vertical to horizontal conductivity). When equal well lengths are compared, there is not a significant difference between the predicted performances of horizontal and vertical wells. However, the length of a horizontal well may exceed the length of a vertical well because the length of the horizontal well is not constrained to the vertical thickness of the geologic formation. Simulations show that, as the length of the horizontal well is allowed to increase, the geologic formation can receive a significantly higher CO₂ injection rate without exceeding a maximum allowable pressure. This result is observed in both isotropic and anisotropic formations, and suggests that horizontal wells may be advantageous under pressure-limited conditions. However, the use of horizontal wells does not significantly improve the storage efficiency, and under strongly anisotropic conditions, a vertical well provides higher storage efficiency than a horizontal well. We conclude that horizontal wells may be preferable if the goal is to sequester a large amount of CO₂ in a short period of time, but do not offer a significant advantage in terms of long-term capacity of a potential repository.     

Effects of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Compressibility on CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Storage in Deep Saline Aquifers

The injection of supercritical CO₂ in deep saline aquifers leads to the formation of a CO₂ plume that tends to float above the formation brine. As pressure builds up, CO₂ properties, i.e. density and viscosity, can vary significantly. Current analytical solutions do not account for CO₂ compressibility. In this article, we investigate numerically and analytically the effect of this variability on the position of the interface between the CO₂-rich phase and the formation brine. We introduce a correction to account for CO₂ compressibility (density variations) and viscosity variations in current analytical solutions. We find that the error in the interface position caused by neglecting CO₂ compressibility is relatively small when viscous forces dominate. However, it can become significant when gravity forces dominate, which is likely to occur at late times of injection.     

CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> injection into saline carbonate aquifer formations I: laboratory investigation

Although there are a number of mathematical modeling studies for carbon dioxide (CO₂) injection into aquifer formations, experimental studies are limited and most studies focus on injection into sandstone reservoirs as opposed to carbonate ones. This study presents the results of computerized tomography (CT) monitored laboratory experiments to analyze permeability and porosity changes as well as to characterize relevant chemical reactions associated with injection and storage of CO₂ in carbonate formations. CT monitored experiments are designed to model fast near well bore flow and slow reservoir flows. Highly heterogeneous cores drilled from a carbonate aquifer formation located in South East Turkey were used during the experiments. Porosity changes along the core plugs and the corresponding permeability changes are reported for different CO₂ injection rates and different salt concentrations of formation water. It was observed that either a permeability increase or a permeability reduction can be obtained. The trend of change in rock properties is very case dependent because it is related to distribution of pores, brine composition and thermodynamic conditions. As the salt concentration decreases, porosity and the permeability decreases are less pronounced. Calcite deposition is mainly influenced by orientation, with horizontal flow resulting in larger calcite deposition compared to vertical flow.     

Characteristics of Salt-Precipitation and the Associated Pressure Build-Up during CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Storage in Saline Aquifers

Mitigation and control of borehole pressure at the bottom of an injection well is directly related to the effective management of well injectivity during geologic carbon sequestration activity. Researchers have generally accepted the idea that high rates of CO₂ injection into low permeability strata results in increased bottom-hole pressure in a well. However, the results of this study suggested that this is not always the case, due to the occurrence of localized salt precipitation adjacent to the injection well. A series of numerical simulations indicated that in some cases, a low rate of CO₂ injection into high permeability formation induced greater pressure build-up. This occurred because of the different types of salt precipitation pattern controlled by buoyancy-driven CO₂ plume migration. The first type is non-localized salt precipitation, which is characterized by uniform salt precipitation within the dry-out zone. The second type, localized salt precipitation, is characterized by an abnormally high level of salt precipitation at the dry-out front. This localized salt precipitation acts as a barrier that hampers the propagation of both CO₂ and pressure to the far field as well as counter-flowing brine migration toward the injection well. These dynamic processes caused a drastic pressure build-up in the well, which decreased injectivity. By modeling a series of test cases, it was found that low-rate CO₂ injection into high permeability formation was likely to cause localized salt precipitation. Sensitivity studies revealed that brine salinity linearly affected the level of salt precipitation, and that vertical permeability enhanced the buoyancy effect which increased the growth of the salt barrier. The porosity also affected both the level of localized salt precipitation and dry-out zone extension depending on injection rates. High temperature injected CO₂ promoted the vertical movement of the CO₂ plume, which accelerated localized salt precipitation, but at the same time caused a decrease in the density of the injected CO₂. The combination of these two effects eventually decreased bottomhole pressure. Considering the injectivity degradation, a method is proposed for decreasing the pressure build-up and increasing injectivity by assigning a ‘skin zone’ that represents a local region with a transmissivity different from that of the surrounding aquifer.     

