Speciation of Heavy Metals in Soils and Sediments. An Account of the Improvement and Harmonization of Extraction Techniques Undertaken Under the Auspices of the BCR of the Commission of the European Communities

Abstract

An account is presented of a series of investigations and collaborative studies, initiated by BCR, on current methods of metal speciation by extraction of soils and sediments with chemical reagents. It was established by extensive consultation with European experts that the diverse procedures used could be harmonized into agreed methods. These methods, including both single extractant and sequential extraction procedures were subjected to collaborative, interlaboratory trials and the results, presented briefly here, showed that it was both possible and desirable that reference soils and sediments, characterised by certified values for extractable contents, be prepared. As a consequence of these studies two soils have been prepared and will shortly be the subject of interlaboratory analysis with a view to certification of their EDTA and acetic acid extractable contents of some heavy metals. Following this workshop a feasibility study of the agreed sequential extraction procedure will, it is believed, shortly lead to certification of sediments for contents extractable by a defined sequential extraction procedure.     

Trace Metal Speciation and Research in Marine Geochemistry

Abstract

In order to precise the origin and behaviour of trace metals associated with coastal marine sediments, marine geochemists frequently utilize various methods of sequential extraction. The main objective is to test the potential mobility / stability of particulate metals in the natural environments. Several examples are presented in the article, namely: i/ Exchangeable Pb from podzolic soils of the drainage basin of a lagoon which sediments and phreatic waters are for a large part inherited from the surrounding soils; ii/ Evolution of particulate metals in an estuary; iii/ Mobility of metals at the sea bottom interface; iv/ Role of amorphous components of estuarine sediments and suspended matter; v/ Effects of dredging activities on solubility of metals in an estuary; vi/ Behaviour of heavy metals in lagoons.

Main results obtained from the extraction procedures are described, as well as particular difficulties encountered when applying some classical methods.     

Single and Sequential Extraction in Sediments and Soils

Abstract

The determination of extractable trace metal contents in soils and sediments is currently performed in many laboratories to assess the bioavailable metal fraction (and related potential phyto-toxic effects) and the importance and possibility of mobilization of trace metals from polluted soil, sludge and sediment upon landfill application. Single and sequential extraction schemes are used for the assessment of the different “forms” of trace metals (e.g. “mobile/bioavailable”, “carbonate-bound” etc.). The lack of uniformity in the different extraction procedures used throughout the world does not allow the results to be compared or the procedures to be validated which has led to many criticisms in the past few years. Moreover, the lack of suitable reference materials for this type of operationally defined determinations did not enable the quality of the measurements to be controlled. Owing to the need for establishing common schemes for single and sequential extractions as well as for the improvement of the quality of extractable trace metal determinations in soil and sediments, the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) has organised a project which results along with the state of the art of extractable trace metal determinations, use and applicability of extraction schemes and analytical limitations were decided to be thoroughly discussed in a workshop. This paper presents its main conclusions.     

Comparison of metal analysis in sediments using EDXRF and ICP-OES with the HCl and Tessie extraction methods

The work presents an investigation on metal availability in sediments during 13 months using the dispersive-energy X-ray fluorescence (EDXRF) and atomic emission spectrometry with induced argon plasma (ICP-OES) techniques and single extraction (0.1 mol l⁻¹ HCl) and Tessie’s sequential speciation methods. The EDXRF technique could yield essentially the same profile as ICP-OES for the seasonal variation of metals in sediments, but in a more practical way. The sequential extraction procedure (SEP) was more efficient in metal dissolution than single extraction. The Pb, Ni, Al, Cr, and Fe elements were less efficiently extracted with single extraction in relation to sequential extraction. For Co both methodologies were equivalent, but for Cu and Mn the extraction was higher with single extraction. Single extraction does not mobilize Pb, Ni, Al, Cr, and Fe adsorbed on oxides and bound to organic matter. However for Cu and Mn, not only extracted these metals from the four fractions, but it also dissolved part of the fifth fraction (residual). Principal Component Analysis discriminated seasonal variations in the content of several metals, mainly Fe, Co, Ni, and Zn. The mobility of metallic ions in the sediments is conditioned to the seasonal flow of organic and inorganic material coming from the river or by the erosion of adjacent soils.     

Trace Element Speciation in Soils and Sediments Using Sequential Chemical Extraction Methods

Abstract

Several commonly used sequential chemical extraction procedures of heavy metals in soils and sediments are compared, and their advantages and disadvantages are discussed focusing on selected case studies. In particular, problems caused by handling of anoxic samples, and of specific phases (e.g. organic fractions and sulfides) are addressed.

Eventually, recommendations for the improvement of extraction selectivity as well as the reduction of readsorption effects are given.     

