Budding dynamics of individual domains in multicomponent membranes simulated by N-varied dissipative particle dynamics

We study the budding dynamics of individual domains in flat, multicomponent membranes using dissipative particle dynamics (DPD) simulations with varied bead number N, in which addition and deletion of beads based on their density at the membrane boundary is introduced. The budding process of a tubular bud, accompanied by a dynamical transition reflected in the energy and morphology evolutions, is investigated. The simulations show that budding duration is shortened with increasing line tension and depends on the domain size quadratically. At low line tension, increasing bending modulus accelerates budding at first, but suppresses the process as it increases further. In addition, the controlling role of the surface tension in the budding process is also explored. Finally, we use the N-varied DPD to simulate the experimentally observed multicomponent tubular vesicles, and the three bud growth modes are confirmed.     

Lipid nanotube formation from streptavidin-membrane binding

A novel transformation of giant lipid vesicles to produce nanotubular structures was observed upon the binding of streptavidin to biotinylated membranes. Unlike membrane budding and tubulation processes caused by proteins involved with endocytosis and vesicle fusion, streptavidin is known to crystallize at near the isoelectric point (pI 5 to 6) into planar sheets against biotinylated films. We have found, however, that at neutral pH membranes of low bending rigidity (<10kT), such as 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC), spontaneously produce tubular structures with widths ranging from micrometers to below the diffraction limit (<250 nm) and lengths spanning up to hundreds of micrometers. The nanotubes were typically held taut between surface-bound vesicles suggesting high membrane tension, yet the lipid nanotubes exhibited a fluidic nature that enabled the transport of entrained vesicles. Confocal microscopy confirmed the uniform coating of streptavidin over the vesicles and nanotubes. Giant vesicles composed of lipid membranes of higher bending energy exhibited only aggregation in the presence of streptavidin. Routes toward the development of these highly curved membrane structures are discussed in terms of general protein-membrane interactions.     

Glass Microsphere‐Supported Giant Vesicles for the Observation of Self‐Reproduction of Lipid Boundaries

Growth and division experiments on phospholipid boundaries were carried out using glass microsphere‐supported phospholipid (DOPC) giant vesicles (GVs) fed with a fatty acid solution (oleic acid) at two distinct feeding rates. Both fast and slow feeding methods produced daughter GVs. Under slow feeding conditions the membrane growth process (evagination, buds, filaments) was observed in detail by fluorescence microscopy. The density difference between supported mother vesicles and newly formed daughter vesicles allowed their easy separation. Mass spectrometric analysis of the resulting mother and daughter GVs showed that the composition of both vesicle types was a mixture of original supported phospholipids and added fatty acids reflecting the total composition of amphiphiles after the feeding process. Thus, self‐reproduction of phospholipid vesicles can take place under preservation of the lipid composition but different aggregate size.     

Complete budding and asymmetric division of primitive model cells to produce daughter vesicles with different interior and membrane compositions

Asymmetric cell division is common in biology and plays critical roles in differentiation and development. Unicellular organisms are often used as model systems for understanding the origins and consequences of asymmetry during cell division. Although basic as compared to mammalian cells, these are already quite complex. We report complete budding and asymmetric fission of very simple nonliving model cells to produce daughter vesicles that are chemically distinct in both interior and membrane compositions. Our model cells are based on giant lipid vesicles (GVs, 10-30 μm) encapsulating a polyethylene glycol (PEG)/dextran aqueous two-phase system (ATPS) as a crowded and compartmentalized cytoplasm mimic. Ternary lipid compositions were used to provide coexisting micrometer-scale liquid disordered (L(d)) and liquid ordered (L(o)) domains in the membranes. ATPS-containing vesicles formed buds when sucrose was added externally to provide increased osmotic pressure, such that they became not only morphologically asymmetric but also asymmetric in both their interior and their membrane compositions. Further increases in osmolality drove formation of two chemically distinct daughter vesicles, which were in some cases connected by a lipid nanotube (complete budding), and in others were not (fission). In all cases, separation occurred at the aqueous-aqueous phase boundary, such that one daughter vesicle contained the PEG-rich aqueous phase and the other contained the dextran-rich aqueous phase. PEGylated lipids localized in the L(o) domain resulted in this membrane domain preferentially coating the PEG-rich bud prior to division, and subsequently the PEG-rich daughter vesicle. Varying the mole ratio of lipids resulted in excess surface area of L(o) or L(d) membrane domains such that, upon division, this excess portion was inherited by one of the daughter vesicles. In some cases, a second "generation" of aqueous phase separation and budding could be induced in these daughter vesicles. Asymmetric fission of a simple self-assembled model cell, with production of daughter vesicles that harbored different protein concentrations and lipid compositions, is an example of the seemingly complex behavior possible for simple molecular assemblies. These compartmentalized and asymmetrically dividing ATPS-containing GVs could serve as a test bed for investigating possible roles for spatial and organizational cues in asymmetric cell division and inheritance.     