Injection and Storage of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> in Deep Saline Aquifers: Analytical Solution for CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Plume Evolution During Injection

Injection of fluids into deep saline aquifers is practiced in several industrial activities, and is being considered as part of a possible mitigation strategy to reduce anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Injection of CO₂ into deep saline aquifers involves CO₂ as a supercritical fluid that is less dense and less viscous than the resident formation water. These fluid properties lead to gravity override and possible viscous fingering. With relatively mild assumptions regarding fluid properties and displacement patterns, an analytical solution may be derived to describe the space–time evolution of the CO₂ plume. The solution uses arguments of energy minimization, and reduces to a simple radial form of the Buckley–Leverett solution for conditions of viscous domination. In order to test the applicability of the analytical solution to the CO₂ injection problem, we consider a wide range of subsurface conditions, characteristic of sedimentary basins around the world, that are expected to apply to possible CO₂ injection scenarios. For comparison, we run numerical simulations with an industry standard simulator, and show that the new analytical solution matches a full numerical solution for the entire range of CO₂ injection scenarios considered. The analytical solution provides a tool to estimate practical quantities associated with CO₂ injection, including maximum spatial extent of a plume and the shape of the overriding less-dense CO₂ front.     

An Experimental Study of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Exsolution and Relative Permeability Measurements During CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Saturated Water Depressurization

Dissolution of CO₂ into brine is an important and favorable trapping mechanism for geologic storage of CO₂. There are scenarios, however, where dissolved CO₂ may migrate out of the storage reservoir. Under these conditions, CO₂ will exsolve from solution during depressurization of the brine, leading to the formation of separate phase CO₂. For example, a CO₂ sequestration system with a brine-permeable caprock may be favored to allow for pressure relief in the sequestration reservoir. In this case, CO₂-rich brine may be transported upwards along a pressure gradient caused by CO₂ injection. Here we conduct an experimental study of CO₂ exsolution to observe the behavior of exsolved gas under a wide range of depressurization. Exsolution experiments in highly permeable Berea sandstones and low permeability Mount Simon sandstones are presented. Using X-ray CT scanning, the evolution of gas phase CO₂ and its spatial distribution is observed. In addition, we measure relative permeability for exsolved CO₂ and water in sandstone rocks based on mass balances and continuous observation of the pressure drop across the core from 12.41 to 2.76 MPa. The results show that the minimum CO₂ saturation at which the exsolved CO₂ phase mobilization occurs is from 11.7 to 15.5%. Exsolved CO₂ is distributed uniformly in homogeneous rock samples with no statistical correlation between porosity and CO₂ saturation observed. No gravitational redistribution of exsolved CO₂ was observed after depressurization, even in the high permeability core. Significant differences exist between the exsolved CO₂ and water relative permeabilities, compared to relative permeabilities derived from steady-state drainage relative permeability measurements in the same cores. Specifically, very low CO₂ and water relative permeabilities are measured in the exsolution experiments, even when the CO₂ saturation is as high as 40%. The large relative permeability reduction in both the water and CO₂ phases is hypothesized to result from the presence of disconnected gas bubbles in this two-phase flow system. This feature is also thought to be favorable for storage security after CO₂ injection.     

Dissolution of CO2 From Leaking Fractures in Saline Formations

Leakage of CO₂ through fractures in saline formations will increase the CO₂??brine interface and promote CO₂ dissolution. We use a 2D, finite difference MATLAB model to simulate dissolution rates from a vertical fracture, with CO₂ flowing through it, in a secondary storage formation. The instigation of convection currents increases dissolution rates leading to higher dissolution in higher Rayleigh number systems. Comparison of our results with fracture flow rates shows that for typical fracture apertures dissolution from a fracture is small relative to the amount of CO₂ flowing through the fracture. Temporal and spatial variations in fracture permeability may reduce fracture flow rates and increase the relative amount of CO₂ dissolved from the fracture compared to the CO₂ flowing through the fracture. Further work on CO₂ dissolution in relation to fracture heterogeneity, flow of CO₂ within fractures and the interaction of multiple fractures will improve our ability to predict CO₂ dissolution rates for site characterisation.     

