Dipolar chemical shift correlation spectroscopy for homonuclear carbon distance measurements in proteins in the solid state: application to structure determination and refinement

High-resolution solid-state NMR spectroscopy has become a promising tool for protein structure determination. Here, we describe a new dipolar-chemical shift correlation experiment for the measurement of homonuclear 13C-13C distances in uniformly 13C,15N-labeled proteins and demonstrate its suitability for protein structure determination and refinement. The experiments were carried out on the beta1 immunoglobulin binding domain of protein G (GB1). Both intraresidue and interresidue distances between carbonyl atoms and atoms in the aliphatic side chains were collected using a three-dimensional chemical shift correlation spectroscopy experiment that uses homogeneously broadened rotational resonance recoupling for carbon mixing. A steady-state approximation for the polarization transfer function was employed in data analysis, and a total of 100 intramolecular distances were determined, all in the range 2.5-5.5 A. An additional 41 dipolar contacts were detected, but the corresponding distances could not be accurately quantified. Additional distance and torsional restraints were derived from the proton-driven spin diffusion measurements and from the chemical shift analysis, respectively. Using all these restraints, it was possible to refine the structure of GB1 to a root-mean square deviation of 0.8 A. The approach is of general applicability for peptides and small proteins and can be easily incorporated into a structure determination and refinement protocol.     

Protein structure determination from 13C spin-diffusion solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Proton-driven 13C spin diffusion (PDSD) is a simple and robust two-dimensional NMR experiment. It leads to spectra with a high signal-to-noise ratio in which cross-peaks contain information about internuclear distances. We show that the total information content is sufficient to determine the atomic-resolution structure of a small protein from a single, uniformly 13C-, 15N-labeled microcrystalline sample. For the example of ubiquitin, the structure was determined by a manual procedure followed by an automatic optimization of the manual structure as well as by a fully automated structure determination approach. The relationship between internuclear distances and cross-peak intensities in the spectra is investigated.     

Protein 3D structure determination by high-resolution solid-state NMR

Developments in NMR technology, sample preparation, pulse sequence methodology and structure calculation protocols have recently allowed one to progress towards structure determination at high-resolution of proteins by solid-state NMR spectroscopy. We here report solid-state NMR protocols based on magic-angle-spinning experiments, combined with modified structure calculation protocols, for structure determination of uniformly ¹³C, ¹⁵N isotopically labeled proteins. We demonstrate the use of these protocols to obtain high-resolution structures for the example of the microcrystalline Crh protein. The CHHC, DARR and PAR solid-state NMR experiments, as well as the calculation protocols using the program ARIA, are presented.     

Conformational flexibility of a microcrystalline globular protein: order parameters by solid-state NMR spectroscopy

The majority of protein structures are determined in the crystalline state, yet few methods exist for the characterization of dynamics for crystalline biomolecules. Solid-state NMR can be used to probe detailed dynamic information in crystalline biomolecules. Recent advances in high-resolution solid-state NMR have enabled the site-specific assignment of (13)C and (15)N nuclei in proteins. With the use of multidimensional separated-local-field experiments, we report the backbone and side chain conformational dynamics of ubiquitin, a globular microcrystalline protein. The measurements of molecular conformational order parameters are based on heteronuclear dipolar couplings, and they are correlated to assigned chemical shifts, to obtain a global perspective on the sub-microsecond dynamics in microcrystalline ubiquitin. A total of 38 Calpha, 35 Cbeta and multiple side chain unique order parameters are collected, and they reveal the high mobility of ubiquitin in the microcrystalline state. In general the side chains show elevated motion in comparison with the backbone sites. The data are compared to solution NMR order parameter measurements on ubiquitin. The SSNMR measurements are sensitive to motions on a broader time scale (low microsecond and faster) than solution NMR measurements (low nanosecond and faster), and the SSNMR order parameters are generally lower than the corresponding solution values. Unlike solution NMR relaxation-based order parameters, order parameters for (13)C(1)H(2) spin systems are readily measured from the powder line shape data. These results illustrate the potential for detailed, extensive, and site-specific dynamic studies of biopolymers by solid-state NMR.     