Shear-driven release of a bud from a multicomponent vesicle

The authors study the response of a multicomponent budded vesicle to an imposed shear flow using dissipative particle dynamics. Under certain circumstances, phase separation in the vesicle membrane leads to the formation of a minority domain which deforms into a nearly spherical bud in order to reduce its interfacial energy. The authors show that an imposed shear force has a varying effect on the vesicle, tending either to separate the bud from the vesicle or to stretch the bud open, depending on the vesicle orientation. The authors examine the interplay of membrane bending rigidity, line tension, and shear in determining the behavior of the vesicle. With the appropriate design, vesicles can be made to release buds in a controlled manner in response to shear. The authors outline a regime in which bud release is favorable.     

Domain growth, budding, and fission in phase-separating self-assembled fluid bilayers

A systematic investigation of the phase-separation dynamics in self-assembled binary fluid vesicles and open membranes is presented. We use large-scale dissipative particle dynamics to explicitly account for solvent, thereby allowing for numerical investigation of the effects of hydrodynamics and area-to-volume constraints. In the case of asymmetric lipid composition, we observed regimes corresponding to coalescence of flat patches, budding, vesiculation, and coalescence of caps. The area-to-volume constraint and hydrodynamics have a strong influence on these regimes and the crossovers between them. In the case of symmetric mixtures, irrespective of the area-to-volume ratio, we observed a growth regime with an exponent of 1/2. The same exponent is also found in the case of open membranes with symmetric composition.     

Single vesicle observations of the cardiolipin-cytochrome C interaction: induction of membrane morphology changes

We present a novel platform for investigating the composition-specific interactions of proteins (or other biologically relevant molecules) with model membranes composed of compositionally distinct domains. We focus on the interaction between a mitochondrial-specific lipid, cardiolipin (CL), and a peripheral membrane protein, cytochrome c (cyt c). We engineer vesicles with compositions such that they phase separate into coexisting liquid phases and the lipid of interest, CL, preferentially localizes into one of the domains (the liquid disordered (L(d)) phase). The presence of CL-rich and CL-depleted domains within the same vesicle provides a built-in control experiment to simultaneously observe the behavior of two membrane compositions under identical conditions. We find that cyt c binds strongly to CL-rich domains and observe fascinating morphological transitions within these regions of membrane. CL-rich domains start to form small buds and eventually fold up into a collapsed state. We also observe that cyt c can induce a strong attraction between the CL-rich domains of adjacent vesicles as demonstrated by the development of large osculating regions between these domains. Qualitatively similar behavior is observed when other polycationic proteins or polymers of a similar size and net charge are used instead of cyt c. We argue that these striking phenomena can be simply understood by consideration of colloidal forces between the protein and the membrane. We discuss the possible biological implications of our observations in relation to the structure and function of mitochondria.     

