Quantitative assessment of human serum high-abundance protein depletion

The aim of this study is to quantify the effectivity of the depletion of human high-abundance serum and plasma proteins for improved protein identification and disease marker candidate discovery and to assess the risk of concomitant removal of relevant marker proteins. 2-DE and bottom-up shotgun MS combining 2-D capillary chromatography with MS/MS were applied in parallel for the analysis of fractions resulting from the depletion procedure. For many proteins the factors of enrichment by the depletion were obvious allowing their enhanced detection and identification upon high-abundance protein depletion. Nano-liquid chromatography linked MS allowed the efficient identification of several low-abundant proteins that were not identified on the 2-DE gels. Resolving the fractions that were eluted from the matrix upon depletion indicated unspecific binding of disease relevant proteins in plasma samples from acute myocardial infarction patients. The unspecific binding to the depletion matrix of inflammatory markers spiked into the serum was found to depend on the type of capturing agent used. Polyclonal avian antibodies (IgY) displayed the least unspecific binding due to the high immunogenicity of mammalian proteins in avian hosts.     

Application of thiophilic chromatography to deplete serum immunoglobulins in sample preparation for bidimensional electrophoresis

Serum is a typical sample for non-invasive studies in clinical research. Its proteome characterization is challenging, since requires extensive protein depletion. Methods used nowadays for removal of high-abundance proteins are expensive or show quite often a low loading capacity, which has strong repercussions on the number of samples and replicates per analysis.In order to deplete immunoglobulins (Igs) and albumin (HSA) from 1 mL serum samples, we have developed a protocol based on a combination of thiophilic chromatography, not previously used in clinical proteomics, and a HSA-specific resin. Ig/HSA-depleted samples, immunoglobulinome and albuminone were analyzed by 2-DE. Thiophilic chromatography, coupled with HSA-depletion, allows a good 2-DE resolution as well as the visualization of new spots. Moreover, it yields enough protein to evaluate technical variability and facilitate subsequent protein identification. To validate the protocol, we carried out a preliminary comparative study between triplicate Igs/HSA-depleted serum samples from healthy control individuals and recently diagnosed/untreated rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. RA patients showed several acute phase proteins, as well as additional serum proteins, differentially and significantly regulated.Therefore, thiophilic chromatography can be used as an efficient and economical method in 2-DE to deplete immunoglobulins from large human serum samples before a more extensive fractioning.     

Expression of high-abundance proteins in sera of patients with endometrial and cervical cancers: analysis using 2-DE with silver staining and lectin detection methods

The expression of high-abundance serum proteins in newly diagnosed patients with endometrial adenocarcinoma (EACa), squamous cell cervical carcinoma (SCCa) and cervical adenocarcinoma (ACCa), relative to control female subjects, was analyzed by subjecting serum samples to 2-DE followed by image analysis of the silver-stained protein profiles. The three cohorts of cancer patients demonstrated different altered expression of serum high-abundance proteins compared to negative control women. The expression of alpha1-antitrypsin, alpha1-B glycoprotein, cleaved high-molecular-weight kininogen (light chain) and antithrombin III were consistently altered in all the patients. However, clusterin was upregulated only in the patients with EACa, while those with SCCa and ACCa were typically characterized by the upregulated expression of zinc alpha-2-glycoprotein. The aberrant expression of selective serum proteins in the various cohorts of cancer patients was validated by competitive ELISA as well as by lectin detection. Analysis by using the champedak galactose binding lectin further highlighted an unidentified protein that may be differently glycosylated in the sera of the EACa patients that were studied.     

Enrichment of low-abundant serum proteins by albumin/immunoglobulin G immunoaffinity depletion under partly denaturing conditions

We present a simple protocol for affinity depletion to remove the two most abundant serum proteins, albumin and immunoglobulin G (IgG). Under native conditions, albumin/IgG were efficiently removed and several proteins were enriched as shown by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Besides that, partly denaturing conditions were established by adding 5 or 20% acetonitrile (ACN) in order to disrupt the binding of low-molecular-weight (LMW) proteins to the carrier proteins albumin/IgG. 2-DE results showed that the total number of detected LMW proteins increased under denaturing conditions when compared to native conditions. Interestingly, the presence of 5% ACN in serum revealed better enrichment of LMW proteins when compared to 20% ACN condition. Seven randomly distributed spots in albumin/IgG depleted serum samples under 5% ACN condition were picked from the 2-DE gels and identified by mass spectrometry (MS). The intensity of five LMW protein spots increased under denaturing conditions when compared to native conditions. Three of the seven identified spots (serum amyloid P, vitamin D-binding protein, and transthyretin) belong to a group of relatively low-abundant proteins, which make up only 1% of all serum proteins. The method presented here improves the resolution of the serum proteome by increasing the number of visualized spots on 2-D gels and allowing the detection and MS identification of LMW proteins and proteins of lower abundance.     