High resolution 1H-detected solid-state NMR spectroscopy of protein aliphatic resonances: access to tertiary structure information

Biological magic angle spinning (MAS) solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy has developed rapidly over the past two decades. For the structure determination of a protein by solid-state NMR, routinely (13)C,(13)C distance restraints as well as dihedral restraints are employed. In protonated samples, this is achieved by growing the bacterium on a medium which contains [1,3]-(13)C glycerol or [2]-(13)C glycerol to dilute the (13)C spin system. Labeling schemes, which rely on heteronuclei, are insensitive both for detection and in terms of quantification of distances, since they are relying on low-γ nuclei. Proton detection can in principle provide a gain in sensitivity by a factor of 8 and 31, compared to the (13)C or (15)N detected version of the experiment. We report here a new labeling scheme, which enables (1)H-detection of aliphatic resonances with high resolution in MAS solid-state NMR spectroscopy. We prepared microcrystals of the SH3 domain of chicken α-spectrin with 5% protonation at nonexchangeable sites and obtained line widths on the order of 25 Hz for aliphatic (1)H resonances. We show further that (13)C resolved 3D-(1)H,(1)H correlation experiments yield access to long-range proton-proton distances in the protein.     

3D structure determination of the Crh protein from highly ambiguous solid-state NMR restraints

In a wide variety of proteins, insolubility presents a challenge to structural biology, as X-ray crystallography and liquid-state NMR are unsuitable. Indeed, no general approach is available as of today for studying the three-dimensional structures of membrane proteins and protein fibrils. We here demonstrate, at the example of the microcrystalline model protein Crh, how high-resolution 3D structures can be derived from magic-angle spinning solid-state NMR distance restraints for fully labeled protein samples. First, we show that proton-mediated rare-spin correlation spectra, as well as carbon-13 spin diffusion experiments, provide enough short, medium, and long-range structural restraints to obtain high-resolution structures of this 2 x 10.4 kDa dimeric protein. Nevertheless, the large number of 13C/15N spins present in this protein, combined with solid-state NMR line widths of about 0.5-1 ppm, induces substantial ambiguities in resonance assignments, preventing 3D structure determination by using distance restraints uniquely assigned on the basis of their chemical shifts. In the second part, we thus demonstrate that an automated iterative assignment algorithm implemented in a dedicated solid-state NMR version of the program ARIA permits to resolve the majority of ambiguities and to calculate a de novo 3D structure from highly ambiguous solid-state NMR data, using a unique fully labeled protein sample. We present, using distance restraints obtained through the iterative assignment process, as well as dihedral angle restraints predicted from chemical shifts, the 3D structure of the fully labeled Crh dimer refined at a root-mean-square deviation of 1.33 A.     

Diluting abundant spins by isotope edited radio frequency field assisted diffusion

A new solid-state NMR method is described for obtaining long-range distance constraints in nanocrystalline samples of 13C-, 15N-, and 2H-enriched protein. The method selects only those 13C or 15N nuclei close to 1Hs for dipolar recoupling. When used with extensive deuteration, the bath of abundant 13C spins is made to appear dilute. Contacts over 4.5 A are readily observed in human ubiquitin.     

Assignment of the backbone resonances for microcrystalline ubiquitin

Site-specific assignments for the solid-state NMR spectra of uniformly 13C,15N-enriched ubiquitin are described. The assignments are derived from three three-dimensional 15N-13C-13C correlation spectra collected at 400 MHz on microcrystalline material. A few residues (the loop near Threonine 9 and the C-terminal fragment) were missing and correspond to regions previously reported to be mobile on the basis of X-ray crystallography and solution NMR studies. A few additional sites exhibit shifts that differ from previously reported solution NMR assignments. Nonetheless, these de novo assignments indicate close agreement between the chemical shifts observed in solution and those in microcrystalline or precipitated solids. The methods utilized are likely to be generally applicable for other noncrystalline, nonsoluble proteins.     