Lipid-based mechanisms for vesicle fission

Shape transformations and topological changes of lipid vesicles, such as fusion, budding, and fission, have important chemical physical and biological significance. In this paper, we study the fission process of lipid vesicles. Two distinct routes are considered that are both based on an asymmetry of the lipid distribution within the membrane. This asymmetry consists of a nonuniform distribution of two types of lipids. In the first mechanism, the two types of lipids are equally distributed over both leaflets of the membrane. Phase separation of the lipids within both leaflets, however, results in the formation of rafts, which form buds that can split off. In the second mechanism, the asymmetry consists of a difference in composition between the two monolayers of the membrane. This difference in composition yields a spontaneous curvature, reshaping the vesicle into a dumbbell such that it can split. Both pathways are studied with molecular dynamics simulations using a coarse-grained lipid model. For each of the pathways, the conditions required to obtain complete fission are investigated, and it is shown that for the second pathway, much smaller differences between the lipids are needed to obtain fission than for the first pathway. Furthermore, the lipid composition of the resulting split vesicles is shown to be completely different for both pathways, and essential differences between the fission pathway and the pathway of the inverse process, i.e., fusion, are shown to exist.     

Positioning lipid membrane domains in giant vesicles by micro-organization of aqueous cytoplasm mimic

We report localization of lipid membrane microdomains to specific "poles" of asymmetric giant vesicles (GVs) in response to local internal composition. Interior aqueous microdomains were generated in a simple model cytoplasm composed of a poly(ethyleneglycol) (PEG)/dextran aqueous two-phase system (ATPS) encapsulated in the vesicles. The GV membrane composition used here was a modification of a DOPC/DPPC/cholesterol mixture known to form micrometer-scale liquid ordered and liquid disordered domains; we added lipids with PEG 2000 Da-modified headgroups. Osmotically induced budding of the ATPS-containing GVs led to structures where the PEG-rich and dextran-rich interior aqueous phases were in contact with different regions of the vesicle membrane. Liquid ordered (L o) membrane domains rich in PEG-terminated lipids preferentially coated the PEG-rich aqueous phase vesicle "body", while coexisting liquid disordered (L d) membrane domains coated the dextran-rich aqueous phase "bud". Membrane domain positioning resulted from interactions between lipid headgroups and the interior aqueous polymer solutions, e.g., PEGylated headgroups with PEG and dextran polymers. Heating resulted first in patchy membranes where L o and L d domains no longer showed any preference for coating the PEG-rich vs dextran-rich interior aqueous volumes, and eventually complete lipid mixing. Upon cooling lipid domains again coated their preferred interior aqueous microvolume. This work shows that nonspecific interactions between interior aqueous contents and the membrane that encapsulates them can drive local chemical heterogeneity, and offers a primitive experimental model for membrane and cytoplasmic polarity in biological cells.     

Surface response methodology for the study of supported membrane formation

We report on the investigations of the formation of the tethered lipid bilayer by vesicle deposition on amine-functionalized surfaces. The tethered bilayer was created by the deposition of egg-PC vesicles containing 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-poly-(ethyleneglycol)-N-hydroxysuccinimide as anchoring molecules on an amine-coated surface. This approach is an easy route for the formation of a biomimetic-supported membrane. A Doelhert experimental design was applied to determine the conditions leading to the formation of a continuous and defect-free tethered bilayer on different surfaces (gold and glass). Doehlert designs allow modeling of the experimental responses by second-order polynomial equations as a function of experimental factors. Four factors expected to influence bilayer formation were studied: the lipid concentration in the vesicle suspension, the mass percentage of anchoring molecules in the vesicles, the contact time between the vesicles and the surface, and the resting time of the membrane after buffer rinse. The optimization of the membrane preparation parameters was achieved by monitoring lipid assembly formation using surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy on gold and by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching on glass. Three characteristic responses were systematically measured: the bilayer thickness, the lipid diffusion coefficient, and the lipid mobile fraction. The simultaneous inspection of the three characteristics revealed that a restricted experimental domain leads to properties that are in accordance with a bilayer presence. The factors of this domain are a lipid concentration from 0.1 to 1 mg/mL, 4-8% of anchoring molecules in the vesicles, 1-4 h of contact time between vesicles and surface, and 21-24 h of resting time after buffer rinse. Under these conditions, a membrane having a lipid mass per surface between 545 +/- 5 and 590 +/- 10 ng/cm2, a diffusion coefficient of between 2.5 +/- 0.3 x 10(-8) and 3.60 +/- 0.5 x 10(-8) cm2/s, and a mobile fraction between 94 +/- 2 and 99 +/- 1% was formed. These findings were confirmed by atomic force microscopy observations, which showed the presence of a continuous and homogeneous bilayer in the determined experimental domain. This formation procedure presents many advantages; it provides an easily obtainable biomimetic membrane model for proteins studies and offers a versatile tethered bilayer because it can be adapted easily to various types of supports.     