Reduction of the concentration difference of proteins in biological liquids using a library of combinatorial ligands

The discovery of polypeptides and proteins with relevance to a particular biological state is complicated by their vast number and concentration range in most biological mixtures. Depletion methodologies are frequently used to remove the most abundant species; however, this removal not only fails significantly to enrich trace proteins, it may also nonspecifically deplete them due to their interactions with the removed high-abundance proteins. Here we report a simple-to-use methodology that reduces the protein concentration range of a complex mixture like whole serum through the simultaneous dilution of high-abundance proteins and the concentration of low-abundance proteins. This methodology utilizes solid-phase ligand libraries of immense diversity, generated by "split, couple, recombine" combinatorial chemistry, that are used for affinity-based binding to the proteins of a given mixture. With a controlled sample-to-ligand ratio it is possible to modulate the relative concentration of proteins such that many peptides or proteins that are undetectable by classical analytical methods become easily accessible. The reduction in the dynamic range of unfractionated serum is specifically described along with treatment of other proteomes such as extracts from Escherichia coli, chicken egg white and cell culture supernatant. Mono- and bi-dimensional electrophoresis (1-DE and 2-DE respectively) and surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization-mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF-MS) technology demonstrate the reduction in protein concentration range. Combining this approach with additional fractionation methods further increased the number of detectable species.     

Liquid-phase-based separation systems for depletion, prefractionation and enrichment of proteins in biological fluids and matrices for in-depth proteomics analysis--an update covering the period 2008-2011

This review article expands on the previous one (Jmeian, Y. and El Rassi, Z. Electrophoresis 2009, 30, 249-261) by reviewing pertinent literature in the period extending from early 2008 to the present. Similar to the previous review article, the present one is concerned with proteomic sample preparation (e.g. depletion of high-abundance proteins, reduction of the protein dynamic concentration range, enrichment of a particular subproteome), and the subsequent chromatographic and/or electrophoretic prefractionation prior to peptide separation and identification by LC-MS/MS. This review article differs from the first version published in Electrophoresis 2009, 30, 249-261 by expanding on capturing/enriching subglycoproteomics by lectin affinity chromatography. Ninety-eight articles published in the period extending from early 2008 to the present have been reviewed. By no means is this review article exhaustive: its aim is to give a concise report on the latest developments in the field.     

Depletion of high-abundance proteins from human plasma using a combination of an affinity and pseudo-affinity column

Human serum albumin (HSA) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) represent over 75% of all proteins present in human plasma. These high-abundance proteins prevent the detection of low-abundance proteins which are potential markers for various diseases. The depletion of HSA and IgG is therefore essential for further proteome analysis. In this paper we describe the optimization of conditions for selective depletion of HSA and IgG using affinity and pseudo-affinity chromatography. A BIA Separations CIM (convective interaction media) Protein G disk was applied for the removal of IgG and the Mimetic Blue SA A6XL stationary phase for the removal of HSA. The binding and the elution buffer for CIM Protein G disk were chosen on the basis of the peak shape. The dynamic binding capacity was determined. It was shown to be dependent on the buffer system used and independent of the flow rate and of the concentration of IgG. Beside the binding capacity for the IgG standard, the binding capacity was also determined for IgG in human plasma. The Mimetic Blue SA A6XL column was characterized using human plasma. The selectivity of the depletion was dependent on the amount of human plasma that was loaded on the column. After the conditions on both supports had been optimized, the Mimetic Blue SA A6XL stationary phase was combined with the CIM Protein G disk in order to simultaneously deplete samples of human plasma. A centrifuge spin column that enables the removal of IgG and HSA from 20 μL of human plasma was designed. The results of the depletion were examined using sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis.     