Use of the 2D 1H-13C HSQC NMR Methyl Region to Evaluate the Higher Order Structural Integrity of Biopharmaceuticals

The higher-order structure (HOS) of protein therapeutics is directly related to the function and represents a critical quality attribute. Currently, the HOS of protein therapeutics is characterized by methods with low to medium structural resolution, such as Fourier transform infrared (FTIR), circular dichroism (CD), intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopy (FLD), and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). High-resolution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods have now been introduced, representing powerful approaches for HOS characterization (HOS by NMR). NMR is a multi-attribute method with unique abilities to give information on all structural levels of proteins in solution. In this study, we have compared 2D ¹H-¹³C HSQC NMR with two established biophysical methods, i.e., near-ultraviolet circular dichroism (NUV-CD) and intrinsic fluorescence spectroscopy, for the HOS assessments for the folded and unfolded states of two monoclonal antibodies belonging to the subclasses IgG1 and IgG2. The study shows that the methyl region of the ¹H-¹³C HSQC NMR spectrum is sensitive to both the secondary and tertiary structure of proteins and therefore represents a powerful tool in assessing the overall higher-order structural integrity of biopharmaceutical molecules.     

Structural characterization of proteins with an attached ATCUN motif by paramagnetic relaxation enhancement NMR spectroscopy

The use of a short, three-residue Cu(2+)-binding sequence, the ATCUN motif, is presented as an approach for extracting long-range distance restraints from relaxation enhancement NMR spectroscopy. The ATCUN motif is prepended to the N-termini of proteins and binds Cu(2+) with a very high affinity. Relaxation rates of amide protons in ATCUN-tagged protein in the presence and absence of Cu(2+) can be converted into distance restraints and used for structure refinement by using a new routine, PMAG, that has been written for the structure calculation program CNS. The utility of the approach is demonstrated with an application to ATCUN-tagged ubiquitin. Excellent agreement between measured relaxation rates and those calculated on the basis of the X-ray structure of the protein have been obtained.     

A strategy for the NMR characterization of type II copper(II) proteins: the case of the copper trafficking protein CopC from Pseudomonas Syringae

CopC from Pseudomonas syringae was found to be a protein capable of binding both Cu(I) and Cu(II) at two different sites. The solution structure of the apo protein is available, and structural information has been obtained on the Cu(I) bound form. We attempt here to set the limits for the determination of the solution structure of a Cu(II) protein, such as the Cu(II) bound form of CopC, in which the Cu(II) ion takes a type II coordination. The electron relaxation time is estimated from NMRD measurements to be 3 ns which leads to a correlation time for the nuclear spin-electron spin dipolar interaction of 2 ns. This information allowed us to tailor the NMR experiments and to fully exploit purely heteronuclear spectroscopy to assign as many signals as possible. In this way, 37 (13)C and 11 (15)N signals that completely escape detection with conventional approaches were assigned. Paramagnetic based structural constraints were obtained by measuring paramagnetic longitudinal relaxation enhancements (rho(para)) which allowed us to precisely locate the copper ion within the protein frame. Pseudocontact shifts (pcs's) were also used as constraints for 83 (1)H and 18 (13)C nuclei. With them, together with other standard structural constraints, a structure is obtained (and submitted to PDB) where information is only missing in a sphere with a 6 A radius from the copper ion. If we borrow information from EXAFS data, which show evidence of two copper coordinated histidines, then His 1 and His 91 are unambiguously identified as copper ligands. EXAFS data indicate two more light donor atoms (O/N) which could be from Asp 27 and Glu 89, whereas the NMRD data indicate the presence of a semicoordinated water molecule at 2.8 A (Cu-O distance) roughly orthogonal to the plane identified by the other four ligands. This represents the most extensively characterized structure of a type II Cu(II) protein obtained employing the most advanced NMR methods and with the aid of EXAFS data. The knowledge of the location of the Cu(II) in the protein is important for the copper transfer mechanism.     