Novel method for obtaining homogeneous giant vesicles from a monodisperse water-in-oil emulsion prepared with a microfluidic device

A novel technique called the "lipid-coated ice droplet hydration method" is presented for the preparation of giant vesicles with a controlled size between 4 and 20 microm and entrapment yields for water-soluble molecules of up to about 30%. The method consists of three main steps. In the first step, a monodisperse water-in-oil emulsion with a predetermined average droplet diameter between 4 and 20 microm is prepared by microchannel emulsification, using sorbitan monooleate (Span 80) and stearylamine as emulsifiers and hexane as oil. In the second step, the water droplets of the emulsion are frozen and separated from the supernatant hexane solution by precipitation, followed by a removal of the supernatant and followed by the replacement of Span 80 by using a hexane solution containing egg yolk phosphatidylcholine, cholesterol, and stearylamine (5:5:1, molar ratio). This procedure is performed at -10 degrees C to keep the water droplets of the emulsion in a frozen state and thereby to avoid extensive water droplet coalescence. In the third step, hexane is evaporated at -4 to -7 degrees C and an external water phase is added to the remaining mixture of lipids and water droplets to form giant vesicles that have an average size in the range of that of the initial emulsion droplets (4-20 microm). The entrapment yield and the lamellarity of the vesicles obtained depend on the lipid/water droplet ratio and on the composition of the external water phase. At high lipid/water droplet ratio, the giant vesicles have a thicker membrane (indicating multilamellarity) and a higher entrapment yield than in the case of a low lipid/water droplet ratio. The highest entrapment yield ( approximately 35%) is obtained if the added external water phase contains preformed unilamellar egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles with an average diameter of 50 nm. The addition of these small vesicles minimizes the water droplet coalescence during the third step of the vesicle preparation, thereby decreasing the extent of release of water-soluble molecules originally present in the water droplets. The GVs prepared can be extruded through polycarbonate membranes to yield large unilamellar vesicles with about 100 nm diameter. This size reduction, however, leads to a decrease in the entrapment yield to about 12% due to solute leakage from the vesicles during the extrusion process.     

Cationic vesicles consisting of 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium propane (DOTAP) and phosphatidylcholines and their interaction with erythrocyte membrane

We studied the formation and stability of vesicles consisting of 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium propane (DOTAP) and phosphatidylcholines by electron spin resonance (ESR) analysis and observation of their hemolytic activities. In contrast with previous findings on dimethyldialkylammoniums, DOTAP formed vesicles at 37 degrees C with phosphatidylcholines containing either saturated acyl chains such as dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) or unsaturated acyl chains such as dilinoleoylphosphatidylcholine (DLPC). Phosphatidylcholines made the bilayer more rigid and significantly reduced the hemolytic activity of DOTAP. In the presence of equimolar concentration of DOTAP and phosphatidylcholines, formation of tightly aggregated structures of several erythrocytes was observed, as previously reported for the vesicles containing dimethyldipalmitylammonium. These findings indicate that DOTAP vesicles were stabilized by phosphatidylcholines with either saturated acyl chains or unsaturated acyl chains, and the interaction with the lipid bilayer of biological membranes as cationic vesicles became prominent with minimal membrane damage by DOTAP monomers.     

Formation of tubules and giant vesicles from large multilamellar vesicles

This study reports an observation of submicrometer multilamellar vesicles (MLVs) prepared by simply freeze-thawing a phospholipid dispersion at full hydration that transformed into giant vesicles (GVs) and tubules (TUs) when confined between microscope glass slides. Cover slide cleaning and surface treatment did not hamper the formation of GVs or TUs. However, when small unilamellar vesicles (SUV) were prepared or when MLVs were not confined but rather freely moved between the glass slides or when the phospholipid was in its gel phase, neither GVs nor TUs were observed. Altogether, our results suggested that MLVs would play a role as a lipid reservoir and that the liquid flow between the glass slides induces the peeling of the external bilayers, yielding the formation of tubules and giant unilamellar vesicles.     