Identification of low-abundance proteins of bovine colostral and mature milk using two-dimensional electrophoresis followed by microsequencing and mass spectrometry

We identified several low-abundance proteins of bovine colostrum and mature milk using the immunoabsorption technique and two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) followed by microsequencing and mass spectrometry. Two major milk proteins, beta-casein and immunoglobulin G (IgG), were effectively removed from the milk using immunoabsorbents. Milk samples before and after immunoabsorption were separated by 2-DE. Protein identification of the spots on 2-DE was performed by either gel comparison, microsequencing, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass-spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS), peptide mass fingerprinting or peptide sequencing using tandem MS by hybrid quadrupole/orthogonal acceleration time of flight-MS (Q-TOF). Significant differences in protein patterns were observed between the low-abundance proteins of colostrum and mature milk. In addition, several low-abundance proteins including fibrinogen beta-chain, chitinase 3-like 1, alpha-antitrypsin, complement C3 alpha-chain, gelsolin and apolipoprotein H were observed only in colostrum. However, the level of beta-casein fragments increased significantly during this lactation period. alpha-Lactalbumin and beta-lactoglobulin as well as some low-abundance proteins including bovine serum albumin, serotransferrin and lactoferrin were identified in both colostral and mature milk. Low-abundance proteins in bovine colostrum may have special physiologic relevance to the health and development of calves early in lactation.     

Reduction of protein concentration range difference followed by multicolumn fractionation prior to 2-DE and LC-MS/MS profiling of serum proteins

This article is concerned with the reduction of protein concentration range differences by the peptide beads library technology (ProteoMiner? or "equalizer" technology), which in principle allows the enrichment of proteins to the same concentration level (i.e. protein equalizer) regardless of the original protein abundance in a given biological fluid such as human serum, which is the subject of our investigation. After the equalization step, the captured proteins from human serum were fractionated on a series of tandem monolithic columns with surface-bound iminodiacetic acid ligands to which three different metal ions, namely, Zn2+, Ni2+ and Cu2+ were immobilized to yield the so-called immobilized metal affinity chromatography columns. These three monolithic columns were connected to a reversed-phase column packed with polystyrene divinyl benzene beads. Aliquots taken from the four collected fractions from the four tandem columns were subsequently fractionated by 2-DE. Also, aliquots from the four collected fractions were tryptically digested and analyzed by LC-MS/MS. The strategy of subsequent fractionation on the four tandem columns after equalization allowed the identification of more proteins than simply using the equalization by ProteoMiner? . The equalizer technology was compared to the immuno-subtraction approach. While the ProteoMiner? technology is superior in terms of the overall number of captured proteins, it only complements the immuno-subtraction approach since the latter can capture the proteins that were not captured by the former.     

Iron protoporphyrin-modified monolithic support for on-line preconcentration of angiotensin prior to CE analysis

An on-line preconcentration method using a polymeric monolithic support is proposed for the retention of the decapeptide angiotensin I and its subsequent analysis by CZE. Monolithic capillary columns were prepared in fused-silica (FS) capillaries of 150 microm id by ionizing radiation-initiated in situ polymerization and cross-linking of diethylene glycol dimethacrylate and glycidyl methacrylate, and chemically modified with iron protoporphyrin IX (Fe-ProP). Monolithic microcolumns (8 mm long) were coupled on-line to the inlet of the separation capillary (FS capillary, 75 microm id x10 cm from the inlet to the microcolumn and 27 cm from the microcolumn to the detector). Angiotensin I was released from the sorbent by a 50 mM sodium phosphate, pH 2.5/ACN, 75:25 v/v solution and then analyzed by CZE with UV absorption detection at 214 nm. The concentration LOQ (CLOQ) was 0.5 ng/mL. The Fe-ProP-derivatized monolithic microcolumn coupled to the separation capillary exhibited a high retention capacity for peptide angiotensin I, and showed as much as 10,000-fold improvement in concentration sensitivity.     

Phenotyping apolipoprotein E*3-leiden transgenic mice by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and mass spectrometric identification

Apolipoprotein E (ApoE) plays an important role in cholesterol and triglyceride metabolism, being one of the major structural components of chylomicrons and very low density lipoprotein (VLDL) remnants. ApoE functions as a ligand in the receptor-mediated uptake of these remnants from the blood by the liver. A variant form of ApoE, apolipoprotein E*3-Leiden, shows reduced affinity for the low density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor, and results in the dominant expression of type III hyperlipoproteinemia. Two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) has been used to characterise protein expression in serum samples from control and transgenic mice expressing the human ApoE*3-Leiden mutation, fed a cholesterol-rich diet, and transgenic mice fed a normal diet. For the identification of proteins, single silver-stained spots were excised from the 2-DE gels and subjected to in-gel enzymatic digestion. Extracted peptides were analysed by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS). This proteomic approach has enabled the ApoE*3-Leiden variant to be positioned in a 2-DE separation of serum proteins, and has identified changes in the expression of haptoglobin, indicating that this protein may provide a marker for the potential onset of atherosclerosis.     