Analytical Solution Incorporating History-Dependent Processes for Quick Assessment of Capillary Trapping During CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Geological Storage

Carbon storage in saline formations is considered as a promising option to ensure the necessary decrease of CO₂ anthropogenic emissions. Its industrial development in those formations is above all conditioned by its safety demonstration. Assessing the evolution of trapped and mobile CO₂ across time is essential in the perspective of reducing leakage risks. In this work, we focus on residual trapping phenomenon occurring during the wetting of the injected CO₂ plume. History dependent effects are of first importance when dealing with capillary trapping. We then apply the classical fractional flow theory (Buckley–Leverett type model) and include trapping and hysteresis models; we derive an analytical solution for the temporal evolution of saturation profile and of CO₂ trapped quantity when injecting water after the gas injection (“artificial imbibition”). The comparison to numerical simulations for different configurations shows satisfactory match and justifies, in the case of industrial CO₂ storage, the assumptions of incompressible flow with no consideration of capillary pressure. The obtained analytical solution allows the quick assessment of both the quantity and the location of mobile gas left during imbibition.     

The Footprint of the CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Plume during Carbon Dioxide Storage in Saline Aquifers: Storage Efficiency for Capillary Trapping at the Basin Scale

We study a sharp-interface mathematical model of CO₂ migration in deep saline aquifers, which accounts for gravity override, capillary trapping, natural groundwater flow, and the shape of the plume during the injection period. The model leads to a nonlinear advection–diffusion equation, where the diffusive term is due to buoyancy forces, not physical diffusion. For the case of interest in geological CO₂ storage, in which the mobility ratio is very unfavorable, the mathematical model can be simplified to a hyperbolic equation. We present a complete analytical solution to the hyperbolic model. The main outcome is a closed-form expression that predicts the ultimate footprint on the CO₂ plume, and the time scale required for complete trapping. The capillary trapping coefficient and the mobility ratio between CO₂ and brine emerge as the key parameters in the assessment of CO₂ storage in saline aquifers. Despite the many approximations, the model captures the essence of the flow dynamics and therefore reflects proper dependencies on the mobility ratio and the capillary trapping coefficient, which are basin-specific. The expressions derived here have applicability to capacity estimates by capillary trapping at the basin scale.     

Numerical Simulations of the Thermal Impact of Supercritical CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Injection on Chemical Reactivity in a Carbonate Saline Reservoir

Geological sequestration of CO₂ offers a promising solution for reducing net emissions of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. This emerging technology must make it possible to inject CO₂ into deep saline aquifers or oil- and gas-depleted reservoirs in the supercritical state (P > 7.4MPa and T > 31.1°C) to achieve a higher density and therefore occupy less volume underground. Previous experimental and numerical simulations have demonstrated that massive CO₂ injection in saline reservoirs causes a major disequilibrium of the physical and geochemical characteristics of the host aquifer. The near-well injection zone seems to constitute an underground hydrogeological system particularly impacted by supercritical CO₂ injection and the most sensitive area, where chemical phenomena (e.g. mineral dissolution/precipitation) can have a major impact on the porosity and permeability. Furthermore, these phenomena are highly sensitive to temperature. This study, based on numerical multi-phase simulations, investigates thermal effects during CO₂ injection into a deep carbonate formation. Different thermal processes and their influence on the chemical and mineral reactivity of the saline reservoir are discussed. This study underlines both the minor effects of intrinsic thermal and thermodynamic processes on mineral reactivity in carbonate aquifers, and the influence of anthropic thermal processes (e.g. injection temperature) on the carbonates’ behaviour.     

Effect of Vertical Heterogeneity on Long-Term Migration of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> in Saline Formations

For deep injection of CO₂ in thick saline formations, the movements of both the free gas phase and dissolved CO₂ are sensitive to variations in vertical permeability. A simple model for vertical heterogeneity was studied, consisting of a random distribution of horizontal impermeable barriers with a given overall volume fraction and distribution of lengths. Analytical results were obtained for the distribution of values for the permeability, and compared to numerical simulations of deep CO₂ injection and convection in heterogeneous formations, using multiple realizations for the permeability distribution. It is shown that for a formation of thickness H, the breakthrough times in two dimensions for deep injection scale as H ² for moderate injection rates. In comparison to heterogeneous shale distributions, a homogeneous medium with equivalent effective vertical permeability has a longer breakthrough time for deep injection, and a longer onset time for convection.     