Quantitative Determination of Resin Loading in Solid-Phase Organic Synthesis Using (13)C MAS NMR

The use of quantitative carbon nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((13)C NMR) for the determination of resin loadings has been investigated. Magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR spectra have been obtained for solvent-swollen resins on a conventional 7 mm CP/MAS probe using the two pulse phase modulation (TPPM) proton decoupling sequence. Loadings of resin-bound organic compounds were evaluated via addition of tetrakis(trimethylsilyl)silane as reference or using the carbon resonances of the polymeric resin material as an internal standard. Results for several functionalized Wang and trityl resins are consistent with those obtained using well-established analytical methods. The (13)C NMR method has interesting applications in the field of solid-phase organic synthesis (SPOS), since no functional group acting as a support for the attachment of a quantifiable chromophore must be available in the material of interest.     

The structure of poly(carbonsuboxide) on the atomic scale: a solid-state NMR study

In this contribution we present a study of the structure of amorphous poly(carbonsuboxide) (C3O2)x by 13C solid-state NMR spectroscopy supported by infrared spectroscopy and chemical analysis. Poly(carbonsuboxide) was obtained by polymerization of carbonsuboxide C3O2, which in turn was synthesized from malonic acid bis(trimethylsilylester). Two different 13C labeling schemes were applied to probe inter- and intramonomeric bonds in the polymer by dipolar solid-state NMR methods and also to allow quantitative 13C MAS NMR spectra. Four types of carbon environments can be distinguished in the NMR spectra. Double-quantum and triple-quantum 2D correlation experiments were used to assign the observed peaks using the through-space and through-bond dipolar coupling. In order to obtain distance constraints for the intermonomeric bonds, double-quantum constant-time experiments were performed. In these experiments an additional filter step was applied to suppress contributions from not directly bonded 13C,13C spin pairs. The 13C NMR intensities, chemical shifts, connectivities and distances gave constraints for both the polymerization mechanism and the short-range order of the polymer. The experimental results were complemented by bond lengths predicted by density functional theory methods for several previously suggested models. Based on the presented evidence we can unambiguously exclude models based on gamma-pyronic units and support models based on alpha-pyronic units. The possibility of planar ladder- and bracelet-like alpha-pyronic structures is discussed.     

Solid‐state NMR Study of the YadA Membrane‐Anchor Domain in the Bacterial Outer Membrane

MAS‐NMR was used to study the structure and dynamics at ambient temperatures of the membrane‐anchor domain of YadA (YadA‐M) in a pellet of the outer membrane of E. coli in which it was expressed. YadA is an adhesin from the pathogen Yersinia enterocolitica that is involved in interactions with the host cell, and it is a model protein for studying the autotransport process. Existing assignments were sucessfully transferred to a large part of the YadA‐M protein in the E. coli lipid environment by using ¹³C‐¹³C DARR and PDSD spectra at different mixing times. The chemical shifts in most regions of YadA‐M are unchanged relative to those in microcrystalline YadA‐M preparations from which a structure has previously been solved, including the ASSA region that is proposed to be involved in transition‐state hairpin formation for transport of the soluble domain. Comparisons of the dynamics between the microcrystalline and membrane‐embedded samples indicate greater flexibility of the ASSA region in the outer‐membrane preparation at physiological temperatures. This study will pave the way towards MAS‐NMR structure determination of membrane proteins, and a better understanding of functionally important dynamic residues in native membrane environments.     