Interaction of cationic lipid vesicles with model cell membranes--as determined by neutron reflectivity

Transfection of cells by DNA (for the purposes of gene therapy) can be effectively engineered through the use of cationic lipid/DNA "lipoplexes", although the transfection efficiency of these lipoplexes is sensitive to the neutral "helper" lipid included. Here, neutron reflectivity has been used to investigate the role of the helper lipid present during the interaction of cationic lipid vesicles with model cell membranes. Dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide (DDAB) vesicles were formed with two different helper lipids, 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) and cholesterol, and the interaction of these vesicles with a supported phospholipid bilayer was determined. DOPE-containing vesicles were found to interact faster with the membrane than those containing cholesterol, and vesicles containing either of the neutral helper lipids were found to interact faster than when DDAB alone was present. The interaction between the vesicles and the membrane was characterized by an exchange of lipid between the membrane and the lipid aggregates in solution; the deposition of vesicle bilayers on the surface of the membrane was not apparent.     

Interactions between antimicrobial polynorbornenes and phospholipid vesicles monitored by light scattering and microcalorimetry

Antimicrobial polynorbornenes composed of facially amphiphilic monomers have been previously reported to accurately emulate the antimicrobial activity of natural host-defense peptides (HDPs). The lethal mechanism of most HDPs involves binding to the membrane surface of bacteria leading to compromised phospholipid bilayers. In this paper, the interactions between biomimetic vesicle membranes and these cationic antimicrobial polynorbornenes are reported. Vesicle dye-leakage experiments were consistent with previous biological assays and corroborated a mode of action involving membrane disruption. Dynamic light scattering (DLS) showed that these antimicrobial polymers cause extensive aggregation of vesicles without complete bilayer disintegration as observed with surfactants that efficiently solubilize the membrane. Fluorescence microscopy on vesicles and bacterial cells also showed polymer-induced aggregation of both synthetic vesicles and bacterial cells. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) afforded free energy of binding values (Delta G) and polymer to lipid binding ratios, plus revealed that the interaction is entropically favorable (Delta S>0, Delta H>0). It was observed that the strength of vesicle binding was similar between the active polymers while the binding stoichiometries were dramatically different.     

Change of line tension in phase-separated vesicles upon protein binding

We measured the effect of a model membrane-binding protein on line tension and morphology of phase-separated lipid-bilayer vesicles. We studied giant unilamellar vesicles composed of a cholesterol/dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/palmitoylsphingomyelin mixture and a controlled mole fraction of a Ni-chelating lipid. These vesicles exhibited two coexisting fluid-phase domains at room temperature. Owing to the line tension, σ, between the two phases, the boundary between them was pulled like a purse string so that the smaller domain formed a bud. While observing the vesicles in a microscope, histidine-tagged green fluorescent protein was added, which bound to the Ni-chelating lipid. As protein bound, the vesicle shape changed and the length of the phase boundary increased. The change in morphology was attributed to a reduction of σ between the two phases because of preferential accumulation of histidine-tagged green fluorescent protein-Ni-chelating lipid clusters at the domain boundary. Greater reductions of σ were found in samples with higher concentrations of Ni-chelating lipid; this trend provided an estimate of the binding energy at the boundary, approximately k(B)T. The results show how domain boundaries can lead to an accumulation of membrane-binding proteins at their boundaries and, in turn, how proteins can alter line tension and vesicle morphology.     