Analysis of human serum by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry: improved sample preparation and data analysis

Discovery of biomarkers is a fast developing field in proteomics research. Liquid chromatography coupled on line to mass spectrometry (LC-MS) has become a powerful method for the sensitive detection, quantification and identification of proteins and peptides in biological fluids like serum. However, the presence of highly abundant proteins often masks those of lower abundance and thus generally prevents their detection and identification in proteomics studies. To perform future comparative analyses of samples from a serum bank of cervical cancer patients in a longitudinal and cross-sectional manner, methodology based on the depletion of high-abundance proteins followed by tryptic digestion and LC-MS has been developed. Two sample preparation methods were tested in terms of their efficiency to deplete high-abundance serum proteins and how they affect the repeatability of the LC-MS data sets. The first method comprised depletion of human serum albumin (HSA) on a dye ligand chromatographic and immunoglobulin G (IgG) on an immobilized Protein A support followed by tryptic digestion, fractionation by cation-exchange chromatography, trapping on a C18 column and reversed-phase LC-MS. The second method included depletion of the six most abundant serum proteins based on multiple immunoaffinity chromatography followed by tryptic digestion, trapping on a C18 column and reversed-phase LC-MS. Repeatability of the overall procedures was evaluated in terms of retention time and peak area for a selected number of endogenous peptides showing that the second method, besides being less time consuming, gave more repeatable results (retention time: <0.1% RSD; peak area: <30% RSD). Application of an LC-MS component detection algorithm followed by principal component analysis (PCA) enabled discrimination of serum samples that were spiked with horse heart cytochrome C from non-spiked serum and the detection of a concentration trend, which correlated to the amount of spiked horse heart cytochrome C to a level of 5 pmol cytochrome C in 2 microl original serum.     

Impact of prefractionation using Gradiflow on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and protein identification by matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry

Prefractionation of protein samples prior to two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) has the potential to increase the dynamic detection range for proteomic analysis. We evaluated a membrane-based electrophoretic separation technique (Gradiflow) for its ability to fractionate an exoproteome sample from the filamentous fungus Trichoderma reesei. The sample was separated on the basis of size and charge. Buffer optimization was found to be necessary for successful size fractionation. Fractionation by charge was used to resolve the sample into four fractions that were subjected to analysis by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Enhanced detection of low-abundance proteins with selective removal of high-abundance species was achieved. Fractionated and unfractionated samples were examined for differences in the ability to identify proteins following 2-DE using trypsin in-gel digestion followed by peptide mass fingerprinting using matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS). Fractionated samples showed marked improvement in protein identification ability and sequence coverage. This study demonstrates the utility of the Gradiflow for fractionation, resulting in an enhancement of resolution and characterization of a moderately complex proteome.     

An analysis of protein abundance suppression in data dependent liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectrometry with tryptic peptide mixtures of five known proteins

Reverse phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) has been widely used in proteomics research for peptide separation. When protein samples are separated by RPLC and identified with electrospray ion trap mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), the signals of high-abundance proteins may suppress those of low-abundance proteins, a phenomenon known as abundance suppression. To what degree the abundance suppression correlates to the number of tryptic peptides in the high-abundance proteins has not been carefully investigated. We tried to answer this question by studying the mixtures digested from five known proteins. The numbers of identified tryptic peptides (longer than five amino acids) of the five proteins ranged from 12 to 47. Four different peptide mixtures with 10- to 100-fold abundance differences of five known proteins were separated by RPLC and identified by ESI-MS. Our results showed that abundance suppression was related to the tryptic peptide numbers in the high-abundance protein. Within a 100-fold protein abundance difference range, tryptic peptide number in the low-abundance proteins could be suppressed up to seven times by high-abundance proteins. The procedure we suggest here can help to identify low-abundance proteins co-purified with their high-abundance binding protein. The result can also help to identify specific high-abundance proteins for removal by immunoaffinity.     

Separation of proteins by microcolumn liquid chromatography based on the reversed-phase and size-exclusion principles

Slurry-packed fused-silica microcolumns of 250 micron I.D., are characterized for use in high-performance liquid chromatographic studies of proteins. The present work utilizes the reversed-phase and size-exclusion chromatographic modes for the separation of standard protein mixtures. A 5-micron, 300-A octyl material is utilized for the reversed-phase studies, and the size-exclusion studies are accomplished with 5-micron diol material of 60-, 100- and 300-A pore sizes. Column efficiency and packing reproducibility, as well as sample capacity in a micropreparative mode, are discussed. In addition, the inherent mass sensitivity of a microcolumn liquid chromatography system as applied to protein detection is demonstrated.     