Structure calculation from unambiguous long-range amide and methyl 1H-1H distance restraints for a microcrystalline protein with MAS solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Magic-angle spinning (MAS) solid-state NMR becomes an increasingly important tool for the determination of structures of membrane proteins and amyloid fibrils. Extensive deuteration of the protein allows multidimensional experiments with exceptionally high sensitivity and resolution to be obtained. Here we present an experimental strategy to measure highly unambiguous spatial correlations for distances up to 13 ?. Two complementary three-dimensional experiments, or alternatively a four-dimensional experiment, yield highly unambiguous cross-peak assignments, which rely on four encoded chemical shift dimensions. Correlations to residual aliphatic protons are accessible via synchronous evolution of the (15)N and (13)C chemical shifts, which encode valuable amide-methyl distance restraints. On average, we obtain six restraints per residue. Importantly, 50% of all restraints correspond to long-range distances between residues i and j with |i - j| > 5, which are of particular importance in structure calculations. Using ARIA, we calculate a high-resolution structure for the microcrystalline 7.2 kDa α-spectrin SH3 domain with a backbone precision of ～1.1 ?.     

Insight into the structure of silver cyanide from (13)C and (15)N solid-state NMR spectroscopy

The structure of silver cyanide has been investigated by solid-state multinuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Carbon-13 and nitrogen-15 NMR spectra of magic-angle-spinning (MAS) and stationary powder samples of isotopically enriched Ag(13)CN, Ag(13)C(15)N, and AgC(15)N have been acquired at the external applied magnetic field strengths 4.7, 7.05, and 9.4 T. Axially symmetric carbon and nitrogen chemical shift (CS) tensors provide evidence for linearity of the polymeric (-Ag-CN-)(n)() chains. A two-site model is required to successfully simulate the (13)C MAS NMR line shape, which is dominated by indirect nuclear spin-spin coupling between (109/107)Ag and (13)C nuclei. In combination with relativistic zeroth-order regular approximation density functional theory (ZORA-DFT) calculations on model AgCN fragments, the (13)C MAS NMR results show that 30 +/- 10% of the silver sites are disordered, that is, either -NC-Ag-CN- or -CN-Ag-NC-, and 70 +/- 10% of the silver sites are ordered, that is, -NC-Ag-NC-. Effective dipolar coupling data extracted from (13)C NMR spectra of stationary samples allow an upper limit of 1.194 A to be placed on the carbon-nitrogen internuclear distance. After incorporation of the effects of anisotropic indirect nuclear spin-spin coupling and motional averaging on the NMR-derived distance, a corrected value of r(CN) = 1.16 +/- 0.03 A is obtained. This work provides an example of the type of information which may be obtained from solid-state NMR studies of disordered materials and how such information may complement that available from diffraction studies.     

Magic angle spinning solid-state NMR spectroscopy for structural studies of protein interfaces. resonance assignments of differentially enriched Escherichia coli thioredoxin reassembled by fragment complementation

De novo site-specific backbone and side-chain resonance assignments are presented for U-15N(1-73)/U-13C,15N(74-108) reassembly of Escherichia coli thioredoxin by fragment complementation, determined using solid-state magic angle spinning NMR spectroscopy at 17.6 T. Backbone dihedral angles and secondary structure predicted from the statistical analysis of 13C and 15N chemical shifts are in general agreement with solution values for the intact full-length thioredoxin, confirming that the secondary structure is retained in the reassembled complex prepared as a poly(ethylene glycol) precipitate. The differential labeling of complementary thioredoxin fragments introduced in this work is expected to be beneficial for high-resolution structural studies of protein interfaces formed by protein assemblies by solid-state NMR spectroscopy.     

(¹⁵N ± ¹³C') edited (4, 3)D-H(CC)CONH TOCSY and (4, 3)D-NOESY HNCO experiments for unambiguous side chain and NOE assignments of proteins with high shift degeneracy