Heterogeneity and deformation behavior of lipid vesicles

Recent studies on the deformation of lipid vesicles which is a simple model of biological membranes, and the factors that influence it are reviewed. In homogeneous vesicles, the deformation from spherical to various shapes was observed by adjusting the temperature and the osmotic pressure. This is mainly explained by a balance between the bending elasticity and the area difference energy. In phase separated vesicles, the effect of line tension makes a significant contribution to the deformation. In addition, asymmetric distribution of lipid molecules in bilayers caused by lipid sorting determines deformation behaviors including budding, pore, tube, adhesion, and self-reproduction. The change in membrane curvature due to shielding of lipid charges by electrolytes, proteins, peptides, and solid nanoparticles was also reviewed.     

Fluorescence wavelength, intensity and lifetime for multidimensional transduction of selective interactions of acetylcholine receptor by lipid membranes

Concurrent analysis of the fluorescence intensity, at different emission wavelengths, of lipid vesicles containing acetylcholine receptor (AChR) labelled with a nitrobenzoxadiazole (NBD) moiety shows that selective interactions with the agonist carbamylcholine can be detected reproducibly by a self-calibration method with muM detection limits. Concurrent analysis of the fluorescence intensity and lifetime of the new probe 4-dicyanomethylene-1,2,3,4-tetrahydromethylquinoline (DCQ) shows that general alterations of lipid membrane structure induced by temperature variation in the head-group region of lipid vesicles can be determined. A general approach to detection of selective interactions is introduced by observation of fluorescence intensity and lifetime changes of the probe NBD-phosphatidyl ethanolamine dispersed in lipid membranes containing unlabelled AChR. Detection and differentiation of selective interactions between carbamylcholine and the antagonist alpha-bungarotoxin are possible by correlation with intensity and lifetime at different emission wavelengths.     

Critical factors for detection of biphasic changes in membrane properties at specific sterol mole fractions for maximal superlattice formation

Here we use the excitation generalized polarization (GPex) of 6-lauroyl-2-(dimethylamino)naphthalene (Laurdan) fluorescence in fluid cholesterol/1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-l-alpha-phosphatidylcholine large unilamellar vesicles to explore the experimental conditions that would be required in order to detect a biphasic change in membrane properties at specific sterol mole fractions (Cr) (e.g., 20.0, 22.2, 25.0, 33.3, 40.0, and 50.0 mol %) for maximal sterol superlattice formation. Laurdan's GPex changes with sterol content in an alternating manner, showing minima (termed as GPex dips) at approximately Cr. GPex dips are detectable if the vesicles are preincubated for a sufficient time period and protected from sterol oxidation. In most cases, vesicles with a higher lipid concentration take a longer time to show a GPex dip at Cr. The depth of the GPex dip increases with increasing incubation time and eventually reaches a plateau, at which the maximum area covered by superlattices is expected to be achieved. However, if the vesicles are not protected against sterol oxidation, the GPex dips are attenuated or obliterated. These effects can be attributed to the increased inter-bilayer lipid exchange and the increased vesicle-vesicle interactions present at high lipid (vesicle) concentrations as well as the decreased interactions between oxysterols and phospholipids. These possible explanations have been incorporated into a kinetic model that is able to calculate the effects of sterol oxidation and lipid concentration on the depth of the GPex dip. The depth of the GPex dip, the required incubation time for the dip formation, and the lipid concentration dependence of the GPex dip vary with Cr, suggesting different physical properties for different sterol superlattices. To detect a biphasic change in membrane properties at Cr, one should also use small sterol mole fraction increments over a wide range, keep all of the vesicles in the same sample set under the same thermal history, and consider lipid concentration, probe type, and Cr value. These results improve our mechanistic understanding of sterol superlattice formation and explain why some studies, especially those requiring high lipid concentrations, did not detect a biphasic change in membrane properties at Cr.     

Spontaneous Formation of Giant Polymer Vesicles through a Nucleation and Growth Pathway

The non‐membrane‐closing formation of polymer vesicles was demonstrated by the self‐assembly of an amphiphilic hydrogen‐bonded interpolymer complex of HPC and PAA. A dynamic‐formation process that involved a nucleation and growth pathway was observed experimentally that was different from the theoretical predictions of both the membrane‐closing model and the nucleation and growth model. A series of intermediate states between the solid spheres and vesicles were visually captured by the addition of an inorganic salt followed by dilution.