Combination of affinity depletion of abundant proteins and reversed-phase fractionation in proteomic analysis of human plasma/serum

The tremendous complexity of the serum and plasma proteome presents extreme analytical challenges in comprehensive analysis due to the wide dynamic range of protein concentrations. Therefore, robust sample preparation methods remain one of the important steps in the proteome characterization workflow. We present the results on a new column for the specific depletion of 14 high-abundant proteins from human serum and plasma and the subsequent reversed-phase fractionation of the flow-through proteins. Analysis of tryptic peptides was accomplished with microfluidic HPLC-Chip/MS system. Results indicate that high-abundant protein depletion combined with RP fractionation of plasma showed an improved dynamic range for proteomic analysis and enabled the identification of low-abundant plasma proteins.     

Analysis of drug–protein binding by ultrafast affinity chromatography using immobilized human serum albumin

Human serum albumin (HSA) was explored for use as a stationary phase and ligand in affinity microcolumns for the ultrafast extraction of free drug fractions and the use of this information for the analysis of drug–protein binding. Warfarin, imipramine, and ibuprofen were used as model analytes in this study. It was found that greater than 95% extraction of all these drugs could be achieved in as little as 250 ms on HSA microcolumns. The retained drug fraction was then eluted from the same column under isocratic conditions, giving elution in less than 40 s when working at 4.5 mL/min. The chromatographic behavior of this system gave a good fit with that predicted by computer simulations based on a reversible, saturable model for the binding of an injected drug with immobilized HSA. The free fractions measured by this method were found to be comparable to those determined by ultrafiltration, and equilibrium constants estimated by this approach gave good agreement with literature values. Advantages of this method include its speed and the relatively low cost of microcolumns that contain HSA. The ability of HSA to bind many types of drugs also creates the possibility of using the same affinity microcolumn to study and measure the free fractions for a variety of pharmaceutical agents. These properties make this technique appealing for use in drug-binding studies and in the high-throughput screening of new drug candidates.     

Analysis of two-dimensional electrophoretic patterns of proteins obtained from the sera of normal and tumor-bearing nude rats

To classify two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) patterns of normal and abnormal samples, a new parameter, named shift value, is introduced. The shift value is defined by the product of three indices; differences in density, differences in area, and the Euclid distance between peaks of matched glycoprotein spots in the 2-DE patterns. Shift values obtained from the differences between the 2-DE patterns of tumor-bearing and normal sera (control) were always found to be larger than those obtained from two control patterns. The shift value obtained from glycoprotein spots could be more effectively used to distinguish normal and abnormal patterns than that obtained from simple proteins. In our earlier attempts to compare serum proteins of normal and tumor patients, we could not discriminate differences caused by genetic background. In order to circumvent this difficulty, we employed an inbred strain of nude rats into which various types of human cancer had been implanted. Reliability of the analysis is enhanced by using a polyacrylamide gel backed with a silanized glass support and an automatic 2-DE apparatus.     

Sample-induced internal pH gradients in microcolumn liquid chromatography of proteins

Summary The technique of an internal pH gradient induced by the sample is applied to the separation of proteins by liquid chromatography. Compatibility of the method with microcolumns is demonstrated and examples of separations on different types of sorbents are given.     

Tandem lectin affinity chromatography monolithic columns with surface immobilised concanavalin A, wheat germ agglutinin and Ricinus communis agglutinin-I for capturing sub-glycoproteomics from breast cancer and disease-free human sera

In this study, a liquid-phase separation platform consisting of tandem lectin affinity chromatography was introduced for the selective capturing of sub-glycoproteomics that are affected in cancers, e.g. breast cancer. The platform is comprised of three monolithic columns with surface immobilised lectins including concanavalin A (Con A), wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) and Ricinus communis agglutinin-I (RCA-I). While WGA and Con A have specificities directed towards the core portion of N-glycans on the glycoprotein surface, RCA-I specifically interacts with the non-reducing terminal moieties of the outer chain structures of N-glycans. The effects of the order in which the three lectin columns were arranged in the tandem columns format were evaluated. The most suitable order proved to be WGA → Con A → RCA-I (denoted as WCR) as far as the number of captured proteins was concerned. The WCR tandem columns allowed the capture of 113 and 112 proteins from disease-free and breast cancer sera, respectively, corresponding to 75 and 65 non-redundant proteins, respectively. Using mass spectral count ratios and Q-Q plots yielded a panel of 23 non-redundant differentially expressed proteins (i.e. a panel of 23 candidate markers), which should in principle be more representative of a pathophysiological state than a single marker candidate.