Kinetic approach to heavy metal mobilization assessment in sediments: choose of kinetic equations and models to achieve maximum information

Studies of trace metal mobilization in sediments are generally performed using sequential extraction schemes at equilibrium. In the present work, a kinetic fractionation of trace metals in sediments has been developed to assess that information. The extraction rate data have been obtained using a single extraction scheme with EDTA and following a protocol previously optimized. Two kinetic equations and two kinetic models were used to fit the experimental data. The two constants equation fits well the extraction rate data used in this work but does not present any physico-chemical meaning. The diffusion model and the two first-order reactions model allow determining which parameter (the reaction between the metal M and the EDTA or the diffusion of the complex M/EDTA) is rate limiting in the trace metal extraction by EDTA. It appears that the two first-order reactions model is more efficient than the diffusion model to fit the present extraction rate data so it can be deduced that the diffusion of the complex M/EDTA is not the limiting step of the trace metal extraction by EDTA in estuarine sediments. In a second part, relationships between the fraction of metals determined with the two first-order reactions model and the sediments composition were established.     

Optimization of a Sequential Extraction Scheme for the Characterization of Heavy Metal Mobility in Iron Oxide Rich Sediments

Abstract

Several parameters governing the extraction of metals from iron oxide rich sediments, using sequential extraction schemes were optimized. The mode of shaking, soil/extractant ratio and concentrations of MgCl₂ and NH₂OH·HCl, for samples collected in the Odiel Marshes Natural Park (SW Spain), were considered. The concentration of NH₂OH·HCl deserved particular attention due to the nature of the studied sediments. A 0.4 M concentration of this extractant was needed to avoid readsorption of Cu and As in the samples. In addition, readsorption processes were studied using a candidate to reference material with a high organic matter content that was previously analyzed in an interlaboratory study.     

New Sediment and Soil CRMs for Extractable Trace Metal Content

Abstract

The lack of uniformity in leaching procedures used to measure broadly defined forms of heavy metals does not allow the results to be compared world-wide nor the methods to be validated since the results obtained are “operationally defined”. An attempt was made to certify several mineral soils CRMs for single extraction by using acetic acid, EDTA and DTPA for Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn. Recently, to complete the series of soil CRMs, an organically enriched soil was prepared SO25. For sediments a CRM 601 was produced and certified for metals extractable by using the BCR three step sequential extraction. Not all the trace elements were certified and only indicative values were given for some of them due to poor reproducibility. We performed a systematic study of the effect of the variables identified as potential sources of uncertainty in the use of this scheme. With this study the sources of uncertainty were revealed and an optimised version of the protocol was proposed. With this new version it was possible to certify all the trace elements studied. New sediment material S33 is now proposed for certification and additional data are given for the sediment CRM 601. This modified procedure was also applied to a soil CRM 483 and good results were obtained. This procedure may thus be applied to polluted soils.     

Chemical Speciation and Fractionation in Soil and Sediment Heavy Metal Analysis: A Review

Abstract

Today it is generally recognized that the particular behaviour of trace metals in the environment is determined by their specific physicochemical forms rather than by their total concentration. Several chemical speciation and fractionation methods for heavy metal analysis in soils and sediments have been and are still being developed and applied. They primarily are intended to understand the particular environmental behaviour of metals, present in a variety of forms and in a variety of matrices.

Analytical developments, modifications of existing methods, and recent new approaches are reviewed and discussed. Techniques used include chemical extractions, ion-exchange/gel chromatography, filtration, centrifugation and sieving, selective solvent extraction.

Moreover, the application of these various techniques in different research fields over the last years is explored. The value and the limitations of speciation and fractionation techniques applied in specific experimental work is outlined. It is discussed to what extent these methods have, up to now, filled in the expectations or have been satisfactory in particular applications.     

Sequential extraction of phosphorus in soil and sediment using a continuous-flow system

Distribution and mobility of phosphorus in soil and sediment are usually studied by sequential extraction. In the extraction procedure, a sample is treated with a series of reagents to distinguish the phases to which phosphorus is associated such as carbonate and iron or manganese oxides, etc. There have been a number of extraction schemes presented for phosphorus. At present, all of the existing schemes are carried out batchwise. Phosphorus contents derived from all sequences are operationally defined and depend on experimental conditions.An extraction procedure, which is a continuous-flow-based technique, was recently proposed by our group for metals in soils and sediments. The extraction is carried out in a closed chamber through which extractants are passed sequentially. In this paper, the system was investigated using the extraction scheme of Hieltjes and Lijklema to study distribution of phosphorus in three certified reference materials (CRMs). A number of fractions were collected for each reagent for subsequent colorimetric determination. The results are compared with those obtained from a batch extraction. The summation of phosphorus contents of all phases were compared with the certified values and with the values obtained from total digestion. These results have demonstrated that the continuous extraction system developed is also applicable for fractionation of phosphorus. Advantage and disadvantage are discussed.     