Well-resolved and unambiguous through-bond correlations and NOE data are crucial for high-quality protein structure determination by NMR. In this context, we present here (4, 3)D reduced dimensionality (RD) experiments: H(CC)CONH TOCSY and NOESY HNCO--which instead of (15)N shifts exploit the linear combination of (15)N(i) and (13)C'(i-1) shifts (where i is a residue number) to resolve the through-bond (1)H-(1)H correlations and through-space (1)H-(1)H NOEs. The strategy makes use of the fact that (15)N and (13)C' chemical shifts when combined linearly provide a dispersion which is better compared to those of the individual chemical shifts. The extended dispersion thus available in these experiments will help to obtain the unambiguous side chain and accurate NOE assignments especially for medium-sized alpha-helical or partially unstructured proteins [molecular weight (MW) between 12-15 kDa] as well as higher MW (between 15-25 kDa) folded proteins where spectral overlap renders inaccurate and ambiguous NOEs. Further, these reduced dimensionality experiments in combination with routinely used (15)N and (13)C' edited TOCSY and NOESY experiments will provide an alternative way for high-quality NMR structure determination of large unstable proteins (with very high shift degeneracy), which are not at all amenable to 4D NMR. The utility of these experiments has been demonstrated here using (13)C/(15)N labeled ubiquitin (76 aa) protein.     

Recent advances in protein NMR spectroscopy and their implications in protein therapeutics research

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography are the two main methods for protein three-dimensional structure determination at atomic resolution. According to the protein structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank, X-ray crystallography has become the dominant method for structure determination, particularly for large proteins and complexes. However, with the developments of isotope labeling, increase of magnetic field strength, common use of a cryogenic probe, and ingenious pulse sequence design, the applications of NMR spectroscopy have expanded in biological research, especially in characterizing protein dynamics, sparsely populated transient structures, weak protein interactions, and proteins in living cells at atomic resolution, which is difficult if not impossible by other biophysical methods. Although great advances have been made in protein NMR spectroscopy, its applications in protein therapeutics, which represents the fastest growing segment of the pharmaceutical industry, are still limited. Here we review the recent advances in the use of NMR spectroscopy in studies of large proteins or complexes, posttranslation modifications, weak interactions, and aggregation, and in-cell NMR spectroscopy. The potential applications of NMR spectroscopy in protein therapeutic assays are discussed.     

Determinations of 15N chemical shift anisotropy magnitudes in a uniformly 15N,13C-labeled microcrystalline protein by three-dimensional magic-angle spinning nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

Amide 15N chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) tensors provide quantitative insight into protein structure and dynamics. Experimental determinations of 15N CSA tensors in biologically relevant molecules have typically been performed by NMR relaxation studies in solution, goniometric analysis of single-crystal spectra, or slow magic-angle spinning (MAS) NMR experiments of microcrystalline samples. Here we present measurements of 15N CSA tensor magnitudes in a protein of known structure by three-dimensional MAS solid-state NMR. Isotropic 15N, 13C alpha, and 13C' chemical shifts in two dimensions resolve site-specific backbone amide recoupled CSA line shapes in the third dimension. Application of the experiments to the 56-residue beta1 immunoglobulin binding domain of protein G (GB1) enabled 91 independent determinations of 15N tensors at 51 of the 55 backbone amide sites, for which 15N-13C alpha and/or 15N-13C' cross-peaks were resolved in the two-dimensional experiment. For 37 15N signals, both intra- and interresidue correlations were resolved, enabling direct comparison of two experimental data sets to enhance measurement precision. Systematic variations between beta-sheet and alpha-helix residues are observed; the average value for the anisotropy parameter, delta (delta = delta(zz) - delta(iso)), for alpha-helical residues is 6 ppm greater than that for the beta-sheet residues. The results show a variation in delta of 15N amide backbone sites between -77 and -115 ppm, with an average value of -103.5 ppm. Some sites (e.g., G41) display smaller anisotropy due to backbone dynamics. In contrast, we observe an unusually large 15N tensor for K50, a residue that has an atypical, positive value for the backbone phi torsion angle. To our knowledge, this is the most complete experimental analysis of 15N CSA magnitude to date in a solid protein. The availability of previous high-resolution crystal and solution NMR structures, as well as detailed solid-state NMR studies, will enhance the value of these measurements as a benchmark for the development of ab initio calculations of amide 15N shielding tensor magnitudes.