Estimating Caprock Impact on CO2 Migration in the Gassum Formation Using 2D Seismic Line Data

Realizable CO₂ storage potential for saline formations without closed lateral boundaries depends on the combined effects of physical and chemical trapping mechanisms to prevent long-term migration out of the defined storage area. One such mechanism is the topography of the caprock surface, which may retain CO₂ in structural pockets along the migration path. Past theoretical and modeling studies suggest that even traps too small to be accurately described by seismic data may play a significant role. In this study, we use real but scarce seismic data from the Gassum Formation of the Norwegian Continental shelf to estimate the impact of topographical features of the top seal in limiting CO₂ migration. We seek to estimate the amount of macro- and sub-scale trapping potential of the formation based on a few dozen interpreted 2D seismic lines and identified faults. We generate multiple high-resolution realizations of the top surface, constructed to be faithful to both large-scale topography and small-scale statistical properties. The structural trapping and plume retardation potential of these top surfaces is subsequently estimated using spill-point (static) analysis and dynamical flow simulation. By applying these techniques on a large ensemble of top surface realizations generated using a combination of stochastic realizations and systematic variation of key model parameters, we explore the range of possible impacts on plume advancement, physical trapping and migration direction. The stochastic analysis of trapping capacity and retardation efficiency in statistically generated, sub-seismic resolution features may also be applied for surfaces generated from 3D data.

     

Injection,Flow, and Mixing of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> in Porous Media with Residual Gas

Geologic structures associated with depleted natural gas reservoirs are desirable targets for geologic carbon sequestration (GCS) as evidenced by numerous pilot and industrial-scale GCS projects in these environments world-wide. One feature of these GCS targets that may affect injection is the presence of residual CH₄. It is well known that CH₄ drastically alters supercritical CO₂ density and viscosity. Furthermore, residual gas of any kind affects the relative permeability of the liquid and gas phases, with relative permeability of the gas phase strongly dependent on the time-history of imbibition or drainage, i.e., dependent on hysteretic relative permeability. In this study, the effects of residual CH₄ on supercritical CO₂ injection were investigated by numerical simulation in an idealized one-dimensional system under three scenarios: (1) with no residual gas; (2) with residual supercritical CO₂; and (3) with residual CH₄. We further compare results of simulations that use non-hysteretic and hysteretic relative permeability functions. The primary effect of residual gas is to decrease injectivity by decreasing liquid-phase relative permeability. Secondary effects arise from injected gas effectively incorporating residual gas and thereby extending the mobile-gas plume relative to cases with no residual gas. Third-order effects arise from gas mixing and associated compositional effects on density that effectively create a larger plume per unit mass. Non-hysteretic models of relative permeability can be used to approximate some parts of the behavior of the system, but fully hysteretic formulations are needed to accurately model the entire system.     

Linear Stability Analysis of Double-Diffusive Convection in Porous Media,with Application to Geological Storage of CO<Subscript>2</Subscript>

Onset of double-diffusive buoyancy-driven flow resulted from vertical temperature and concentration gradients in a horizontal layer of a saturated and homogenous porous medium is investigated using amplification factor theory. After injection of CO₂ into a deep saline aquifer, the density of the brine saturated with CO₂ increases slightly. This increase in density induces natural convection. The effect of geothermal gradient is also considered in this work as a second incentive for convection and the double-diffusion convection was studied. Linear stability analysis is used to predict the inception of instabilities and initial wavelength of the convective instabilities. The analysis presented is applied to acid gas injection (as an analogue for CO₂ storage) into saline aquifers in the Alberta basin. It is found that the geothermal gradient does not have significant effect on the onset of convection for these aquifers. It is shown that the geothermal effects on the onset of natural convection are negligible as compared to the solutal effects induced by dissolution and diffusion of CO₂ in deep saline aquifers. Therefore, the linear stability analysis and the long-term numerical simulation of CO₂ sequestration into such saline aquifers may be assumed to be isothermal in terms of natural convection occurrence.     

Supercritical CO2-Brine Relative Permeability Experiments in Reservoir Rocks��Literature Review and Recommendations

The relative permeability of carbon dioxide (CO₂) to brine influences the injectivity and plume migration when CO₂ is injected in a reservoir for CO₂ storage or enhanced oil recovery (EOR) purposes. It is common practice to determine the relative permeability of a fluid by means of laboratory measurements. Two principal approaches are used to obtain a relative permeability data: steady state and unsteady state. Although CO₂ has been employed in enhanced oil recovery, not much data can be found in the open literature. The few studies available report wide ranges for CO₂ relative permeability in typical sedimentary rocks such as Berea sandstone, dolomite, and others. The experimental setups vary for each study, employing steady and unsteady state approaches, different experimental parameters such as temperature, pressure, rock type, etc. and various interpretation methods. Hence, it is inherently difficult to compare the data and determine the origin of differences. It is evident that more experiments are needed to close this knowledge gap on relative permeability. This article concludes that standards for lab measurements need to be defined a. to establish a reliable CO₂-brine relative permeability measurement method that can be repeated under the same conditions in any lab and b. to enable comparison of the data to accurately predict the well injection and fluid migration behavior in the reservoir.