Sequential Extraction of Copper and Zinc from Sewage Sludges. Use of Organic Solvents

Abstract

Sequential extraction procedures were used to evaluate the bioavailability of metals from two sewage sludges after application in soils. Organic solvents were used prior to sequential extraction to evaluate the influence of oil and waxes on heavy metals extractability.

The preliminary results showed that a extraction of oil and waxes present in the sewage sludges by n-hexane followed by acetone increased the accessibility of Cu and Zn and did not remove substantial metal amounts.     

Optimizing standard sequential extraction protocol with lake and ocean sediments

The environmental mobility/availability behavior of radionuclides in soils and sediments depends on their speciation. Experiments have been carried out to develop a simple but robust radionuclide sequential extraction method for identification of radionuclide partitioning in sediments and soils. The sequential extraction protocol was optimized for temperature, concentration of reagents and reaction time. Optimum extraction conditions were chosen based on the release of ^239,240Pu, ²³⁸U and stable elements. Results from the experiments with lake sediment (SRM 4354) are compared to the previous trials where the sequential extraction protocol was optimized with the ocean sediment (SRM 4357). Based on these two trials the NIST standard sequential extraction protocol is established for defined extraction settings for temperature, reagent concentration and time.     

Evaluation of a sequential extraction procedure for the determination of extractable trace metal contents in sediments

The determination of extractable trace metals in sediments using sequential extraction procedures has been performed in many laboratories within the last ten years in order to study environmental pathways (e.g. mobility of metals, bounding states). However, the results obtained by different laboratories could hardly be compared due to lack of harmonized schemes. Owing to the need for standardization and subsequent validation of extraction schemes for sediment analysis, the Measurements and Testing Programme (formerly BCR Programme) of the European Commission has organized a project to adopt a sequential extraction procedure that could be used as a mean of comparison of data of extractable trace metals in sediments. A scheme was designed after a series of investigations on existing schemes and tested in interlaboratory studies. This paper presents the results of two round-robin exercises on extractable trace metals using this sequential extraction protocol and describes the final version of the extraction procedure amended according to the most recent improvements.     

Rotating coiled columns in the speciation analysis of natural samples: Dynamic fractionation of element forms in soils,sludges, and bottom sediments

The potentials of dynamic extraction in rotating coiled columns (RCCs) for the speciation analysis of soils, sludges, and bottom sediments is discussed on an example of the fractionation of element forms. A comparative study of the results of the fractionation of the forms of heavy metals differing in physicochemical mobility and bioavailability (Zn, Cd, Pb, Cu, Ni, Cr), obtained using a number of procedures of sequential extraction, is performed. Particular attention is paid to mercury, which is quite different from other metals in biogeochemical properties. Conditions are described for the dynamic fractionation of arsenic species occurring in natural samples in anionic forms. It is revealed that, in contrast to batch extraction, the continuous renewal of the eluent in a rotating column eliminates the problem of readsorption and overlapping of isolated fractions and enables the correct assessment of the concentration of the most mobile and bioavailable forms of toxic elements. A hyphenated method for the fractionation and determination of certain forms of elements (based on the ICP-AES detection of elements in the column eluate in the on-line mode) is described, ensuring the processing and a real-time control of the dynamic extraction of the forms of elements. The kinetic aspects of selective leaching are considered. It is shown that a comparison of the elution curves of micro- and macrocomponents makes possible a judgment about the selectivity of the leaching reagent, optimization of the conditions for the isolation of each fraction, and the investigation of the features of the binding of heavy metals and matrix elements in soils and bottom sediments. Some recommendations are given for the dynamic fractionation of the forms of elements in soils, sludges, and bottom sediments in RCCs.     

Evaluation of some Isolation Methods for Organomercury Determination in Soil and Fish Samples by Capillary Gas Chromatography—Atomic Fluorescence Spectrometry

Abstract

Three extraction methods, acidic KBr/CuSO₄ isolation-methylene chloride extraction. acidic KBr/CuSo₄ isolation-methylene chloride extraction with an alkaline digestion pretreatment, and an extration method at a milder condition with citrate buffer and dithizone in chloroform, were studied for methylmercury and ethylmercury determination in soils, sediments and fish samples by the recently developed capillary gas chromatography—atomic fluorescence spectrometry system (GC-AFS). The acidic KBr/CuSO₄-methylene chloride extraction and the acidic KBr/CuSO₄-methylene chloride extraction with an alkaline digestion pretreatment were shown to be the effective methods for soils/sediments and fish samples analysis, respectively. The presence of ethylmercury species in soils of the Florida Everglades, observed with the acidic KBr/CuSO₄ isolation and methylene chloride extraction procedure, was further confirmed with the dithizone complexation/extraction procedure. The GC-AFS analytical method offers high senstivity and selectivity for the determination of organomercury halides. The GC column maintenance, a critical step for organomercury halides analysis using GC, is also discussed.     

Extraction and analysis of arsenic in soils and sediments

The ability to extract arsenic (As) from soils and sediments, and analyze it with accuracy and precision, is of paramount importance, given the high risk that As, even in relatively low concentrations, poses to pore waters and biota. A large number of methods exist for extracting and analyzing total As, and As associated with a variety of operationally defined phase associations, in soils and sediments. We give an overview of methods used at present, and consider potential problems. We strongly recommend adoption of universal standard techniques and certified reference materials, especially for sequential extraction schemes.     

A modified sequential extraction method for arsenic fractionation in sediments

A modified sequential extraction method was developed to characterize arsenic (As) associated with different solid constituents in surficial deposits (sediments), which are unconsolidated glacial deposits overlying bedrock. Current sequential extraction methods produce a significant amount of unresolved As in the residual fraction, but our proposed scheme can fractionate >90% of the As present in sediments. Sediment samples containing different As concentrations (3–35 μg g⁻¹) were used to assess the developed method. The pooled amount of As recovered from all the fractions using the developed method was similar (83–122%) to the total As extracted by acid digestion. The concentrations of As in different fractions using the developed scheme were comparable (89–106%) to the As fractions obtained by other existing methods. The developed method was also evaluated for the sequential extraction of other metals such as copper (Cu), cobalt (Co), chromium (Cr) and strontium (Sr) in the sediment samples. The pooled concentrations of these four individual metals from all the fractions were similar (96–104%) to their total concentrations extracted by acid digestion. During method development, we used extractants that did not contain chloride to eliminate formation of polyatomic ions of argon chloride (⁴⁰Ar³⁵Cl) that interfered with ⁷⁵As when analyzed using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS). The results suggest that the developed method can reliably be employed for complete As and other metals’ fractionation in sediments using ICP-MS.     

Evaluation of Ammonium Oxalate for Fractionating Metallic Trace Elements in Soils by Sequential Extraction

Abstract

Ammonium oxalate is largely used to extract the trace elements bound to Mn-oxides, amorphous compounds and crystalline Fe-oxides. The objective of this work was to evaluate the selectivity and the efficiency of ammonium oxalate for extracting Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn by sequential extraction of soils. For this purpose, three schemes were selected and applied to three different soil samples of the Swiss Jura. Each extraction scheme consisted of six steps, where different reagents were used to extract Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn bound to the Mn and Fe compounds. The results showed that metallic trace elements extraction with ammonium oxalate are very dependant on the metal studied. The reason could be the capability of oxalate to form stable complexes with the metals considered which sometimes are only slightly soluble.     

Recent Developments in Automated Determinations of Trace Level Concentrations of Elements and On‐Line Fractionation Schemes Exploting the Micro‐Sequential Injection—Lab‐On‐Valve Approach

Abstract

The determination of trace level concentrations of elements, such as metal species, in complex matrices by atomic absorption or emission spectrometric methods often requires appropriate pretreatments comprising separation of the analyte from interfering constituents and analyte preconcentration. In this context sequential injection (SI) and lab‐on‐valve (LOV) schemes have proven themselves as superb vehicles to act as front‐end microanalytical methodologies, particularly when employing solid‐phase extraction (SPE) procedures. In this communication, selected SPE‐procedures in the bead‐renewable fashion are presented as based on the exploitation of micro‐sequential injection (µSI‐LOV) using hydrophobic as well as hydrophilic bead materials. The examples given comprise the presentation of a universal approach for SPE‐assays, front‐end speciation of Cr(III) and Cr(VI) in a fully automated and enclosed setup, and the combination of SPE with fractionation schemes of environmentally interesting solid samples (such as soils or sediments) in order to conduct ecotoxicological studies.     

Extraction procedures for the determination of heavy metals in contaminated soil and sediment

Extraction tests are commonly used to study the mobility of metals in soils and sediments by mimicking different environmental conditions or dramatic changes on them. The results obtained by determining the extractable elements are dependent on the extraction procedure applied. The paper summarises state of the art extraction procedures used for heavy metal determination in contaminated soil and sediments. Two types of extraction are considered: single and sequential. Special attention is paid to the Standard, Measurement and Testing projects from the European Commission which focused on the harmonisation of the extraction procedures and on preparing soil and sediment certified reference materials for extractable heavy metal contents.